Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu: the new Vanish advert makes autistic teens look like assholes

264 replies

Squirrefromthewirrell · 13/04/2023 16:47

Just seen the new (at least to me) vanish detergent advert. It focuses on an autistic teen girl called Ash who has a favourite hoodie. All through the add the character is just displaying awful behaviour that even being autistic doesn't excuse (shouting at siblings to shut up, having a go at someone who accidentally walks into her, playing drums whilst her family are trying to spend time together)

Am I wrong to think it's just showing a very unsavoury side ? The overall message is lovely - extend the life of familiar clothes that can comfort people like ash who are autistic but the actual advert just rubbed me the wrong way

OP posts:
TooManyPlatesInMotion · 14/04/2023 11:27

yaaarrrp · 14/04/2023 01:45

I am the sibling of someone with severe autism and a learning disabilty. Its taken me getting to adulthood to realise I was in an extremely abusive home all due to my brother and it has affected me profoundly into my adult life. I was beaten up, spat at, had shit smeared all over my possessions, had him screaming from 4am till well into the night all of this was a daily occurance... yet throughout my childhood I was told that I basically had to get on with it, as my brother couldn't help it. It makes me so angry that siblings are sidelined constantly in this argument. There is absolutely no support for us. To the poster saying that because its Autism it cant be considered 'abuse' I definitely feel well and truly abused, have several scars and injuries to prove it!!

@yaaarrrp I'm so sorry you went through this, it sounds horrible. And you are absolutely correct that the scars (physical and emotional) are carried on into adulthood. My younger sister was abusive towards me. She basically ruled our household due to her extremely violent temper and often very cruel behaviour. My parents never sought a diagnosis or any help whatsoever for her, and we all lived in fear. I tried to talk to my mum about it a few years ago (I'm now 43, my sister is 41) and my DM brushed it off and said that yes Dsis behaviour was "challenging" and that if she were a child now they would seek a diagnosis for her. No acknowledgment of what is was like for me or my brother being constantly hit, spat at, having our belongings and homework destroyed, while m parents essentially did nothing about it.

It really affected my relationship with my parents. Seeing them constantly overlook the violence and cruelty alienated me from them for years, as it did with my much younger brother.

IamMoiraRose · 14/04/2023 11:16

@TuesdayJulyNever If you're referring to me that's not what I said at all. Use your reading skills and look again. Silly woman.

MichelleScarn · 14/04/2023 11:09

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 14/04/2023 10:37

It’s very hard for them and the more I think about it the less sympathy I have for the sister. She shud know by now that noise/too much talking etc crowds, transitions r a lot for her sister, but she doesn’t change her behaviour and keeps on doing it (I agree the drums r out of order but sometimes u have to tolerate something for the sake of someone else - it’s called caring) like if I called u something and u asked me to stop but I kept doing it until I shouted at u, who’s the 'pain'?

That's really quite sad, so you're saying if Ash doesn't want her sister to talk, then the sister must remain silent?
Where's any caring for the sister then?

WhiteFire · 14/04/2023 11:04

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 14/04/2023 10:37

It’s very hard for them and the more I think about it the less sympathy I have for the sister. She shud know by now that noise/too much talking etc crowds, transitions r a lot for her sister, but she doesn’t change her behaviour and keeps on doing it (I agree the drums r out of order but sometimes u have to tolerate something for the sake of someone else - it’s called caring) like if I called u something and u asked me to stop but I kept doing it until I shouted at u, who’s the 'pain'?

Whilst I will deal with my younger DD if she is doing something with the sole intention of winding her brother up, or just to annoy him, I will not expect her to not do anything because he might find it problematic.

The sister here already does so much, but they are individuals in their own right and they need to also do normal everyday things like talking and listening to music. She will tolerate things every single day and make allowances every single day, but sometimes she wants to just talk to her friends.

I said it before but I wonder if the response would be different if it was the same dynamic as it my house, brother (autism) and younger sister.

jeaux90 · 14/04/2023 10:38

I have an ASD teen the advert made me well up. I thought it was really good.

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 14/04/2023 10:37

It’s very hard for them and the more I think about it the less sympathy I have for the sister. She shud know by now that noise/too much talking etc crowds, transitions r a lot for her sister, but she doesn’t change her behaviour and keeps on doing it (I agree the drums r out of order but sometimes u have to tolerate something for the sake of someone else - it’s called caring) like if I called u something and u asked me to stop but I kept doing it until I shouted at u, who’s the 'pain'?

booboo24 · 14/04/2023 10:22

@TuesdayJulyNever so so true of my experiences, it's a conplete balancing act 24/7

WhiteFire · 14/04/2023 10:09

One poster suggested giving her a hiding and I’ve heard that a few times in real life

Tbf to that poster that is not exactly what they said. It was pointed out that in a different area/school telling another pupil they were going to fail the exam may end with a punch.

MarshaBradyo · 14/04/2023 09:55

I understand people can relate to it but in some cases would t you mitigate impact. To give an example the drums - so would you allow it or choose headphones and silent drums

Or noise cancelling headphones in car

I know the sister had to be pissed off to create the narrative but I’m assuming it’s advertising spin and families wouod find more balance

TuesdayJulyNever · 14/04/2023 09:52

I’m struck by how so many people can identify with either Ash or the sister but not both.

As a parent that is one of the hardest things to try and balance. Ds needs to be cut a lot of slack because what we see as acting out is him struggling with more than he can handle.

And dd is growing up in an environment of chaos walking on eggshells. If it were dh that brought that, I would leave in a heartbeat but instead I’m constantly trying to protect both of my dc from an unnecessarily hard life .

It absolutely breaks my heart when ds is in a meltdown, and I’m in there with him, being the bridge back to calm, and I know that dd wants, more than anything, to be wrapped up in my arms safe. And I’m literally aching to hold someone - ds that can’t be touched in those moments and dd who needs to be in a separate room for her safety.

We haven’t built our family around his needs but life is a constant round of compromises and someone is always struggling. Both my dc are convinced the other gets priority or is loved and favoured more and all I can do is reassure them that they’re loved, valued and important and do my best to carve out space for both of them.

It’s really disheartening to see how many people can look at that ad and still only see bad behaviour. One poster suggested giving her a hiding and I’ve heard that a few times in real life.

My own experience is that my ds has incredible self discipline, and when he acts out, I need to work fast to figure out the problem and help him. Over the years we’ve developed strategies to slow the eruption but puberty has introduced new challenges. What looks to an outsider like wishy washy parenting is me in the trenches, thinking at a million miles an hour, defusing a bomb.

If I could fix our problems with a sharp reprimand or a smack, do you honestly think I’d be faffing around deliberately making life harder for everyone?

Tr33sPl3as3 · 14/04/2023 09:52

pandarific

Autism varies hugely. That may work for your child( presuming you have a child with autism) it wouldn’t with others.

Badbadtromance · 14/04/2023 09:41

I normally turn off adverts but saw that and it's just like my youngest. I thought it was lovely 🌹

AngelinaBallerina122 · 14/04/2023 09:41

I wouldn't know how to deal with a ND teenager who because of no fault of her own her disability makes her react in ways that if they were done by a NT sibling they'd be considered abusive. How do you discipline (if at all) when the person is disabled? I can imagine if Ash's sister posted a thread on Relationships she'd be advised to move out and place some boundaries with her sister. Ash's sister's childhood and life is really affected by her sister's disability.
The headphone thing in the car or when she wants to drum is a tricky point because it could be that Ash doesn't like the feeling of headphones. The whole family's lives are shaped and dictated by Ash but then the whole outside world Ash has to adapt. It's not unreasonable to want to feel safe and comfortable in your own home but the bit I'm struggling with is how do you balance this with the wellbeing of the rest of the family particularly the youngest sister? I don't think there is enough support for people with Autism let alone for people like Ash's sister? I think when one child needs more attention, even if it's for a good and justified reason it can impact the other children so they shouldn't be forgotten about and supported, as well.

yaaarrrp · 14/04/2023 09:35

Thank you to those that replied to me. Im not sure how to tag posters. It feels so good to be heard as i spent my childhood being completely ignored because my brothers needs were so much greater. I also had everyone around me telling me my mum was a saint for having a child like him but they truly had no idea the extent of how violent he was behind closed doors. We lived the life of prisoners, due to catering to his every whim and need. Social services were heavily involved, but the support was all focused on how they could help him, and they offered things like respite which were amazing when it happened, but it was minimal and the rest of the time when he was at home was complete hell.

I now as an adult cant be around him as it sets off Ptsd like symptoms like feeling shakey and palpitations etc. I probably do actually have ptsd tbh Ive just always felt to ashamed to see anyone about it for fear the response that I will just be told that he couldnt help it and how difficult it must have been for my parents.

I do realise my case is way more extreme than that showed in the video, but I was actually really moved by the fact that people were commenting on here about the sister and actually how difficult it must be for her. It just got me very emotional for all the other children going through what I did.

stickygotstuck · 14/04/2023 09:25

Tr33sPl3as3 · 14/04/2023 08:10

I think this thread shows how much autism is misunderstood and how much more awareness is needed.

I came to say exactly that.

There is a move to go from 'awareness' to 'acceptance'. Which I think it's like learning to run before walking. Awareness of Autism (actual, accurate, widespread knowledge) is still in its infancy. As this thread demonstrates.

TravellingSpoon · 14/04/2023 09:01

I havent read the full thread, but as the parent of an ND and a NT teen, what got me was how difficult it must also be for Ash's sister.

orangeflags · 14/04/2023 09:00

I'm in my late fifties now. There wasn't the internet or any support groups for siblings when I was growing up and I only knew one other young person who had a brother like mine.

Because my brother was so much older than me (ten years) he wasn't someone I could have shared a sibling relationship with really, he was just an angry person who lived in and controlled our house. When I became a teenager I was embarrassed to be around him in public but we never went out as a family or on holiday anyway because he wouldn't have coped. People used to tell me how wonderful my mum was for how she looked after him, and I would be so angry inside because they had no idea how the family functioned. All I could see was that he called the shots. Keeping him happy was the purpose of the family. If I got praise for something, it would be for doing something for him, my function was a back up carer for him.

Now as an adult with grown up children of my own I see what a difficult struggle it was for my mum looking after him. He's in a home with carers who understand him beautifully and he's happy and doesn't have that same constant fight to control his environment

My mum did her best and I can see that now. I hope all the parents of children who are in a similar family as mine today listen to the siblings. Give them time and allow them to express themselves about how they feel, and praise them for their achievements.

knackeredcat · 14/04/2023 08:53

Oh. Have just watched and I'm very moved. I never played drums, but much of Ash is who I was. Especially at the accidental bump being catastrophised. The sensory overload portrayal feels very real and I can feel how overwhelmed she is.I'm crying here at the realisation that I repeatedly displayed much of this behaviour, but was never offered any understanding or compassion simply because I was her in the 1990s. What if...

pandarific · 14/04/2023 08:44

I am pretty sure I’m ND and my DS is too, and I would absolutely tell my daughter off for shouting ‘shut up’ ant her sibling - it’s very much how I grew up and imo is unacceptable. I would be telling her she could apologise for her rudeness to her sibling and then either put on headphones to muffle the noise or ask them politely if they could be a bit quieter as she is struggling with the noise. So, respectfully voicing her own needs - which are fair enough - and not just snapping rudely.

Obviously it may happen in the moment, but that’s what parenting is, isn’t it? Modelling good behaviour, correcting undesirable behaviour and redirecting to a better alternative, while being respectful of everyone in the family.

booboo24 · 14/04/2023 08:42

@yaaarrrp I'm so so sorry, its terribly sad all round. Yes I agree with your parents that it isn't your brother's fault, and it must have been incredibly hard for them, but there should have been some escape and support for you in all of this. I hope you've been able to get some help in adulthood to deal with this x

booboo24 · 14/04/2023 08:28

@Tr33sPl3as3 Totally agree you, help is non existent. The worry is endless isn't it- my eldest has taken some flack from my youngest over the years, some of which is normal sibling arguments, some is, as we now know, her being overwhelmed, but families are left just feeling around in the dark on this

megletthesecond · 14/04/2023 08:26

yy whata. After my three parenting courses had "failed" we were assigned an early help worker. She had to meet my eldest teens school to check how he was getting on. She reported back that they think he's great and have never had any concerns. It also must have ticked the 'not a parenting problem' box a decade too late as I was given a bit more support and DLA for my youngest. My DC's need to be parented differently.

booboo24 · 14/04/2023 08:24

I hadn't heard of or seen this, so I just looked it up on YouTube and am sat here crying! My 15 year old daughter was only diagnosed last year, Ash is her to a tee. My eldest is NT, she's now 21
For years we struggled thinking that she was being awkward, rude etc As we had no understanding at all of ASD or ADHD, noone else in our family had it (although with things I've learnt now maybe that's a naive assumption!) I was and still am heartbroken that none of us realised until last year and we've all had to massively change the way we all think in order to help my youngest, by trying to see how she interprets the world. It's terrible that girls are so often left floundering and are so late to be diagnosed. I found the ad wonderful and so moving

Tr33sPl3as3 · 14/04/2023 08:22

And how hard it is to live with. I have 2 children with autism and there isn’t a day that goes by that I don’t worry about the impact on the third.

What do people expect us parents to do, wave a magic wand? There should be support for families but there isn’t.

A few points. The girl in the advert is very like my daughter. Many teens won’t wear headphones as they don’t want their autism to stand out. My Dd wouldn’t in front of somebody outside the family. Those with autism can be very blunt, there is no filter. Many of us are doing the best we can in small houses. The drums may be a lifeline and the lounge the only place to keep them. The only criticism I’d make of the mother was the marching into the bedroom, threatening and bulldozing. We’ve all done it in panic but from experience I know it just heightens everything and other strategies are needed.

Finally can we just remember most teens can be unpleasant and shout at their siblings at times. It’s not great and it’s not ok but it does happen. In reality my dc take their meltdowns out on me as I’m safe. In an ideal world the sibling would have therapy or be part of a young carers group but families struggling with autism get nothing. We can’t make the autism go away. We get no support in how to handle it.

Finally the sibling would have benefited from some positive attributes her sister would have too.

Whatafustercluck · 14/04/2023 08:10

I often find that parents with NT DCs who don't have these kind of challenges with their DCS congratulate themselves on how well their DCs are doing and put it down to their parenting, or (eg) how much they read to their DCs when they were younger, or the boundaries they set when they were younger. We as parents of ND DCs did exactly the same as you. Your DCs just don't happen to be Neurodiverse.

This really strikes a chord with me. The singularly most helpful conversation I've had with anyone regarding my 6yo dd (then 5) was with a person from Young Minds. "You have an older child who, by the sounds of it, is thriving. He's doing well socially and academically, he is well liked and displays typical behaviours and reactions. You have a ND diverse - this is not a parenting problem." I got off the phone and cried. Until that point, all the focus had been on us as parents, what we might be doing wrong, not employing the correct behaviour management strategies. We couldn't understand it because we were raising our dd no differently to our ds. But that was precisely the problem. As soon as we understood that her behaviour was a communication of her difficulties and stopped treating her as a naughty child, we began to make more progress.

The Vanish advert is brilliant. I see so much of my own dd in Ash. And so much of ds in Ash's sibling.

Swipe left for the next trending thread