Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Jeremy Vine - people are morally obliged to downsize and free up property

668 replies

JoanThursday1972 · 14/04/2023 12:17

Currently have this on the radio. Suggestion is that people are not entitled to remain in and live in the house that they have bought and paid for. That they should downsize and free this up for more deserving occupants, ie families.

This is surely a personal choice and not an obligation? Anyone is entitled to live in a house they have bought, regardless of size.

OP posts:
WickedSerious · 15/04/2023 08:47

Down here you can guarantee that when a couple in their seventies sell their five bed detached because they need to downsize it'll be snapped up by people the same age who've always wanted to live by the sea.

SquidwardBound · 15/04/2023 08:47

There’s also the issue that the design of smaller properties simply does not suit downsizers. They may be looking to have fewer bedrooms, but that generally doesn’t mean they want a cupboard for a kitchen and a tiny living room.

Then there’s the fact that it costs money to move. If you own a house outright, in a location you like, and which you’ve decorated to your taste, why would you want to pay stamp duty and have to start again in sorting out a house?

MarshaBradyo · 15/04/2023 08:41

Yanbu there are plenty of older people living nearby who live their home, community and area

Some widowed and relying on being settled

If something was introduced to force them to shift I’d be against it

Swiftbushome · 15/04/2023 08:36

@JoanThursday1972 you could look at it another way though. If everyone waited until they could afford a 4 bed house to live in most people (at least round where I live which is London) wouldn't be able to afford until it was too late to have kids. So who's going to be paying the pensions of all those retirees living in the big houses?

JoanThursday1972 · 15/04/2023 08:33

@StaringAtTheWater Being devil's advocate, why would they not make sure they could afford to buy and maintain a house big enough for a family before having children?

OP posts:
StaringAtTheWater · 15/04/2023 08:16

The issue is a lack of available property not people hoarding houses which are too big.

It's the same thing though. In theory a large house could be converted into four flats. Given that a) households have been getting smaller with birth rates going down and more people remaining single, b) there's a lot of old houses in the UK, of course you were going to end up with a situation where we have too many large dwellings and not enough small dwellings. And lack of availability is exacerbated by the fact we are also not building enough new houses for a growing total population. Currently councils aren't incentivised to allow much more building, as they don't make much money of it. So it's not worth them taking on the NIMBYs etc to make it happen. If council tax was raised it would be worth their while to force through more new builds and the extra money would help improve the infrastructure, that a larger settlement needs to function smoothly.

The sensible way to fix this issue is via market forces - tax property more heavily, and make the tax difference between small and large properties larger.

Yes, the idea of someone having to leave a large property they have worked hard on and love doesn't seem fair. But neither is it fair that a family with hard working parents can't afford a house where they are not all on top of each other. A sensible balance needs to be found. At the moment we have a massive wealth divide based on the luck of your generation.

napody · 15/04/2023 08:15

ifIwerenotanandroid · 14/04/2023 15:17

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-462092/Britains-gardens-threat-Prescotts-rules-allow-new-homes-built-green-spaces.html

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-440794/Thirty-thousand-gardens-year-torn-Prescotts-policies.html

http://news.bbc.co.uk/today/hi/today/newsid_8729000/8729919.stm

It seems to have been about legally designating gardens as brownfield sites & thus allowing several houses to be built where there had previously been just one house & a large garden. So not compulsory purchasing, though that's the way I seem to remember it being presented in the media. (And no criticism for the DMail links, please - I was a Guardian woman in those days!).

Thanks for returning with clarification on this- no, labour never made noises about compulsory purchase of people's gardens. God, we had it good then, and let the media twist things to a point that let the coalition in... and normal people have been fucked ever since.

KimberleyClark · 15/04/2023 06:51

TheGoogleMum · 14/04/2023 18:02

I think it's weird how many couples seem to have 4 bed houses and no kids (not kids that have grown either, just literally a couple in a large house with no dependants). I'd love a 4 bed house but can't afford one (have 2 kids and DH works from home so office would be useful). There's no way to enforce this though and it does seem unfair to make older people move who have lived somewhere for years and may still have grandkids come to stay.

Some of these couples may have bought these houses assuming they would have children and it never happened. Should they then be expected to vacate their homes for people who are more fertile than they are?

Creepyrosemary · 15/04/2023 04:11

I find it such a weird idea to "just" downsize. I spent at least 20k on the garden so it would be exactly what I want it to be, all building work on the house is done with the idea in mind that we want good quality (so the dearer option) because we want to stay in this house. It's not like you can get the same quality by downsizing, you'd have to start over! Oh, and since covid our extra bedrooms are offices... that did come in handy when we were told to stay away from other people.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 15/04/2023 00:51

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 00:35

Read the post above mine. Plenty of people on this thread have said it should be one rule for owners and another rule for SH tenants

Social housing should be temporary housing not for life. It should be there to cover a need and there should be affordable non social housing for when people are back on their feet. If you have a property you own and have paid for you should be able to live in it as long as you can afford it. It's not rocket science to say you should be able to control something you own. I say that as someone who grew up in poverty, free school meals and shank's pony, and lived in housing association and council homes until we could afford to buy. We then moved to allow another tenant who needed council housing to move in. That is the way it should be. Our childhood was hard but all of us children worked from as early as we could and parents had two jobs for most of their working lives.

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 00:35

Read the post above mine. Plenty of people on this thread have said it should be one rule for owners and another rule for SH tenants

GettingStuffed · 15/04/2023 00:34

We have a 4 bed house, just us and DS1 live here. We currently have DGS staying over so that's 3 out of the 4 taken so it only needs DD and her DH to want to stay too and we're full. Then if my other DS and his family want to come were talking mattresses in the office. I've mentally chosen a 5 bed and a 3 reception room property when we next move.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 15/04/2023 00:32

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 00:31

So why is it ok for social housing tenants to be responsible for others life choices?

What does that mean?

JenniferBooth · 15/04/2023 00:31

So why is it ok for social housing tenants to be responsible for others life choices?

LadyVictoriaSponge · 15/04/2023 00:28

WarmWinterSun · 14/04/2023 21:15

Just to add- I live on a nice street with: one elderly woman in a 6 bedroom house, one elderly woman in a 4 bedroom house, one couple in a five bedroom house, one man in a 5 bedroom house, one couple in a 5 bedroom house, and two other families in 4-5 bedroom houses. It’s like this in all the nice parts of my city with mostly elderly couples or widows/widowers living in the larger houses. The families I know with school ages children are crammed into very modest and small homes. It makes me really angry.

Do you get really angry at celebrities, royals, bankers etc occupying large homes? or is your venom just saved for average people living in normal homes, you know the ones that they have bought and paid for? The ‘families crammed into very modest and small homes’ should have thought if they could house their children adequately, it isn’t Mrs Smith in her 6 bedroom house problem that the Jones’s down the road are crammed into a 2 bed terrace, it is not up to her to solve those peoples life choices. There are plenty of family sized houses for sale, the fact is families ‘crammed into very modest and small homes’ are highly unlikely to suddenly be able to afford the 6 bedroom house even if it did come up for sale.

XenoBitch · 14/04/2023 23:59

Kendodd · 14/04/2023 23:09

While I don't think anyone should forced to downsize I don't think anyone should be subsidised to stay in a big house. I'd do away with stuff like single person discount on council tax, and as for people whingeing that they can't afford to heat or maintain a massive house they live alone in, zero sympathy, just downsize. This might be easy for me to say though because I'll never understand the love some people have for their house or other material possession.

Doing away with single person rate on council tax would affect single people living in a teeny one bed Band A flat. What would you actually gain by penalising them for committing the shocking crime of being single?

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 14/04/2023 23:49

StaringAtTheWater · 14/04/2023 22:14

In a democratic free market capitalist country you obviously can't force people to move out of houses they own.

You can however tax in a way that better incentivises downsizing. The generational wealth divide could be tackled much more effectively if we taxed income less and overall assets more. Compared to the US, the taxes we pay in the UK that relate to house size are ridiculously small! In the UK you can live in a mansion and only be paying a couple of k more in council tax than someone living in a tiny flat. People are not going to move out of their lovely big empty houses if there is no sensible financial incentive to do so.

The issue is a lack of available property not people hoarding houses which are too big.

Kendodd · 14/04/2023 23:09

While I don't think anyone should forced to downsize I don't think anyone should be subsidised to stay in a big house. I'd do away with stuff like single person discount on council tax, and as for people whingeing that they can't afford to heat or maintain a massive house they live alone in, zero sympathy, just downsize. This might be easy for me to say though because I'll never understand the love some people have for their house or other material possession.

Zipps · 14/04/2023 22:53

These journalists are just hypocrites. Just like the government, royal family, celebs - forever telling us what us plebs should be doing whilst doing the opposite.
We aren't boomers but we did downsize from a big 5 bedroom house because we wanted to and eldest dc has own house, youngest is in last year at uni with no intention of moving back home. But it took us ages to find a house that fit our criteria because we didn't want a starter home or a bungalow, both are far too small for a start. Definitely wouldn't want a not a flat or retirement apartment.

How about someone create houses that people want to downsize to?
Ours has everything we had before minus the extra bedrooms we no longer needed. Two double bedrooms, two bathrooms, small utility, kitchen/diner/living room and another reception room, tiny study, plus double garage, driveway, manageable garden.

echt · 14/04/2023 22:49

mostlysunnywithshowers · 14/04/2023 17:30

The only issue I have with people staying in their large property and rattling around til the bitter end, like my gm did until she was ordered by doctors into a nursing home, is the poor people who then buy it and have 3
30 years of neglect to sort out. Young families taking on older properties from elderly people and having to spend significant amounts of time and money returning them to a state fit for purpose is the biggest generational joke, along with pension deficits and old people complaining about living next to schools!

Diddums. Also a ludicrous attempt to make it a generational issue

Surely if the house is fucked it will be cheaper?

Isleoftights · 14/04/2023 22:47

YetMoreNewBeginnings · Today 22:15
A good social and affordable housing building splurge is what’s needed.

Two big HAs have done a shit tonne of building here the last few years. They build a load of two bed bungalows with gardens.

Where are you. ? In the year to March 2021, only 1,800 bungalows were built in the whole of the UK (and only 70 in Greater London). The UK population explosion is not going to met by building bungalows. We need to build a city the size of Liverpool every year, just to keep abreast of the growing population; that's only going to happen by building (as is happening in every UK city) 50+ story tower blocks. Bungalows ? It ain't gonna happen.

echt · 14/04/2023 22:39

StaringAtTheWater · 14/04/2023 22:14

In a democratic free market capitalist country you obviously can't force people to move out of houses they own.

You can however tax in a way that better incentivises downsizing. The generational wealth divide could be tackled much more effectively if we taxed income less and overall assets more. Compared to the US, the taxes we pay in the UK that relate to house size are ridiculously small! In the UK you can live in a mansion and only be paying a couple of k more in council tax than someone living in a tiny flat. People are not going to move out of their lovely big empty houses if there is no sensible financial incentive to do so.

First of all the houses aren't empty. The owners live there.
Those who are asset-rich and money poor will end up being forced, sorry, incentivised out of their homes. They will be very likely obliged to move out of their social circles to their detriment.

Being taxed out of their homes does not mean families will get those homes, just as likely to be snapped up by developers.

Also where are all the smaller houses?

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 14/04/2023 22:15

A good social and affordable housing building splurge is what’s needed.

Two big HAs have done a shit tonne of building here the last few years. They build a load of two bed bungalows with gardens. As a result a lot of older people locally did downsize - the mix of affordable and social meant there was movement in both sectors.

it’s made a huge difference to the rental market locally as tenant movement meant tenants had choices. Rents came down (and quite a few really shit landlords ended up forced out).

But the key was that the new builds fitted in with the community - people weren’t isolated out. The new health centre was built next to them, a shop was built and the bus routes were cemented in place.

StaringAtTheWater · 14/04/2023 22:14

In a democratic free market capitalist country you obviously can't force people to move out of houses they own.

You can however tax in a way that better incentivises downsizing. The generational wealth divide could be tackled much more effectively if we taxed income less and overall assets more. Compared to the US, the taxes we pay in the UK that relate to house size are ridiculously small! In the UK you can live in a mansion and only be paying a couple of k more in council tax than someone living in a tiny flat. People are not going to move out of their lovely big empty houses if there is no sensible financial incentive to do so.

Goodoccasionallypoor · 14/04/2023 22:07

itsnotmeitsu · 14/04/2023 22:00

If the 'boomers' have created this society than their parents before them created the society 'boomers' were born into; just as the generation born to boomers will be responsible for the social conditions their children inherit. Not sure how this negates the responsibility of central government to provide social housing and affordable homes.

I think the point many would make is that boomers have consistently voted in their own self interests rather than in favour of supporting their children or grandchildren. They are a large group (in terms of generation) and have a lot of wealth, so govts. act in line with those interests. Not building enough affordable housing is part of this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread