Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying for luggage and seats together on flights?

62 replies

RosemaryAndTime · 13/04/2023 13:53

If you were costing flights for a family of 4 would you consider the charges for seats together and luggage as "extras" or as part of the overall cost for what you need?

If I'm travelling alone and don't need luggage, I consider this a saving I can take advantage of.

I like the separate pricing as I can choose what I need but so many people seem to really resent this sort of pricing, especially over seating!

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 13/04/2023 16:14

Luggage I think is a reasonable extra. Charging so you can sit together I resent as that’s often a matter of them creating an issue in order to charge for fixing it rather than simply charging more for something thats more desireable to others in order to manage demand or cover the costs of providing it.

GBoucher · 13/04/2023 16:11

Quveas · 13/04/2023 15:50

I agree this is going too far. Obesity can be a result of a health condition not poor dietary habits - policing "lifestyle" over "health conditions" is not a road we should be expecting companies to go down.

My comment was not at all a value judgement on thinness vs fatness. I am aware people's weight (or height) isn't something that can be controlled at will. The passenger+baggage combined weight pricing scheme is merely a cost-based model. A heavier passenger+baggage weight is costlier to transport than a lighter one, so everyone is charged according to their combined weight. My husband is tall and finds economy seating very cramped and uncomfortable, so he pays to fly business. It's not his fault he's tall, he was born that way. Does that mean he should pay economy price to sit in business? If you are of the opinion that a combined weight pricing scheme is 'unfair' on obese people who can't control their weight, then tall people who have to fly business should also not have to pay any more than a short person in economy.

MNisMyGuiltyPleasure · 13/04/2023 15:52

Very fair to make them extras when not everyone wants them. When they are not extra, travelers who are not using them, are still paying for them.

Quveas · 13/04/2023 15:50

Neededanewuserhandle · 13/04/2023 14:19

Should an obese person weighing 400kg with no baggage pay less than a 30kg person with 20kg of baggage?
Put another way though and setting the extreme argument about obese people aside: why should a petite person who weighs less just because they are small get a discount over a taller person? They have no control over their size - the all person could never be as light as the shorter one.

I agree this is going too far. Obesity can be a result of a health condition not poor dietary habits - policing "lifestyle" over "health conditions" is not a road we should be expecting companies to go down.

randomsabreuse · 13/04/2023 15:43

Airlines are one of the few situations where it does actually cost more to move more weight. So there's more justification of charging by weight (airfreight) as well as by volume (per seat).

Obviously big commercial planes of the 3+3 variety don't need to weigh and balance every single passenger but all the small planes will weigh every single thing and person that gets on the plane and calculate fuel load, take off etc accordingly!

Nordicrain · 13/04/2023 15:43

I think it generally works fine if the airline is sensible. That said apparently some airlines specifically split up families to encourage people to pay to be sat together. That's annoying.

TheKobayashiMaru · 13/04/2023 15:40

Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday · 13/04/2023 13:58

It used to all be included, people wanted ‘low cost’ flights and therefore these things to be optional so if they weren’t bothered about them the could make savings.

I think that’s definitely been forgotten

I remember this as well. You once paid a lot for flights but now you have the option as to what you want included. I pay for seat allocations as I am particular where I sit.

randomsabreuse · 13/04/2023 15:38

I'd like to be able to pay for a proper sized piece of hand luggage but not have it bundled into the "choose a seat" side of things. I'm generally flying solo so I don't care where I sit (prefer window but not enough to pay £££ for it) but do want to make sure crucial kit gets through (one of the things is too big for the mini luggage slot without a bag around it, even though the bag definitely fits in the under seat area!) so accept the extra cost. I'm also short so have never found leg room a problem on any flight!

I was annoyed that you can only check in 24h in advance if you don't book a specific seat (Ryanair) as 48h gives a lot more opportunity to find reliable internet when travelling. Also cost of roaming so I gritted my teeth and paid for one of the cheapest "assigned" seats £8 to be able to check in before I left for my outward flight!

Most of my travel is hand luggage plus sports equipment (with an extra hand luggage item for outbound only) so it's kind of handy to pick what I care about.

I'd probably give in and book seats regardless of travelling with the kids (although I'm very tempted to book the 3 in a row under 1 booking and let the other adult be wherever).

I don't really care who I'm next to on a flight, happy with my book!

GBoucher · 13/04/2023 15:29

@Neededanewuserhandle It's not 'fair', but fairness doesn't come into it. It's a business. A heavier person+baggage costs less to transport than a lighter person+baggage. Let's say someone is a really unusual size (extremely tall, short, fat, skinny, whatever) to the extent that they can't wear off the rack clothes because their size isn't catered for in the mass market due to extreme rarity. They have to get their clothes specially tailored which is obviously heaps more expensive than buying off the rack. It's not their fault they're that size but they still have to pay the extra to get clothes that fit them. They can't force mass market clothing companies to produce clothes in sizes only they can wear and sell to them for the same price as the 'standard' range of clothing. There are many examples like this in the world. Inconveniences or costs that you have to deal with due to something that you can't control. Why should flying be any different?

TruffleShuffles · 13/04/2023 15:27

Maverickess · 13/04/2023 14:33

I think it needs to be more transparent, so you get the price of the basic flight and then the 'extras' priced and available to choose right at the start, not at the end when you've put everything in to find out a actually it's almost doubled because you want to sit next to your child or you want to take some luggage on holiday with you.
But I guess they do it that way because it's harder and more time consuming to shop around and get different prices.

This is how it’s done, Ryanair has 3 different prices when you click on each flight at the very beginning.

purplecorkheart · 13/04/2023 15:23

I like the fact that you can get a flight cheaply and then pay for the extras you need. However that is because I travel a lot on my own and rarely check in a bag. With airlines where luggage is included for everyone then you are paying for this in the ticket price regardless as whether you are checking a bag or not so basically you are paying for someone else bag if you do not check one,

Clymene · 13/04/2023 15:18

Extras. I often travel alone for the day for meetings. I don't want to pay for things I don't need.

BillyNoM8s · 13/04/2023 15:18

It doesnt bother me on the budget airlines, though I do hate how much faff there is to find the final price.

Pisses me off that all the "premium" airlines seem to charge for both now. It gets incredibly expensive to choose seats on long haul flights with Qatar/BA etc. Their base flight prices never got any cheaper. They just added on extra charges for things they used to include as standard.

Champagneforeveryone · 13/04/2023 15:14

My seat costs the cost of the flight, anything else is an extra in my view.

If we fly short haul we don't pay to book seats as there's only DH and I and we can sit independently for a couple of hours. The money we've saved can pay for a nice meal or similar. We've actually only ever been separated either side of an aisle, but maybe we've been lucky.

We're flying long haul next month and have paid for allocated seats as DH will never last 9 hours without someone to natter to 🙄

We pay for the amount of luggage we need. I much prefer this as it encourages us to pack light and means we're not penalised for not taking a full wardrobe away with us.

JeansSausageSurprise · 13/04/2023 15:05

Luggage as an extra I don’t mind at all.

I do resent having to pay extra to sit next to my young child though, especially when I don’t give an arse about ‘choosing seats’ as such, I just want them together.

countrygirl99 · 13/04/2023 14:57

This has been the short haul model for years so anyone assuming the headline price isn't the final price needs to catch up. I like the separate elements. Sometimes I'm traveling light and on my own and only pay the basic. I can get a return to Finland to see family for less than £100. Sometimes I'm with family and with luggage so pay more. I can pay what is appropriate for me each time.

EsmeSusanOgg · 13/04/2023 14:51

Maverickess · 13/04/2023 14:33

I think it needs to be more transparent, so you get the price of the basic flight and then the 'extras' priced and available to choose right at the start, not at the end when you've put everything in to find out a actually it's almost doubled because you want to sit next to your child or you want to take some luggage on holiday with you.
But I guess they do it that way because it's harder and more time consuming to shop around and get different prices.

This. It feels a bit bait-and-switchy otherwise.

EsmeSusanOgg · 13/04/2023 14:50

Freshstarts22 · 13/04/2023 13:57

I resent it. I think seats and luggage should be included as a rule but there should be the option of a downgraded version to pick if you want.

If I price up flights for our family and it shows me £500, but then it’s actually more like £800 when I’ve added extras then I feel cheated. I think it’s worse because when pricing up holidays, some companies include it and some don’t. So I might get a price that’s affordable, assuming in everything’s included, to find out later it isn’t and I can’t afford that holiday.

Agree. For example, a reservation and meal and basic checked luggage were included as standard (back in the day!) But you could opt to downgrade and not have the meal to save £10 a seat each way... Now everything is 'added on'..

Isseywith3witchycats · 13/04/2023 14:39

we fly with jet2 and their free hold baggage is very generous and no extra charge and as my OH is 6ft 4 i dont mind paying extra for a seat that means he dosent have his knees under his chin the whole flight

Toottooot · 13/04/2023 14:34

If I want a specific seat or to sit together then I fully expect I pay for it. Depending on airline - same for luggage.

Maverickess · 13/04/2023 14:33

I think it needs to be more transparent, so you get the price of the basic flight and then the 'extras' priced and available to choose right at the start, not at the end when you've put everything in to find out a actually it's almost doubled because you want to sit next to your child or you want to take some luggage on holiday with you.
But I guess they do it that way because it's harder and more time consuming to shop around and get different prices.

Brunilde · 13/04/2023 14:31

People can't seem to understand that if booking seats and luggage was free your ticket would be more expensive. It's not rocket science. If you want those things you will pay more. It's an added bonus for those who don't need them.

Ponoka7 · 13/04/2023 14:22

As said, if booking a all inclusive family holiday, they should come as standard. For city break flights, they should be add ons.

Neededanewuserhandle · 13/04/2023 14:19

Should an obese person weighing 400kg with no baggage pay less than a 30kg person with 20kg of baggage?
Put another way though and setting the extreme argument about obese people aside: why should a petite person who weighs less just because they are small get a discount over a taller person? They have no control over their size - the all person could never be as light as the shorter one.

TruffleShuffles · 13/04/2023 14:14

We’re a family of 4 and I like the extras, I don’t need luggage for all 4 of us so I like the option of adding maybe one large case and a couple of carry ons. I very much benefitted from the options when it was only me and my husband and we could get away with carry on luggage and risking the seating allocation so I don’t mind now paying the extra for seats together and an extra bit of more luggage.