Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dsis is neglecting her own child

410 replies

aunty2 · 13/04/2023 15:33

I know neglect is a big word to use, but at this point I'm at my wits end and had enough. I will be careful on how to word this as don't want it to be outing.

I want to start off by saying I love my sister, I know she is a good person, but life hasn't been kind to her and consequently she has derailed quite abit which unfortunately impacts the kids the most negatively. I can't respect her as a mother anymore.

Dsis has 3 children and lives with their dad. They don't have a healthy relationship, that is a whole different thread.

My concern is dnephew. He has been sick for quite a while with this chronic symptoms that won't seem to go. On the outside my nephew looks and seems fine. I've constantly pointed out to dsis and family his symptom doesn't seem right and needs checking upon. He is 6. This has been ongoing for a year now until recently his symptom has got worse and means that he is constantly throwing up. Again he still looks well but the poor thing is suffering and has become normalised to being sick. Me, dparents, and my siblings have all said nephew needs to go to the drs asap. However everytime we say this dsis comes up a list of excuses.

First it was the drs can't see him on the same day

Then it was they won't want to know it's not that bad

Then it was oh well I'm working and bla bla bla.

Thing is dsis constantly makes time for herself and her unhealthy needs. Meanwhile my nephew isn't being prioritised. I can't even book the appointment for him as I have no idea what his Dr is. We are all worried he will suffocate on his own sick in the night. I'm really getting angry about dsis and her behaviour, and also their waste of space dad who can never be held responsible for anything. That child is being failed by his own parents.

What do I do? Aibu to have ago at dsis. I've had enough of being nice about it. My only worry is by confronting dsis she will distance herself and nephew from me which will mean I won't be able to know how he is or what is going on.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Throckmorton · 16/04/2023 22:11

@aunty2 - you know people can die of asthma? Even if there is nothing else going on, he could go to sleep one day and never wake up due to his asthma. Or he could collapse one day and die right there. Asthma kills, and by standing by and doing nothing, you are contributing to the risk of him dying. he could be fine one day, dead the next. Don't be that aunt.

LolaLu1980 · 16/04/2023 21:33

My curiosity was around your repeated posts confidently suggesting that there was nothing to be concerned about for the OP’s nephew and that MN was just creating drama, and what exactly you meant by a ‘SS legal threshold’ in relation to actually protecting this little boy from a possibly serious illness that none of his caregivers were accessing medical help for. And also your ignorance of the other red flags around his well-being, given that OP has stated that his parents have had previous SS input for arguments (and the nephew has disclosed to OP that this still goes on), that he is smacked regularly by his dad/mothers partner and that his mum has unhealthy habits that she prioritises over the care of her children. As someone who does work first hand in a child
protection field, there is enough written in OP’s posts to worry me, and to absolutely merit SS doing an assessment of this child’s situation, and I find it amazing that you choose to fixate on the ‘overuse of inhalers’ when the child hasn’t even been diagnosed with asthma. Really amazing…..
But thanks for clarifying the legal bits for me…😃

whyhelloo · 16/04/2023 20:23

LolaLu1980 · 15/04/2023 16:54

What exactly is the ‘legal SS threshold’ you make reference to? I’m curious…..

Assuming you are genuinely curious, I actually grew curious as well. According to a quick Lexis Nexis: harm requirement in Children Act 1989 S31(2) and S31(9). For statutory interpretation, see Re B; Re L; Re A (the court will be willing to tolerate “very diverse standards of parenting, including the eccentric, the barely adequate and the inconsistent”); and most significantly North East Lincolnshire Council v G and L ("the courts are not in the business of social engineering"). Obviously lots to read up on if your curiosity persists!

whyhelloo · 16/04/2023 20:09

HRA is under my former field of expertise btw. So while social services isn't, I know the requirements for a justified breach will probably be onerous!

whyhelloo · 16/04/2023 20:08

Wow, I'm actually a bit confused... I'm sure those 2-syllable words would be self-explanatory to most people, so I can only imagine the both of you are acting oblivious / feigning illiteracy on purpose – or just have a really poor vocabulary? @LolaLu1980

The right to undisturbed family and private life is enshrined in law (ECHR art 8 at first but now incorporated in the UK under HRA), so while admittedly social services isn't my area of expertise at all, legally speaking there is always going to be a legal threshold for these bodies to step into your domestic life! That's why they conduct an initial assessment, and why I imagine there will be lots of paperwork afterwards. Social services isn't generally known to act quickly, and I can't imagine how that would be beneficial when this boy needs immediate medical attention due to the vomiting.

LolaLu1980 · 15/04/2023 17:09

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 17:00

Best to ignore @whyhelloo
we all know that “legal SS threshold” is the posters making shit up!

🤣🤣

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 17:00

LolaLu1980 · 15/04/2023 16:54

What exactly is the ‘legal SS threshold’ you make reference to? I’m curious…..

Best to ignore @whyhelloo
we all know that “legal SS threshold” is the posters making shit up!

LolaLu1980 · 15/04/2023 16:54

whyhelloo · 15/04/2023 11:28

Oh dear. There is no magical cure or remedy for asthma. You actually seem to believe there is some magic bionic cure – which might be why you've been continuing this ridiculousness for pages, implying my parents had a poor relationship with my brother(??) and lots of other weird stuff, just because they didn't have access to your top secret classified imaginary magic cure.

I would genuinely say where I'm from, we have a more informed understanding compared to what it seems to be in the UK, if your belief in a magic cure is any indication? Plus, in relation with the unique mould and damp conditions here, asthma is seen as a more complex and alarming condition – sudden deaths etc. Which does legitimise the MN concern. I've said all of this in previous posts.

Generally we take a multi-pronged approach of OTC inhalers, steroids and medication (none are available in the UK), anything else that's prescribed upon doing various tests, exercise/fresh air etc.

Perhaps this is not common knowledge in the UK: overuse of inhalers and medication worsens asthma in the long term. This is a well-documented fact. In many circumstances, no matter how much it pains you, you have to ignore a mild but persistent cough (in terms of medication - not emotions, attention for your child, etc). It's incredibly detrimental and harmful parenting to keep administering your child a quick fix that worsens their condition in the long-term, just to make yourself feel better.

And, as we've been through multiple times, if you rush to the doctor 500 times a year, every single time your child coughs, the doctor will not be able to do anything anyway.

Many children "grow out of it" (before this becomes another one of your conspiracy theories, the medical term is "became asymptomatic", and it's extremely common in children with asthma). Both my brother and I had asthma/coughing which was dealt with before we became asymptomatic – me much, much earlier than him though, so I can barely remember that period.

I've explained multiple times that I wouldn't do the same as this woman, I don't condone her irresponsibility, but in light of the legal SS threshold plus the fact that his school didn't consider his cough a concern for the whole duration, I'm unsure if all the pearl-clutching "you must contact SS now, for the love of god!" posts are counterproductive to the immediate ends of getting the boy to a doctor immediately.

Again, I'll leave you to swoon over the sound of your own voice, actually this time.

What exactly is the ‘legal SS threshold’ you make reference to? I’m curious…..

Exhibity · 15/04/2023 12:32

@whyhelloo can you get otc inhalers in the UK ?

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 11:32

Again, I'll leave you to swoon over the sound of your own voice, actually this time.

fingers crossed! 😂

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 11:31

so I'll leave you to it!

WineIsMyMainVice · 15/04/2023 11:30

Greensleeves · 13/04/2023 15:45

I would have one blunt - not nasty, but plain-speaking - conversation with her and let her know that she must seek help for him immediately - no excuses. If she doesn't repond properly to that, then I think I'd call SS. This child could be seriously ill. Not a nice thing to have to do do a family member, but children's welfare always trumps everything else.

Sorry you're in this position. I've been there and it sucks. But someone has to do the right thing for this child.

Exactly this.
good luck op. Hope he gets some proper treatment soon.

whyhelloo · 15/04/2023 11:28

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 11:07

So the child was diagnosed asthmatic

but still had a constant cough throughout childhood

and it was ignored

no treatment or remedy sought? Asthma can be treated very effectively

Oh dear. There is no magical cure or remedy for asthma. You actually seem to believe there is some magic bionic cure – which might be why you've been continuing this ridiculousness for pages, implying my parents had a poor relationship with my brother(??) and lots of other weird stuff, just because they didn't have access to your top secret classified imaginary magic cure.

I would genuinely say where I'm from, we have a more informed understanding compared to what it seems to be in the UK, if your belief in a magic cure is any indication? Plus, in relation with the unique mould and damp conditions here, asthma is seen as a more complex and alarming condition – sudden deaths etc. Which does legitimise the MN concern. I've said all of this in previous posts.

Generally we take a multi-pronged approach of OTC inhalers, steroids and medication (none are available in the UK), anything else that's prescribed upon doing various tests, exercise/fresh air etc.

Perhaps this is not common knowledge in the UK: overuse of inhalers and medication worsens asthma in the long term. This is a well-documented fact. In many circumstances, no matter how much it pains you, you have to ignore a mild but persistent cough (in terms of medication - not emotions, attention for your child, etc). It's incredibly detrimental and harmful parenting to keep administering your child a quick fix that worsens their condition in the long-term, just to make yourself feel better.

And, as we've been through multiple times, if you rush to the doctor 500 times a year, every single time your child coughs, the doctor will not be able to do anything anyway.

Many children "grow out of it" (before this becomes another one of your conspiracy theories, the medical term is "became asymptomatic", and it's extremely common in children with asthma). Both my brother and I had asthma/coughing which was dealt with before we became asymptomatic – me much, much earlier than him though, so I can barely remember that period.

I've explained multiple times that I wouldn't do the same as this woman, I don't condone her irresponsibility, but in light of the legal SS threshold plus the fact that his school didn't consider his cough a concern for the whole duration, I'm unsure if all the pearl-clutching "you must contact SS now, for the love of god!" posts are counterproductive to the immediate ends of getting the boy to a doctor immediately.

Again, I'll leave you to swoon over the sound of your own voice, actually this time.

rc22 · 15/04/2023 11:24

Hankunamatata · 13/04/2023 15:38

Is he throwing up in school? Surely they will have raised it

Was also wondering this.

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 11:08

so I'll leave you to it!

thank you

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 11:07

So the child was diagnosed asthmatic

but still had a constant cough throughout childhood

and it was ignored

no treatment or remedy sought? Asthma can be treated very effectively

whyhelloo · 15/04/2023 11:06

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 10:43

Had very middle class attentive parents plus nannies - in fact my mum was a major hypochondriac around her own and our health. But generally we just ignored his permanent cough because we knew it was asthma/hay fever.@whyhelloo do you have children?

because if my child had a permanent cough, I would be crawling over hot coals to get to the bottom of the issue and treat it.

a permanent cough would have had such an impact on his quality of life in terms of sport, sleep, everything actually

By just “ignoring” your parents must have realised this and yet the ignored it.

That is awful and I ask if you have children because I am curious whether you would ignore or whether you would seek every avenue for treatment and be very disturbed by your child coughing so very regularly ?

Hahahah yes, if my child was diagnosed with the common childhood condition of asthma or allergies, I would sit outside A&E everyday in homeless rags to doggedly protest the fact that they haven't invented a magical cure yet.

I would quit my job and take Big Pharma to The World Court! I would crowdfund for Top Secret Scientist Lawyers. Mumsnet would flock to chip in for a good cause, I'm sure.

For every single cough they emerged from my child's mouth, I would whip myself once to self-flagellate for the fact that I obviously hate them and delight in abusing them.

I would also make non-stop posts on MN to draw attention to the issue (whatever issue that would be........) in hopes that Social Services and Big Pharma team up to give my child – and all other deserving children in this world! We are the world, we are the children! – a set of bionic replacement lungs. You are my role model in this aspect.

Or I might just buy my child some OTC inhalers, keep personal tabs on their condition over years, and give my child attention and sympathy without disrupting my child's daily schedule, education and life by rushing them into urgent care every single day, and installing a direct line to the hospital and Social Services in my living room.

I appreciate my brother's situation and OP's situation aren't exactly the same, but I've made multiple posts explaining the nuanced similarities and differences, and overall general context. At this point I honestly think you just truly adooooooore the sound of your own voice, so I'll leave you to it!

Gingernaut · 15/04/2023 11:05

aunty2 · 14/04/2023 09:41

Dnephew is NOT being physically abused for god sake. I'm not having this thread escalate into something it's not.

https://www.nspcc.org.uk/what-is-child-abuse/types-of-abuse/neglect/

He absolutely IS being abused.

Medical neglect is abuse.

Neglect

Neglect can be hard to spot. We've got advice on the types and signs of neglect and what you can do if you’re worried about a child.

https://www.nspcc.org.uk/what-is-child-abuse/types-of-abuse/neglect

whyhelloo · 15/04/2023 10:56

Chazzles81 · 15/04/2023 10:36

No, smacking is illegal in Wales (I live here):

Sorry, England and NI

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 10:50

Oh sorry @whyhelloo

you do have children

so my question - would you do as your mother did and ignore her son’s permanent cough throughout his childhood?

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 10:45

it is legal in England and Wales for a carer or parent to discipline their child physically if it is a "reasonable" punishment

ignore @whyhelloo
all physical punishment is illegal in Wales

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 10:43

Had very middle class attentive parents plus nannies - in fact my mum was a major hypochondriac around her own and our health. But generally we just ignored his permanent cough because we knew it was asthma/hay fever.@whyhelloo do you have children?

because if my child had a permanent cough, I would be crawling over hot coals to get to the bottom of the issue and treat it.

a permanent cough would have had such an impact on his quality of life in terms of sport, sleep, everything actually

By just “ignoring” your parents must have realised this and yet the ignored it.

That is awful and I ask if you have children because I am curious whether you would ignore or whether you would seek every avenue for treatment and be very disturbed by your child coughing so very regularly ?

Chazzles81 · 15/04/2023 10:36

whyhelloo · 15/04/2023 03:56

Just to amend my earlier post:

I've said multiple times I think this mother is irresponsible. At the same time, how many posts on MN have you seen where a mother hasn't completely stayed on top of a child's chronic cough, or recurring illness? "We thought it was getting better and then it keeps coming back". It would be extremely easy for an otherwise middle class looking mother to claim she was in that category, even though we know she's not.

Re: smacking – it is legal in England and Wales for a carer or parent to discipline their child physically if it is a "reasonable" punishment. Smacking is very, very much within the bounds of legality. I don't hit my own children, don't like the thought of a child being hit, but absolutely no one is going to have their child taken away for smacking.

2 weeks of vomiting – many parents let vomiting bugs run their course in the child. I do think this is a major visible and quantifiable red flag though, especially given the vomiting might be respiratory-illness based, is potentially what could get SS over the legal threshold to get involved.

Sorry to multiple post but I just find the pearl-clutching hysteria on MN so ridiculous and lacking in critical thought – plus, crucially, unhelpful. Get the child in front of an actual doctor first and then you can spam call SS all you want, probably fruitlessly, but you're very free to try.

No, smacking is illegal in Wales (I live here):

Ending physical punishment of children | GOV.WALES

From March 2022 the law in Wales is changing. Physically punishing a child - in any way, will be against the law.

https://www.gov.wales/ending-physical-punishment-children#:~:text=What's%20the%20law%20on%20physical,protection%20from%20assault%20as%20adults.

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 10:29

Sorry that was for @whyhelloo 💐

Cleoforever · 15/04/2023 10:29

Gosh! 😬 !

Swipe left for the next trending thread