Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Different views about money and debt

81 replies

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 14/04/2023 05:43

So some of my friends spend around £1k over what they earn every month. They do get occasional lump sums from family members, or bonuses from work which will obviously help reduce the debt a bit. But the debt value is going up not down over time. They all have mortgages also.

For me, other than essential debts (mortgage and car finance) I try to stay out of further debt. If I do borrow money I work hard to pay off the loan. But my friends have around £20-30k debt on top of the essentials which is always increasing (they are not paying it off, just getting further and further into debt). They go on a holiday abroad every year which cost around £6k each holiday. They always have take aways and buy designer clothes etc.

I have been asked to go on a holiday abroad with them with our husbands and kids. The holiday sounds incredible and I would absolutely love to go. It would also add depth to our friendships and be a lovely bonding trip. But I don't think my family can afford it so politely declined, but said that I hope they have a lovely time on the trip. It would cost about £6k for travel and accommodation which is a lot of money for me.

My household income is less than theirs so I accept my lifestyle will look considerably different from theirs. But they we're visibly stunned when I declined. I think they think I am being tight.

I could go. But would have to be incredibly frugal with money for a very long time to pay off the holiday, which does not appeal. I also don't want to get into debt over it?

AIBU to not go? Or is it worth the money to boost the friendship and have a nice time? I can't work out if I'm just tight with money of if my friends are reckless.... or something in between!

I may suggest a cheaper holiday, but they seem to have their hearts set on this place. I wonder if I am a buzz kill.

OP posts:
MurderAtTheBeautyPageant · 14/04/2023 13:06

I was watching a video on Twitter yesterday about a young (30-ish I think) American couple who have $1m in debt. $300K on student loans (what a country!), $200K on their mortgage and the rest on credit card debt. My gast was flabbered. I've been in debt before myself and don't plan on going back there. Especially in the current climate. Your friends spending £1K over their earnings each month sounds nuts.

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 14/04/2023 13:00

I definitely wouldn't go on this holiday, I imagine your friends will be spending a lot whilst they are there too, and it will end up costing even more than 6k.

Also, if you did end up getting into debt for the holiday it would end up costing more with the interest payments. And lost interest if you take the money out of your savings account.

I'd also question why somebody would be "visibly stunned" at you declining a holiday invite. I have friends with different finances to me, but we are never "visibly stunned" like this! Do you think they were trying to make you feel bad?

Whether or not accumulating debt you can't pay off is "normal", it is not a good idea. Everything they buy will cost them much more with years of compounding interest added on. They are also missing out on earning money through investments or savings interest.

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 14/04/2023 12:57

You do sound a little bit judgy about your friends though

How so? Please explain.

OP posts:
Biscuitlover456 · 14/04/2023 12:42

YANBU. There is no way I would risk financially destabilising my family for the sake of a fancy holiday. If they are true friends they will get it and not pressure you or make you feel bad about it.

We all have our levels of comfort in terms of things like debt; I too am super uncomfortable being in debt so try and stay as far out of it as possible. I don’t judge others for being in debt, although I think some reasons for being in debt are better than others - eg being in debt to keep up with the Joneses seems oddly self-destructive to me. Living for today is great but why does that necessarily have to involve living outside your means?

Jagoda · 14/04/2023 12:32

YANBU not to go on a holiday you cannot afford without getting into debt.

You do sound a little bit judgy about your friends though Smile

I have a friend who was like this, got into loads of debt, but she knew she was going to inherit shedloads of money, so she wasn't bothered about it. Obviously that could have gone terribly wrong for her in a myriad of ways, but it didn't.

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 14/04/2023 12:29

Chevybaby · 14/04/2023 10:24

I feel like I’m way more relaxed about debt than other commenters here. I am currently choosing not to work too much while my child is very little, for now I’d rather spend time with her gardening and making biscuits than slaving away in a room with 25 other farting swearing adults. I’ve totally adjusted my lifestyle to keep costs down but I’ve also decided to accept that I’ll need to get in a bit of debt for now too. Nothing near the 30k (or 100k 😱) mark but still it is debt. When she’s in school I’ll be back working full time and can play a bit of catch up as long as I keep up the frugality for a couple years.

re Your friends I on the whole don’t disagree with the idea of enjoy life now, worry later. I do find it shocking though that they wouldn’t compromise on an extravagant holiday so that everyone in the group could afford to come. That’s pretty strange behaviour. I’d rather be in a cheapo caravan with my friends around me than a posh resort without them. Everyone’s different I guess 🤷‍♀️

I think getting into debt that will be paid off later is completely understandable and wouldn't worry me. Especially for your reasons.

However their children are older and at school. As far as I'm aware they do not have a grand solution to solve their money problems in time.

I do worry though that I'm not living my life enough though.

OP posts:
KleineDracheKokosnuss · 14/04/2023 12:29

PurBal · 14/04/2023 06:36

my friends have around £20-30k debt on top of the essentials which is always increasing this horrifies me, surely this can’t be normal?!

I’m with you.

me too! Our society runs on an unmanageable debt mountain.

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 14/04/2023 12:27

BertieBotts · 14/04/2023 09:01

I don't really understand why the long ramble about how your friends afford things and how you disagree with it.

YANBU to make the choice that makes sense for your family. What your friends do is not really relevant.

My AIBU has 2 parts I guess

  1. AIBU to not go on the holiday
  1. Is my view on debt unreasonable. Is it just the norm now to be in debt and not seem to care

Hence the long ramble.

I don't disagree with their spending. It's none of my business what they do or don't buy and I am genuinely happy for them if it makes them happy. However MY money is my business as is MY attitude to spending. I am concerned I am not 'living' enough because of my fear of debt. I am curious if that is unreasonable. I am jealous of the lovely things they do and buy, and wonder if it is worth the debt.

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 14/04/2023 12:04

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 14/04/2023 05:43

So some of my friends spend around £1k over what they earn every month. They do get occasional lump sums from family members, or bonuses from work which will obviously help reduce the debt a bit. But the debt value is going up not down over time. They all have mortgages also.

For me, other than essential debts (mortgage and car finance) I try to stay out of further debt. If I do borrow money I work hard to pay off the loan. But my friends have around £20-30k debt on top of the essentials which is always increasing (they are not paying it off, just getting further and further into debt). They go on a holiday abroad every year which cost around £6k each holiday. They always have take aways and buy designer clothes etc.

I have been asked to go on a holiday abroad with them with our husbands and kids. The holiday sounds incredible and I would absolutely love to go. It would also add depth to our friendships and be a lovely bonding trip. But I don't think my family can afford it so politely declined, but said that I hope they have a lovely time on the trip. It would cost about £6k for travel and accommodation which is a lot of money for me.

My household income is less than theirs so I accept my lifestyle will look considerably different from theirs. But they we're visibly stunned when I declined. I think they think I am being tight.

I could go. But would have to be incredibly frugal with money for a very long time to pay off the holiday, which does not appeal. I also don't want to get into debt over it?

AIBU to not go? Or is it worth the money to boost the friendship and have a nice time? I can't work out if I'm just tight with money of if my friends are reckless.... or something in between!

I may suggest a cheaper holiday, but they seem to have their hearts set on this place. I wonder if I am a buzz kill.

It sounds like your relationship with money is a lot healthier. If your friends already have mortgages they may feel 'comfortable' however if the debts get out of hand, as the T&Cs say 'your home could be at risk'. If they were to re-mortgage after a break up/house move etc there's a real chance they could lose their home. Having CCJs /bankruptcy etc can also exclude you from various professions and emigrating etc.
Some people run up debt when they first start a family but have a plan to clear it once both partners are back at work and childcare costs are reduced.
I don't know your friends' circumstances but it sounds like they are being very irresponsible and extremely selfish. Debtors rarely pay back what they owe!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/04/2023 11:58

Eggyeaster · 14/04/2023 07:32

also these threads will only be replied to by people who have zero debt and incredibly good for money, which honestly I admire, but you probably won’t get a very balanced conversation about debt.

I wondered about this too.

Nordicrain · 14/04/2023 11:56

Chevybaby · 14/04/2023 10:24

I feel like I’m way more relaxed about debt than other commenters here. I am currently choosing not to work too much while my child is very little, for now I’d rather spend time with her gardening and making biscuits than slaving away in a room with 25 other farting swearing adults. I’ve totally adjusted my lifestyle to keep costs down but I’ve also decided to accept that I’ll need to get in a bit of debt for now too. Nothing near the 30k (or 100k 😱) mark but still it is debt. When she’s in school I’ll be back working full time and can play a bit of catch up as long as I keep up the frugality for a couple years.

re Your friends I on the whole don’t disagree with the idea of enjoy life now, worry later. I do find it shocking though that they wouldn’t compromise on an extravagant holiday so that everyone in the group could afford to come. That’s pretty strange behaviour. I’d rather be in a cheapo caravan with my friends around me than a posh resort without them. Everyone’s different I guess 🤷‍♀️

My experience is that it's more difficult to work full time when they are in school than when they are tiny.

Nordicrain · 14/04/2023 11:54

I have a friend who lives in constant debt. She doesn't, I think, think of money as infinite as she always has grand plans. She shops around for 0% interest every few years to keep her interest payments low and "treats" herself to a big designer item every time she does it because "she may as well". She's got a house (that she wants to upgrade) and 3 kids too. I don't know how she does it, I would be constantly stressed about that hanging over me, and keeping up with repayments, but it doesn't seem to bother her too much except when an unexpected expense comes up or if she wants to change jobs etc. Then she's very sterssed about it for a short period and then continues.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/04/2023 11:50

Chevybaby · 14/04/2023 10:24

I feel like I’m way more relaxed about debt than other commenters here. I am currently choosing not to work too much while my child is very little, for now I’d rather spend time with her gardening and making biscuits than slaving away in a room with 25 other farting swearing adults. I’ve totally adjusted my lifestyle to keep costs down but I’ve also decided to accept that I’ll need to get in a bit of debt for now too. Nothing near the 30k (or 100k 😱) mark but still it is debt. When she’s in school I’ll be back working full time and can play a bit of catch up as long as I keep up the frugality for a couple years.

re Your friends I on the whole don’t disagree with the idea of enjoy life now, worry later. I do find it shocking though that they wouldn’t compromise on an extravagant holiday so that everyone in the group could afford to come. That’s pretty strange behaviour. I’d rather be in a cheapo caravan with my friends around me than a posh resort without them. Everyone’s different I guess 🤷‍♀️

I hope that you don't end up regretting your relaxed attitude to debt. So many people do.

Chevybaby · 14/04/2023 10:24

I feel like I’m way more relaxed about debt than other commenters here. I am currently choosing not to work too much while my child is very little, for now I’d rather spend time with her gardening and making biscuits than slaving away in a room with 25 other farting swearing adults. I’ve totally adjusted my lifestyle to keep costs down but I’ve also decided to accept that I’ll need to get in a bit of debt for now too. Nothing near the 30k (or 100k 😱) mark but still it is debt. When she’s in school I’ll be back working full time and can play a bit of catch up as long as I keep up the frugality for a couple years.

re Your friends I on the whole don’t disagree with the idea of enjoy life now, worry later. I do find it shocking though that they wouldn’t compromise on an extravagant holiday so that everyone in the group could afford to come. That’s pretty strange behaviour. I’d rather be in a cheapo caravan with my friends around me than a posh resort without them. Everyone’s different I guess 🤷‍♀️

Tinkerbyebye · 14/04/2023 10:12

YANBU I am with you. I have credit cards I use, mainly for the protection they afford, but they are paid off each month. I save up to purchase stuff, do stuff, and like another op save each month towards Christmas, birthdays, put money in a pot for car service, tyres etc each month.

I don’t understand this attitude toward debt

AdeIe · 14/04/2023 10:03

I wouldnt be going into debt for it, but if I really wanted to go on the holiday (not to build friendships, but for myself and my family) then I'd go. I'd take being a bit more careful with money for a few months to have a fabulous holiday. But having been through losing my Dad and some other health shit going on that's why I feel that way. But I wouldnt be borrowing or going into debt for it.

tona79 · 14/04/2023 09:14

I've never borrowed a penny from anyone, worked my way through college, stayed at home into my 30's until I had saved enough to buy a small home outright, never had a credit card or credit agreement. Don't think I could do the stress of mounting debts growing with interest.

Alarae · 14/04/2023 09:10

I do utilise credit cards but do so responsibly- I never put anything on a card which does not have a plan to be paid off. Generally, the cards are used for cashback and paid off each month or to spread larger payments over time on 0%.

Technically speaking while we have c.£9k on a credit card it is on 0% and we have the same amount in savings to pay it off when needed. Until then, we are paying it down a little each month while our money works for us in a savings account.

I've watched my sister get saddled with a lot of debt due to her useless ex which she is only just paying off this year (she left him around 5-6 years ago) so I don't like the idea of just whacking lots of stuff on credit.

Used responsibly, credit is a useful thing. I do however appreciate some people are extremely cautious and do not wish to use credit at all which is also fine.

BertieBotts · 14/04/2023 09:02

Oblomov23 · 14/04/2023 08:58

It staggers me the way people chose to live. We earn ok, live within our means. Credit card gets paid off monthly by dd. Very occasionally I'll spread it over 2 months. My boss who has no money wants to take his kids to Disney world. £8k. We went to Majorca all inclusive for 4, for a week last Easter £1100. Why do this when you don't have £8k. I just don't get it.

How did you get AI for £1100?? I can never find anything close to that.

BertieBotts · 14/04/2023 09:01

I don't really understand why the long ramble about how your friends afford things and how you disagree with it.

YANBU to make the choice that makes sense for your family. What your friends do is not really relevant.

Oblomov23 · 14/04/2023 08:58

It staggers me the way people chose to live. We earn ok, live within our means. Credit card gets paid off monthly by dd. Very occasionally I'll spread it over 2 months. My boss who has no money wants to take his kids to Disney world. £8k. We went to Majorca all inclusive for 4, for a week last Easter £1100. Why do this when you don't have £8k. I just don't get it.

FilthyforFirth · 14/04/2023 08:56

I am probably like your friends, I have more cc debt than I should. But we are so poor paying £1k a month nursery fees. I just got a big payrise and from Jan we get our free hours.

Our debt is manageable as we earn over £100k as a household but I am looking forward to next year when we can pay it down further.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 14/04/2023 08:44

$20,000 would cost you $74,364 and would take 55 years and 9 months to pay off.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 14/04/2023 08:42

It's quite scary, but a $5,000 credit card debt (I'm in Australia) with 18% interest, making minimum payments (and not increasing the debt) will cost you $17,181 over 33 years.

33 YEARS!!!!!!

youveturnedupwelldone · 14/04/2023 08:37

I should add - I've been in a lot of debt before, paid it off (painfully) and now use debt responsibly eg I bought a car with a manageable loan and use my credit card to the extent I can pay it off monthly eg big purchases I want the protection on and already have the funds set aside.

I like to spend on things like holidays but rather than use debt I make a concerted (and also painful!) effort to increase my income to afford what I want.

I can vouch for the fact that no debt is a much better lifestyle 😊

Swipe left for the next trending thread