Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't ask me to confirm who I am!

106 replies

Inthebathagain · 13/04/2023 11:29

Is it just me who can't get their head around a bank/company ringing you up from an unknown number, telling you who they are and expecting you to confirm your mother's maiden name/dob etc?

How do I know you are who YOU say you are?!

Wherever I point this out to the person on the end of the phone, they always tell me to put the phone down and ring the company line I find on the internet...which often gets you caught up in a queue of at least 30mins.

Surely there must be some way of them giving a little information and you confirming the rest of the information? Or some other way that I as a consumer can be happy that I'm not being scammed?

AIBU?

OP posts:
PacificState · 13/04/2023 21:40

Haven't read the whole thread but are banks aware of the increasing number of people who have Alzheimer's or other kinds of cognitive decline? My dad was targeted by scammers last year, they got bloody close to emptying his account. How on earth is my 80-something dad with brain disease supposed to parse the sophisticated nuance of 'personal but not identifying' FFS?

Although tbh the way high street banks just do not give the tiniest fuck about customers with Alzheimer's is a whole other thread.

Elphame · 13/04/2023 21:38

I am very unco-operative when they do this to me.

They just get told to write or email me if it's important and that I am not divulging any personal information over the phone.

Never hear from them again so it's probably just a sales call.

PerkingFaintly · 13/04/2023 21:32

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 13/04/2023 20:38

The gigantic hole in the picture is the utter failure of the bank to realise that the person they are calling ALSO needs to put the bank through security, for the same reason

The problem here is that the banks are simply unable to conceptualise that security is a two-way process. They're clearly in little castles of their own making, going, "Out there it's all baddies, but WE'RE THE GOOD GUYS."

Do you think that people that work in the bank don't have bank accounts of their own?

Honestly, I appreciate you don't like these processes, but this just makes you sound utterly dense. Banks have entire arms of their back office staff dealing with identification issues and reporting and preventing fraud. They are completely aware that most customers don't like this - which is why it's MASSIVELY scaled back now. Banks ALL have a way to opt out of marketing calls, and only calls where there is a fraud concern will generate an outbound call (or an appointment, which you'll be expecting anyway). There's no point having a number displayed because fraudsters can spoof them anyway. There's also no point spending £££ on outbound methods of ID&V when in the main, a customer can either call in or instigate an online chat to find out what the contact was for. If the agent who's called you is arsey, that's a them problem not a bankwide issue.

PS I'm not one of the poor frontline agents that will have to speak to you. But I do work for a bank, in change and governance. So this is something that is regularly talked about and looked at.

<bashes head repeatedly against wall>

The person sounding dense here is you!

It's nothing whatever, at all, even a little bit, to do with whether I, personally, like or dislike a process. The problem here is that the banks are training customers to do something fundamentally insecure.

A person is sitting minding their own business, when the phone rings and a strange voice says, "This is your bank. Please give me the following data used to establish your identity to banks."

According to the bank's thinking, the recipient in this situation should now give their identity data to the unknown incoming caller – to do with what they will.

Yes or no?

Obviously for the customer's security, the answer is No. Therefore the bank shouldn't expect them to. Shouldn't tell them to. Shouldn't have to manage not to get arsey because... they shouldn't be asking for the information in the first place.

If the security procedure the bank would prefer is that the recipient should put the phone down (and make a test call to ensure the line really has disconnected, because that's another scam) and call in to the published bank number THEN THAT IS WHAT THE INCOMING CALLER SHOULD INSTRUCT IN THE FIRST PLACE. Not encourage the person they're calling to do something fundamentally insecure, but then "permit" them to act more securely by calling back.

This is what I mean by banks' refusal to conceptualise that security is two-way.

Or, you know, I could just believe the banks are deliberately doing something they know full well is insecure for the customer but is more convenient for the bank, if you prefer? That they understand full well, but plan that the customer will bear the loss come the day that call is from a scammer, therefore from the bank's point of view this isn't a problem?

PocketBattleship · 13/04/2023 21:27

It's not an account I'll access regularly. No chance of remembering all the codes and numbers.
So I've written them all down. Ridiculous and the opposite of what I know I should be doing. But what the hell else am I supposed to do?

Absolutely nothing wrong with writing down passwords. It's how carefully you look after the piece of paper that then becomes important.

Tarantullah · 13/04/2023 21:24

Always always hang up and phone the number of your bank directly, they don't really call and if they do they'll know what it was about when you phone back.

bumpytrumpy · 13/04/2023 21:21

I find the whole security thing infuriating.

I recently set up a new bank account. To log on I need 5 separate pieces of information (customer number, ID number, password, pin etc. Not chosen by me so impossible to make "memorable " ) PLUS a card PLUS a card reader. Logging on takes about 5 different steps including scanning a QR code on screen with the card reader.

It's not an account I'll access regularly. No chance of remembering all the codes and numbers.
So I've written them all down. Ridiculous and the opposite of what I know I should be doing. But what the hell else am I supposed to do?

SerendipityJane · 13/04/2023 20:47

There is a whole area of debate about the asymmetry of power here. Companies that are quite happy to make you wait hours to answer that at the same time have an expectation that you jump to answer your phone at the drop of a hat.

If a banks "fraud prevention" is based on a customer immediately answering a call in real time, then maybe they need better processes.

If you do want to confirm the identity of a caller claiming to be from your bank (for example) the easiest way is to deliberately give them incorrect security details and see how they react. If they know they are incorrect, then they are probably the real McCoy. Of course if they don't know they are incorrect then (a) they are probably scammers, and (b) good luck trying to use that personal data to commit fraud.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 13/04/2023 20:38

The gigantic hole in the picture is the utter failure of the bank to realise that the person they are calling ALSO needs to put the bank through security, for the same reason

The problem here is that the banks are simply unable to conceptualise that security is a two-way process. They're clearly in little castles of their own making, going, "Out there it's all baddies, but WE'RE THE GOOD GUYS."

Do you think that people that work in the bank don't have bank accounts of their own?

Honestly, I appreciate you don't like these processes, but this just makes you sound utterly dense. Banks have entire arms of their back office staff dealing with identification issues and reporting and preventing fraud. They are completely aware that most customers don't like this - which is why it's MASSIVELY scaled back now. Banks ALL have a way to opt out of marketing calls, and only calls where there is a fraud concern will generate an outbound call (or an appointment, which you'll be expecting anyway). There's no point having a number displayed because fraudsters can spoof them anyway. There's also no point spending £££ on outbound methods of ID&V when in the main, a customer can either call in or instigate an online chat to find out what the contact was for. If the agent who's called you is arsey, that's a them problem not a bankwide issue.

PS I'm not one of the poor frontline agents that will have to speak to you. But I do work for a bank, in change and governance. So this is something that is regularly talked about and looked at.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 13/04/2023 20:30

EmmaEmerald · 13/04/2023 13:32

It's not marketing though
they called me because they wanted to check a payment made into my account
I still don't know why!

...yes? Like I said, or fraud. Which if they needed to call you about it, there was something they wanted to check.

CatOnTheChair · 13/04/2023 19:38

I have failed security several times when called about my accounts - semi expected calls
No, off the top of my head, I don't have a clue what my account number the direct debit comes from is. I can get you close to the value of the last transaction, but nearest pound, not penny. I have no idea if your DD goes out on the 1st, 2nd or 3rd of the month (every single one goes on one of those three dates).
So, companies add questions that are less useful to a scammer, and block some genuine customers.
Its not straight forward to sort from either side.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/04/2023 19:32

The problem here is that the banks are simply unable to conceptualise that security is a two-way process. They're clearly in little castles of their own making, going, "Out there it's all baddies, but WE'RE THE GOOD GUYS."

There are some parallels here with how a lot of ordinary people - especially women - now view the police.

Granted, for different reasons, as it isn't actual bank employees who are trying to scam you; but, as you say, it all comes back to the insistence that 'but WE KNOW we're legitimate, so THEY should be psychic and instinctively know that we aren't the baddies who will present in exactly the same way'.

PerkingFaintly · 13/04/2023 19:20

But this is missing the point entirely.

I completely understand that the bank have to put the person who picks up the phone through a security procedure on their side to identify who they are speaking to.

The gigantic hole in the picture is the utter failure of the bank to realise that the person they are calling ALSO needs to put the bank through security, for the same reason.

It's not hard to come up with ways to do this. In fact, I do things like give a bank or other organisation a one-time codeword to use with me when they make a call that I am expecting. No codeword = they're just a scammer who hit lucky, like the "We're trying to deliver your parcel" scammers when you're expecting one.

Given the level of technological grief the bank has introduced for buying mundane groceries from high street supermarkets to be delivered to the known address of the card – multistep processes with PINs, one-time codes, etc – it's not beyond the wit of the bank to introduce a protocol for customers to security-check the bank when it calls.

The problem here is that the banks are simply unable to conceptualise that security is a two-way process. They're clearly in little castles of their own making, going, "Out there it's all baddies, but WE'RE THE GOOD GUYS."

(Obviously I am talking about the bods who set the procedures, before some bank employee starts up with "snot my fault." Yes. I know. It's still a problem; a problem being dumped by the bank ON ME. Please stop it.)

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/04/2023 19:15

I think, by way of analogy, this is a bit like approaching a child wandering through the street. Of course, if they are lost, you need to step in - but you also need to be aware that you are a stranger to them, and so they should be very cautious of you.

Of course, YOU know that you're just a concerned, innocent passer-by who wants to help a child get back home, but as far as the child knows, you could be a child abductor, abuser or worse; so ideally you would want them to be very hesitant indeed to open up and trust you - for their safety, not for your convenience or feelings.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/04/2023 19:10

We're taught that with any sign of doubt to tell them they can check the number were calling from if its visible

It's ridiculously easy for criminals to spoof the number that they're calling from nowadays, though. They often spoof a random number for their scam calls and I always feel very sorry for the ordinary person who has that number, who probably then gets angry people calling them back and saying "Don't try to lie to me; I SAW your number come up on my caller display, you were trying to scam me" - when they genuinely don't have the faintest idea what the person is going on about.

Mstxxx · 13/04/2023 18:48

I work in financial crime at a bank & I get the frustration but it is for good reason.

Firstly if you’re talking about calls that you completely aren’t expecting and have no idea about - 100% never give them your information and you are right not to answer.

However if you have asked your bank to phone you/contact you, are expecting a call back at a certain time etc - they literally cannot speak to you about your account or personal information without asking you those questions. If they don’t ask you they are breaking data protection laws. Typically this is 5 questions.

Imagine if someone got hold of your bank statement (delivered to wrong address, found outside) and they rang your bank to try and access your money or emailed them to give them a call. Your bank calls them and they can’t answer those 5 questions (name, address, DOB, account number, national insurance number) because they aren’t you - so your bank won’t speak to them. Imagine if the bank didn’t need to ask all of those questions. You’d be surprised how many fraud calls I have listened to that are very clever at trying to access someone’s account!

I get it’s annoying when it’s legitimately you but it’s for very good reason.

User365 · 13/04/2023 17:36

I work in a career that I have to go through these sorts of questions when I make a call. We're taught that with any sign of doubt to tell them they can check the number were calling from if its visible or they can call back the number on our website.

Its frustrating for us as well as you, but anything we tell the person is breaching data protection if we haven't gone through the security questions. I get that we've called you, but there's no saying that the number on the records could be incorrect, or not belong to the registered person but a family member.

You can be in a queue for half an hour, but I'd rather that than be scammed if there's doubt as to who has called.

44PumpLane · 13/04/2023 16:56

When you set up your banking you should have to set up a password that the bank says to you that means you know it's them..

"Hi Mrs 44....it's HSBC here, our key word on the account is "superstitious", if you're comfortable it's HSBC can we now take you through your security questions? After this call we will ask you to log on to your online banking and change your key word now it's been used"

Then I'd know it was them.

SerendipityJane · 13/04/2023 16:53

2bazookas · 13/04/2023 16:17

Just tell them she's deaf, so please send a letter.

In a world that still struggles to send letters in large print, that's a challenge.

MuffinToSeeHere · 13/04/2023 16:31

ocpwr · 13/04/2023 16:26

At the end of the day, if I were to answer the security questions thinking it was the bank, and it did turn out to be a scammer, I know for a fact that the bank will try their hardest not to refund me if the scammer did take money out of the account. So I don't care how hard it makes their job or how frustrated they might be on the other end. I WILL NOT risk losing my money.

Exactly what I said up thread. If the worst did happen and the call was a scam you know you wouldn't be supported by the bank in getting your money back and they would be indignant that they could not help because you willing gave the information. At the end of the day the bank are not the ones who are going to be financially in the shit if you're scammed on a call you think is your bank so no matter how inconvenient it might be for those calling I can't see why the customer is in the wrong for saying they won't provide the details.

SeatonCarew · 13/04/2023 16:29

listsandbudgets · 13/04/2023 11:32

Scam. Banks won't ( or shouldnt) call you out of the blue requesting this information and you've every right to refuse it

I can assure you NatWest fraud team do this. (Ooh, the irony!) I responded like the OP.

ocpwr · 13/04/2023 16:26

At the end of the day, if I were to answer the security questions thinking it was the bank, and it did turn out to be a scammer, I know for a fact that the bank will try their hardest not to refund me if the scammer did take money out of the account. So I don't care how hard it makes their job or how frustrated they might be on the other end. I WILL NOT risk losing my money.

Maple2023 · 13/04/2023 16:23

BelindaMelinda · 13/04/2023 16:05

I tell people why I'm ringing straight away though as it's not sensitive info

That's not strictly true.

You could tell them you were calling from the complaints/insurance renewal/credit card team or whatever - which often gives a heavy hint.

But any more than that, you're breaking DPA. I'm calling about your credit card with us - breach. I'm calling about your missed payment - breach. You've just told an unidentified person that a relationship exists between Mrs June Thomas and Barclays Bank (or whoever).

I'm being deliberately vague but when I say where I'm calling from it would mean people know Smile so I introduce myself and the name of where I'm calling from
Most people tend to answer the phone with their name which is all that I need to start talking!

Companies can't win though
We (not me) for example send emails, texts and ring people that say their car insurance is due. People think phone calls are a scam so won't confirm any details so we can't tell them and send email/letter instead
Then they say they don't want any correspondence
Then ring angry that their car insurance has expired and we haven't told them Hmm
Well we did try, then you said you didn't want any contact so...

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/04/2023 16:19

I used to work for a bank where we made outbound calls for very good reason. Some people took absolute delight in outright refusing to answer even the most basic of questions (second part of postcode or month of birth for example). Some would refuse to confirm if they were [name]. They'd make a triumphant sound as they hung up. Winning.

Fair enough if some of them were just cantankerous arses for the sake of it, that was a bit pointless; but how do you know that they hadn't already had half a dozen scam calls that day, which had already poisoned the well and drained every last bit of their goodwill and bonhomie?

They may be relatively innocuous questions, but if they're already in the mindset of 'everybody has just been calling me to try to scam me', they're likely to object to everything. I know that, when I have a definite/likely/possible scam or cold sales call, I don't want to engage with them at all.

They usually start off with a 'Good afternoon, and how are you on this fine day?' kind of faux-pleasantry - part of their playbook to try to get you on side so that they can start to reel you in. It also doesn't help that most banks will call you from overseas call centres - which is of course absolutely fine if it's genuine - but again, it's also a common marker of most scams, that they call from abroad, with a slight delay on the line and not having English as a first language.

2bazookas · 13/04/2023 16:17

Just tell them she's deaf, so please send a letter.

BelindaMelinda · 13/04/2023 16:05

I tell people why I'm ringing straight away though as it's not sensitive info

That's not strictly true.

You could tell them you were calling from the complaints/insurance renewal/credit card team or whatever - which often gives a heavy hint.

But any more than that, you're breaking DPA. I'm calling about your credit card with us - breach. I'm calling about your missed payment - breach. You've just told an unidentified person that a relationship exists between Mrs June Thomas and Barclays Bank (or whoever).

Swipe left for the next trending thread