Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nursery issue - Toddler was told not to tell me

132 replies

crimsonpeak · 13/04/2023 20:48

What would you do in this situation?

DD (2) is a lively, chatty and happy little girl. After I picked her up from nursery today she told me that another little girl had hit her on the hand with a toy and that she had told the little girl that she was going to tell me about what she had done. She then said a member of staff had told her not to tell me.

So - a nursery worker told my child not to tell
me about an upset at nursery. I am not concerned about the ‘incident’ - neither child was injured, kids snatch and bash, it’s what they do and it’s our job to help them develop into kind and thoughtful adults. My concern is that my DD was told not to tell me about it. I think in any context this is not the right thing to be saying to a child, whether you think the incident was minor or otherwise.

I raising my DD to know that she is to come to me and tell me if anything has upset her. If someone has hurt her etc. I have my own history of childhood trauma so it is very important to me that my child knows that she can come to me, always. I was told not to tell about what was happening to me as a child and I didn’t and things got very bad for me.

I have spoken to nursery who seem more concerned about my child’s behaviour towards the other girl than about my concerns that they have told a child not tell their mother something that upset them. They said my child put their finger in the other girls face and was unkind and made the other girl cry. I said I didn’t condone that but that was not my main issue.

The manager said they want to talk to my child about how to be kind at nursery and I have said I am fine with this but I also want to be present to reiterate that she can come to me and tell me anything. I now feel this is too much and what actually should have happened is at the time of the ‘incident’ the staff should have said what she did was not right but that she could talk to me about it, of course. The manager described my child as wilful and that if she was male she probably wouldn’t have responded with such upset - to which I said that I know my child is ebullient and I don’t want her to be inappropriate with other kids but also I do feel that as soon girls are told too young that they need to ‘be kind’ and effectively smile and suck it up.

AIBU? What would you do now in my shoes? I feel very upset about it but also relieved that my little one was able to tell
me about it.

OP posts:
canonlydoblue · 13/04/2023 23:54

She's been there for two years without incident and you're wanting to remove her because she was told not to tell tales? Is this the approach you'll take towards her schooling as well?

crimsonpeak · 13/04/2023 23:52

saraclara · 13/04/2023 23:47

No nursery can completely align with every parents views on eveything. For starters one parent's views won't align with another's. And they have a lot of children and parents to satisfy.
The only person who can look after her in a way that aligns with your views, is you.

I once saw an ad on the pinbard at my local baby cilnic. It was from a mum looking for a childminder for her one year old (the same age as mine at the time). She literally listed every single thing that she wanted her childminder to do. From morning until evening, her child had to be treated, practically and emotionally, exactly as her mother wanted. It was really quite an insane list. It also meant that the minder couldn't look after any other children (nap times specified to the minute, and overlapping any school or playgroup pick up time). 35 years later I still remember it, and wonder how that child turned out.

It is absolutely not unreasonable to expect that my child’s caregivers support my view on my DD being able to confide in me. That is basic safeguarding. I am my DDs advocate and that’s just the way it is.

OP posts:
crimsonpeak · 13/04/2023 23:51

RobinaHood · 13/04/2023 23:43

I think you have to remove your DC. There are so many issues with their response. They shouldn't have told her not to tell you. They shouldn't have been defensive when you raised it as an issue. They absolutely shouldn't have tried to distract you from the issue by turning it into a problem with your DD's behaviour when they obviously hadn't planned to contact you to discuss your DD's actions. And the sexist comment is the icing on the cake.

Thankyou. On reflection when I picked her up today the nursery worker in question told me she had been ‘emotional’ and didn’t elaborate. I said maybe she was tired as she woke up around 5.30am today and she didn’t volunteer any other information - and then a queue was forming behind me with other parents wanting to collect their children so I left it there. My DD was happy to see me and in good spirits, as she usually is when I collect her. I am sad to be considering moving her as I don’t want to uproot her and as I posted earlier I was very happy with their pre-school provision but the managers response today gives me pause.

The manager also said that my DS probably wouldn’t have reacted in this way due to him being a boy - totally unnecessary comment and not right to bring my DS into it as he no longer attends nursery (he’s at school now).

She also said she would be talking to my DD about her behaviour and that’s when I said I would also be present - as it needs to be reiterated by staff that my DD can tell
me anything - but in all
honesty, if I went to such a meeting and then left her in their care - what would they be like towards her and what would they say to her? I just feel like it’s an untenable situation the more I think about it.

OP posts:
saraclara · 13/04/2023 23:47

No nursery can completely align with every parents views on eveything. For starters one parent's views won't align with another's. And they have a lot of children and parents to satisfy.
The only person who can look after her in a way that aligns with your views, is you.

I once saw an ad on the pinbard at my local baby cilnic. It was from a mum looking for a childminder for her one year old (the same age as mine at the time). She literally listed every single thing that she wanted her childminder to do. From morning until evening, her child had to be treated, practically and emotionally, exactly as her mother wanted. It was really quite an insane list. It also meant that the minder couldn't look after any other children (nap times specified to the minute, and overlapping any school or playgroup pick up time). 35 years later I still remember it, and wonder how that child turned out.

melj1213 · 13/04/2023 23:47

I think you're totally ignoring the nuance of a situation by saying never tell a child not to tell their parent something, no matter the circumstances as there are often times it is appropriate to say words to the effect of "You don't need to tell mummy" without meaning "Don't breathe a word of this to your parent at all" but more "It's something that can be dealt with here and now, you don't need to tell mummy later as it will have been dealt with appropriately at the time by the people currently in charge". You're doing your child a disservice to make her think that she can't be corrected if she uses "I'm telling!" as a way to threaten/intimidate other children.

  • Child gets hit accidentally but with no lasting damage and then threatens the other child with words to the effect "I'm telling my mummy on you!" whilst pointing in their face
  • The other child, who didn't do it maliciously and who is upset at hurting another child and being threatened gets upset
  • The staff member who saw it all happen and has checked over the injured child and can see there is no injury or cause for concern tries to diffuse the situation. "No, we don't need to tell mummy, I'm here to sort it out. It was an accident, Jenny needs to remember to be more careful with the toys and Sarah needs to remember to use your kind words. Jenny can you say sorry for hitting Sarah with the train? ... Sarah can you say sorry for using unkind words to Jenny? ... Lovely, shall we all go and read a story?"

That is a totally acceptable use of "don't tell mummy" as they aren't saying that your child should never tell you anything, they're trying to teach your child that she can't use "telling mummy" as a threat to other children.

That is totally different to if they said "We don't need to tell mummy you fell off the top of the climbing frame" or "Don't tell mummy that Sarah repeatedly bashed you over the head with a toy train because there wasn't enough staff in the room to supervise you adequately" because they're trying to cover up a safeguarding issue or an injury caused by their negligence.

crimsonpeak · 13/04/2023 23:44

Margot78 · 13/04/2023 23:38

Sounds like your daughter hurt the other girl first and then threatened to tell on the other girl when she retaliated. The nursery worker quite rightly pulled her up on it. Happens a lot with two year olds. I think you’ve essentially misunderstood what the worker was saying and I’m sorry but over reacting a little. Spats between two year olds are very common.

Read the thread. The worker and my child’s account were the same. The other little girl hit my child on the hand with a wooden shape sorter. My daughter put her finger in her face and said she would tell me about what happened. The nursery worker said don’t tell mummy. I am sure they said that as in their eyes there was no need to do so but I have shared my concerns on this numerous times above.

Of course I don’t disagree that the worker should have intervened, but telling my daughter not to tell me about what happened is not on. I am a mother of two and know very well how common these spats are. I feel like a referree some days!

OP posts:
RobinaHood · 13/04/2023 23:43

I think you have to remove your DC. There are so many issues with their response. They shouldn't have told her not to tell you. They shouldn't have been defensive when you raised it as an issue. They absolutely shouldn't have tried to distract you from the issue by turning it into a problem with your DD's behaviour when they obviously hadn't planned to contact you to discuss your DD's actions. And the sexist comment is the icing on the cake.

WhoWhatWhenWhereWhyHow · 13/04/2023 23:40

Sugargliderwombat · 13/04/2023 22:13

Sounds like your child is maybe using you as a threat 😆 which obviously isn't nice for the other child, I can see how a member of staff would try to diffuse this by saying that they didn't need to tell you anything.

This. As a teacher for many years, I think this is what happened. You sound like a parent who is hard work, OP.

crimsonpeak · 13/04/2023 23:39

PollyPeptide · 13/04/2023 23:35

From your posts, I can't see how you can leave her in the nursery. You now have the belief that the staff and the manager are happy to tell your daughter that she shouldn't tell her mummy things. And you fundamentally disagree with that. You will always wonder from now on if your child's version of any event is being influenced by the staff. To not remove her is just going to leave you with a constant question mark over everything that happens there. That would be a poor situation for all three of you.

Thankyou. I am sleeping on it tonight but yes, in all honesty how can I now trust them to look after her in the way that aligns with my own views?

OP posts:
Margot78 · 13/04/2023 23:38

Sounds like your daughter hurt the other girl first and then threatened to tell on the other girl when she retaliated. The nursery worker quite rightly pulled her up on it. Happens a lot with two year olds. I think you’ve essentially misunderstood what the worker was saying and I’m sorry but over reacting a little. Spats between two year olds are very common.

BombasticSideEye · 13/04/2023 23:36

God this place is weird sometimes. How can a two year old "threaten" another by saying they're telling their mummy? Language matters.

Genuinely shocked that so many posters cannot see how completely inappropriate it is for a nursery worker to tell a child not to tell their parent something. It actually doesn't matter whether the nursery were sorting it out themselves, no child should be discouraged from telling their parents something even if something small, that is safeguarding 101, anyone working with kids should know this.

OP- years ago, I removed my child from her first nursery because one day I went to pick her up and was told she hadn't been allowed to have a special biscuit at tea time because she'd "been naughty" Hmm by hitting another child. She was 18 months old at the time. Go with your gut.

PollyPeptide · 13/04/2023 23:35

From your posts, I can't see how you can leave her in the nursery. You now have the belief that the staff and the manager are happy to tell your daughter that she shouldn't tell her mummy things. And you fundamentally disagree with that. You will always wonder from now on if your child's version of any event is being influenced by the staff. To not remove her is just going to leave you with a constant question mark over everything that happens there. That would be a poor situation for all three of you.

crimsonpeak · 13/04/2023 23:30

quickchangeof · 13/04/2023 23:25

I think it's good you've asked for other views to try and weigh up your own response, but you must listen to your gut. Something was said to your daughter that completely transgressed your boundary lines of how you need to protect and nurture her.

That's one issue.

The second issue is how the nursery responded when you raised it with them. Turning it into a finger-pointing dynamic by suddenly raising your daughter's behaviour, when this has never previously been mentioned to you, is pretty revolting. This nursery is not thinking about your child or any other, but about their own backs.

Listen to your gut.

Thankyou - I really appreciate your considered response. My DH said he felt their response was very defensive. I did call at 15 minutes before closing so perhaps they were feeling quite fraught and I imagine quite keen to go home after a long day. I think I will get more idea about their position on things tomorrow morning.

OP posts:
Mossstitch · 13/04/2023 23:28

ClairDeLaLune · 13/04/2023 23:07

Suppose your child was being abused and the abuser told her not to tell Mummy. It’s completely unacceptable to tell her not to tell you things. She should be able to tell you everything.

Report to Ofsted, it’s a possible safeguarding issue.

Also, the manager made a sexist remark.

Glad someone else picked up on the managers comments re boys.............they need some equality & diversity training as well as safeguarding training!

crimsonpeak · 13/04/2023 23:26

LizzieSiddal · 13/04/2023 23:21

@crimsonpeak I’d love to know what you think the nursery should do with a child who is threatening another child with “I’m telling my mummy on you” whilst pointing her finger in the other child’s face.

I will be discussing this with nursery. Obviously I don’t want my child to be aggressive towards other children. I want to know more about the circumstances leading up to what happened. I have seen my little girl at play with others and beyond the typical snatching there has been nothing to raise my concerns about her social development, and nursery have never raised any issues previously. I also want to know what nursery will be doing in the future to appropriately respond to minor events of this nature.

OP posts:
quickchangeof · 13/04/2023 23:25

I think it's good you've asked for other views to try and weigh up your own response, but you must listen to your gut. Something was said to your daughter that completely transgressed your boundary lines of how you need to protect and nurture her.

That's one issue.

The second issue is how the nursery responded when you raised it with them. Turning it into a finger-pointing dynamic by suddenly raising your daughter's behaviour, when this has never previously been mentioned to you, is pretty revolting. This nursery is not thinking about your child or any other, but about their own backs.

Listen to your gut.

Flubby65 · 13/04/2023 23:23

At our setting we tell parents if there’s been a significant incident between their child and another but explain that we can’t identify which other child was involved (9 times out of 10 the child will tell their parent/s who it was anyway and we can’t do anything to prevent that). Unfortunately we occasionally get kids who make things up about other children and we get accused of not telling parents of ‘incidents’ that haven’t actually happened. But your child shouldn’t have been told not to tell you if something happened to her.

crimsonpeak · 13/04/2023 23:21

saraclara · 13/04/2023 23:14

another little girl had hit her on the hand with a toy

..and we don't know what size or weight of toy, and whether it was purposeful or accidental, and if it caused even a mark.
The person saying an incident form needs filling in every time such an incident occurs is being ridiculous. It could hav ebeen a plastic toy teaspon that the other girl tapped her with deliberately, or it could be a full sized wooden abacus that she hit her with accidentally.

For clarification it was a wooden shape sorter. My DD said it hurt at the time but feels fine now.

OP posts:
LizzieSiddal · 13/04/2023 23:21

@crimsonpeak I’d love to know what you think the nursery should do with a child who is threatening another child with “I’m telling my mummy on you” whilst pointing her finger in the other child’s face.

saraclara · 13/04/2023 23:20

How would you feel about a child threatening yours, OP? Because this behaviour at 2 leads to bullying if not corrected.

LizzieSiddal · 13/04/2023 23:18

Good lord - I understand that. I know they were taking issue with my daughter but to tell her that there was no need to tell me is MY issue. She shouldn’t be given the message by caregivers that she shouldn’t tell her mummy something.

So you think the nursery worker should sit by and watch your DD tell another child they are going to tell their mummy on them? There’s absolutely nothing wrong with that worker telling your child that they should not be threatening another child in that way.

saraclara · 13/04/2023 23:18

crimsonpeak · 13/04/2023 23:12

Good lord - I understand that. I know they were taking issue with my daughter but to tell her that there was no need to tell me is MY issue. She shouldn’t be given the message by caregivers that she shouldn’t tell her mummy something.

She issued a threat to the other girl. The staff member handled it correctly in telling her not to carry out that threat.
Why did DD say that she'd 'tell on her' to you? Because she wanted to frighten her and make her worry that you'd tell her off. That's how kids do threats. The staff member was right to tell her not to threaten the other girl.

Justdontbejudgy · 13/04/2023 23:17

Livelovebehappy · 13/04/2023 23:09

Come on, toddlers push and hit out at each other all the time. You really wouldn’t expect an incident form to be completed every time it happens would you?

If my child later told me they were hit at nursery I would. I've had to sign forms where they've been the "victim" and "perpetrator " , where it's been significant enough for a child to mention it afterwards , it's significant. So yes, put it on the record.
On second read, I'm way more concerned about the "not telling Mummy" element, what else then slips into that bracket?
I place my kid in nursery all day, I'd like to know about any incident that they were clearly still thinking about the later that day. Welfare of the child is paramount

crimsonpeak · 13/04/2023 23:16

ClairDeLaLune · 13/04/2023 23:07

Suppose your child was being abused and the abuser told her not to tell Mummy. It’s completely unacceptable to tell her not to tell you things. She should be able to tell you everything.

Report to Ofsted, it’s a possible safeguarding issue.

Also, the manager made a sexist remark.

Thankyou. This was exactly my experience. I suppose someone will now accuse me of being triggered etc and therefore being over sensitive but in reality I am just a mother who wants her little girl to know that she can come to me with anything. I don’t want her to be alone with her thoughts (in any circumstance) like I was.

OP posts:
Wetnwindy · 13/04/2023 23:14

HNRTFT but a complete storm in a teacup …a non event! Toddlers are the reason they are called toddlers!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread