Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dsis is neglecting her own child

410 replies

aunty2 · 13/04/2023 15:33

I know neglect is a big word to use, but at this point I'm at my wits end and had enough. I will be careful on how to word this as don't want it to be outing.

I want to start off by saying I love my sister, I know she is a good person, but life hasn't been kind to her and consequently she has derailed quite abit which unfortunately impacts the kids the most negatively. I can't respect her as a mother anymore.

Dsis has 3 children and lives with their dad. They don't have a healthy relationship, that is a whole different thread.

My concern is dnephew. He has been sick for quite a while with this chronic symptoms that won't seem to go. On the outside my nephew looks and seems fine. I've constantly pointed out to dsis and family his symptom doesn't seem right and needs checking upon. He is 6. This has been ongoing for a year now until recently his symptom has got worse and means that he is constantly throwing up. Again he still looks well but the poor thing is suffering and has become normalised to being sick. Me, dparents, and my siblings have all said nephew needs to go to the drs asap. However everytime we say this dsis comes up a list of excuses.

First it was the drs can't see him on the same day

Then it was they won't want to know it's not that bad

Then it was oh well I'm working and bla bla bla.

Thing is dsis constantly makes time for herself and her unhealthy needs. Meanwhile my nephew isn't being prioritised. I can't even book the appointment for him as I have no idea what his Dr is. We are all worried he will suffocate on his own sick in the night. I'm really getting angry about dsis and her behaviour, and also their waste of space dad who can never be held responsible for anything. That child is being failed by his own parents.

What do I do? Aibu to have ago at dsis. I've had enough of being nice about it. My only worry is by confronting dsis she will distance herself and nephew from me which will mean I won't be able to know how he is or what is going on.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 13/04/2023 21:23

whyhelloo · 13/04/2023 19:22

Not really "regular medical care" but ok. By yearly routine checkups I meant the one every child has to go through.

I think mysterious on-off coughs, potentially from allergies and asthma (potentially overlapping, but they are 2 different things), might be thought of in a more relaxed way where I'm from.

On this MN thread, if it is reflective of the UK, the approach seems very much "YOUR CHILD COULD DIE IN THE NEXT 5 MINS!!!!!!" (which yes, I do appreciate is a legitimate risk).

Generally asthma plus allergy (eg hay fever) medication is available OTC where I'm from. Some kids aren't even diagnosed – if allergies and/or asthma run in the family, just lots of outdoor play in fresh air to strengthen lungs and try to make chronic cough go away for a while.

I did wonder if maybe we just have a ridiculously ignorant approach... I'm a bit of a nerd so I googled statistics. The asthma mortality rate plus exacerbation rate in my country is similar to or lower than that of the UK, despite having similar initial asthma occurrence statistics.

Again, reinforcing that I think it's crazy to have got to the point of vomiting. But people seem so hung up on the 1 year thing – I would not do that personally, but I can see how some parents would've let it get to that stage, even on MN where you sometimes see posters ask about their child's chronic on-off cough.

Here is the big difference. In the UK you don’t do regular yearly check up. If all healthy then they can go years between seeing a medical professional.

In your case, there was a diagnosis, medicine and yearly reviews. Totally different to the scenario described.

LuckyPeonies · 13/04/2023 21:18

aunty2 · 13/04/2023 16:53

@IForgotMyUsernameAgain coughing. To the point that he can't breath and throws up

I have asthma. It is a potentially serious illness which must be treated. If he does have asthma and coughs so much that he can’t breathe and then throws up, he could end up with a severe asthma attack and suffocate. If he has asthma, he needs allergy and breathing tests, plus daily maintenance meds and rescue inhalers. Please help him.

Gagaandgag · 13/04/2023 20:58

Op can you speak with your nephew privately about it?

Jagoda · 13/04/2023 20:58

I would call the school and SS to raise a welfare concern.

This poor child has been suffering for a year, with exacerbated symptoms since half term, so seven or eight weeks.

If you don’t do the right thing OP, how will you sleep at night?

Mamamess · 13/04/2023 20:57

whyhelloo · 13/04/2023 18:25

Wow... I feel like I'm going crazy from the hysterics/ lack of reading comprehension on this thread.

The throwing up has only been going on for 1-2 weeks, not a year. I agree any decent mother would rush their child to the doctor, but will SS actually consider 1-2 weeks abuse/neglect? Especially considering how hard it is to book a GP these days – I tried getting my DC same-day appointments a few times unsuccessfully over weeks (though I know this mother is not trying at all).

It looks like they have only had a cough for a year. Yes it should definitely have been seen to earlier, but at the same time a long term cough is generally common, especially in children with allergies or asthma.

Me too this is how I read it. One symptom been going on for a year later explained in a post to be a cough. Symptom has recently got much worse leading child to throw up. Same still applies Op needs to act but shame the Op got completely tore into.

whyhelloo · 13/04/2023 20:44

@UnshakenNeedsStirring yes of course, I think the wiser thing to do would be to just somehow take him to the bloody dr herself though.

Plus it's a pity asthma inhalers not available OTC in the UK as trialling asthma inhalers is not harmful, probably no more than taking Calpol for everything anyway! Is hay fever/allergy medication available OTC in the UK? OP can pass some to her sister to try in low doses.

Reason why direct action is more effective imo – I don't know how long the SS process will take; secondly, I don't know if this meets the threshold. The poor boy in the link above had a literal crack den household and SS didn't really intervene.

UK posters are saying not taking child to GP for chronic cough is abuse though, so ok (though I'm still not sure if MN reflective of real life as why didn't school/teachers ask, if it had been going on for a year?) maybe SS would consider it so. To me the ignoring vomiting bit is more shocking, but I think ignoring vomiting might be ok/common in the UK.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 13/04/2023 20:42

Take him to A&E? Call his school?

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 13/04/2023 20:38

@whyhelloo how on earth is the poor boy going to get better without any adult taking responsibility and having him seen?
OP should be on the phone to her sister and then she should be reporting her to SS.
I wouldnt want to be in touch with anyone who has knowingly put any child in harms way or has deliberately neglected a child or person for that matter

whyhelloo · 13/04/2023 20:34

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 13/04/2023 20:12

This! Maybe OP is also minimising the sickness. Poor boy, hes got no one looking after him. Why do these women have kids? Its easy not to!!

Original post: This has been ongoing for a year now until recently his symptom has got worse and means that he is constantly throwing up

Later update: Ironically the throwing up with it only started when he was on half term. My mum said she is hoping when he goes up to school someone will flag it

To be honest I think OP might not be back because no one on this thread can read before going into hysterics. I do hope her poor niece gets medical help asap though, must be in such discomfort with the vomiting

DrPrunesquallor · 13/04/2023 20:32

2bazookas · 13/04/2023 15:54

I'd just contact social services with details (and address of his school, who must be aware of this) and ask them to investigate urgently.

They won't tell Dsis it came from you and if the child has been so ill for so long, there must be many concerned adults. So she won't blame you.

This is excellent advice.
Take control of the situation as your sister won’t.

CurlyTop1980 · 13/04/2023 20:30

Take him to the walk in centre and voice your concerns. Tell his school. Tell your sister. There is nothing more important than Safeguarding children. This is when things go wrong- you're the one seeing it. You need to act on this. No SW/Gp/school will.unless YOU TELL them.

whyhelloo · 13/04/2023 20:26

@alyceflowers I mean someone up there said they'd ignore a kid vomiting for several weeks, which would be utterly crazy and considered deadly/negligent where I'm from (not shaming them btw, they are in the UK), so hey presto, cultural differences... that is, assuming MN is even reflective of real life

To clarify, I think some people, esp my vvv anxious mother, would go to a dr at least once if totally unexplained on-off cough for a relatively long period (not weeks as you said, that's too paranoid)

Equally many others would just put it off for ages (free healthcare btw so not a factor), hoping/assuming it's allergies that will eventually die down on its own. Lots of fresh air for the kid. Many will variously trial OTC inhalers (not harmful for non asthmatics even according to uk guidance) or OTC hayfever / allergy medication

Also don't know how OP is to blame, as coughs tend to fluctuate or be on-off, so every time she visits it won't be consistent, may be fed the "it's getting better" line (up until vomiting lately)

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 13/04/2023 20:12

aloris · 13/04/2023 19:21

In your original post you said this has been going on for a year. Later you said it has only been since this half-term. ???

This! Maybe OP is also minimising the sickness. Poor boy, hes got no one looking after him. Why do these women have kids? Its easy not to!!

SuperSue77 · 13/04/2023 20:10

Not read the full thread but could it be whooping cough? I know children are vaccinated against these days, but not everyone has the vaccine. I had it when I was a similar age to your nephew and I would throw up after I coughed. According to the NHS website it can last 2-3 months and after 3 weeks of having it no treatment is given, so it might be a case of getting better over time. Hoping he gets better soon whatever is causing it.

G21 · 13/04/2023 20:10

Why don’t you call an ambulance? Or get a home visit. Your mother can be in the house and call them, that way she can answer questions being asked on the phone. I would act now, rather then have regrets.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 13/04/2023 20:09

You sister is an awful person and your mum is a disgrace as she is enabling her daughter. Do you wan a tragedy to one of the kids before you lift a finger.
OP, dont stand and watch, you dont want this on your conscience.
Please report this asap.

Nocutenamesleft · 13/04/2023 20:07

For those saying she could be causing it. I would say unlikely. Fictitious disorder by proxy is about wanting to have attention on you and neglect is never a sign of it as it kinda goes against nearly all reasons for it.

Gagaandgag · 13/04/2023 19:50

OnMyWayToSenility · 13/04/2023 15:50

I'm sure your nephew would like someone to help him and not turn a blind eye! I'd rather be cut off than see a child suffer

👏

Justalittlebitduckling · 13/04/2023 19:48

Make an anonymous safeguarding concern to school. Every child matters.

Twilight7777 · 13/04/2023 19:43

Agree with others that your mother is complicit in the abuse, as are you if nothing is done. Ring social services anonymously if you must, but for the love of god please do something!

Morningcoffeeview · 13/04/2023 19:41

Totally disagree with making a scene and marching him to A&E. if he’s not in immediate danger, call social services or speak to his school. Be supportive of your DSIS and act totally dumbstruck when you find out about SS. You might help him this once if you make a scene but long term you won’t be able to and I think it would be better for him to have you as an insider, speaking to relevant agencies where necessary than ostracised by your sister and cut off from your nephew.

alyceflowers · 13/04/2023 19:41

whyhelloo · 13/04/2023 19:22

Not really "regular medical care" but ok. By yearly routine checkups I meant the one every child has to go through.

I think mysterious on-off coughs, potentially from allergies and asthma (potentially overlapping, but they are 2 different things), might be thought of in a more relaxed way where I'm from.

On this MN thread, if it is reflective of the UK, the approach seems very much "YOUR CHILD COULD DIE IN THE NEXT 5 MINS!!!!!!" (which yes, I do appreciate is a legitimate risk).

Generally asthma plus allergy (eg hay fever) medication is available OTC where I'm from. Some kids aren't even diagnosed – if allergies and/or asthma run in the family, just lots of outdoor play in fresh air to strengthen lungs and try to make chronic cough go away for a while.

I did wonder if maybe we just have a ridiculously ignorant approach... I'm a bit of a nerd so I googled statistics. The asthma mortality rate plus exacerbation rate in my country is similar to or lower than that of the UK, despite having similar initial asthma occurrence statistics.

Again, reinforcing that I think it's crazy to have got to the point of vomiting. But people seem so hung up on the 1 year thing – I would not do that personally, but I can see how some parents would've let it get to that stage, even on MN where you sometimes see posters ask about their child's chronic on-off cough.

I don't believe it is normal in any country with a decent healthcare system to ignore a child coughing for weeks/months/a year without seeking any medical attention, but if you insist it is normal in your country then fine.

Creditscoredrop · 13/04/2023 19:34

Cleoforever · 13/04/2023 15:51

The child attends school?

what’s his absence rate like

I wouldn’t “have a go at my sister”

because someone like this a essentially abusing their child. I would speak to the school a a concerned close family member. I would be very very surprised if they too aren’t getting concerned

tomorrow

I just wanted to agree with this point.

Have a similar situation with my SIL who is very volatile and there is no reasoning with her. So I totally understand not being able to make her see what is right without losing contact with DN. We raised our concerns with the school who already had their own concerns with DNs behaviour. I’m not sure if the situation has been completely resolved but at least we feel like we have said something and we know they are on the schools radar.

I don’t know what else you can do other than report? Don’t tell your mum you’ve done it if she will cause drama too. Ultimately it’s about keeping your nephew safe.

I hope your nephew gets the help he needs and your sister too if she needs it. Try not to be too hard on yourself, it’s an incredibly stressful situation to feel all you can do is just watch the destruction and bad decisions. But, you’ve offered help and keep on doing so but it’s being rejected and there’s nothing left but to get the school and/or social services involved. Best of luck to you all. 💐

mindutopia · 13/04/2023 19:31

By ‘this half term’ do you mean Easter Holidays? Half term was in February. If he’s been vomiting constantly, since Feb, yes a concern and I would ring the school and SS. I would assume the school already knows.

If you mean, Easter holidays, those started last week. I would assume he has a bug like nearly everyone does right now. I’ve never taken any of mine to the GP for a vomiting bug. It will run its course but they will be off for several weeks. No need to be ringing SS.