Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Drag vs cultural misappropriation

217 replies

marahippo · 13/04/2023 21:44

I'd like to preface by saying I am all for LGBQT+ rights.

However I can't see why we tolerate men pretending to dress as women with over the top make up and clothing. These are not trans men, these are men who dress up with the sole purpose to mock and humiliate for entertainment. They talk about "fannies", grab their artificial boobs, dress like no woman would really dress and make a mockery/objectify women as sexual objects.

Even the names are designed to offending- I give you a few examples:
Cheryl Hole
A'Whora
Ginger Minj

Why is this acceptable?
The days of dressing up and pretending to be a different race/culture for entertainment is now unacceptable. Why is "sexual misappropriation" different?

OP posts:
Feelinglow27 · 14/04/2023 04:04

Totally agree OP

DeeCeeCherry · 14/04/2023 03:59

Blackface and other offensive representations of oppressed groups are offensive to men

Another dumb comment. Who are you speaking for? Blackface presumably isn't offensive to Black people who aren't men in your uninformed mind it seems.

If you want to be racist just own it, no need to pretend it's all about men in dresses.

I know racists are dim but much of this thread is even beyond that. How you'll ever make any headway re your fuss about Drag when you can't even stick to the subject at hand without throwing in diversions to trip yourselves up with, God alone knows. If indeed it is really about Drag, which I doubt.

MockneyReject · 14/04/2023 03:59

'You'll find drag queens are the biggest supporters of women'.
Where is this happening?
I've not seen this. I've not noticed a significant drag queen presence at women's rights marches or protests, 'Let Women Speak' events, protesting against men in women's sports etc. Nor supporting feminists in those debates, online.

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 14/04/2023 03:54

Lordy, black face? Tell me you're white, without telling me you're white. Please don't. My kid got called the N word last week in primary school. You have no clue at all if you are comparing the two. This is embarrassing. This is white feminism does not represent all feminism. Shot like that.

DeeCeeCherry · 14/04/2023 03:49

The days of dressing up and pretending to be a different race/culture for entertainment is now unacceptable

What are you talking about? It's not versus/either or. If you can't make a point without throwing in yeah but Black people style commentary then you lack discernment.

As for your examples - Comparing White privilege in dress up costume to racism - you really don't have a clue.

Cheekymaw · 14/04/2023 03:22

Agree, OP.
Some drag used to be quite amusing.
Now it's sleazy, sexist shite.

Notarealmum · 14/04/2023 03:15

I’m interested to know what people think about ‘ladyboy’ shows - biological men who look like (generally) beautiful women - not parodying women, I wouldn’t say, or particularly comedic for that matter.

marseille · 14/04/2023 02:22

Hate drag with a passion. Men prancing about miming the words to songs they can't sing. Never seen the point.
And no it is not pro-women

roaringmouse · 14/04/2023 01:25
  • deemed unacceptable
roaringmouse · 14/04/2023 01:25

Totally agree OP. I went to a drag show once, many years ago, and found the whole sexual innuendo thing incredibly tedious. But personal taste aside, I don't understand how if 'blackface' is now deemed acceptable, 'womanface' isn't also.

Bazinga007 · 14/04/2023 01:06

Not a fan at all. It's ugly blokes dressing up as ugly women, making crap crude jokes at the expense of women.

SemperIdem · 14/04/2023 00:51

nothingcomestonothing · 13/04/2023 22:28

The days of dressing up and pretending to be a different race/culture for entertainment is now unacceptable. Why is "sexual misappropriation" different?

Because it only affects women, so it's not important. Blackface and other offensive representations of oppressed groups are offensive to men. Womanface is only insulting to women so it's just a joke/inclusive/shut up bigot. It really is that simple.

Exactly this.

maddy68 · 14/04/2023 00:37

Are you being offended for something to be offended at sake?

Ridiculous

Also cultural appropriation o don't always agree with. If a blonde person wants corn rows for a hair style then why shouldnt they? They look good !

Life has just become silly

Mangogirl12 · 14/04/2023 00:27

StaunchMomma · 14/04/2023 00:20

The sole purpose is entertainment.

The names are supposed to be funny.

Not to you, clearly, but millions do like those particular queens.

I don't find it offensive in any way, nor do I think it's anything like cultural misappropriation.

Likening drag to black face is ridiculous, IMO. Drag artists often speak about the strong women in their lives who have supported them. It's a labour of love, not hate.

The sole purpose is entertainment.

Exactly the same with the Black Minstrel shows. The audiences were laughing hard.

The names are supposed to be funny.

MOLESTIA Child,
Ann Abortion,
Miss Carriage
etc

are NOT FUNNY to any decent, normal, warm-blooded human being.

Drag artists often speak about the strong women in their lives who have supported them. It's a labour of love, not hate.

The white men who participated in Black Minstrels often spoke about the slaves in their lives and how valuable they were to them.

It is the EXACT....SAME.....THING.

And you know it. It is deeply offensive. It mocks women. You've just been too programmed to accept it, and too desensitised to make the connection.

StaunchMomma · 14/04/2023 00:20

The sole purpose is entertainment.

The names are supposed to be funny.

Not to you, clearly, but millions do like those particular queens.

I don't find it offensive in any way, nor do I think it's anything like cultural misappropriation.

Likening drag to black face is ridiculous, IMO. Drag artists often speak about the strong women in their lives who have supported them. It's a labour of love, not hate.

Rummykitten · 14/04/2023 00:04

I totally agree with the OP. Still haven’t seen anybody explain how drag/womanface is different from blackface. Simply saying “it’s just for fun” or “they aren’t intentionally mocking women” doesn’t make it acceptable. Would blackface be acceptable if the ‘performer’ promised he wasn’t racist and wasn’t aiming to mock, but was just making goodnatured jokes about harmless stereotypes? I think not.

defsilent · 13/04/2023 23:58

I find it offensive - it is certainly not in support of women.

Somebodiesmother · 13/04/2023 23:57

Mangogirl12 · 13/04/2023 23:54

The shows are not allowed anymore though are they?

But I was specifically asking what crime it would be and what that crime would entail. You can't just decide things are crimes because you don't like them.

FuckNuggets · 13/04/2023 23:55

Magentaa · 13/04/2023 23:50

@FuckNuggets If you think that’s what I was saying…then you go ahead luvvy. If you think drag is the same as black face knock yourself out!! I get some people don’t like drag but comparing it to black face/appropriation is crackers

Why is it crackers?

Mangogirl12 · 13/04/2023 23:54

Somebodiesmother · 13/04/2023 23:50

Blackface isn't a crime.

The shows are not allowed anymore though are they?

Mangogirl12 · 13/04/2023 23:53

Magentaa · 13/04/2023 23:50

@FuckNuggets If you think that’s what I was saying…then you go ahead luvvy. If you think drag is the same as black face knock yourself out!! I get some people don’t like drag but comparing it to black face/appropriation is crackers

but comparing it to black face/appropriation is crackers

No it isn't, and you know. It's the exact same thing. And you have no argument to disprove it. Both are the dominant culture or group - white men in blackface, white men in drag - mocking the oppressed group. It is exactly the same.

Pearfacebananapoop · 13/04/2023 23:52

I'm in two minds about it. Totally get the blackface comment but can't get away from the fact I do find some (not all) v funny.
I think the recent death of Paul O'Grady and how he was held with such love by the nation was really interesting, I don't think anyone has ever broken through drag like he did.
On the flip side I know a lot of women who are incredibly open minded but just despise drag. Not because of misogyny or any political view but it just totally and utterly creeps them out.

Mangogirl12 · 13/04/2023 23:51

Tomorrowisagesaway · 13/04/2023 23:48

I agree with you - it's generally intended to demene women, not to celebrate them, and, from my experienceof watching a couple of episodes of Drag Race is that they they don't tend to be that talented/entertaining.

I think the women who profess to enjoy drag have internalised misogyny and/or want to prove that they're fun and uninhibited ie not humourless feminists who won't let anyone have fun.

I think the women who profess to enjoy drag have internalised misogyny and/or want to prove that they're fun and uninhibited ie not humourless feminists who won't let anyone have fun.

Yes, the women who defend it have been so brainwashed, so desensitised to it that they actually think it's a good thing. They have no idea how they've been programmed to accept it over the years. They can't see it.

Somebodiesmother · 13/04/2023 23:50

Mangogirl12 · 13/04/2023 23:47

The same as what blackface is and counts as.

Blackface isn't a crime.

Magentaa · 13/04/2023 23:50

@FuckNuggets If you think that’s what I was saying…then you go ahead luvvy. If you think drag is the same as black face knock yourself out!! I get some people don’t like drag but comparing it to black face/appropriation is crackers