Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu: the new Vanish advert makes autistic teens look like assholes

264 replies

Squirrefromthewirrell · 13/04/2023 16:47

Just seen the new (at least to me) vanish detergent advert. It focuses on an autistic teen girl called Ash who has a favourite hoodie. All through the add the character is just displaying awful behaviour that even being autistic doesn't excuse (shouting at siblings to shut up, having a go at someone who accidentally walks into her, playing drums whilst her family are trying to spend time together)

Am I wrong to think it's just showing a very unsavoury side ? The overall message is lovely - extend the life of familiar clothes that can comfort people like ash who are autistic but the actual advert just rubbed me the wrong way

OP posts:
LysHastighed · 13/04/2023 19:02

Since this is an advert, it could garner a huge amount of negative attention and BBC still be considered a success if more Vanish is sold.

Alexandra2001 · 13/04/2023 19:02

Wow! what a powerful advert!

Just watched the full version, in tears.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 13/04/2023 19:02

Teenagers do those things even when not autistic....

I think it was a weird idea because it acted like their specific brand of detergent was helping autistic teens loads. Very self aggrandising.

But I didn't mind the portrayal.

Boomboom22 · 13/04/2023 19:00

A few points here.

Just because a behaviour us caused by autism does not make it Ok and siblings and other classmates should not have to just put up and shut up as some parents on here seem to think. The autistic child also needs strategies to manage not just everyone around them. Sen schools should be vastly expanded tbh as what nt kids have to cope with, especially in primary, is completely unacceptable. Eg chairs being thrown and extreme violence, whole classes evacuated daily for safety, and there is no way for the school to keep them safe as the minority are prioritised every time. This cannot just be ignored and does nothing to help acceptance and tolerance.

MoMandaS · 13/04/2023 19:00

MrsDoylesDoily · 13/04/2023 18:55

Ridiculous though to compare it to living with an abusive parent.

Absolutely ridiculous, yes, and very naive /uninformed/ lacking experience to suggest that children who have disabilities that make them wheelchair users don't also display 'challenging' behaviour.

42isthemeaning · 13/04/2023 18:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hmm interesting point of view. Hmm
My dd is one of the silent majority who has to put up with others' poor behaviour - she's autistic.

MrsDoylesDoily · 13/04/2023 18:58

“The film was truly a co-production with Ash and the family – I wanted it to be their voice. Everything in the film is based on Ash and the family’s experience of living with autism. The script was completely rewritten to reflect their lived experience, and we used improvisation on set throughout so that I could capture their voices. Ash’s mum has a background in stage acting, but Ash’s dad and her sister Lily were also acting here for the first time. Even Ash’s two friends in the school scenes were played by her actual best friends – also non-actors!

Interesting info here from the makers of the advert.

MrsDoylesDoily · 13/04/2023 18:55

SeulementUneFois · 13/04/2023 18:53

@MoMandaS

It's not ableist to say a child living in fear in one's home, and walking on eggshells, is living in an abusive environment.

Ridiculous though to compare it to living with an abusive parent.

IncompleteSenten · 13/04/2023 18:54

You need to rethink your attitude of autism doesn't excuse bad behaviour.

It's not bad behaviour.

It's behaviours that occur as a result of the person's autism.

Sensory overload causing meltdown for example.

You see 'bad behaviour'. Oh they're shouting and throwing things or yelling or lashing out. Tsk tsk what bad behaviour. Autism is no excuse for that...

I see a person with autism being completely overwhelmed and reacting in very typical and well documented ways that are wholly a result of their disability.

SeulementUneFois · 13/04/2023 18:53

MoMandaS · 13/04/2023 18:45

You seem to have a very narrow understanding of what constitutes a disability, and it's incredibly ableist to insist that living with an autistic person is living in an abusive environment.

@MoMandaS

It's not ableist to say a child living in fear in one's home, and walking on eggshells, is living in an abusive environment.

MotherofBingo · 13/04/2023 18:52

I actually really related to a lot of it which is odd because you don't usually see it being portrayed on TV, particularly not like that. I think if you dont really understand what shes going through, maybe it can come across as horrible but certain things like the shouting at her siblings to shut up - if there's too much noise around me, it can feel like someone is jamming knitting needles into my ears and like my skin is peeling from my bones and I can't breathe so that can be expressed as anger. Its not anger its just unbearable especially when you can't escape. With the person bumping into her, again when it's crowded and busy and loud and bright it's confusing and really disorientating and scary, so someone bumping into you just feels awful because your on high alert anyway. Well at least that's how it is for me - my mum did call me an arsehole and a bitch and an evil cow and all manner of other names growing up, I was always called a drama queen and laughed at when I got upset about things and called crazy and insane. So yeah, I think a lot of people can have that perception but feeling like that isn't easy.

EdwardTeachBornOnABeach · 13/04/2023 18:50

I have an ASD son and he has terrible self esteem issues related to his diagnosis. I have had to turn the tv over quickly if that ad comes on as I know it would make him feel 10 x worse to see that his ASD could be viewed that way to others.
I’m all for more representation but the ad does focus on the negative behaviours and impacts on the family a bit too much.

MrsDoylesDoily · 13/04/2023 18:47

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 13/04/2023 18:45

It annoyed me because my daughter is not a genius. She isn't getting all the answers correct in class in record speed . She is actually behind due to school attendance and her anxiety. She would never put her hand up and draw attention to herself. A lot if girls with autism wouldn't put their hand up.

I think it runs the risk of stereotyping to Sheldon and Rainman. While this can be the case particularly as it is harder to diagnose in girls.

Some people may think oh can't be my child they aren't clever. I think this is worrying. Though obviously some kids are clever. Some are average or behind due to attendance struggles.

I hear what you're saying.

Perhaps (hopefully) that might be their next ad.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 13/04/2023 18:47

SwedishEdith · 13/04/2023 18:13

Have seen this quite a few times but never clocked it was for Vanish. The drums though. I understand the need for a coping outlet and that the ad is showing that may bug the rest of the family if it just happened like that when everyone else is watching telly. But, I'm assuming, there'd be some parental intervention to explain why that's not appropriate now?

Yes agreed @SwedishEdith .

On the one hand, great that there is more visibility for young autistic women. But I found its portrayal really quite negative and ended up feeling sorry for her siblings and wondering why some behaviours weren't addressed by her parents - eg the drumming.

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 13/04/2023 18:45

It annoyed me because my daughter is not a genius. She isn't getting all the answers correct in class in record speed . She is actually behind due to school attendance and her anxiety. She would never put her hand up and draw attention to herself. A lot if girls with autism wouldn't put their hand up.

I think it runs the risk of stereotyping to Sheldon and Rainman. While this can be the case particularly as it is harder to diagnose in girls.

Some people may think oh can't be my child they aren't clever. I think this is worrying. Though obviously some kids are clever. Some are average or behind due to attendance struggles.

MoMandaS · 13/04/2023 18:45

SeulementUneFois · 13/04/2023 18:41

@MoMandaS

No it's not like with other disabilities.
If a sibling is in a wheelchair chair, there may physical adaptations to the house. Less money to go around. Possibly less parent time for their sibling. Fewer family activities that they can go to.

But not the overwhelming feeling of fear in one's home. Of having to walk on eggshells. Of being in an abusive environment.

You seem to have a very narrow understanding of what constitutes a disability, and it's incredibly ableist to insist that living with an autistic person is living in an abusive environment.

LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus · 13/04/2023 18:44

And as for siblings, my children have an amazing awareness of ND and are unlikely to come out with a load of crap that's spouted on here. I am very proud of them for that. But it is hard on them too. It's hard on all of us, which is why we all need understanding and awareness.

MrsDoylesDoily · 13/04/2023 18:44

Smokingonthestairs · 13/04/2023 18:33

Yep and I see the similarities. These siblings are often scared in their own home , they’re reluctant to bring friends over , their own needs are secondary. A teenager that is liable to kick off and become aggressive / violent over small things is high risk, so the usual normal parts of teen life become very hard for the siblings, and for the rest of the family to arrange. How to leave a sibling safely home alone with the other child for instance, knowing they could explode over any teeny thing. Serious questions, what is put in place after diagnosis to protect other children in the family, and allow them to live a life in safety and without feeling frightened ?

But that's nothing like living with an abusive parent.

Abusive parents choose to abuse. No child chooses to be autistic.

Yes it can be scary growing up in a house with a sibling that's prone to outbursts, no matter what the reason for them.

There's absolutely not enough help out there, so teaching coping strategies is yet another thing that's left to the parents.

SnarkyBag · 13/04/2023 18:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Not all teenagers with autism are time consuming and hard work just like not all those who teach FE are cunts.

having just had parents evening for my autistic teen I was blown away by how many teachers referred to him as one of the most valuable members of their class. He’s not academic at all but his enthusiasm and kind nature is highly valued by his teachers so no need to feel sorry for his peers.

If you don’t want people to infer the the wrong thing from your posts then don’t post such sweeping and harmful statements about children with disabilities.

SeulementUneFois · 13/04/2023 18:41

@MoMandaS

No it's not like with other disabilities.
If a sibling is in a wheelchair chair, there may physical adaptations to the house. Less money to go around. Possibly less parent time for their sibling. Fewer family activities that they can go to.

But not the overwhelming feeling of fear in one's home. Of having to walk on eggshells. Of being in an abusive environment.

LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus · 13/04/2023 18:41

Some awful comments on here, especially from a teacher for fuck's sake. Can't you see that 'the system' isn't made for autistic people? No wonder our autistic kids find life so hard. So much ignorance. I have a ND family inc teens. It's great to have this representation and I don't feel like we're so 'abnormal' now.

YunaBalloon · 13/04/2023 18:38

I've only seen it once (and the extended version I think) and I thought it was brilliant. I wasn't aware they weren't actors, it's so well done.

MoMandaS · 13/04/2023 18:38

Smokingonthestairs · 13/04/2023 18:33

Yep and I see the similarities. These siblings are often scared in their own home , they’re reluctant to bring friends over , their own needs are secondary. A teenager that is liable to kick off and become aggressive / violent over small things is high risk, so the usual normal parts of teen life become very hard for the siblings, and for the rest of the family to arrange. How to leave a sibling safely home alone with the other child for instance, knowing they could explode over any teeny thing. Serious questions, what is put in place after diagnosis to protect other children in the family, and allow them to live a life in safety and without feeling frightened ?

There's nothing put in place for siblings, just as there's nothing put in place for the autistic child. What do you imagine this would look like? Families will do their best for all their children, but the impact on siblings is unavoidable, just as it is for those families living with any other disability. There is a charity called Young Sibs, in case useful for anyone in this situation who isn't aware.

Motheranddaughtertotwo · 13/04/2023 18:38

The fact that the advert has incited discussion means some people might learn something from it, it’s raising awareness in lots of ways.
I have worked with children with ASD for over 20 years and have a child with it too so I speak from experience and would like to reply to the many people saying that drums were unrealistic they absolutely are a realistic way for many people to cope. My child is sensory seeking so when he’s exhausted, when he’s distressed he needs noise and to burn off energy. As a baby he would only fall asleep to loud, fast music.
Girls are hugely under diagnosed and mask more than boys so I think it’s great that this teen has shown her story.

Smokingonthestairs · 13/04/2023 18:33

Yep and I see the similarities. These siblings are often scared in their own home , they’re reluctant to bring friends over , their own needs are secondary. A teenager that is liable to kick off and become aggressive / violent over small things is high risk, so the usual normal parts of teen life become very hard for the siblings, and for the rest of the family to arrange. How to leave a sibling safely home alone with the other child for instance, knowing they could explode over any teeny thing. Serious questions, what is put in place after diagnosis to protect other children in the family, and allow them to live a life in safety and without feeling frightened ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread