Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't ask me to confirm who I am!

106 replies

Inthebathagain · 13/04/2023 11:29

Is it just me who can't get their head around a bank/company ringing you up from an unknown number, telling you who they are and expecting you to confirm your mother's maiden name/dob etc?

How do I know you are who YOU say you are?!

Wherever I point this out to the person on the end of the phone, they always tell me to put the phone down and ring the company line I find on the internet...which often gets you caught up in a queue of at least 30mins.

Surely there must be some way of them giving a little information and you confirming the rest of the information? Or some other way that I as a consumer can be happy that I'm not being scammed?

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SerendipityJane · 03/05/2023 12:11

Funny how the default for spam calls is to be opted in, whereas when it was about porn it was to be be opted out and you had to choose to opt in.

Those of us that remember premium rate numbers will also remember that they were automatically enabled and - certainly in the case of Virgin Media - you had to pay to block them.

Combination of losing my landline and an aggressive spam blocker on my mobile means I've forgotten what they are like.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/05/2023 12:09

@forrestgreen , mine did too,,years ago - asking whether I’d be interested in internet banking.

When they asked for personal info I put the phone down, took their number (last call landline, this is how long ago it was) and phoned their fraud line - who said it was on the level.
How they can still be doing this - unsolicited phone calls - defeats me.

PerkingFaintly · 03/05/2023 12:01

Just bumping this to say, the government understands why a mix of similar genuine and scam calls is a bad thing!

UK to ban all cold calls selling financial products
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-65466653

The government said the blanket ban on cold calls selling financial products would cover legitimate calls as well.
This will mean that "anyone who receives a call trying to sell them products such as cryptocurrency schemes or insurance will know it's a scam", it said.

Woman on smartphone

UK to ban all cold calls selling financial products

It comes as part of a wider crackdown on scams that affect millions of people each year.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-65466653

SerendipityJane · 14/04/2023 17:47

determinedtomakethiswork · 14/04/2023 17:07

But why didn't they tell you the last three transactions? That would tell you that they were the bank

Because if it isn't you, they have divulged personal information.

Going back, before the madness, there was a vaguely inbuilt protection around expecting to speak to a man or a woman. But I wouldn't want to be the first bank that declined to speak to a "woman" just because they had a rich baritone (or vice versa).

When blockchain was a thing, I was exposed to various "theories of trust" (so you didn't have to be ...😀)

Createausername1970 · 14/04/2023 17:10

We just say "can you confirm who you are? No?, oh dear, you had better call back when you can" and end the call.

determinedtomakethiswork · 14/04/2023 17:07

Jules912 · 13/04/2023 11:53

Last time my bank called me they asked for something like my last three transactions on my debit card (it was a while ago!). That seems sensible as something only I was likely to know but would be useless to a scammer.

But why didn't they tell you the last three transactions? That would tell you that they were the bank

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 14/04/2023 17:06

Stuff along the lines of: "We, the bank, will only call you if it's important, so you really ought to take our call."

If we knew it was you calling, then we would take the call!

But scammers lie and say they are the bank, too.

It doesn't seem to quite compute with some people, does it?! The banks can have the world's finest anti-fraud teams in their back office along with the most powerful security software; but if some bloke in a basement decides to call you and claim that he is your bank, all of that amazing stuff won't do you the slightest bit of good!

I think that this might be a bit like when you know somebody very well, but you don't know that they are an identical twin; and then, when you bump into their twin in town and they (quite reasonably) act like they have no idea who you are, getting angry and offended at why such a supposedly good friend would just blank you and lie to you like that!

PerkingFaintly · 14/04/2023 16:16

Anamechangeisasgoodasaholiday · 14/04/2023 13:53

Funny enough I had this exact discussion with John Lewis of all companies. Their exact response was in a tone of outrage: But we’re John Lewis! You know you can trust us! They were terribly offended when I said, actually, no I don’t trust you.

HSBC do this too. Infuriating.

Exactly.

I might know I can trust John Lewis.

But I don't know you are John Lewis. You could be someone else, lying.

And given they want to put you through their security, the whole premise of which is that you might someone else, lying, it's a bit rich when they can't see the symmetry.

Anamechangeisasgoodasaholiday · 14/04/2023 13:53

PerkingFaintly · 13/04/2023 12:12

You're totally right. And presumably if people get used to this it makes them more vulnerable to scammers in future.

Absolutely this.

It's the mindset of: "We'll tell people it's vitally important to follow security procedures and they'll be liable for their losses if they don't. Then we'll break aforesaid procedures, because we know we're the good guys."

Yeah, no.

Funny enough I had this exact discussion with John Lewis of all companies. Their exact response was in a tone of outrage: But we’re John Lewis! You know you can trust us! They were terribly offended when I said, actually, no I don’t trust you.

HSBC do this too. Infuriating.

Greentree1 · 14/04/2023 13:26

The con men can also make it seem like they hung up, to allow you to dial the bank directly, and then answer it themselves again when you dial out. So use a different phone if you do this or dial your mum first to prove you have got a proper line.

And yes it's annoying and I don't give them the info, the last guy I said, 'how do I know who you are' and he just laughed, I think we both knew we were who we said. He told me in general terms what the concern was and I told him it was fine.

StarlightLady · 14/04/2023 13:06

This happens. My view is that this represents bad training or lack of training for bank staff.

The advice from the Information Commissioner's Office is quite clear. Never disclose personal details on an incoming call unless you know the person who is calling you. There are scams which may prevent you hanging up on the caller as well. So not only should you call back to an officially published number, if possible you should do it from a different phone as well.

Alwayswonderedwhy · 14/04/2023 10:20

Why are they ringing you? Been with HSBC years and do everything online so I'd think it was a scam if someone phoned saying they were from the bank.

melj1213 · 14/04/2023 10:17

I agree - I hate when people call me and then start asking me to verify my information. I understand why, from a security POV, that they might need to confirm they're speaking to the correct person before revealing information but when they don't even identify themselves/the company clearly first then I am not telling them anything and I refuse to waste my time calling them back and waiting in a queue to speak to someone only to find out that they were calling me to tell me that my phone contract is due for renewal and they want to offer me an upgrade, as per the email, letter and text I had already received.

I prefer how my old Housing Association dealt with it - you had to have a "memorable word" of a minimum of 8 letters and a memorable year (that couldn't be your DOB) and then every time they called they would ask you to confirm your name, post code and a combination of two letters/numbers from your word and/or number to verify your identity. That word and number could be anything and you could change it as often or as little as you liked, but to do so you had to jump through 101 hoops on the website (so you were the one to go to the website and volunteer your information, knowing it's the official channel) so your info was safe.

Additionally because there were so many potential combinations of letters/numbers they could ask for from an 8 letter word and 4 digit number it would have taken scammers ages to get all of the letters/numbers in order to work out your passcode, and they did advise that you changed the word/number periodically to prevent any security issues, so it was infinity more secure than having to give out the usual "security question" answers (which are always the same themes - pet names, schools and parents names, favourite Xs)

They also had a "password" set up for any contractors they sent out - you would set a passcode in your account (again, you could change it whenever you wanted via your account) and when they sent the contractor out if you weren't sure if they were legit or wanted to check for any kind of safety reason you could also ask them to confirm your password and they should know it, and if they didn't then they knew how to access the information, before you let them in to your property.

PerkingFaintly · 14/04/2023 09:36

Agreed, OP.

And this quick-response work from the fraud team could be backed up by a requirement for the customer to call into the published phone number at a convenient time, spend the usual 30 mins queueing, pass bank security and confirm that the fraud team had indeed talking to the right person.

And meanwhile the account is secure from further fraudulent spending until this happens.

Inthebathagain · 14/04/2023 09:14

user1471453601 · 13/04/2023 21:56

My bank, First Direct, an arm of HSBC did this once. I told them they had rung me, so it was up to them to prove their identity. I hung up.

two minutes later I got a text on my mobile, saying they were the fraud department of the bank (and approved of my reluctance to answer any of their questions). They said my debit card had been used in this country at a supermarket, could I confirm that was me? I saw no harm in confirming.

they then asked if I had the card in my possession and was I currently in my home?

Again, I saw no harm, so confirmed both. They then said someone in New York had tried to use my card in an Apple store, 20 minutes after I'd used it in this country. They advised me to change all my passwords on my computer and they'd cancelled current card and send replacement.

It really was my bank, and they saved me from a whole sea of shit.

But even they, the fraud department, thought it was ok for me to refuse to confirm any personal information on my land line.

And this is why I started the thread. This is a good solution to the problem.

Bank rings customer. Bank then confirms it's the bank via a verified channel. Customer is then safe to share personal details. Everyone protected and verified.

Good on FD

OP posts:
NannyGythaOgg · 13/04/2023 22:47

Years ago they did and I would never comply.

It hasn't happened for well over 10 years. There are still a few things I find questionable but this is not one that has happened for me for at least 10 years

MuffinToSeeHere · 13/04/2023 22:21

justasmalltownmum · 13/04/2023 22:12

It's a scam. Happens with "phone companies" too.

That's the whole point though it often isn't a scam it genuinely is the bank or phone company calling but us mere mortals are expected to know which ones are scams and which ones are genuine.

justasmalltownmum · 13/04/2023 22:12

It's a scam. Happens with "phone companies" too.

CaputDraconis · 13/04/2023 22:07

HMRC called me at work to discuss the business tax account. They had about 16 security questions including all random ones like who was the finance manager before me (who tf would I know it was pre-me!) So they said i failed security. They asked me to call them back the following day. I refused. I said you want ti talk to me. I don't want to talk to you. You either tell me what you want or you can write to me. Argued about it for a further 5 minutes before I hung up on them.

Elphame · 13/04/2023 21:58

SeatonCarew · 13/04/2023 16:29

I can assure you NatWest fraud team do this. (Ooh, the irony!) I responded like the OP.

Oh don't they just! My card was busy in NYC whilst I'd just used it to cross the Severn bridge.

I had 4 calls from "Nat West" but they sounded so scammy that I hung up. After the 4th call I did wonder and googled the number. Some sites said it was genuine, others that it was a scam. Eventually I found it buried deep on a Nat West site page so rang them back.

Even so and after the conversation I wasn't 100% sure I had done the right thing as the woman I spoke to really didn't sound genuine.... although as it happened she was.

MuffinToSeeHere · 13/04/2023 21:57

PerkingFaintly · 13/04/2023 21:52

I think some people on this thread are seriously lacking in theory of mind.

Stuff along the lines of: "We, the bank, will only call you if it's important, so you really ought to take our call."

If we knew it was you calling, then we would take the call!

But scammers lie and say they are the bank, too.

So from the state of knowledge of the call recipient, this might be a scammer or it might be the bank, we can't tell.

Exactly. I love that the customer is to blame and some posters sound almost gleeful that not taking these calls has led to the customers having accounts closed etc when the customer is literally doing exactly what banks tell them to do to ensure their information is not used by scammers.

A scammer calling is going to say they are the bank and they need to discuss a serious issue but cannot proceed until the customer gives the personal information.

A bank calling is going to say they are the bank and they need to discuss a serious issue but cannot proceed until the customer gives the personal information.

Apparently customers are meant to be psychic and know which is the scammer and which is actually the bloody bank and they are at fault for even daring to be suspicious...

user1471453601 · 13/04/2023 21:56

My bank, First Direct, an arm of HSBC did this once. I told them they had rung me, so it was up to them to prove their identity. I hung up.

two minutes later I got a text on my mobile, saying they were the fraud department of the bank (and approved of my reluctance to answer any of their questions). They said my debit card had been used in this country at a supermarket, could I confirm that was me? I saw no harm in confirming.

they then asked if I had the card in my possession and was I currently in my home?

Again, I saw no harm, so confirmed both. They then said someone in New York had tried to use my card in an Apple store, 20 minutes after I'd used it in this country. They advised me to change all my passwords on my computer and they'd cancelled current card and send replacement.

It really was my bank, and they saved me from a whole sea of shit.

But even they, the fraud department, thought it was ok for me to refuse to confirm any personal information on my land line.

PerkingFaintly · 13/04/2023 21:52

I think some people on this thread are seriously lacking in theory of mind.

Stuff along the lines of: "We, the bank, will only call you if it's important, so you really ought to take our call."

If we knew it was you calling, then we would take the call!

But scammers lie and say they are the bank, too.

So from the state of knowledge of the call recipient, this might be a scammer or it might be the bank, we can't tell.

toiletinacupboard · 13/04/2023 21:46

My doctor did it today! And I said my name and he said "I've phoned the wrong person! I thought you were XX"

😂 it was a good job he asked!

Banks on the other hand are arses for doing this.

AnneElliott · 13/04/2023 21:42

Yes I get annoyed with this as well. I refuse to do it and tell them to put it in writing if it's important. They rarely do so I assume they're mostly trying to sell me stuff.