Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take my friend on holiday for free?

185 replies

Trul · 13/04/2023 11:26

DP and I booked a luxury all-inclusive holiday abroad a few months ago. Due to unforeseen circumstances, and despite our best efforts, it's now unlikely that DP will be able to come. We cannot get a refund or reschedule as the holiday is now only a few weeks away. Between DP and I, we earn well into six figures and the holiday is already paid for upfront.

I have said to DP that I will take my friend, which he is happy with, but he wants my friend to pay for 'his' share. My friend is a single parent to an autistic DC, there is no way she could ever afford to pay for his share. I've suggested that as it's already paid for, and is no financial loss to us, I take my friend for free. She can pay for a few meals / drinks out there, if she wishes. I'm sure my friend will offer to pay a token amount, but as it's already paid for, and the other option is me going alone or us both losing out completely, I'd rather she didn't. It would also make a much bigger impact to her (if she offered £500 for example), then if we lost out on that amount. She has been a very good friend to me over the years.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Wishawisha · 14/04/2023 09:55

And also presumably she’s need to pay for flights? You can’t just change names easily?

On top of sorting out childcare, this could be a bit of a headache for her.

No harm offering though but I wouldn’t necessarily feel like I was doing her a massive favour.

MangoPi · 14/04/2023 09:52

I think there is nothing wrong with treating a friend who is not in as a financially fortunate position as you. Especially as you say she has been a good friend to you over the years.

We don't always need something in return - it's nice to just be nice sometimes. Especially to those who this would be an amazing opportunity in an otherwise presumably challenging life (single parent alone is not the easiest, let alone with a child who has additional needs).

Seems a shame for the extra space to go to waste, if it is non refundable.

A good friend is worth far more than what his share would be.

GanjaDhin · 14/04/2023 09:44

Facem81 · 13/04/2023 11:33

She can pay for a few meals / drinks out there, if she wishes.

but it’s AI?

I am guessing that op means that they may choose to eat out somewhere else and the friend can offer to pay for that if she wants. I don't think op wants her friend to pay for anything at all and is just giving her friend that option so that she doesn't feel entirely beholden to op. What an amazing friendship.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 14/04/2023 09:41

He’s being petty and mean because he can’t come and unless a huge backstory doesn’t want your friend to come.

A friend of long standing and who has a lot on her plate as a single mum with an autistic child, deserves to come, even if she just pays for some meals/drinks.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 14/04/2023 09:36

If it's genuinely non-refundable for this particular situation, then it would be wonderful to take your friend (assuming she can sort out childcare). Thirty years ago, I'm a not dissimilar scenario, DM was on the receiving end of a free holiday from friends. She needed it so much, and appreciated it even more. Be a Good Samaritan OP!

Pipsquiggle · 14/04/2023 09:32

I think that's a really kind thing to do for your friend. She will probably want to contribute something so I would have a chat re. money with her before you go.

I am hoping your DH is not horrible but is just clueless about other people's incomes / financial pressures

madamovaries · 14/04/2023 09:30

Take your friend and tell her it is a present. Sounds like she has a tough time. You are being generous; your husband stingy, esp as he's basically already lost the money

rookiemere · 14/04/2023 09:29

I'd just like to say if anyone would like to take me on holiday, I can make myself available Grin.

I would say though that unless it was a holiday I really wanted to go on, I'd have to think long and hard if I was asked to pay my full share. After all I've not been involved in the choosing of destination or dates, and I'm doing someone a favour by providing company and meaning they can go away. So I can see how it might get awkward once money is involved.

JackHackettsMac · 14/04/2023 09:23

You said your friend had been a good friend to you over the years. That's worth more than money IMO.

Sounds like this holiday is a good opportunity for you to repay her?

WilsonMilson · 14/04/2023 09:18

Depending on the reason your dp can’t go, perhaps you could claim on insurance?

Can your friend actually go/wants to go? I wouldn’t presume anything until you’ve spoken to her.

Changing the name on flights will cost a bit - who is going to pay that?

Can she afford spending money/insurance.

Sounds like you’re making a lot of presumptions about your friend before asking her. I was once (a long time ago) presented with a fait accompli holiday to New York that knew nothing about, from a (platonic to me) male friend who’d broken up with his girlfriend (nothing to do with me) and had just taken upon himself to change her flights to my name which apparently cost him £250 just to change and this was circa 2002! He had paid for the holiday as he was planning to propose to her before she dumped him, oops, and thought he was offering me an amazing holiday.
Which, in fairness, I guess he was.

I didn’t go - I was actually really annoyed he thought he could just do that and expect me to go along with it. Felt very uncomfortable and unreasonable to just presume someone wants to go on a holiday like that with short notice and taking no account of their circumstances. There may be many reasons that this could become a bit of a difficult situation, I would tread carefully.

SleepingStandingUp · 14/04/2023 09:16

Facem81 · 13/04/2023 11:33

She can pay for a few meals / drinks out there, if she wishes.

but it’s AI?

Lots of people actually leave their hotel even when it's ai

rookiemere · 14/04/2023 09:15

I don't understand your DHs logic.
Unless you're happy going on your own, then if you don't go twice as much money would be wasted, than if you go with your friend.

Doesitreallymatteranyway · 14/04/2023 09:09

What a lovely and kind thing to do! Being able to go with a dear friend saves the day .YANBU

crispsnutsandcake · 14/04/2023 09:08

It's a nice gesture and means you can still go but as PP said it raises several questions. Can your friend get childcare? Is the holiday transferrable anyway? If it is perhaps there's a charge to change the name on the booking or the room from a double to a twin, for example.

If I was your friend I wouldn't feel right about accepting such generosity unless I could pay something towards it, a token gesture or an arrangement to pay for some trips maybe. Give her small contribution to charity if you like. Would your DP accept that?

Cinnamon23 · 14/04/2023 09:04

Facem81 · 13/04/2023 11:33

She can pay for a few meals / drinks out there, if she wishes.

but it’s AI?

People do venture out of their complex on AI… eg. they go sightseeing and try a local place for a bite to eat? Spend an afternoon in the nearest town and stop for a drink or two?

Pretty standard.

Nosleepforthismum · 14/04/2023 09:03

Aww OP you sound lovely. Of course take your friend and just laugh off your DH’s suggestions that she pays. He’s being a knob but I’d let it slide on the basis of him feeling like he’s missing out.

Schnooze · 14/04/2023 09:02

Is he worried she is single so you’ll go out pulling men?

Schnooze · 14/04/2023 08:58

Say that you won’t ask her to contribute as she can’t afford it, so is he happy that you don’t go at all or go on your own. Is that fair considering it’s him that’s messed your holiday up.

Id love a free holiday not of my choosing. If I was paying for it, I’d be much more particular about where, how much it cost etc.

Qilin · 14/04/2023 08:54

Unless they have an extra add on for being called into work, or similar, it's unlikely travel insurance will cover this.

To take my friend on holiday for free?
KettrickenSmiled · 14/04/2023 08:51

Facem81 · 13/04/2023 11:45

We don’t know enough to say that

perhaps he doesn’t like this woman at all. A bad history

perhaps he wants to claim on insurance

perhaps the op and DP have very separate finances and she’s offered something that really was only his to offer

We do know enough.

Maybe he doesn't like OP's friend. So he's trying to punish OP by making her go solo, or not at all. Disproportionate & controlling.

Of course he wants to claim on the insurance. But Op has already said there is no way of clawing back the money, so this is irrelevant.

Maybe they have separate finances, but as he's not getting the money back either way, what's the point of being dog in the manger about it? It makes no odds to him whether the friend takes his place, & will obviously suit OP better - but he seems to care more about being mean & controlling than OP's comfort.

Tracker1234 · 14/04/2023 08:48

I would definitely make some investigations regarding how to change the names on the current booking before you make this a big thing. Flights depending on what airline you are going with might be tricky. It might well not be a matter of changing the name for a few quid.

HarrietStyles · 14/04/2023 08:43

”Ok husband, I chatted to my friend and she can’t afford to take your place. But since recouping the money is so important to you, I asked around and great news ………. My hot male PT is able to pay for the place and is even happy to share the room with me. You ok with that?”

Qilin · 14/04/2023 08:43

He’s not “choosing” not to go! Unforeseen circumstances mean he can’t.

But unless that 'unforeseen' reason meets one of the pretty strict criteria allowed with travel insurance it simply isn't covered.
The comment is suggested on MN all the time and for most of the reasons suggested it simply wouldn't be covered.

SparklyBlackKitten · 14/04/2023 08:41

He sounds lovely...

TheChoiceIsYours · 14/04/2023 08:39

Presumably charging her isn’t really an option if she’s hard up - if she’s offered the chance to buy his place presumably she will say no as she can’t afford it. So it’s kind of a moot point? He has the options of losing the money and no one getting anything from it, or losing the money and she gets an amazing treat. But mean to choose the former over the latter!! Unless he wants to find someone else who will pay him full price for a holiday that they go on with you and have had no say in booking, and who you’re also keen to go with - is that likely…?!

If you take her just be careful he isn’t the type to make digs at her or make her feel horrifically awkward for taking up the offer. If you offer her this you need to make sure it is a genuine nice thing for her that comes with no weirdness that leaves her feeling like she needs to find some money to pay for a holiday she didn’t choose or ask to go on.