Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu: the new Vanish advert makes autistic teens look like assholes

264 replies

Squirrefromthewirrell · 13/04/2023 16:47

Just seen the new (at least to me) vanish detergent advert. It focuses on an autistic teen girl called Ash who has a favourite hoodie. All through the add the character is just displaying awful behaviour that even being autistic doesn't excuse (shouting at siblings to shut up, having a go at someone who accidentally walks into her, playing drums whilst her family are trying to spend time together)

Am I wrong to think it's just showing a very unsavoury side ? The overall message is lovely - extend the life of familiar clothes that can comfort people like ash who are autistic but the actual advert just rubbed me the wrong way

OP posts:
Tr33sPl3as3 · 14/04/2023 08:10

I think this thread shows how much autism is misunderstood and how much more awareness is needed.

WhiteFire · 14/04/2023 07:52

I note that there were a couple of other people on the thread who recounted their experiences of living in an abusive environment as children due to their sibling. No one engaged with their posts

It's unfair to say no one did, a few posters have acknowledged their struggles as a parent in the situation with a sibling, they've been largely ignored by the masses bar others in a similar situation.

imip · 14/04/2023 07:05

I have two autistic teen dds, one autistic tween dd and one NT teen dd. I feel the add is true to life, though a little more violence in mine. It is hard to balance the needs of all 4, I only work part time and at times need to take time out of work. Because my NT teen needs lots of support also.

Florissante · 14/04/2023 06:57

CandyLeBonBon · 14/04/2023 01:02

My ds is 'an arshole' if you look at it from that perspective. But aren't we ALL arseholes sometimes?

Oh, no. MNers are never 'arseholes'. It's always other people (who don't know they're being criticised and aren't around to give their side of the story) who are. The lack of self-awareness on MN is astounding.

SeulementUneFois · 14/04/2023 06:15

@yaaarrrp

I'm so sorry for what you went through.
And further, for people basically ignoring it even now.

I think that all that can be done is to keep raising it, highlight people's hypocrisy in trying to ignore and sweep under the carpet the abuse of other children.

Completely understand though if that just feels too much. And hopeless really.

I note that there were a couple of other people on the thread who recounted their experiences of living in an abusive environment as children due to their sibling. No one engaged with their posts.

In theory one should be able to create a running post on Mumsnet titled Survivors of childhood abuse from autistic siblings.

But I bet if one did that it would immediately be filled with verbal abuse to the Op, and swiftly get deleted as ableist.

Fieldsodgold21 · 14/04/2023 02:51

@lemonsaretheonlyfruit and others

As a result of this thread, I watched the ad. I recognised so much in my young adult DD. She is not diagnosed and tbh I think any suggestion from me that she might be ND would result in backlash. She lives at home and there can be a huge amount of tension between us. No one can understand this, because with others, she masks. I’ve been in therapy for years, as it has affected by MH. I haven’t always coped. I just wonder if there are any support or advice networks for parents of adults on the spectrum? I feel I need assistance from people who don’t just make suggestions that don’t take into account the struggles. It’s complex and I want to be the best parent I can. Thank you.

yaaarrrp · 14/04/2023 01:45

I am the sibling of someone with severe autism and a learning disabilty. Its taken me getting to adulthood to realise I was in an extremely abusive home all due to my brother and it has affected me profoundly into my adult life. I was beaten up, spat at, had shit smeared all over my possessions, had him screaming from 4am till well into the night all of this was a daily occurance... yet throughout my childhood I was told that I basically had to get on with it, as my brother couldn't help it. It makes me so angry that siblings are sidelined constantly in this argument. There is absolutely no support for us. To the poster saying that because its Autism it cant be considered 'abuse' I definitely feel well and truly abused, have several scars and injuries to prove it!!

ImInACage · 14/04/2023 01:31

I have autism and I hate this advert. It isn't clear, it doesn't bring awareness to those who have no experience with autistic people and I feel like our struggles are just being used to sell a product.

TheOriginalEmu · 14/04/2023 01:31

Smokingonthestairs · 13/04/2023 18:16

I wonder how helpful this ‘raising awareness’ will be, given that the waiting time for assessment in this age group is currently years in most areas. Doctors are currently very reluctant to refer, usually stating that the referral request should come from school (we know that many girls mask in certain environments). Schools are reluctant to refer unless the case is extreme because it means a huge amount of paperwork etc for them. Teens are in comprehensive for 5 years, if you’re waiting two years to be assessed , that’s a very large proportion of the whole school time to struggle.
Given that this ad has gone viral on social media, and particularly tiktok, (the comments are all ‘omg that’s me I have a favourite hoody too’), will we have a huge surge of people seeking diagnosis , causing more pressure on an already strained system ?
And for anyone on this thread with experience ,I’d really like to know, what benefit does a diagnosis have to kids this age, and their families? In the video the mother is doing her best and seems to have developed coping strategies but it’s clear that the lives of the other family members (particularly the sister) are very hard ,despite the diagnosis. Are there things in place to help the siblings of these children , so that they don’t grow up walking on eggshells in their own homes?
It seems strange to me that it would seem the absolute worst thing in the world to teach a child to walk on eggshells around an abusive parent, but teaching them to walk on eggshells around an abusive sibling (if autistic) is almost expected.

A diagnosis can facilitate medication such as melatonin to help with sleep. In my area at least you can’t get that prescribed without an ASD diagnosis.
A diagnosis at any age (I was 40) can be hugely beneficial in accommodations at school and work.
A diagnosis is very very helpful in accessing a EHCP or equivilant which facilitates help with educational settings.
Most importantly for me it helped me to understand myself. So yes it’s worth it. Massively so.

Singleandproud · 14/04/2023 01:26

My DD watched it and saw alot of herself in it. She is an only child so we've managed to avoid those additional pressures from having a sibling. But regimental morning routines, silent car rides, amazing at maths and art, says what she thinks, if someone can't do the maths = they are going to fail the test on that topic. Even down to the drums although I bought electric ones she plays wearing her headphones. She wouldn't tell someone to shut up but would bottle it up until she gets home then shutdown, definitely wouldn't want to be touched.

We thought it was a good advert - still won't be buying vanish though.

CandyLeBonBon · 14/04/2023 01:02

My ds is 'an arshole' if you look at it from that perspective. But aren't we ALL arseholes sometimes?

lemonsaretheonlyfruit · 14/04/2023 01:01

I suppose what I was trying to say (albeit inefficiently) was that a lot of behaviour of teens / DCs can outwardly look the same Ie this ad , but the reasons why someone might act like this in their home or in certain situations can differ greatly and requires more examination than just the surface level understanding and commenting. Being the parent of a child / teen with ASD requires a different approach.

lemonsaretheonlyfruit · 14/04/2023 00:48

@IamMoiraRose and others.

I have a 15 year old autistic DD who is incredibly similar to Ash. I think that if you don't have first hand experience of living with or parenting someone who is autistic then yes it might look like 'bad or normal teen behaviour.

I often find that parents with NT DCs who don't have these kind of challenges with their DCS congratulate themselves on how well their DCs are doing and put it down to their parenting, or (eg) how much they read to their DCs when they were younger, or the boundaries they set when they were younger.

We as parents of ND DCs did exactly the same as you. Your DCs just don't happen to be Neurodiverse.

They are also the same parents who say that someone like Ash's behaviour is unacceptable. It comes from a lack of first hand experience of parenting a neurodiverse child. Being honest I'm not sure I would have fully understood this ad either if it wasn't for my DD.

The drum playing isn't her being rude. The not being able to tolerate the radio in the car is not unacceptable- she's struggling. Needing the hoody (or another item of clothing) is necessary for her to be able to function ok. Being bumped into at school is her feeling threatened, her telling her friend she was going to fail is her not being able to read when it's appropriate to speak her truth or keep it to herself. And many more things in that advert.

I really appreciated the advert.

MoMandaS · 14/04/2023 00:26

VestaTilley · 13/04/2023 21:06

@MoMandaS I’m not for a minute assuming this was a widespread- but sibling abuse does happen. A male friend of ours was badly bullied to the point of abuse as a child by his older autistic brother. His autistic mother did absolutely nothing about it. It made our friend a very badly damaged and angry man for many years.

I haven't said it doesn't happen. I'm saying it doesn't happen automatically where there's an autistic sibling and most families will do their utmost to mitigate the impact of that situation. Where they don't, it isn't the fault of the autistic person and, as I have said, there is no support available for anyone in this situation: not for the autistic person, not for the sibling and not for the parent(s).

SpringCherryTrees · 13/04/2023 23:20

I was expecting to be annoyed by the advert, but like others I was quite moved.

Maybe because it shows the tension within families, something quite authentic about that, and the impact on siblings.

DS also has a lot of tics so the eye blinking felt quite real. Like the girl he can’t tolerate other people speaking but is extremely loud himself. He wouldn’t tell others to shut up, but he’d start being so stressed that it’s the same thing, we have to be quiet in the car. It’s just how it is for many autistic teens.

MrsDoylesDoily · 13/04/2023 23:00

AdoraBell · 13/04/2023 22:45

I haven’t seen the advert so I can’t really comment on it.

Love this post 😂😂

LumpySpaceGoddess · 13/04/2023 22:57

I found it really hard to watch because my DD has autism and there were so many similarities, lack of emotional regulation is a huge aspect of autism and it’s so unfair to expect a child with autism to be able to react in the appropriate ways, even with interventions and support, it’s incredibly difficult to try and stay focused and regulated in a world with so much noise and so many rules.

AdoraBell · 13/04/2023 22:45

I haven’t seen the advert so I can’t really comment on it.

CrotchetyCrocheting · 13/04/2023 22:43

I think that the reality is that some autistic behaviour can look very much like asshole behaviour. Unless you know someone in real life who talks about it/live with someone with asd you often won't realise this because if people try and talk about it and try and talk about the effects it can have on the NT members of the family on sites like this are shouted down and heavily reported by some autistic members of mumsnet who (understandably)find it upsetting to see how their behaviour can come across to and effect NT people.

There is also guilt associated with talking about it, talking about how it effects you when they are the disabled one feels selfish. Talking about how you feel abused when you know they don't mean to abuse you and that it is just a result of their inability to cope/overwhelm feels like betraying them.

I'm really pleased that they showed this side in the ad, I think it needs to be spoken about more. Very often we are fed the line that autism looks like a quirky savant with poor social skills but the reality is mostly very different.

mastertomsmum · 13/04/2023 22:41

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 22:10

@mastertomsmum I think it's best you give up too

Lols 😂

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 22:12

@MrsDoylesDoily I do, thank you.

MrsDoylesDoily · 13/04/2023 22:11

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 19:57

The advert is ridiculous. No sibling should have to put up with that. And telling the classmate she was going to fail her exam?! Utter nastiness and would result in a hiding around here. I have no doubt that girl has many wonderful features and abilities but the advert makes her come across as an abusive arse.

I don't know where 'around here' is, but you sound like you fit in very well there.

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 22:10

@mastertomsmum I think it's best you give up too

mastertomsmum · 13/04/2023 22:08

IamMoiraRose · 13/04/2023 21:01

@mastertomsmum I am assuming you don't, I asked because you're the one that brought up what may or may not happen on Snapchat or Instagram. I check mine so I am 99% sure the teens I have contact with would not treat their friends like the kid in the advert. Of course, I can't say 100%, I'm not that naive. However what I can be certain of is that no child of mine or any of my friends would allow their kid to talk to someone else like that. Autism or not, there needs to be consequences for bad behaviour, and being rude and insulting is bad behaviour. Yes children with autism need different parenting to NT children but they can't be allowed to get away with abuse of others, where would that end?
I stand by my original point, the advert shows that girl being a complete brat and abusing her sibling.

I give up 👀 Your answers are not real world or 21st century. If you are so in touch you will know that PHSE lessons cover cyber bullying extensively. Maybe if a teen has Instagram at 13 there are some parents checking feed, but wouldn’t know of any of them from either schools I know well

Re the advert - I saw no brats