Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried to bring this to manager's attention?

111 replies

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 08:42

Last year I requested a reduction in my hours from full time (37.5 hrs) to 32 hrs. I did this through formal channels with my manager and have the paperwork to back up my request. I have never looked at my payslips (all electronic, don't get them through the post), and just took for granted that this had been correctly processed as requested, and therefore assumed that the new amount I was being paid reflected the number of hours I'd asked for.

I have looked at my payslip for the first time properly today and noticed it says 33 hours at the top. I've looked back and they are all the same, since I requested the reduction. This means for the best part of a year I have been paid for 1 hour more per week than I've worked.

I am now really worried that if I raise this with my manager I will owe back a lot of money. 😩 Can to be made to pay it back if I raise it, do you think? This obviously wasn't my error as I was very clear in my flexible working request that I wanted to reduce to 32 hours. But could they argue that I should have checked my pay slips before now? What should I do?!

OP posts:
toiletinacupboard · 14/04/2023 09:23

Aw OP. It sounds like a nice place! If this happened in my old job there'd be a few jokes about Manager dishing out cash to his favourites.

But it'll be resolved easily and nicely. And repayment or overtime arranged to suit you. (Not them)

Good luck. Am sure it'll be cool!!

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 09:21

GoodChat · 14/04/2023 09:19

Would you feel more comfortable contacting HR/payroll direct rather than having the conversation with your manager?

Just say to them you had your working hours agreed at 32 but noticed your payslip states 33 and ask if there's a reason for this?

That way you're not telling them they've overpaid you, you're just asking them to clarify your payslip.

Yeah this is a good idea, I will give them a call. Just trying to summon up the courage! 😩

OP posts:
BoneBrothByDayDonutByNight · 14/04/2023 09:19

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 08:59

I wonder if the paperwork I submitted that my manager rubber stamped would be sufficient to argue the case I shouldn't owe it as he made the error? Or will they likely say the onus was on me to check he had done it correctly?

No, they issued you a payslip with the number of hours clearly stated, so (annoyingly) this may have started as your manager’s error, but after the first payslip it was your error. And every week since the change you’ve missed the chance to check. But yeah, annoying!!

GoodChat · 14/04/2023 09:19

Would you feel more comfortable contacting HR/payroll direct rather than having the conversation with your manager?

Just say to them you had your working hours agreed at 32 but noticed your payslip states 33 and ask if there's a reason for this?

That way you're not telling them they've overpaid you, you're just asking them to clarify your payslip.

Moltenpink · 14/04/2023 09:18

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 08:50

Wonder if I could tally up all the hours I owe and work them back instead? 🤔

You would be allowed to do this where I work.

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 09:17

toiletinacupboard · 14/04/2023 09:14

@emmalouise83 I'd take control of this situation.

And message HR or whoever and say "I've just noticed I've been overpaid as per my payslip. I'm happy to pay it back over XX months. Please can you check my file and get back to me?"

You choose how many months would suit you and make it known.

This is their mistake so they'll be blushing - not you! Just fess up with a solution (do the critical thinking on their behalf! Looks like they might need it 😂)

It will by my direct manager who's made this error, not HR/payroll. My manager has to log into my electronic record and change things, which notifies payroll to adjust my pay. So payroll are just paying me what he's told them to pay me. But he's entered 33 instead of 32. So it's his error really, not theirs. We are a huge team and he manages a lot of people so I'm assuming it's an honest mistake on his part, but now I'm in this situation which doesn't seem fair 🙈

OP posts:
GoodChat · 14/04/2023 09:16

@SquidGinn so they'd take OP's hourly rate minus tax, NI etc? Or they'd just pay her 31 hours until it's resolved?

toiletinacupboard · 14/04/2023 09:14

@emmalouise83 I'd take control of this situation.

And message HR or whoever and say "I've just noticed I've been overpaid as per my payslip. I'm happy to pay it back over XX months. Please can you check my file and get back to me?"

You choose how many months would suit you and make it known.

This is their mistake so they'll be blushing - not you! Just fess up with a solution (do the critical thinking on their behalf! Looks like they might need it 😂)

Malarandras · 14/04/2023 09:14

If it’s the NHS then they have a duty to spend public money responsibly. So they will want the money back. I work for central government and they are very clear that it is our responsibility to check our payslips are correct. It will likely be the same for you. It would be best to raise the issue now and agree a repayment schedule. Now that you know you can’t keep taking money you are not owed.

signalsnap · 14/04/2023 09:12

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 09:08

@toiletinacupboard

Yeah mine is also a pain to access - passwords and all that. And I always forget them! So I don't bother as I know what I got paid last month so it's just the same etc

Yep mine too. Although to be fair, I rarely opened the old school printed ones with the perforated edges.

SquidGinn · 14/04/2023 09:12

GoodChat · 14/04/2023 09:04

This is a very good point. If they do ask for it back, OP, make sure they work out how much NI, tax, pension, student loan etc you've paid extra and deduct that from the figure you owe

They will take the overpayment from her gross corrected salary so she would pay less tax etc going forward for the period of overpayment, so it’s not really an issue whilst the person is still in employment.

Obviously bands change through tax years but the differences would be minimal.

I honestly wouldn’t worry though OP - they will either work to a repayment plan that suits you, or even correct and write off the overpayment x

Beseen22 · 14/04/2023 09:09

I am NHS and had this along with 4 other employees who work with me (management not the brightest or most computer literate). It was 4 months and HR noticed but it was when the void bonus payment was made plus emergency tax so my wage hadn't changed by much but had to pay £1k back. Took it over about 4 months.

You have to tell them and will most likely have to pay it back but you can negotiate how long for.

MercianQueen · 14/04/2023 09:09

Our rule of thumb for paying back payroll errors is that it's paid back gradually over the same period of time that the overpayment was in place for. So if you've been overpaid for a year, you pay back over a year - hopefully that wouldn't be too painful.

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 09:08

@toiletinacupboard

Yeah mine is also a pain to access - passwords and all that. And I always forget them! So I don't bother as I know what I got paid last month so it's just the same etc

OP posts:
toiletinacupboard · 14/04/2023 09:08

MsCunk · 14/04/2023 09:03

Is it really common to not check one's payslip? I always check mine!

Depends if yours is a nice friendly email. Or if it's a PDF password protected pain in the ass.

For my last 3 jobs mine have been password protected and a PITA to access. So what's the point in checking? You work the same hours every week

signalsnap · 14/04/2023 09:07

Testina · 14/04/2023 08:55

In my large corporate workplace, my line manager would point out all the times I’ve worked late for “free” and even if I hadn’t - would tell HR to get to fuck if they wanted to claw back the money. To be fair, my HR wouldn’t even try. Don’t assume you’ll definitely have to pay it back or work the hours in lieu.

Sounds like this has been less than a year - 52 hours max. So even if you did have to repay it - it’s not unusual to use the same overpayment period as the repayment period - so it won’t be much per week.

I honestly expect this will go away, once you raise it. Be brave!

Likewise in my sme.

I suspect if you've reduced your hours it's unlikely you're giving many for 'free', but if you do work lunches/log on at home sometimes, and aren't a complete clock watcher they may still suck it up as an admin error their side.

Don't mention paying it back just inform him that the payslip mistakenly says 33 hours and needs to be reduced to 32 as per your agreement. With any luck they'll just adjust future payments, or as others have said will work out a payment plan that works for you.

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 09:07

It's been around 11 months of this, so about 44/45 ish weeks. That means I potentially owe 45 weeks x my hourly rate 😭

OP posts:
MsCunk · 14/04/2023 09:06

Mine doesn't change either, I still always look at it. Especially when I know there's been a change, like hours worked or COL increase.

Anyway, I hope HR has a reasonable response, OP. Best to address it ASAP.

GoodChat · 14/04/2023 09:06

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 09:05

@GoodChat thank you, will do. Oh god I feel sick at the thought of raising it 🙈

They're much more likely to be reasonable if you raise it rather than waiting for them to realise so don't worry. As you say, it's not your error.

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 09:05

@GoodChat thank you, will do. Oh god I feel sick at the thought of raising it 🙈

OP posts:
Testina · 14/04/2023 09:05

Honestly though, whether you repay or they write it off, it’s not as big a deal as you think right now - and the sooner you raise it the better you’ll feel. Honest!

GoodChat · 14/04/2023 09:04

Mangomingo · 14/04/2023 09:03

This exact thing happened to me, also NHS. It was ten years ago though. I went down to 23 and they paid me 24 for a year. HR noticed not me.
At first I was told I would need to pay it or I could sell some annual leave. I asked for a breakdown of the full amount, with an email outlining my various options (lump sum, pay back monthly and selling leave). I also pointed out I was paying childcare vouchers out my pre tax amount and whether that was going to affect anything and whether I would be entitled to tax or NI back and pension.

They went away to get me all the information and never came back to me. Nothing ended up happening. Certainly there was no pressure or horribleness from them, it was very much their mistake and I was going to be given lots of time and options to pay it back.

This is a very good point. If they do ask for it back, OP, make sure they work out how much NI, tax, pension, student loan etc you've paid extra and deduct that from the figure you owe

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 09:04

MsCunk · 14/04/2023 09:03

Is it really common to not check one's payslip? I always check mine!

No because my hours and pay don't ever change. I get the same amount every month so I don't bother looking at it.

OP posts:
SD1978 · 14/04/2023 09:04

If they'd been paying you for 31 and you had o my just realised the error- you would be expecting that mo ey to be given to you. The company will probably expect the same. Let your manager know ASAP, and they should let you work out a payment plan.

Testina · 14/04/2023 09:03

Here’s the ACAS page about overpayments, and it includes their free helpline number.

https://www.acas.org.uk/check-if-your-employer-can-make-deductions-from-your-wages

It will tell you, that they have an obligation to make a fair repayment plan with you.

Check if your employer can make deductions from your wages - Acas

What to do if you have not been paid the amount you were expecting.

https://www.acas.org.uk/check-if-your-employer-can-make-deductions-from-your-wages