Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Different views about money and debt

81 replies

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 14/04/2023 05:43

So some of my friends spend around £1k over what they earn every month. They do get occasional lump sums from family members, or bonuses from work which will obviously help reduce the debt a bit. But the debt value is going up not down over time. They all have mortgages also.

For me, other than essential debts (mortgage and car finance) I try to stay out of further debt. If I do borrow money I work hard to pay off the loan. But my friends have around £20-30k debt on top of the essentials which is always increasing (they are not paying it off, just getting further and further into debt). They go on a holiday abroad every year which cost around £6k each holiday. They always have take aways and buy designer clothes etc.

I have been asked to go on a holiday abroad with them with our husbands and kids. The holiday sounds incredible and I would absolutely love to go. It would also add depth to our friendships and be a lovely bonding trip. But I don't think my family can afford it so politely declined, but said that I hope they have a lovely time on the trip. It would cost about £6k for travel and accommodation which is a lot of money for me.

My household income is less than theirs so I accept my lifestyle will look considerably different from theirs. But they we're visibly stunned when I declined. I think they think I am being tight.

I could go. But would have to be incredibly frugal with money for a very long time to pay off the holiday, which does not appeal. I also don't want to get into debt over it?

AIBU to not go? Or is it worth the money to boost the friendship and have a nice time? I can't work out if I'm just tight with money of if my friends are reckless.... or something in between!

I may suggest a cheaper holiday, but they seem to have their hearts set on this place. I wonder if I am a buzz kill.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bertiesmum3 · 30/10/2023 18:39

We’re fortunate not to have to get into debt
We go on 3/4 holidays a year and we save, it’s now only us living at home no dependents.
we’ve got a credit card and we pay for our holidays with it for security and as soon as our monthly statement comes in we pay it off immediately, I’ve got a £500 o/d on my bank account and it’s very rare I use it, unfortunately this month I booked a hotel and it’s meant to be paid on arrival but for some reason they’ve taken the money out of my account, so I kn I’m going to be using my o/d this month for 1 day and I hate knowing that!
I don’t know how people sleep at night knowing that they are in debt

muchamoon · 15/04/2023 16:13

I grew up very poor e.g. hiding with my mum from debt collectors at the door, provy cheque to pay for school shoes and winter jackets and swore I'd never get into any debt as an adult.

Then I came of age in the era of cheap credit, you know that time when banks wrote to you as soon as you hit 18 saying you'd been preapproved for a credit card or unsecured load. Well sometime in my early 20's I did get myself in a couple of thousand pounds worth of debt, paying for driving lessons, some things I needed and more still that I wanted. At the time and in my youthful stupidity the money did feel free but I really wasn't earning that much and I eventually twigged that by paying the affordable minimum payments I wasn't actually paying the debt down. I got some advice and managed to pay it all off over the next couple of years but even that small amount of debt really marred my 20's and held me back getting my masters, buying a home, travelling and so on.

Now I never have debt, I do use a credit card for the various protections it offers but I always pay off completely every month. My car is 2nd hand but paid for in cash my mortgage is paid off and I have savings. I don't think I'm mean and I have nice things but things that I think are wasteful like constant takeaways, coffee from the shops, lunches out, getting things from the shops ubered to you I don't do. Getting takeaway is a nice treat but its not once a week or even once a month.

Some people do borrow a lot and for a long time debt was cheap so borrowing might have made sense for many, I know many people who bought the most expensive house they could afford or always have car's on lease and if that works for them then that is fine but for me I like knowing that what I have is mine, that I have money in the bank for a rainy day and enough to enjoy nice things in life including holidays without any worry about debt. I agree with other posters who say it's vital that couples are on the same page about money.

fiftiesmum · 15/04/2023 13:48

My Dp's (well DM as she was financially controlling) were quite the opposite and wouldn't spend money if they could help it the house was cold and we never had fancy holidays. It was always need to save for a rainy day which never actually happened.
I don't want to be sitting in a chair in a care home with a fat bank account regretting not doing things while i was still able.

sociallydistained · 15/04/2023 13:34

I also have a friend who is in so much debt but it doesn't bother her at all. She still laughs she's paying off a holiday we took together in 2017 i was shocked at that. She's had many many since Including 3 weeks at Disney world with her kids! Her parents give her loans too whereas my mum was always in debt when I was a child and struggles now. I have to lend her money (very small amounts until payday). I think this has made me the way I am. I can't do debt at all!

Luckynumbereight · 15/04/2023 13:33

I know what you mean, OP. I don’t have any debt and I’m sitting on a reasonable amount of savings. My plan is to live the high life in a few years when I give up work, but I often worry that I will keel over before getting the chance to spend it. Perhaps I should also start living the good life now, while I still can!

ShagratandGorbag4ever · 15/04/2023 13:06

Borrowing is not always bad per se, but getting into debt for something that won't outlast the debt is a mug's game.

Blip · 15/04/2023 13:05

I always think that if you have debt you are paying a higher price for everything you buy, so overall you can have less of what you want and not more.

So for me it's aspirational to have less debt and not more debt.

1offnamechange · 15/04/2023 13:00

Eggyeaster · 14/04/2023 07:32

also these threads will only be replied to by people who have zero debt and incredibly good for money, which honestly I admire, but you probably won’t get a very balanced conversation about debt.

this.
Although to be fair the people at the other extreme end who are saying they have never even had a credit card also aren't the most financially savvy either - certainly financially responsible but using credit appropriately (i.e. when you know you can definitely pay it off) is far better than avoiding it altogether. It allows you to build up a credit rating, provides legal protection for larger purchases, and via stoozing (using 0% credit cards while saving the money in high interest bank accounts) can even make you money, all the while (again, as long as you can afford it) without risking a penny.

As other pps have said, I can also see some cases when I might think getting into debt is worth the risk - having seen the loss of quality of life (and in some cases actual loss of life) due to waiting lists for medical treatment I could justify using it to get private treatment, and long term even that might work out better financially if it allows you to work for longer.

to be honest if you'd really wanted to go on this holiday as a one off crazy treat when you're careful in every other part of your life, as you say you could afford it but would have to tighten back on other things, I think you could have justified it - going into a fairly small amount of debt for a short time with a clear plan to pay it back isn't the worse thing in the world and is unlikely to lead to you changing your whole financial view and suddenly accruing thousands more. But tbh it doesn't sound like you even want to go that much, so not really sure why you're asking if it's reasonable not to want to spend money you don't have on something you're not hugely bothered about!

DeeCeeCherry · 15/04/2023 12:49

Stop minding your friends' money business, and get on with your own. How on earth do you even know what/when they're paying towards their debts anyway?

You've already said No to the holiday and explained to your friends why. 'I'm so good, me' virtue-signalling for a pat on the back and a chance to smugly criticise your friends to incur judgment of them on here is the bonus extra. Maybe it's some kind of feelgood factor that you need. You speak as if they're in mega-debt, I know people paying off for a car or some such of that amount. So what?

You're not their friend really even if they think you are, so its a good thing you're not going on holiday with them totting up everything they spend...

HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 15/04/2023 12:46

We don't have any debt other than our mortgage (which would probably horrify you as it's about £370k!). I wouldn't go into debt for a holiday, no. But I'm baffled how you know how much your friends overspend etc. I wouldn't be able to tell you which of my friends were in debt or how much anyone spends in a month.

StrawberryWater · 15/04/2023 12:37

All of my close friends are in debt, drive fancy cars which are replaced every 2 years, go on luxurious holidays several times a year and live the high life. Credit is easy and when you have the attitude that you only have one life so should enjoy it while you can you will.

Personally I can’t live like that. I like to live within my means. I do get a bit of light hearted stick about being too sensible but honestly I don’t want to have humongous debts and a mortgage that I’m still paying off when I should be retiring (as many of my friends will be). My mortgage will be paid off by the time I’m in my early 50s and I can enjoy more of life then.

Soakitup37 · 15/04/2023 12:34

Im half and half. I’ve borrowed debt before but with a plan of paying it back. Always have done before another form of debt was picked up (if needed) borrowing can be very useful if done correctly and with careful thought about repayments and consideration for adverse consequences affecting paying it off. I’ve been able to do things and buy things I just couldn’t have done by means of saving before hand and it’s been part of some of the most wonderful memories of my life. I have access to about £40k on credit cards but they are all zero not because the temptation isn’t there ; I have fantasies about blowing a load on just everything I want but the stress it would cause stops me.

I agree though that reckless mindless debt is a fast way to getting yourself into trouble. Sticking meals, a shopping spree or random spends on a card is not a fun way to live as you’re clearly living beyond your means if you’re not able to pay it off and spending like that means you’re unlikely to just pay it off.

all that said it’s not my business how others use their ability to access credit or spend it. Some of my friends do spend as above and know they have forms of help they can tap into if they needed, usually bank of mum and dad. Sadly I don’t have those options which I think puts a clear focus on being careful with finances in a controlled way.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/04/2023 12:15

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 14/04/2023 13:20

I'd also question why somebody would be "visibly stunned" at you declining a holiday invite. I have friends with different finances to me, but we are never "visibly stunned" like this! Do you think they were trying to make you feel bad?

I'm starting to think maybe it's a bit like that friends episode where joey Rachel and Phoebe tell the others they don't have as much money as them. It surprises the others and just makes everything really awkward. Maybe I made them feel uncomfortable.

I think what's been said on here is true. Maybe my friends are able to be this way because they are aware of upcoming funds that will come in. I won't have this for a v.long time so can't.

It's difficult to have these conversations with your friends.

It is difficult. I think all you can do is explain that it isn't affordable for you so you can't come. Don't try and get them to do something else, just keep it to your own situation.

Gemstar2 · 15/04/2023 11:55

YANBU for living within your means. I think you’re right to decline a holiday you know you can’t afford, but it sounds like you feel your attitude towards money might be limiting you. How about planning something in advance that you can save up for and look forward to? Maybe invite these friends on a long weekend away (in the UK, European city break etc) in X months time? Research accommodation you can afford and suggest it to them once you know the exact price? That way you have some fun plans to look forward to, you can budget for it and so when the time comes you know it’s paid for so you can relax and enjoy it? Plus you still get quality time with your friends to make memories etc, but on terms that suit you better?

mrsbyers · 15/04/2023 11:50

I have a rule that I would never have a holiday on credit , coming back and still having it to pay for would be soul destroying and a difficult habit to get out of

skyglass · 15/04/2023 11:23

I'm in between what you describe. If an incredible opportunity came up I wouldn't immediately discount it, I would look to see how I could afford it adjusting my finances, holidays usually require a deposit before paying the full balance, I could reprioritise where my savings go (I plan my money up to 2 years in advance and have lots of pots, so that's what I mean by adjusting) I'm not averse to doing some very short term interest free borrowing so long as it's comfortably within my affordability. But it would have to be for something I really wanted to do, a holiday with a friend probably wouldn't trigger that though for me! I wouldn't just throw it on a credit card.

Bunnycat101 · 15/04/2023 11:18

You are perfectly sensible to say no to a holiday that you can’t afford. But I also think there can be good debt. I used to be firmly in the save up first and then spend camp but am now more comfortable with interest free credit or buy later deals as helpful re cash flow. Eg I booked a holiday in 2022 for 2024. I didn’t have the money available at the point of booking but I will by the time I need to pay the balance. If I can put it on an interest free credit card and then get 18m of the money earning interest then even better. The difference is I know I’m disciplined enough to not spend the money twice. I’ve had friends who have wracked up debt assuming interest free balance transfers would always be available and then getting a nasty shock when they weren’t.

Chevybaby · 14/04/2023 18:11

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/04/2023 11:50

I hope that you don't end up regretting your relaxed attitude to debt. So many people do.

i hope so too! 😂 But I’ve thought about it a lot and Id rather risk regretting a bit of debt than regretting not being around for my daughters early childhood, hence my choice.

Blondeshavemorefun · 14/04/2023 15:57

£6k for a holiday for just you is insane

And even more so to get into debt

If they all wanted you to go they would find a cheaper place

BertieBotts · 14/04/2023 15:46

Ah I see what you mean OP, sorry!

Then yes I think some people do have this attitude. I don't know if it's poor financial literacy, or whether they think they'll come into money later (inheritance?) or whether they think it's the only way they can have anything so just go the whole might as well be hung for a sheep as a lamb thing.

MrsSquirrel · 14/04/2023 14:05

And I agree it's difficult to have these conversations with friends.

MrsSquirrel · 14/04/2023 14:04

They may have seemed stunned because they assumed you are like them, then they were surprised when it turned out their assumption was incorrect.

YANBU not to go on the holiday. They are NBU to go either. It's just different attitudes and values.

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 14/04/2023 13:29

I am more like you. Debt scares me.

We have friends like yours who don’t understand why we don’t just put stuff on a credit card or finance. We don’t bloody want to!

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 14/04/2023 13:20

I'd also question why somebody would be "visibly stunned" at you declining a holiday invite. I have friends with different finances to me, but we are never "visibly stunned" like this! Do you think they were trying to make you feel bad?

I'm starting to think maybe it's a bit like that friends episode where joey Rachel and Phoebe tell the others they don't have as much money as them. It surprises the others and just makes everything really awkward. Maybe I made them feel uncomfortable.

I think what's been said on here is true. Maybe my friends are able to be this way because they are aware of upcoming funds that will come in. I won't have this for a v.long time so can't.

It's difficult to have these conversations with your friends.

OP posts:
GenialHarryGr0ut · 14/04/2023 13:11

I'm like you.
Don't have debt and save for what I want.
But I think we may be in the minority.
A couple of weeks ago a colleague announced - two days after payday- that she was ready in her overdraft.
We work in a fairly well paid profession but her desire for new things, holidays (she's been abroad three times this year) means she is always in debt.