Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu: the new Vanish advert makes autistic teens look like assholes

264 replies

Squirrefromthewirrell · 13/04/2023 16:47

Just seen the new (at least to me) vanish detergent advert. It focuses on an autistic teen girl called Ash who has a favourite hoodie. All through the add the character is just displaying awful behaviour that even being autistic doesn't excuse (shouting at siblings to shut up, having a go at someone who accidentally walks into her, playing drums whilst her family are trying to spend time together)

Am I wrong to think it's just showing a very unsavoury side ? The overall message is lovely - extend the life of familiar clothes that can comfort people like ash who are autistic but the actual advert just rubbed me the wrong way

OP posts:
Smokingonthestairs · 14/04/2023 15:01

@MotherofBingo So there needs to be better residential provisions for people with autism.
Just because we don’t do a good job with this in our country, it doesn’t mean that it wouldn’t be a constructive solution for families if the provisions were better.

CrotchetyCrocheting · 14/04/2023 14:54

MotherofBingo · 14/04/2023 14:48

Do you realise that many ND are sent to mental health units because those are the only places available? And the staff are not well trained or knowledgeable. Those people end up being mistreated, in overwhelming, highly stressful environments and don't get their needs met at all. Not that anyone actually cares - out of sight, out of mind, just so long as the neurodiverse aren't being a nuisance. Yes it's shit having a sibling with a disability/neurodiversity, yes it affects everyone in the household but that doesn't mean they should just be sent away.

I don't really know why are saying no one cares and calling abusing siblings and family members 'a nuisance'? Are you trying to shut down the people who are speaking of the abuse they have experienced at the hands of their ND siblings by using that word and insinuating that by caring for the abused NT sibling that 'no one cares' about the ND one?

I think you find in most ND/NT families there is a hell of a lot of love, care and patience shown towards those who are ND. I find your post really insulting and minimising tbh.

MotherofBingo · 14/04/2023 14:48

Smokingonthestairs · 14/04/2023 14:34

@soundsystem I think that some parents may be forced to make such a decision to protect their other children , and I don’t see that living in an environment with trained knowledgeable staff is necessarily a worse thing for a child who finds a normal domestic environment stressful to the point that they are having daily meltdowns/ missing school/ becoming abusive.

Do you realise that many ND are sent to mental health units because those are the only places available? And the staff are not well trained or knowledgeable. Those people end up being mistreated, in overwhelming, highly stressful environments and don't get their needs met at all. Not that anyone actually cares - out of sight, out of mind, just so long as the neurodiverse aren't being a nuisance. Yes it's shit having a sibling with a disability/neurodiversity, yes it affects everyone in the household but that doesn't mean they should just be sent away.

MasterBeth · 14/04/2023 14:45

Allmyghosts · 13/04/2023 17:59

I barely watch ads but schmaltzy bollocks is what I thought. The only thing it inspired was a fucking gladness that I don't generally watch ads. The playing drums, wtaf, err no.

In what way "schmaltzy"?

MichelleScarn · 14/04/2023 14:42

Florissante · 14/04/2023 14:31

The idea that ND people are an inconvenience and should be sent away somewhere is incredibly offensive

We're acceptable - just - as long as we don't inconvenience the NTs.

But you could say that it's the same for Ash's sister? She's not allowed to inconvenience Ash is she?

IamMoiraRose · 14/04/2023 14:36

Smokingonthestairs · 14/04/2023 14:34

@soundsystem I think that some parents may be forced to make such a decision to protect their other children , and I don’t see that living in an environment with trained knowledgeable staff is necessarily a worse thing for a child who finds a normal domestic environment stressful to the point that they are having daily meltdowns/ missing school/ becoming abusive.

I agree

Smokingonthestairs · 14/04/2023 14:34

@soundsystem I think that some parents may be forced to make such a decision to protect their other children , and I don’t see that living in an environment with trained knowledgeable staff is necessarily a worse thing for a child who finds a normal domestic environment stressful to the point that they are having daily meltdowns/ missing school/ becoming abusive.

Florissante · 14/04/2023 14:31

The idea that ND people are an inconvenience and should be sent away somewhere is incredibly offensive

We're acceptable - just - as long as we don't inconvenience the NTs.

soundsystem · 14/04/2023 14:21

Smokingonthestairs · 14/04/2023 14:19

@soundsystem why is this not an appropriate option in your opinion?

The idea that ND people are an inconvenience and should be sent away somewhere is incredibly offensive

Also, Ash is a real person in a real family...

Smokingonthestairs · 14/04/2023 14:19

@soundsystem why is this not an appropriate option in your opinion?

soundsystem · 14/04/2023 14:16

AngelinaBallerina122 · 14/04/2023 13:11

Or maybe a residential school for Ash.

Are you fucking serious?

MarshaBradyo · 14/04/2023 14:16

MichelleScarn · 14/04/2023 14:13

I've just watched it again and my sympathy is definitely for the sister who looks defeated and cowed throughout the advert.
There's at least some positivity in it for Ash. The sister has to shut up when Ash wants it, Ash has a safe space at school to retreat to, she has the drums at home to help regulate. Lily doesn't seem to have anyone looking out or considering her. The mum and dad don't do anything for her.

It does look tough for her

I get she’s not meant to be the focus but the silence after the shut up and just use subtitles didn’t sit well. Maybe just advertising flavour but still

MichelleScarn · 14/04/2023 14:13

I've just watched it again and my sympathy is definitely for the sister who looks defeated and cowed throughout the advert.
There's at least some positivity in it for Ash. The sister has to shut up when Ash wants it, Ash has a safe space at school to retreat to, she has the drums at home to help regulate. Lily doesn't seem to have anyone looking out or considering her. The mum and dad don't do anything for her.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 14/04/2023 13:53

I’m another that grew up walking on eggshells. My parents were both alcoholics and my sister wasn’t diagnosed but the school pushed for her to be assessed for ADHD. My parents didn’t take it forward: the family motto we grew up with of not drawing attention to what was going on at home (I tried to kill myself as a teenager and my parents did nothing about it).

My parents vacillated between emotionally abusive and total absence, my sister was angry and violent, nobody was allowed to acknowledge any of the dysfunction, and the adults just medicated with alcohol. My overriding memory is just trying always to stay out of the way of everything. Everything was dangerous.

I can remember my sister hitting me over and over and over again with a plastic rod just to watch the marks appear and try and get me to react, and getting angrier and angrier because I wouldn’t. My parents just said, “you know how she is, it’s not her fault.”

As adults my sister and I aren’t close. I don’t speak to my parents anymore. I do feel that awareness is important but I also feel incredibly angry that abuse is permitted to go on between siblings, and that it’s unacceptable to talk about it if there’s any hint that the abusive behaviour is linked to neurodiversity. It doesn’t help anyone to promote a narrative that we can only speak negatively about the impacts of neurodiverse if they’re experienced by the ND person. Everyone else has to remain silent about those impacts on them because that’s ableist - that doesn’t make sense to me.

(The situation is complicated because I strongly suspect my sister and I are both ND in different ways, but mine presents itself in hiding and minimising and being quiet and invisible, which was vey convenient for my parents as it meant I could be ignored.)

RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 14/04/2023 13:36

The exam fail thing I didn't even notice. As a teacher kids joke around like this all of the time. They often don't mean it.

If I heard it I would say no they won't fail now get on with your work.

This comment was an off the cuff remark. Bet the friend wasn't even bothered.

Lemonyfuckit · 14/04/2023 13:35

It sounds like it's depicting a tough life marked with difficult and sometimes inappropriate interactions. Well, yeah.....that's how it is!!

That's a fair point and I guess really makes my previous comment kind of moot - it just is what it is and I guess for family and friends you all just do your best to understand that sometimes interactions won't be quite appropriate.

In that case fair play to them for raising awareness of the realities for autistic teenagers and their friends and families also for featuring a young autistic woman.

Lemonyfuckit · 14/04/2023 13:31

Layla30 · 13/04/2023 17:09

I have watched it twice and both times just can’t get passed feeling so sorry for the sister.
That is possibly because my daughters friend is in exactly that situation and I see how it affects her so much!

That's exactly what I felt too. I get what people are saying in terms of how someone autistic might interpret an accidental jostle as a deliberate shove, how the noise affects them and the need for their favourite item of clothing etc. The things which did jar for me (but appreciate I have no experience of this so happy to have someone more knowledgeable explain) were 1) her yelling at her sister to shut up, 2) telling her friend they would fail their exam and 3) the playing drums in the living room whilst her family were trying to watch a programme. I feel 1 and 3 must be very hard for the sister (and parents) to deal with and 1 and 2 presumably you have ongoing dialogue with autistic children about why it's not kind to speak to your sibling/friend in that way?

AngelinaBallerina122 · 14/04/2023 13:11

Or maybe a residential school for Ash.

AngelinaBallerina122 · 14/04/2023 13:08

I think also that because some of what Ash does due to her Autism is also what some NT 'naughty', rude or anxious teens do like:

  • putting your foot in it (saying to her friend you're gonna fail)
  • assuming that you were bumped into on purpose (social anxiety low self esteem)
  • Crying and getting over emotional (hormones)
  • Shouting at her sister to shut up (siblings fights!)
  • Deciding to do a noisy activity at the 'wrong' time (night time, family watching tv)
I don't think it's fair on Ash's sister to walk on egg shells all the time in her own home, witnessing huge meltdowns is very distressing, having to do things a certain way all the time for her sister but I understand that after a whole day of Ash trying to keep it together and 'survive' she needs her comforts at home to recharge. I think I might separate with my DH and each have a child if it was exactly like the advert all or most of the time so that both girls can have their needs met. But I appreciate people have said it's not always like this.
RoyGBivisacolorfulman · 14/04/2023 13:00

I do agree op my dd does not of the rude things on the advert but she struggles badly and it may take away from that.

WhiteFire · 14/04/2023 12:57

Thank you to the siblings who have shared their stories.

Squirrefromthewirrell · 14/04/2023 12:24

I'm so glad to come back here and see the discussion that's happened whilst I've been gone. I think my original point still stands. I've watched the full version. I still think ash's behaviour wasn't handled appropriately and makes her and in turn lots of young teen girls with autism look bad. That may be their reality but it left a sour taste in my mouth for the sibling and its actually so so sad that she's having to grow up in that compromise.

Parents really minimise the impact of what it's like for siblings, I get why I totally do. The guilt must be horrific that you can't provide 100% for the nt child as unsurprisingly the nd child takes up the most time. But it's still just not fair and a very sad reality.

Point stands I don't like it and a very good point was made about using this sensitive topic as a marketing technique "buy OUR washing powder for your autistic child!!"

OP posts:
SpringCherryTrees · 14/04/2023 12:19

That's really quite sad, so you're saying if Ash doesn't want her sister to talk, then the sister must remain silent? Where's any caring for the sister then?

DS hates people talking, in the car, in the house, anywhere. Sometimes I bribe him with headphones and his favourite game. But often, I just can’t talk. I spend time walking around the house finding a room if I need to speak to someone on the phone, well away from DS. I arrange most meetings (I work from home) in the morning when he is at school. In the car he just starts screaming so yes, his brother can’t talk in the car. He copes by making it all about DS and tickling him so they play non verbal games together. DS doesn’t eat at the table as he hates anyone talking.

But it’s really difficult. I take the brunt of it, but it’s not great for his brother either. And I’ve worked really hard to get the family home to be ‘less controlled’ by DS - I couldn’t even have visitors for years, and he used to control when any TV was on or off, which doors were open etc.

orangeflags · 14/04/2023 12:13

@yaaarrrp this is why it's so helpful to talk to other people who had the same experience of childhood like we had. It's taken me literally decades to get to the place I am now. I can take my brother out with love, drop him back to his home and the emotions carried through from childhood have gone for me.

You talk about it as much as you need to Flowers

SpringCherryTrees · 14/04/2023 12:11

@yaaarrrp It sounds very tough, especially as there is no obvious outlet to say ‘I was abused’ as a child, because apparently one sort of abuse from a parent say is more understandable than a sibling with disabilities. But having to walk around eggshells isn’t healthy and I’m sorry you had to go through it.

For me, I feel that the whole ‘autism is a super power’ has stamped out anyone voicing difficulties, especially parents let alone siblings. If a parent tries to talk about difficulties there is a huge neurodiverse movement that will criticise and demean that parent. Which has gone on for the last few years. There is now even less help and support for families than there was before, sadly.