Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu: the new Vanish advert makes autistic teens look like assholes

264 replies

Squirrefromthewirrell · 13/04/2023 16:47

Just seen the new (at least to me) vanish detergent advert. It focuses on an autistic teen girl called Ash who has a favourite hoodie. All through the add the character is just displaying awful behaviour that even being autistic doesn't excuse (shouting at siblings to shut up, having a go at someone who accidentally walks into her, playing drums whilst her family are trying to spend time together)

Am I wrong to think it's just showing a very unsavoury side ? The overall message is lovely - extend the life of familiar clothes that can comfort people like ash who are autistic but the actual advert just rubbed me the wrong way

OP posts:
WhiteFire · 13/04/2023 21:45

eloquent · 13/04/2023 21:41

You really believe a brand has done this for altruistic reasons?

Perhaps I'm just cynical.

Also 'surrounded' by autism all my life. Being AuDHD 🙄

I'm cynical too.

Tomorrowisagesaway · 13/04/2023 21:43

I found it very moving - sets out the huge challenges which Ash, her parents and her sister face, and didn't sugar coat the condition.

I did feel a lot for her sister - a friend has a son with behavioural difficulties and his sister has missed out a lot, and been exposed to some chaotic behaviour.

eloquent · 13/04/2023 21:41

DeadbeatYoda · 13/04/2023 21:16

Or is it a company using their advertising budget to highlight a a serious problem in our understanding of autism in girls? I have been surrounded by autism all my life and now work in the sector with autistic teens. I'm certainly pleased to see this campaign.

You really believe a brand has done this for altruistic reasons?

Perhaps I'm just cynical.

Also 'surrounded' by autism all my life. Being AuDHD 🙄

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 21:33

But you can't expect people to put up with sheer rudeness incase that person has autism! Again, where would that end? How many other "traits" could be excused?

CoffeeWithCheese · 13/04/2023 21:27

Kingdedede · 13/04/2023 21:01

My year 7 DS finds the corridors stressful - full of smelly year 10 boys hitting him.

I remember as a year 7/8 and not having a clue why I was different - I was walking along a corridor in school and was grabbed and dragged into a classroom by some huge year 10 girls who wanted to show their friends, “you’ve got to see this girl, she’s so weird.” I didn’t have a clue how to respond, so I fumbled with the door to get out of the room and walked away wondering what the hell I had done wrong that time to be singled out.

I didn’t have enough of a social rule book to read what was and wasn’t ok and what I could and couldn’t rightfully get annoyed over - so a bump in the corridor would have confused me - but by the time I was in secondary I had been attacked and abused so much I would have probably internalised it rather than retaliating too heavily - I’d had that knocked out of me by then.

the inappropriate social comments as well - like the exam failing comment - one thing that lots of autistic people do is to try to empathise and relate socially - but usually incredibly clumsily - like over sharing and over-trying to find a common experience to join with another person - which can come across as negativity or me-railing but comes from a place of good intentions and just trying to play the game of social
interactions when we only got given half of the rule book and a cup of coffee was spilt on it before we got that! I got blasted so much for that kind of social faux pas well into adulthood that it made me holding down any sustained job pretty impossible as I just didn’t “fit” socially - however well I did the job and tried to keep my head down, my presence would just piss people off for being too extrovert, or too introvert. It took me until I was 45 and changed careers, plus a diagnosis, to find a job where my team
fully accept me for all the bits where I might get it slightly socially “wrong” on occasions and as a really good solid member of the team.

The advert is fantastic but it seems to have given the usual shitty attitudes the chance for a day out again. Think it’s also fairly apt it being on a laundry product - I get completely thrown (I can cope but things just feel “wrong” even though it doesn’t go to meltdown point) if someone else washes anything in my wardrobe and the smell and feeling of the clothes changes as a result! Stuff I wear endlessly just doesn’t feel… right and that makes the whole day feel the same sort of wrong

TheOriginalEmu · 13/04/2023 21:24

DeadbeatYoda · 13/04/2023 21:16

Or is it a company using their advertising budget to highlight a a serious problem in our understanding of autism in girls? I have been surrounded by autism all my life and now work in the sector with autistic teens. I'm certainly pleased to see this campaign.

Completely agree! (As an autistic female with female autistic children).

TheOriginalEmu · 13/04/2023 21:23

Squirrefromthewirrell · 13/04/2023 16:47

Just seen the new (at least to me) vanish detergent advert. It focuses on an autistic teen girl called Ash who has a favourite hoodie. All through the add the character is just displaying awful behaviour that even being autistic doesn't excuse (shouting at siblings to shut up, having a go at someone who accidentally walks into her, playing drums whilst her family are trying to spend time together)

Am I wrong to think it's just showing a very unsavoury side ? The overall message is lovely - extend the life of familiar clothes that can comfort people like ash who are autistic but the actual advert just rubbed me the wrong way

As a parent to autistic teens, I’d say it’s a very fair representation of autistic teenagers, who, like the majority of teenagers can be arseholes.
I don’t agree that the behaviours aren’t ‘excused’ by autism though: the telling her sibling to shut up/getting annoyed at the person who touched her is an example of autistic overwhelm. the drumming is a child who is disregulated trying to desperately find that balance and that often means not thinking of how it affects other people.
I think it’s a good advert.

january123 · 13/04/2023 21:19

Hate this advert. Seems to me that it gives someone with ASD the green light to act like like a
tyrant. Felt so sorry for her sister.

DeadbeatYoda · 13/04/2023 21:16

eloquent · 13/04/2023 19:15

Can't really get on board with a brand using autistics to get sales.

As that's what this is.

Or is it a company using their advertising budget to highlight a a serious problem in our understanding of autism in girls? I have been surrounded by autism all my life and now work in the sector with autistic teens. I'm certainly pleased to see this campaign.

DeadbeatYoda · 13/04/2023 21:12

Boomboom22 · 13/04/2023 19:00

A few points here.

Just because a behaviour us caused by autism does not make it Ok and siblings and other classmates should not have to just put up and shut up as some parents on here seem to think. The autistic child also needs strategies to manage not just everyone around them. Sen schools should be vastly expanded tbh as what nt kids have to cope with, especially in primary, is completely unacceptable. Eg chairs being thrown and extreme violence, whole classes evacuated daily for safety, and there is no way for the school to keep them safe as the minority are prioritised every time. This cannot just be ignored and does nothing to help acceptance and tolerance.

Sounds like a very narrow experience you have there. Not sure you know much about the wider situation.

VestaTilley · 13/04/2023 21:06

@MoMandaS I’m not for a minute assuming this was a widespread- but sibling abuse does happen. A male friend of ours was badly bullied to the point of abuse as a child by his older autistic brother. His autistic mother did absolutely nothing about it. It made our friend a very badly damaged and angry man for many years.

Kingdedede · 13/04/2023 21:01

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 13/04/2023 20:47

I think the corridor scene was really well done, actually- a lot of secondary school corridors are a nightmare for students with sensory difficulties or anxiety, and unfortunately there isn't a good solution (except to build schools with more space!). Modern schools tend to have much wider corridors to avoid "pinch points" etc- but often older schools have part of the building made for a much smaller school population and the space can be intimidating/unpleasant for everyone. They can be scary for small Y7s, too.

Obviously schools will try to mitigate things, but the character was upset and maybe overreacted- but this honestly happens every day in some schools, and the student often genuinely feels like they have been pushed/targetted because they are scared.

WRT the "you're going to fail" comment- I thought it was an attempt at a joke from someone who's lacking in social skills a bit. Teens do make these sorts of comments.

I can't speak to the scenes at home, but all the scenes in school felt authentic to me.

My year 7 DS finds the corridors stressful - full of smelly year 10 boys hitting him.

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 21:01

@mastertomsmum I am assuming you don't, I asked because you're the one that brought up what may or may not happen on Snapchat or Instagram. I check mine so I am 99% sure the teens I have contact with would not treat their friends like the kid in the advert. Of course, I can't say 100%, I'm not that naive. However what I can be certain of is that no child of mine or any of my friends would allow their kid to talk to someone else like that. Autism or not, there needs to be consequences for bad behaviour, and being rude and insulting is bad behaviour. Yes children with autism need different parenting to NT children but they can't be allowed to get away with abuse of others, where would that end?
I stand by my original point, the advert shows that girl being a complete brat and abusing her sibling.

nimski · 13/04/2023 20:58

This is a really powerful advert which increases understanding of what many of our children - and their siblings - go through on a daily basis. And these are the ones who even make it into school and have supportive schools and friends.
It made me cry as its my 2 daughters exactly and anything that raises awareness of Autism is a good thing in my opinion. We also have a house full of black hoodies!

mastertomsmum · 13/04/2023 20:54

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 20:36

@mastertomsmum you don't check your kids social media?

Right so where are we going with this question? Are you assuming I do or I don’t. Will matter what the answer to the second question is?

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 13/04/2023 20:47

I think the corridor scene was really well done, actually- a lot of secondary school corridors are a nightmare for students with sensory difficulties or anxiety, and unfortunately there isn't a good solution (except to build schools with more space!). Modern schools tend to have much wider corridors to avoid "pinch points" etc- but often older schools have part of the building made for a much smaller school population and the space can be intimidating/unpleasant for everyone. They can be scary for small Y7s, too.

Obviously schools will try to mitigate things, but the character was upset and maybe overreacted- but this honestly happens every day in some schools, and the student often genuinely feels like they have been pushed/targetted because they are scared.

WRT the "you're going to fail" comment- I thought it was an attempt at a joke from someone who's lacking in social skills a bit. Teens do make these sorts of comments.

I can't speak to the scenes at home, but all the scenes in school felt authentic to me.

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 20:36

@mastertomsmum you don't check your kids social media?

Trollsinmyeggbox · 13/04/2023 20:34

The portrayal aside, the fact they're using autism to sell fucking washing powder is a low point.

mastertomsmum · 13/04/2023 20:34

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 20:14

@mastertomsmum I have been around plenty, and parent 2. My kids and their friends are very supportive of each other, and mark my words if I heard anyone of them telling a friend or classmate they were going to fail their exam/exams there would be consequences, not that I or any of their parents have been in that position. Or is rudeness allowed when autism can be used as an excuse?

The none autistic kids would not do this in front of an adult. Many kids would not tell their parents half the stuff that goes on in school/on insta/Snapchat or whatever. Having been at school myself, even I the 1980s kids were not esp kind to each other in reliable fashion. My Mum once told me she thought Grange Hill was an exaggeration (circa 1982) I just looked at her and said “Mum, it’s much worse”

PleaseJustText · 13/04/2023 20:17

I'm with you OP. She just came across as a horrible person in the advert. I felt sorry for the sister more than anything.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 13/04/2023 20:15

She apologised because she realised she'd gone too far when she saw Ash shutting down. She'd thought it would annoy her not make her spiral. It was her realising how much the jumper means to her autistic sister because their brains work differently that made her give it back. She realised the other behaviour was also because of Ash's autism not because of malicious intent.

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 20:14

@mastertomsmum I have been around plenty, and parent 2. My kids and their friends are very supportive of each other, and mark my words if I heard anyone of them telling a friend or classmate they were going to fail their exam/exams there would be consequences, not that I or any of their parents have been in that position. Or is rudeness allowed when autism can be used as an excuse?

Jellycats4life · 13/04/2023 20:13

When I watched it I thought it was very real.

I didn’t think the autistic girl looked like an arsehole. I could see her anxiety and how much she struggled. But then I know what it feels like to be an autistic girl.

Yes, her sibling suffered but that’s real too.

whoami24601 · 13/04/2023 20:13

orangeflags · 13/04/2023 19:05

As a sibling of an older autistic man it really resonated with me. The walking on eggshells and him controlling the house is my overwhelming memory of childhood.

Snap! My sister was violent and abusive. She would throw things and punch/kick/pull hair. Once she laid on top of me until I couldn't breathe because I moved into 'her' spot when she went to the toilet. My parents did their best but it was a shit way to grow up. I was extremely lucky that I had another sister very close in age and we kept each other sane. One of the reasons I have 3 kids now is because my second is autistic and I didn't want the eldest to have to cope with that on her own. If I hadn't have had another sibling I don't think I'd be here now tbh.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 13/04/2023 20:13

Meredusoleil · 13/04/2023 19:17

What I didn't quite get is why the sister took Ash's hoodie in the first place?

Because she was angry at her sister always getting to do what she wanted above everyone else. She perceived it as 'special treatment' that she never gets.

So she did it to hurt Ash as a reaction.

Swipe left for the next trending thread