Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried to bring this to manager's attention?

111 replies

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 08:42

Last year I requested a reduction in my hours from full time (37.5 hrs) to 32 hrs. I did this through formal channels with my manager and have the paperwork to back up my request. I have never looked at my payslips (all electronic, don't get them through the post), and just took for granted that this had been correctly processed as requested, and therefore assumed that the new amount I was being paid reflected the number of hours I'd asked for.

I have looked at my payslip for the first time properly today and noticed it says 33 hours at the top. I've looked back and they are all the same, since I requested the reduction. This means for the best part of a year I have been paid for 1 hour more per week than I've worked.

I am now really worried that if I raise this with my manager I will owe back a lot of money. 😩 Can to be made to pay it back if I raise it, do you think? This obviously wasn't my error as I was very clear in my flexible working request that I wanted to reduce to 32 hours. But could they argue that I should have checked my pay slips before now? What should I do?!

OP posts:
1AngelicFruitCake · 14/04/2023 10:55

Testina · 14/04/2023 08:55

In my large corporate workplace, my line manager would point out all the times I’ve worked late for “free” and even if I hadn’t - would tell HR to get to fuck if they wanted to claw back the money. To be fair, my HR wouldn’t even try. Don’t assume you’ll definitely have to pay it back or work the hours in lieu.

Sounds like this has been less than a year - 52 hours max. So even if you did have to repay it - it’s not unusual to use the same overpayment period as the repayment period - so it won’t be much per week.

I honestly expect this will go away, once you raise it. Be brave!

Shows how different workplaces are! I work somewhere where going above snd beyond is expected. my colleague was overpaid and had to set up a payment plan.

Notamum12345577 · 14/04/2023 10:54

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 08:42

Last year I requested a reduction in my hours from full time (37.5 hrs) to 32 hrs. I did this through formal channels with my manager and have the paperwork to back up my request. I have never looked at my payslips (all electronic, don't get them through the post), and just took for granted that this had been correctly processed as requested, and therefore assumed that the new amount I was being paid reflected the number of hours I'd asked for.

I have looked at my payslip for the first time properly today and noticed it says 33 hours at the top. I've looked back and they are all the same, since I requested the reduction. This means for the best part of a year I have been paid for 1 hour more per week than I've worked.

I am now really worried that if I raise this with my manager I will owe back a lot of money. 😩 Can to be made to pay it back if I raise it, do you think? This obviously wasn't my error as I was very clear in my flexible working request that I wanted to reduce to 32 hours. But could they argue that I should have checked my pay slips before now? What should I do?!

I would assume they would want it back. However, as it is their fault you should have the right to a payment plan that is suitable for yourself

Notamum12345577 · 14/04/2023 10:52

clpsmum · 14/04/2023 09:00

I would keep schtum tbh it's one hour not an extra weeks pay

Imagine if her employer found out in say 10 years time, and asked for the money back. She would owe a lot then.
But anyway, an hour for 52 weeks (which is how long it has been happening for) works out to more than a weeks pay 😁

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 14/04/2023 10:52

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 09:08

@toiletinacupboard

Yeah mine is also a pain to access - passwords and all that. And I always forget them! So I don't bother as I know what I got paid last month so it's just the same etc

Ex-NHS HR Director.

you’ll be asked to pay it back. It will
likely come up in a financial audit at some point so better to deal with it now than a year or 2 down the line.

never assume that your pay is right just because it’s the same as last month. Tax codes can be wrong, pension rates can change. Important messages are often put on payslips because there is an expectation that people will check them.

Not being able to remember a password is a pretty lame excuse TBH.

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 10:46

ReadersD1gest · 14/04/2023 10:44

Could it be a paid for lunch break?

lunch breaks are all unpaid according to my contract.

OP posts:
lovemelongtime · 14/04/2023 10:46

I manage a payroll department in similar org. Unfortunately we would need to recover but will always agree a reasonable recovery plan, especially with COL crisis. You can suggest to repay over the same time that the overpayment occurred.

emmalouise83 · 14/04/2023 10:45

Baconking · 14/04/2023 10:41

Will you have also been given extra leave based on a 33 hour week?

No my leave entitlement is worked out by our admin/ secretary so a separate system entirely. I've seen the spreadsheet she works from and she has me down as working a 32 hour week because this is what I told her I work, so my leave entitlement is correct and based on 32 hrs not 33.

OP posts:
ReadersD1gest · 14/04/2023 10:44

Could it be a paid for lunch break?

Baabaa75 · 14/04/2023 10:43

Speak to your manager, I've handled issues like this in the past. Depending on the company we'd either write it off (usually if employee makes a song and dance about not being able to repay it) or deduct very small amounts over a lengthy period of time.

theemmadilemma · 14/04/2023 10:41

Yep, required to pay it back, but they will allow you to this with a payment plan so as not to cause hardship.

Honestly who throughly checks their payslips? Not many people in a 9-5 salaried role.

As a Manager, we'd be grateful you caught it before it went unnoticed longer, and you'd be getting bonus points for honesty.

Literally you can only come out looking good for pointing this out.

Baconking · 14/04/2023 10:41

Will you have also been given extra leave based on a 33 hour week?

Tandora · 14/04/2023 10:33

As others have said , you will be required to pay it back unfortunately. This happened to me while working for nhs and in another job. Entirely their own fault- overpaid me by a heavy amount. But it was still money that I hadn’t earned and needed to give back. they were willing to negotiate a payment plan, so a small amount came out of my future wages each month until it was paid back x

maddy68 · 14/04/2023 10:28

I would bring it to their attention and offer to work the extra hours until they have been paid off

Ineedtoloseweightnow · 14/04/2023 10:28

I wouldn’t call hr I would speak to your manager. He might not want to admit he made an error and leave it just changing your hours for future.

ObiWanKanobi · 14/04/2023 10:27

Could you offer to work 1 hour extra per week "for free" until it is paid off?

Frabbits · 14/04/2023 10:26

SpicedPumpkinLatte · 14/04/2023 10:22

I'm an employer and if this was my company's mistake, I would let you keep it because I'm not an arsehole.

Public sector is different though.

OP, you'll be able to repay it over time. It's not going to be a huge amount of money if it's just 1 hour over a short period.

Louandsi · 14/04/2023 10:23

Unfortunately the NHS will make you pay it back somehow. I had a friend in the same boat. They let her work some extra hours and the money she owed was done in installments.

AnythingMuppetTM · 14/04/2023 10:22

I work for a public sector organisation who would also take it in one go. The unions have sometimes been able to organise repayment plans but it’s always a battle. The union may be able to help by giving a crisis hardship payment to the member affected.

It does not matter to the organisation whose error it is. To them it’s an accounting error and it needs to be sorted asap. Most contracts have something written in them about overpayments.

im not trying to worry the OP but I don’t think it’s helpful to suggest it will all be fine. Prepare for the worst on this in my experience.

SpicedPumpkinLatte · 14/04/2023 10:22

I'm an employer and if this was my company's mistake, I would let you keep it because I'm not an arsehole.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 14/04/2023 10:16

You need to get ahead of this, if it is NHS they will want to take it in one go, so you need your manager to be really clear with them about how it is to be recovered. I have twice had massive amounts taken from my paycheck without notice and had to fight it out with them. So, the sooner you talk to your manager and get them onside with telling payroll how this is to be handled the better.

Knickerthief1 · 14/04/2023 10:03

Some places would be more than happy to let you work back the overpaid hours. I know I would allow this as a manager.

rainbowstardrops · 14/04/2023 10:00

GoodChat · 14/04/2023 09:19

Would you feel more comfortable contacting HR/payroll direct rather than having the conversation with your manager?

Just say to them you had your working hours agreed at 32 but noticed your payslip states 33 and ask if there's a reason for this?

That way you're not telling them they've overpaid you, you're just asking them to clarify your payslip.

This is how I'd handle it too

tona79 · 14/04/2023 09:30

PS I wouldn't say you have been overpaid, I would say you have noticed the number of hours shown is wrong, do it in writing - let them suggest anything financial - once you have notified them its up to them to correct the 33 to 32 and leave it to them to raise the issue of repayment. Be prepared you probably will have to, but don't offer!

GoodChat · 14/04/2023 09:29

You've got this @emmalouise83. They're not going to see you struggle. Worst case, you'll be able to come to an affordable compromise.

tona79 · 14/04/2023 09:23

A cleaner at a school I worked at was overpaid £10 a week for 8 years, when the employer discovered their mistake they asked for the money back.

As I was a teaching union rep at the time I decided to help her, I got advise from a local solicitor and the situation was very simple, she would reasonably have been expected to check, she had to pay it back.

HR arranged a payment plan and she paid it back.

If you keep schtum it stays incorrect at 33 hours and the debt keeps growing - eventually they will work it out and you will legally have to pay it back. Better to go and discuss, offer to pay it back as a deduction over the same time period as the error, that shouldn't hurt too much, and as its not been too long will clear it down.

They may be nice and say not to worry, depends how flush they are!