Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Drag vs cultural misappropriation

217 replies

marahippo · 13/04/2023 21:44

I'd like to preface by saying I am all for LGBQT+ rights.

However I can't see why we tolerate men pretending to dress as women with over the top make up and clothing. These are not trans men, these are men who dress up with the sole purpose to mock and humiliate for entertainment. They talk about "fannies", grab their artificial boobs, dress like no woman would really dress and make a mockery/objectify women as sexual objects.

Even the names are designed to offending- I give you a few examples:
Cheryl Hole
A'Whora
Ginger Minj

Why is this acceptable?
The days of dressing up and pretending to be a different race/culture for entertainment is now unacceptable. Why is "sexual misappropriation" different?

OP posts:
Naunet · 14/04/2023 11:11

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 11:08

I didn’t restrict it to that time period.
I proved you 100% wrong pre1918
I proved you 100% wrong post 1928
I proved you 66%, so most likely wrong for a very short interlude from 1918-1928.

You haven’t then chosen to start sea lioning about it with silly requests for evidence of the identity, sex and social status of all audience members and all drag performers. You know this is an impossible task that would likely prove you wrong anyway, but think you can get away with pretending there’s no evidence when more than enough has been posted already to prove the rule. If there was some exceptional drag show where all of the queens were rich property owners and all the audience unmarried working class women, that doesn’t make you right btw.

Yes, your example was bad. Let’s just move on from it.

Yes a drag Queen until 1996 could take off his wig and go legally rape his wife or male partner.

60% of men had the vote pre 1918 (since 1884) - prove that none were drag queens and then you’ve proved your point.

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 11:08

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:59

Nope, you restricted it to that period, not me. Please provide evidence that no drag queen ever had the vote before 1918.

Ok though, let’s go with my example of men being able to vote when women couldn’t as bad, let’s instead say a drag queen could still take off his wig go home and legally rape his wife if he wanted to. Does that make it better?

I didn’t restrict it to that time period.
I proved you 100% wrong pre1918
I proved you 100% wrong post 1928
I proved you 66%, so most likely wrong for a very short interlude from 1918-1928.

You haven’t then chosen to start sea lioning about it with silly requests for evidence of the identity, sex and social status of all audience members and all drag performers. You know this is an impossible task that would likely prove you wrong anyway, but think you can get away with pretending there’s no evidence when more than enough has been posted already to prove the rule. If there was some exceptional drag show where all of the queens were rich property owners and all the audience unmarried working class women, that doesn’t make you right btw.

Yes, your example was bad. Let’s just move on from it.

Yes a drag Queen until 1996 could take off his wig and go legally rape his wife or male partner.

Naunet · 14/04/2023 11:03

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 11:00

TheHoover · Today 09:32
“Btw drag existed in bygone ages but women’s activists were far more bothered about getting the vote..”

You said in response:
Yes, because that was yet another way in which men oppressed us. Luckily drag queens could take off their wigs, stop calling themselves she, and go cast their vote though.

I don’t think I’ve inferred anything from this. Your statement above is historically not factual at all. You didn’t have to choose to dig in and compound your error.

Im not denying men have oppressed women (that was a nasty thing to allege), I was correcting your history error. I think it’s important to get historical facts straight when it comes to oppression.

Except it’s not incorrect because they could take off their wigs and go and vote (when many women couldn’t which I didn’t even mention in what you quoted) 😂

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 11:00

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:45

Nope, you just took my comment and decided it “implied” something I didn’t mean, and now you’re saying that was an error. I guess you know what I meant better than I do though?!
Seems like you want to derail from the absolute fact that men oppressed women.

TheHoover · Today 09:32
“Btw drag existed in bygone ages but women’s activists were far more bothered about getting the vote..”

You said in response:
Yes, because that was yet another way in which men oppressed us. Luckily drag queens could take off their wigs, stop calling themselves she, and go cast their vote though.

I don’t think I’ve inferred anything from this. Your statement above is historically not factual at all. You didn’t have to choose to dig in and compound your error.

Im not denying men have oppressed women (that was a nasty thing to allege), I was correcting your history error. I think it’s important to get historical facts straight when it comes to oppression.

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:59

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:53

You were questioning me on whether there women in the audience during the 1918-1920 period when all men had the vote whilst most women had the vote.

If you want to go back to 19th century and earlier, yes women were in the audience as well then, but prior to 1918 the drag queens would not have had the vote either. So pre1918, your scenario is historically not factual at all. Post 1928 everyone has the vote, so your scenario is still historically not factual at all.

So your original scenario of a drag Queen taking off their wig and being able to vote unlike women could, cannot be applied at all pre1918 or post 1928.

This just left the period between 1918 and 1928, and your scenario omits the fact that while all drag queens could take off their wigs and go vote, so could most women. So it’s still not historically accurate. But then you’ve been trying to argue that the 2/3rd women who could vote would not be the women in the audience during this 1918-1928 period where all drag queens could vote, but a minority of women could not- which is frankly pretty desperate grasping at straws.

Just admit your example was a bad one and not historically accurate.

Nope, you restricted it to that period, not me. Please provide evidence that no drag queen ever had the vote before 1918.

Ok though, let’s go with my example of men being able to vote when women couldn’t as bad, let’s instead say a drag queen could still take off his wig go home and legally rape his wife if he wanted to. Does that make it better?

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:54

Typo in first sentence should read 1918-1928 time period not 1918-1920

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:53

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:42

The 20s is not when drag started!!

You were questioning me on whether there women in the audience during the 1918-1920 period when all men had the vote whilst most women had the vote.

If you want to go back to 19th century and earlier, yes women were in the audience as well then, but prior to 1918 the drag queens would not have had the vote either. So pre1918, your scenario is historically not factual at all. Post 1928 everyone has the vote, so your scenario is still historically not factual at all.

So your original scenario of a drag Queen taking off their wig and being able to vote unlike women could, cannot be applied at all pre1918 or post 1928.

This just left the period between 1918 and 1928, and your scenario omits the fact that while all drag queens could take off their wigs and go vote, so could most women. So it’s still not historically accurate. But then you’ve been trying to argue that the 2/3rd women who could vote would not be the women in the audience during this 1918-1928 period where all drag queens could vote, but a minority of women could not- which is frankly pretty desperate grasping at straws.

Just admit your example was a bad one and not historically accurate.

jeaux90 · 14/04/2023 10:49

I dislike the parody and humiliation of women. And whilst I wouldn't go to see drag I don't think it should be banned, it's adult entertainment.

I don't like adult entertainment being near kids though so fundamentally disagree with drag story hour or it being in school.

I think of more inclusive ways to teach children. An old person, a lesbian, a gay man reading stories would be better but no...a parody of a woman apparently is the right answer Confused

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:45

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:37

I suppose I’m focussed on it because I corrected your historical error to set the record straight on the thread and instead of going oops, my mistake L3 thanks for clarifying, you’ve decided to argue about the vote and now about the audience members with me?

Nope, you just took my comment and decided it “implied” something I didn’t mean, and now you’re saying that was an error. I guess you know what I meant better than I do though?!
Seems like you want to derail from the absolute fact that men oppressed women.

Dutch1e · 14/04/2023 10:43

It’s not punching down on women or a minority- it’s subverting the restrictions of gender.

Like fuck it subverts. Quite the opposite... drag uses the oldest trick in the book designed to humiliate women: reduce us to stereotypical caricatures then scorn us for not laughing at The Joke when the joke is us. Drag mocks our higher-pitched voices, our mannerisms, even the smell of our genitals. How nice to be able to take off those costume breasts; I sometimes wish I could also take off these intrinsic parts of my body's sex, the sex that targets me for violence, rape, dismissal, gaslighting, and lower pay. How very amusing it all is.

I won't compare drag to blackface, that's insulting to the hard work done by black civil rights activists with no help from (or outright sabotage by) white feminism. But neither will I be complicit in misogyny and the very best misogyny has traditionally come straight out of the gay male community, the birthplace of drag.

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:42

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:35

Yes women were in the audience and in the shows.

The first drag shows were usually gay men dressing as drag queens and lesbians dressing as drag kings.

It was quite the rage in the roaring 20s amongst the posh, rich, fashionable bright young things. (All women of property who had the vote).

The 20s is not when drag started!!

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:37

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:34

You missed my edit - where is the evidence that these women were the audience members? Also why are you so focused on the vote when it was just ONE of the many ways men oppressed us, or is your argument that they didn’t?

I suppose I’m focussed on it because I corrected your historical error to set the record straight on the thread and instead of going oops, my mistake L3 thanks for clarifying, you’ve decided to argue about the vote and now about the audience members with me?

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:35

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:22

Posted too soon - meant to say please show that this was the majority of the women in drag audiences. Were women even allowed to watch drag back then? Wasn’t it in men’s spaces??

Yes women were in the audience and in the shows.

The first drag shows were usually gay men dressing as drag queens and lesbians dressing as drag kings.

It was quite the rage in the roaring 20s amongst the posh, rich, fashionable bright young things. (All women of property who had the vote).

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:34

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:27

Yes when all men got the votes, most women did as well on the same day in 1918. And you’ve just confirmed that my “claim” is historically factual.

Two thirds of women is, in fact, most women.

You missed my edit - where is the evidence that these women were the audience members? Also why are you so focused on the vote when it was just ONE of the many ways men oppressed us, or is your argument that they didn’t?

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:27

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:19

Between 1918 and 1928 when all men had the vote but not all women had the vote, the drag Queen would have the vote but so would most of his female audience members

So you’re claiming when all men had the vote, so did MOST women?

In 1918 the Representation of the People Act was passed which allowed women over the age of 30 who met a property qualification to vote. Although 8.5 million women met this criteria, it was only about two-thirds of the total population of women in the UK

https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/transformingsociety/electionsvoting/womenvote/overview/thevote/

The vote is pretty irrelevant to this discussion anyway, as it’s simply one example in a long list of ways that men oppressed women.

Yes when all men got the votes, most women did as well on the same day in 1918. And you’ve just confirmed that my “claim” is historically factual.

Two thirds of women is, in fact, most women.

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:22

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:19

Between 1918 and 1928 when all men had the vote but not all women had the vote, the drag Queen would have the vote but so would most of his female audience members

So you’re claiming when all men had the vote, so did MOST women?

In 1918 the Representation of the People Act was passed which allowed women over the age of 30 who met a property qualification to vote. Although 8.5 million women met this criteria, it was only about two-thirds of the total population of women in the UK

https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/transformingsociety/electionsvoting/womenvote/overview/thevote/

The vote is pretty irrelevant to this discussion anyway, as it’s simply one example in a long list of ways that men oppressed women.

Posted too soon - meant to say please show that this was the majority of the women in drag audiences. Were women even allowed to watch drag back then? Wasn’t it in men’s spaces??

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:21

An opinion written in a coursework essay by a law student carries as much weight as any opinion on here. I found it hard going and almost bizarre like when she claims drag tells women how to dress, how to act and the practice of drag is how society imposes gender stereotypes on women. What a load of bollocks.

Naunet · 14/04/2023 10:19

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:04

Except that your scenario that a drag Queen could just take off their wig and go vote while [all of] the women in the audience could not is not representative of historical facts.

Before 1918, Drag queens were all working class/non property owners, and so they’d take off their wig and just like the women in the audience would also have no vote.

Between 1918 and 1928 when all men had the vote but not all women had the vote, the drag Queen would have the vote but so would most of his female audience members.

Between 1918 and 1928 when all men had the vote but not all women had the vote, the drag Queen would have the vote but so would most of his female audience members

So you’re claiming when all men had the vote, so did MOST women?

In 1918 the Representation of the People Act was passed which allowed women over the age of 30 who met a property qualification to vote. Although 8.5 million women met this criteria, it was only about two-thirds of the total population of women in the UK

https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/transformingsociety/electionsvoting/womenvote/overview/thevote/

The vote is pretty irrelevant to this discussion anyway, as it’s simply one example in a long list of ways that men oppressed women.

jellyfrizz · 14/04/2023 10:17

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:10

Erm, you do know that gender stereotypes are social constructs right? That a costume reflecting the biology of the sexes, ie boobs or fake penis, is not and cannot ever be a statement regarding gender stereotypes one way or another?

They’re not pretending to be women because their characters are purposely too outrageous to be like any real woman ever. 🙄

So the fake boobs are not about gender stereotypes AND also not about pretending to be women?!

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:12

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 14/04/2023 10:08

Blackface literally was comedy for white people.

That’s your point? You are saying that because blackface was comedy for white people and Drag can also be comedic, then drag is just like blackface?

This is called a false equivalency.

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:10

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 14/04/2023 10:06

How is fake boobs subverting gender stereotypes?

They’re pretending to be - and taking the piss out of - women.

Erm, you do know that gender stereotypes are social constructs right? That a costume reflecting the biology of the sexes, ie boobs or fake penis, is not and cannot ever be a statement regarding gender stereotypes one way or another?

They’re not pretending to be women because their characters are purposely too outrageous to be like any real woman ever. 🙄

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 14/04/2023 10:08

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:07

No it’s not at all “how blackface was justified and legitimised” that is a spectacular piece of historic ignorance and lack of ability to reason.

Blackface literally was comedy for white people.

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:07

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 14/04/2023 09:55

I don’t think it’s right to dictate how one breaks gender stereotypes. I see nothing wrong with doing it through comedy and fashion acts. It’s obvious that Drag Queens and Kings are not trying to pass as a real woman/man, that’s why it’s got added drama and is more outrageous than what a real woman/man would wear. It’s part of the comedy factor and a costume that pokes fun at gender stereotypes for dress and makeup.

But this is exactly how blackface was justified and legitimised. These exact arguments.

No it’s not at all “how blackface was justified and legitimised” that is a spectacular piece of historic ignorance and lack of ability to reason.

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 14/04/2023 10:06

L3ThirtySeven · 14/04/2023 10:05

I disagree. Because it is obviously a man underneath the costume.

How is fake boobs subverting gender stereotypes?

They’re pretending to be - and taking the piss out of - women.

Swipe left for the next trending thread