Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH agrees with ExH

189 replies

TAmum3 · 13/04/2023 23:40

So to cut a long story short, ExH has our 2 children every other weekend - pick up is usually 5/5:30pm on Friday and Sunday drop back similar. This has been consistent for about 2yrs now, however before that it would fluctuate massive ie sat am pick up, sun am drop off - all depending on ExH schedule and what worked for him. To the point where we (me and DH) had to cancel a Venice weekend trip, numerous dinner/ friends plans etc all cancelled last minute.

ExH puts all shit on us, as his partner (who he had an affair with and subsequently caused our divorce) won’t help out at all.

Tomorrow is ExH weekend but has now messaged to say he can’t pick up until gone 7pm (then a 2.5 hour journey to his house) as he’s working late. I asked to keep plans the same as usual, as I have arrangements. He said I can drop to his partner after 5pm, provided I give them dinner. This means I’ll have to give them dinner at 3pm instead of their usual 6pm (kids are 10 &12), and I’ll still have a really long round trip. He won’t be home until 9:30/10 ish, and they don’t get on well with stepmum due to too many issues to go in to right now.

DH thinks for the sake of ExH picking up a couple of hours later, it’s not worth the argument, and that he has to work so I should be more accommodating, but I’m sick of always having no choice but to be accommodating to ExH when it’s all one sided! DH also agrees with my side but just thinks it’s a hopeless case, and can’t be bothered with the backwards/ forwards after 8 years of this. DH will still go ahead with our social plans for the evening, so doesn’t change his life.

what would you do?

Option 1 (YABU): suck it up once again, and either let ExH pick up late, or drop the kids off to their stepmum who has made it clear she’s not making food for them.

Option 2 (YANBU): keep the kids with me and if ExH can fit them in to his busy schedule at another time ie Saturday morning, then he can see them then?

or any other options I haven’t thought of?!

Just to add, he doesn’t do any extra time in school holidays, it’s always just the every other weekend, he does pay CMO maintenance payments but won’t contribute anything else financially on top ie school trips/ uniform etc.
Either way, another weekend of me cancelling my plans to suit him 🙄. It’s 2 work days a month that I expect him to be able to get to his kids at the same time, I’ve spent my entire life/ career fitting around our children and making it work, it just pisses me off!

OP posts:
80s · 14/04/2023 09:49

Sorry you picked such a dud.
I'd go for the option that was best for the kids, too. In a couple of years they won't need you there quite as constantly and you'll be freed up a little.

Nordicrain · 14/04/2023 09:38

Well I wouldn't send my kids to be with an adult who makes no secret of the fact she dislikes them and won't even give them basic care, just to prove a point to my Ex. So for me that wouldn't be an option.

I'd tell him to collect first thing saturday or not see them at all.

May09Bump · 14/04/2023 09:36

parietal · 13/04/2023 23:43

well if you want to be tough, you'd tell him that you will be going out at 5pm and will leave kids with a babysitter until 7pm and he can pay the babysitter.

I definitely wouldn't spend hours driving to his.

This is the solution I'd take - best for the kids. They don't have to sit with his partner and can have dinner at their normal time. Dad picks them up and you don't have to drive.

FrenchBoule · 14/04/2023 09:28

Keep the kids home. Don’t send them to their feckless father or his oh so hospitable wife. None of them makes your kids priority.

Get the babysitter and go out or leave them at home alone if they are mature enough.

Ask the kids if they want to go to their father so late, if not then tell it to exH to arrange pick up on Saturday. Don’t accommodate it (no dropping off or meeting half way).

Don’t give him reaction, that’s what he’s waiting for.

Take over control.

Axahooxa · 14/04/2023 09:27

I wouldn’t send my kids to have a horrible time with an unfriendly stepmum. I’d speak to them and see what they’d prefer to do. If they want to stay with you, I’d do that and cancel my social plans. Not to accommodate the ex- rather, to prioritize my kids’ wellbeing.

Kennykenkencat · 14/04/2023 09:26

If your Dh thinks you should accommodate exh why doesn’t he do the journey and drop them off

ILoveMontyDon · 14/04/2023 09:24

I'd just tell him not to bother at all.

Moveoverdarlin · 14/04/2023 09:20

I would say ‘ok no probs, Julie (stepmum) can pick them up instead at the normal time of 5.30pm on Friday. If she’s not prepared to cook for your children, that’s fine. They can either bring a frozen pizza each with them which hopefully Julie won’t mind popping in the oven. Or shall I lend you £20 to give to Julie to buy them fish and chips? Have a chat with Julie and see which would be easier for her? Let me know about the food but either way, looking forward to seeing her 5.30pm Friday.

Schnooze · 14/04/2023 09:16

Don’t show him your annoyance. That’s feeding him.

Home alone if they are sensible enough
or
He pays a babysitter. Cash on collection of children
or
Can he pick them up from your friends/their friends houses? And then you owe them a favour. Preferably one that has to put him out/embarrass him.

Iwasafool · 14/04/2023 09:14

So you were expecting him to pick them up at 5.30 and you have plans after that, he can pick them up at 7 so at worst you are leaving a 12 year old in charge for 1hr 30 mins? I don't see the problem unless there is some reason you can't trust a 12 year old to be unsupervised for 90 minutes.

Reugny · 14/04/2023 09:10

KettrickenSmiled · 14/04/2023 08:58

Option 1 (YABU): suck it up once again, and either let ExH pick up late, or drop the kids off to their stepmum who has made it clear she’s not making food for them.
This, but don't give them their supper at 3pm - pack something for them, or collect a takeaway on the way.

Or - Option Take Back Control -
PP - yes, I can’t imagine it will be long DC choose not to go anymore. They both often come home in tears, and although many backward/ forwards conversations with them and their dad, they still haven’t said they want to stop going YET
Text him that he should be putting his children first, but as he cannot even manage to be consistent for them twice a month, & they often come back upset from seeing him, that he can apply to family court if he wants to see them.

Mean it, stick to it, & never rely on him again.

Never put on a reply take me to Family Court.

Let him think of Family Court himself.

The longer it takes for him to think of it and apply the older the children get.

The older the children get the less likely a Court Order will be made to force the OP to make the children available to see their father.

Once the eldest gets to 14 then the court option is off the table for them.

KettrickenSmiled · 14/04/2023 09:04

TAmum3 · 13/04/2023 23:46

I actually thought about this so may suggest - as usual it’s late the night before his weekend and still trying to negotiate details!

Don't suggest it - just do it.
You don't need permission to provide food for your children.

And if Madam Coldheart refuses to cook it for them - that's it, no more visits to dad. Which I think is the optimum solution anyway.

KettrickenSmiled · 14/04/2023 09:02

Bunce1 · 14/04/2023 08:51

Just drop the rope. He makes and sticks to his plans or he finds solutions. He is flakey and relies on you. Just drop the rope.

That would be great, but how?

If the ex isn't there to pick up his DC, OP has no option but to either look after them herself, or footle about with his ridiculous 'solutions' ie feed them at 3pm because ex's partner won't.

It takes a special kind of woman to shag a married man, conspire with him to break up his family, then refuse to do a single small thing for his children twice a month to make their lives easier.
I'd have no compunction about putting a stop to ex's access visits.

SoupDragon · 14/04/2023 09:02

Bunce1 · 14/04/2023 08:51

Just drop the rope. He makes and sticks to his plans or he finds solutions. He is flakey and relies on you. Just drop the rope.

This doesn't really work when you are reliant on the ex aiming to pick the children up as they just won't show. Equally you can't just drop the children off as the fall out isn't fair on the children. It's difficult.

KettrickenSmiled · 14/04/2023 08:58

Option 1 (YABU): suck it up once again, and either let ExH pick up late, or drop the kids off to their stepmum who has made it clear she’s not making food for them.
This, but don't give them their supper at 3pm - pack something for them, or collect a takeaway on the way.

Or - Option Take Back Control -
PP - yes, I can’t imagine it will be long DC choose not to go anymore. They both often come home in tears, and although many backward/ forwards conversations with them and their dad, they still haven’t said they want to stop going YET
Text him that he should be putting his children first, but as he cannot even manage to be consistent for them twice a month, & they often come back upset from seeing him, that he can apply to family court if he wants to see them.

Mean it, stick to it, & never rely on him again.

Bunce1 · 14/04/2023 08:51

Just drop the rope. He makes and sticks to his plans or he finds solutions. He is flakey and relies on you. Just drop the rope.

Ireallycantthinkofagoodone · 14/04/2023 08:50

They could have their main meal midday, and take sandwiches for ‘tea’?

But I don’t understand why your ex won’t be home until 9.30 - 10. If he had planned to pick them up just after 7, presumably he had finished work then. Or does he work near your house so has a long commute?

Wheresthebeach · 14/04/2023 08:49

So the late pick up is due to his work - if this is true, the question is has he known for ages and just dropped it on you now? I get your frustrated as he sounds a dick, but is this a genuine problem for him?. Work...is work and if he can't change it then telling him to suck it up isn't going to work.

The Step Mum sounds a peach. That's a major issue, she ought to be happy to look after the kids for a few hours to facilitate his contact. So there's a problem there and yes I suspect the kids will start to ask not to go, especially as the drive is a nightmare. I bet you've got maybe 2 more years of this before the kids are just busy with their own stuff at weekends, or just don't want to go. The distance means they can't do clubs/sports/see their friends so it's really not going to be long term. I suspect if we wants to see them he'll have to drive down and fit in around their plans soon.

So from now on, if I were you, I'd assume his pick up nights were going to be a pain and try to avoid having plans on those nights, or have a babysitter lined up. yes it's a waste to have to pay a sitter if you cancel them but if the evening is important enough then that's what I'd do. A lot of your post is about his past terrible behaviour, and while it's hard to separate it all out it's easier on you if you can just focus on the pick up issues without reliving the anger over his affair and general shittiness.

Runnerduck34 · 14/04/2023 08:48

Very frustrating and sounds like a recurring pattern that's unlikely to change.
As the saying goes you can't control people's actions ,just your reaction to it- Hard as it is ,so I can see where DH is coming from.
I wouldn't do a 5 hour round trip to drop them off, particularly to a stepmum they don't like.
Their welfare has to come first.
So either a babysitter, a taxi ( at his expense) or you change your plans and hope you can regain some of your evening by getting ready so you can leave as soon as they are picked up.
If it doesn't harm the kids and he refuses to take responsibility for them by 5.30 by paying babysitter or taxi I would also ask him to drop them later to yours on Sunday.
But ultimately the kids welfare has to come first.
I think within the next couple of years they may well decide they dont want to go to dad's eow.
I do wonder whether working late on Friday is genuine or drinks after work??!!
Just be glad you're shot of him and now have a lovely DH . As DC get older you will have less to do with him.

Orangery21 · 14/04/2023 08:46

I would never send my kids away to be with people who they don’t get on with. Not safe.

Sanch1 · 14/04/2023 08:46

We have this sometimes. If we have plans I either get someone to sit with the kids until he is free or get someone else to drop them so we don't ruin our plans. It happens less these days and I just can't be arsed to argue, I do use as leverage sometimes though if we need to shuffle plans slightly.

diddl · 14/04/2023 08:45

Could they be left for a couple of hours?

Could you join the social even late?

Would your husband also go late with you?

AlexisR · 14/04/2023 08:45

TAmum3 · 14/04/2023 00:09

Good question - not sure as I try really hard to keep them from all the adult stuff but it might be time I start asking them!

At 10 and 12, yes, they are definitely old enough to be asked.

Mummyoflittledragon · 14/04/2023 08:36

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 14/04/2023 06:11

At 10 and 12 are they old enough to stay home alone for the couple of hours whilst you are out ? Either make a frozen pizza before you go or see if ex would pay for you to get them a McDonald’s or something.

I would have thought so too. I wouldn’t leave a 10 year old but the 2 children together should be ok, unless they fight or there is another issue. Failing that the suggestion upthread for him to pick them up from wherever you are sounds good. As for food, could you cook pizza and they eat it cold with other bits and bobs? Or salad / pasta salad etc?

Reugny · 14/04/2023 08:31

TAmum3 · 14/04/2023 00:09

Good question - not sure as I try really hard to keep them from all the adult stuff but it might be time I start asking them!

The 12 year old is definitely old enough to be asked - though no-one but you and other adults around them know if they are mature enough to be listened to.

The 10 year old maybe.

I know kids - now older/young adults - who refused to see their other parent after aged 10-13 due to the way they were treated on their visits to them when younger. With 2 kids the parent waited until the younger one was 11. With more kids it was each kid individually. The parent they live with would have liked them to continue to see their other parent for a variety of reasons.

Also don't take him to Court if it isn't Court ordered let him take you. Due to the backlogs by the time he bothers both kids will be old enough to have their voices heard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread