Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A sibling or a private education?

207 replies

Evely · 14/04/2023 00:50

Posting in AIBU for voting.

DH and I discussing, it came up in conversation with family - we can see pros and cons to both sides so we're sat on the fence.

If you had 1 DC and financially could afford to send them to private school but you couldn't afford to send 2 x DC to private school - would you say it would be better to stick at one DC?

Taking into consideration that the catchment state school in your area is OK but not brilliant.

Yabu - it's more important to have a sibling than a private education

Yanbu - stick with one DC and give them the best education you can

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SilverGlitterBaubles · 19/04/2023 20:09

Neither a sibling or private education come with guarantees of happiness and success. It's a very bizarre choice and the obsession with private education being some kind of golden ticket in this country is pretty sad.

redskylight · 19/04/2023 11:28

ChocChipHandbag · 19/04/2023 09:55

@redskylight well quite, so that also includes the private school teenage kids who can also go to the park if they want to!

I don't know why you are so hellbent on pursuing the polarised narrative that private school kids live in a bubble and state school kids mix freely with all walks of life?

Why not just accept that it very much depends on the child and the parents and a large number of individual lifestyle choices, working rhythms etc. The people that we meet and mix with are determined by a lot more than where we go to school.

I have already said it depends on individuals and I was talking in generalities.

However, based on MN threads there are an awful lot of private school parents who choose private schools specifically so their children can take advantage of the wide extra curricular activities, have everything in one place and mix with the "right" peer group (they are generally but not always less vocal about the last of these).

Private schools are more likely to involve a car journey; state schools are more likely to be local.

Private school days tend to be longer than state school days.

Private schools tend to have better extra curricular provision, reducing the need to seek this out of school.

Private schools generally offer wraparound and holiday clubs so children attending them don't need to look elsewhere for childcare provision

All of those last things are facts that will reduce the amount of mixing that, in general, private school children do.

Individuals may do entirely different things. I'm not sure why you are so keen to deny that private school children in general mix with a smaller number of others? Of course, some may have huge wide ranging friendship bases, as some state school children never interact with anyone other than their very close friends, but external factors make it more likely that state school children know more others.

I also think that in general private school parents have more money than state school parents. That doesn't preclude children of millionaires going to state schools or children from less well off families going to private schools on bursaries or because grandparents are paying, and the fact these things happen doesn't make my sentence any less true.

LaLaFlottes · 19/04/2023 10:14

My DD went to a private school. She did clubs at school some nights, and external clubs other days and weekends for other sports. Met people through school and through external clubs.

Not everyone lived as close to school as maybe you would in a catchment, but a lot lived close enough that they could meet and go shopping together etc as they got older. Or they were on the same train line and would meet up.

She definitely didn't live in a bubble of private school friends only.

As she is also an only child, I was committed to making sure she had plenty of opportunities to mix, have friends over and try out different activities. She had a good and varied social life I think.

Everyone's situation is different. I worked 4 days a week, but from home, which made things easier.

I do believe that my DD reached her potential at this school. They don't have a sixth form so she then moved on to a state sixth form, although it is a particularly good one, but it's very large and was a nice stepping stone to Uni.

As long as everyone is happy with their choices for their DC, it shouldn't matter what others chose to do.

ChocChipHandbag · 19/04/2023 09:55

@redskylight well quite, so that also includes the private school teenage kids who can also go to the park if they want to!

I don't know why you are so hellbent on pursuing the polarised narrative that private school kids live in a bubble and state school kids mix freely with all walks of life?

Why not just accept that it very much depends on the child and the parents and a large number of individual lifestyle choices, working rhythms etc. The people that we meet and mix with are determined by a lot more than where we go to school.

redskylight · 19/04/2023 09:27

ChocChipHandbag · 19/04/2023 08:56

@redskylight lots and lots of state school children have parents who work and can't pick them up at 3 so they can run free and mingle in the park. Very many will be in after school club.

Again, this is a generality and clearly doesn't apply to every child.

And actually many after school care providers for state schools do mix children from different schools. Private school after school care is more normally "in house".

And at secondary school age, these children do "run free".

Davros · 19/04/2023 09:15

Have two children. Send them to private school for secondary. If they're different sexes they probably can't go to the same private school anyway and boys don't usually go until age 13.

Jonei · 19/04/2023 09:03

Well, I went to state school, walked there every day and and I can tell you that in 13 years I never once got talking to a random kid from another school on the way to and from school!

My kids both have. They've made really good friends through doing this.

ChocChipHandbag · 19/04/2023 08:56

@redskylight lots and lots of state school children have parents who work and can't pick them up at 3 so they can run free and mingle in the park. Very many will be in after school club.

redskylight · 19/04/2023 08:47

ChocChipHandbag · 19/04/2023 08:21

Well, I went to state school, walked there every day and and I can tell you that in 13 years I never once got talking to a random kid from another school on the way to and from school!

Locally, the catchments meant that people who lived near particular parks all went to the same school.

On the other hand, I was at Brownies, Guides, gymnastics and horse riding with kids who went to the local private schools.

Of course at an individual level some people will mix more with others and some won't.

But there will be at least some children who walk to school, go to the local park after school and play out in the evenings that do meet others that they don't know (and not just others from other schools - maybe others from their own school that aren't on their radar while at school). A child that does none of those things has 100% chance of not meeting anyone else.

I ran our local Brownies for 15 years. In that time we had 1 private school child. We did however, have children from 7 different local state schools. (And yes, we're in an area where state schools are very catchment based, but Brownie places were at a premium and people travelled :))

Reugny · 19/04/2023 08:44

ChocChipHandbag · 19/04/2023 08:21

Well, I went to state school, walked there every day and and I can tell you that in 13 years I never once got talking to a random kid from another school on the way to and from school!

Locally, the catchments meant that people who lived near particular parks all went to the same school.

On the other hand, I was at Brownies, Guides, gymnastics and horse riding with kids who went to the local private schools.

Not every area has or did have catchments.

My schools were done on distance and even then there was overlap. (My primary school was briefly done on catchment after I left but then they realised it was excluding certain people.)

So when I went off to play badminton, the adventure playground or hung out with school friends at secondary school there were kids from our different primary schools, their Saturday school(s) and simply lived next door to someone hanging out with us.

The people I did my A levels with were even more mixed.

My DD aged 4 is taken to a handful of playgrounds to play in. The children playing in them come from the wider local area so don't go to the same schools. And yes the children interact with one another.

ChocChipHandbag · 19/04/2023 08:21

concertgoer · 19/04/2023 07:53

Spot on !
thanks.

also applies to the adults they meet with the children at a younger age. The adults they meet at the extra activities, both with the children and running them.

it’s quite literally a widening of social circles and an ability to act within them!

Well, I went to state school, walked there every day and and I can tell you that in 13 years I never once got talking to a random kid from another school on the way to and from school!

Locally, the catchments meant that people who lived near particular parks all went to the same school.

On the other hand, I was at Brownies, Guides, gymnastics and horse riding with kids who went to the local private schools.

concertgoer · 19/04/2023 07:53

Spot on !
thanks.

also applies to the adults they meet with the children at a younger age. The adults they meet at the extra activities, both with the children and running them.

it’s quite literally a widening of social circles and an ability to act within them!

redskylight · 19/04/2023 07:43

ChocChipHandbag · 18/04/2023 23:17

And how exactly does a state school facilitate seeing different people in your daily life? They also have fixed pupil populations..might be more diverse but it's still the same people day in day out? 🤷‍♀️

Scenario 1: Private school family. The school is 35 minutes drive away and the school day runs until 4pm. There is a lot of extra curricular activities available so children are encouraged to do at least 2 a week. So 3 days a week (multiple children) they are not home until 5.30pm. As this is is already a long day and because parents are keen to minimise doing any other travelling, the children don't do any other activities out of school but focus on relaxing and school work. They don't meet other children around and about as they drive to school and they don't go to the park after school (or "hang out" when an age to do this. So interacting with other children out of school is confined to play dates with school friends.

Scenario 2 : State school family. The school is within walking distance and they meet a lot of children on the way to and from school and after school (not just children who go to their school). As they get old enough to do so they "hang out" after school and again mix with a range of children. The extra curricular provision at their school is ok but not great so they do activities out of school. The after school activities cover a wide range of children and, through those children they meet yet other children. When they get to the age of having phones, they exchange numbers and build friendships with these children even if by then they are not sharing any common activities.

Spot the difference? Of course there will be variation within specific families, but you can see how your average state school child is likely to get to know more others than your average private school child.

Bloopsie · 19/04/2023 07:06

100% sibling (s)

concertgoer · 19/04/2023 06:57

it Doesn’t. You make the effort to do that with other activities.

ChocChipHandbag · 18/04/2023 23:17

concertgoer · 18/04/2023 23:09

to expand my “cult” point. They only see the same people day in and day out. Slightly different focuses, but know expansion of knowledge, people, making friendships, building relationships, initiating conversations with new people. Being in new situations with new people. ….. all life skills !!

just move around in a herd !

And how exactly does a state school facilitate seeing different people in your daily life? They also have fixed pupil populations..might be more diverse but it's still the same people day in day out? 🤷‍♀️

concertgoer · 18/04/2023 23:09

to expand my “cult” point. They only see the same people day in and day out. Slightly different focuses, but know expansion of knowledge, people, making friendships, building relationships, initiating conversations with new people. Being in new situations with new people. ….. all life skills !!

just move around in a herd !

concertgoer · 18/04/2023 23:07

Evely · 14/04/2023 23:12

If it's a serious question I will answer it.

The specific fee paying school my DD has a spot on - is set in acres of land. It has a full climbing wall, and a sort of 'go ape' adventure play ground. The kids learn abseiling and sailing. They have their own swimming pool and tennis courts. They learn archery. It has a fantastic music department. They have one of the best technology departments in the country. It scored excellent across every inspection and won a school of the year award. Class sizes are kept at 30 - the whole school has less than 150 children. Each child has a key worker throughout school. They have a kitchen for cooking and do design and technology. The teachers and headmasters were lovely. We had a full school tour and chance to ask loads of questions and they've been lovely throughout. The reviews are fabulous everywhere all over the Internet.

The local school takes 80 kids each year per year group. It is failing in some areas. It was rated 'good' by ofsted with recommendations. It has a concrete playground, and a gym. It doesn't offer any exciting sport type opportunities, nor offers cooking or design. The reviews are not great - mostly by parents who have kids subjected to bullying.

That's the exact choice I'm facing for DD. We can't afford to send two children to the fee paying school.

It really was a genuine question.

you’ve listed facilities.

what can these facilities give your child(ren) that a state school, some other extra activities and some parental time and affection can’t?!

will these things make your child happy? Will these things make your child a nice person?
will these things help your child be a successful (however you choose to measure that!) adult?

or will it just make you feel like you’ve tried by paying for it?!

if I wanted to my children could go to private school - they don’t, because I don’t believe it’s best for them in many levels and they get so many more life experiences with it her extra curricular activities.

if you “buy” into private schools, it’s all consuming. It’ll dictate family life in its entirety leaving you little options for social life and other extra curricular activities.

you aren’t just buying an education.

you’re buying into a cult !!

my experience is based on people I know who have been to private school (are 40 & 50 and have limited amounts of common sense and knowledge of the world!).
people who have sent their children to private schools and are used to having everything done for them, can barely make a sandwich let alone cook a meal (despite the posh DT kitchens!) and have come out with 3’s & 4’s at GCSE !!

also about 50% of the teens I know who have been through or are going through private school have severe mental health issues ….. due to pressure from school. …. so not exactly making them happy in the process !!

children aren’t chickens. They don’t automatically thrive on a patch of grass & a climbing wall … they need so much more !!

im not saying it’s the wrong decision. I’m saying look at it properly. In my experience it’s not worked as well for those who have done it as they perhaps hoped !!

(I’d have one child and give them £150k when they’re 18 to buy a home! Make them content and well rounded on the way!)

CheersForThatEh · 16/04/2023 13:10

Youre comparing apples and oranges.

Unless you consider private school an absolute essential, on par with feeding and clothing your child, then it's optional and you are making a lifestyle choice.

Blaueblumen · 16/04/2023 13:04

Or better with a sibling?!

Blaueblumen · 16/04/2023 13:04

You can't know how they would have turned out without each other's influence though.

And likewise you'll never know how an only child would have turned out with siblings. I'm an only child and don't think I'd have turned out any worse with a sibling Smile

HouseByTheSeaside · 16/04/2023 12:55

illiterato · 14/04/2023 05:44

To add I have 2 DC. I think both would have been equally happy being an only child as they are both super sociable “joiners” and just find other kids to hang out with. They spend v little time together if I’m honest.

You can't know how they would have turned out without each other's influence though.

HouseByTheSeaside · 16/04/2023 12:53

Lastnightidreamtofmanderley · 14/04/2023 00:54

I think you’re concentrating on the wrong thing. Do you both want another child or not?

This.

Blaueblumen · 16/04/2023 11:42

However, I also think it's sad when people have second and subsequent children without really thinking through whether yet can afford them.

If the op had phrased her op differently -without mentioning private schools specifically- she would probably have received more balanced answers.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 16/04/2023 10:43

marseille · 16/04/2023 10:09

Is this a real thing that people choose between private school or a sibling. So sad .

Well, I agree that it's sad that people would choose not to have a child that they might dearly want just because they wouldn't be able to send their kids to private school.

However, I also think it's sad when people have second and subsequent children without really thinking through whether yet can afford them.

Balance is good!