Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think its morally poor not to provide ANY childcare whatsoever as a grandparent, if you are retired and in good health?

957 replies

uniformotxa · 13/04/2023 11:21

I have young dc and no childcare issues aside from the horrendous cost. My parents, like many others I know, enjoy being with dc but it’s pretty much always on their terms. They would take them for a day but it wouldn’t be consistent or reliable so couldn’t make it a regular thing.

Im not sure how I feel about this and on balance I think it’s pretty morally dire. Luckily I can afford childcare and nursery but I perhaps would feel more strongly if I couldn’t. However, whilst it’s easy for me to say this now, I do think I would step up and do some childcare for my dc if they had children. I can’t imagine just letting the days roll by leisurely and not setting aside even one day a week to be a reliable help.

I know in other cultures this is standard and families pull together much more. AIBU to think there is actually a moral obligation here, to make some form of childcare contribution, however small?

OP posts:
Feetupteashot · 20/04/2023 18:23

Hmm. Are you up for them moving into your digs when they get crumbly in return???

londonmummy1966 · 20/04/2023 18:13

No I don't think it is morally wrong for GPs to provide no childcare. However, they are likely to lose out in terms of a relationship with their GC. Beyond that, it isn't morally wrong for children to provide no care for an aging parent either. The former might also influence the latter, especially where grandparents watch the younger generation struggle with finances as a result of nursery costs etc.

MsRosley · 20/04/2023 17:48

swayingpalmtree · 20/04/2023 13:22

Well raised adults make those provisions and arrangements before having a child , and they certainly don't have several children with the expectation of imposing on grandparents

Well raised adults should also put money aside for their retirement and not expect to impose on their kids for their care too by this rationale. If their adult kids want to help them, thats great, but it shouldnt be "expected" either.

Many older adults do put money aside for their retirement, or free up assets like their house to pay for care. But it can be unpopular with their kids who don't want to see their inheritance go up in smoke.

MsRosley · 20/04/2023 17:43

swayingpalmtree · 20/04/2023 08:16

The exact same applies to their kids! Their grown children are looking after their own kids too so therefore why should they look after two generations? why is that ok for them?

Because the grandparents have probably looked after two generations - their parents and their own children. Bloody hell, think things through instead of just leaping to shame the older generation.

fizzybubblywater · 20/04/2023 16:18

If anything I would say that if you have older parents, maybe you should consider taking care of them rather than expecting them to help take care of you still

Why? They chose to have kids- so the same rationale applies. Unless you have kids for the sole purpose of looking after you when old but thats just as entitled

Lalalalala555 · 20/04/2023 15:03

I'm not good at phrasing things well.
But in a nice way, you are feeling entitled.

No. They should not have to help. Its nice if they do. But no.
You chose to have kids. You are responsible for them.
It is unreasonable to expect someone to come to alleviate your problems.

If anything I would say that if you have older parents, maybe you should consider taking care of them rather than expecting them to help take care of you still.

saraclara · 20/04/2023 14:57

Anyone under 50 saying "I would..." needs to bear in mind that life is very different a couple of decades later. No matter what you'd like to do, or intended to do, a lot of things can change. There are many people judging GPs here, based on how the poster feels at this point.

While I am very grateful for generally good health and joints that still work, my energy levels have slumped massively in the last couple of years. I hate it, frankly, but keep reminding myself that compared to others I'm very fortunate.

But the me who would have said 20 (or even 10) years ago, that I'd love to have my GCs two or three days a week, is not the me now. I still love having them, and have not yet said no whenever I've been needed. But there's no way that I could now look after a couple of toddlers on my own regularly and for multiple days a week every week, even though I do go for long walks and have backpacking holidays. It's a totally different kind of energy. I love having mine for a day and a sleepover. It's really special time. But then I'm drained.

As I said way back in the thread, remember before you first had kids, and all the things you said you'd be as a parent? Multiply the difference when you actually became one, by 100 and you get the GP equivalent. You simply can't predict nor imagine with any accuracy, who you'll be in your mid 60s+, or how your parents feel, energy-wise... because you haven't experienced it yet.

That said, yes, I do feel for some of the posters here whose parents are nearby and won't even step up in an emergency or other practical need. That must hurt a lot.

HAF1119 · 20/04/2023 14:39

I would want to offer as a retired person myself, I think it depends on the person, some people would find it stressful or restricting and it is okay to say no. My mum does a couple of hours a week for me as it's evening after nursery closes but does always tell me if someone asked her to do something or there was an appointment she could have gone to but 'had to turn it down because of this'..

If I could have found something with those times and paid I would prefer that myself, I think when someone does you a favour they will feel a little resentment if they have to turn down other plans regularly.

Saying that, I would want to do one or two days a week happily for grandchildren, and would just plan things on other days - I really love babies/young children though. Has to be something they are happy to/want to do

Viviennemary · 20/04/2023 14:32

Lonejohny · 20/04/2023 14:24

What upsets me most when I'm on my knees is that someone who is meant to love me so much can stand by and watch me suffer. That's what makes me physically cry.
My kids see me so stressed trying to arrange childcare, but I promise myself I will never stand by and watch them have the same issue. As they get older I will make them promise to help each other.

It's a very bad idea indeed to force people into promising to care for others.

Carsarelife · 20/04/2023 14:27

@Groutyonehereagain how rude you are. I'm no spring chicken myself actually. You didn't say more tired on your original comment you simply just said if you don't have your health. I would consider health to be health related issues. My parents are both in good health. No question they are more tired now than 30 years ago, but both in good health.

Lonejohny · 20/04/2023 14:24

What upsets me most when I'm on my knees is that someone who is meant to love me so much can stand by and watch me suffer. That's what makes me physically cry.
My kids see me so stressed trying to arrange childcare, but I promise myself I will never stand by and watch them have the same issue. As they get older I will make them promise to help each other.

Liorae · 20/04/2023 14:17

swayingpalmtree · 20/04/2023 13:22

Well raised adults make those provisions and arrangements before having a child , and they certainly don't have several children with the expectation of imposing on grandparents

Well raised adults should also put money aside for their retirement and not expect to impose on their kids for their care too by this rationale. If their adult kids want to help them, thats great, but it shouldnt be "expected" either.

Most do. That is why we see so many posts on Mumsnet whining that the older generation have more money. Money that they saved all their lives. That their adult children think should be handed over to them.

Floofydawg · 20/04/2023 13:44

swayingpalmtree · 20/04/2023 13:22

Well raised adults make those provisions and arrangements before having a child , and they certainly don't have several children with the expectation of imposing on grandparents

Well raised adults should also put money aside for their retirement and not expect to impose on their kids for their care too by this rationale. If their adult kids want to help them, thats great, but it shouldnt be "expected" either.

But no one is saying the grandparents are expecting to be financially (or otherwise) looked after in their old age are they? This is a bonkers rationale.

swayingpalmtree · 20/04/2023 13:22

Well raised adults make those provisions and arrangements before having a child , and they certainly don't have several children with the expectation of imposing on grandparents

Well raised adults should also put money aside for their retirement and not expect to impose on their kids for their care too by this rationale. If their adult kids want to help them, thats great, but it shouldnt be "expected" either.

Skyla01 · 20/04/2023 13:20

YABU. Let grandparents enjoy their retirement in peace! A bit of help here and there is great, but I would never ask for regular help (and pretty sure my parents would say no anyway).

Groutyonehereagain · 20/04/2023 13:19

You’re lucky to be healthy when you’re older but there’s no doubt your body has aged, it happens to everyone and most peers I talk to have some health issues in their later years.

You youngsters need to remember and respect that. We don’t all moan about get older and all our aches and pains but it’s a reality for us all.

Obligated? I think not!

Mari9999 · 20/04/2023 13:16

@Yummymummy2020
My children spent a lot of time with their grandparents, by choice of the grandparents. However, we did not choose to have children until we could afford children and all of the costs and time commitments associated with having children. Grandparent time and relationships can be very special, and most grandparents want those special experiences. However, with that does not come the expectation that you are going to become the default
nursery provider. Well raised adults make those provisions and arrangements before having a child , and they certainly don't have several children with the expectation of imposing on grandparents.

There seems to be an endless number of postings lamenting the lack of support from grandparents and extended families. Few of these complaining posters ever bother to articulate the plans and resources that they had in place before deciding to have a child, and many have several young children without planning for these very obvious needs.

No matter how willing parents are to step in and assist, it is an inconsiderate and entitled adult child who expects child care support from parents and extended family who have not made an offer of such support.

The real solution is to not have any or more children than you can provide for on your own.

Thighlengthboots · 20/04/2023 13:14

JaneFondue · 20/04/2023 11:14

You should have a look at the Brown MN forum sometime to see many posters who rushed to enter joint families because they thought intergenerational living would be great and found it didn't work for them. It's very romanticised on the rest of MN.

Oh I'm not saying everything in different cultures is perfect by any means. However, one thing I do greatly respect is that there is always help and care. You can admire the way other people treat their families without rose tinted glasses. There are many disadvantages to western style nuclear families too and its ok to recognise that, it doesnt mean you hate western culture or anything. Most cultures have their good points and bad points.

loislovesstewie · 20/04/2023 13:06

Well, I'm 67 and definitely more tired than I was 10 years ago. I don't do so much DIY as I used to for example because it becomes knackering. But I can pay someone to do that! If I had grandkids I really would be exhausted having to care for them on a daily basis. I know I would not be able to do it, not week in week out. I have no real health issues, touch wood, but get tired more. It's a natural part of aging.

Thighlengthboots · 20/04/2023 13:01

Yummymummy2020 · 20/04/2023 12:40

I don’t think there is obligation - however, I was minded by my nana as a child and when she got older I loved helping her out, she meant the world to me. I didn’t see or spend much time with my other nana and as an adult I feel indifferent really about her in comparison. It sounds mean but it’s honest. The previous poster who said you reap what you sow was right In my experience. I don’t get any help but will help my kids, I would love my grandkids to be as close to me as I was my nana! I think had it not been for her childcare, our time together wouldn’t have been half as special! I remember her making barbie doll dresses with me out of dusters, something that just wouldn’t have happened had it been a normal visit with my parents.

Very similar situation here- I was looked after by my nan a lot when young and as a result we were very close. I helped her/visited her a lot when I was in college and years afterwards when I started my career, did lots for her. I didnt help out with my other grandparent as I rarely saw her and we didnt really have any relationship at all- (it was her choice not to see me much when I was young and whilst she wasnt unpleasant, she simply showed no interest in me or my life). To me, she was just a distant relative whom I barely knew. Therefore, in this sense its completely natural to "reap what you sow" because if you dont foster relationships then they will drift. Thats just common sense- all relationships take effort on both sides. You cant expect to be largely absent from someone's life for years and then suddenly expect them to jump when you need something from them.

Groutyonehereagain · 20/04/2023 12:58

Carsarelife · 19/04/2023 23:44

@Groutyonehereagain but the op asked if they are retired and healthy. You are talking about grandparents that aren't so healthy.

When you get older, you aren’t so healthy, fact. You also get more tired, fact. Try being older before you comment.

Yummymummy2020 · 20/04/2023 12:40

I don’t think there is obligation - however, I was minded by my nana as a child and when she got older I loved helping her out, she meant the world to me. I didn’t see or spend much time with my other nana and as an adult I feel indifferent really about her in comparison. It sounds mean but it’s honest. The previous poster who said you reap what you sow was right In my experience. I don’t get any help but will help my kids, I would love my grandkids to be as close to me as I was my nana! I think had it not been for her childcare, our time together wouldn’t have been half as special! I remember her making barbie doll dresses with me out of dusters, something that just wouldn’t have happened had it been a normal visit with my parents.

Mari9999 · 20/04/2023 12:34

There was an interesting post on a mother of 2 expressing concern that her 2 older children ages 19 and 15, when asked, stated that they were adverse to her having a new sperm donor.fathered with her same sex partner of 5 years.

Many of the responders said that the children should have no input into the mother's exercise of her reproductive rights and raised issues of a woman 's right to autonomous control of her body.

Questions like this one go a long way to suggest that for many women, the exercise of " their reproductive rights " comes with big expectations of other people. If grand parents are expected to contribute child care, support, etc. This ceases to be such an autonomous decision. Maybe women who need and expect assistance should also seek input from those that they expect assistance before they decide to become pregnant or choose to follow through with the pregnancy.

Woman should be consulting those people from whom they are experiencing support as to the timing of the pregnancy, the number of children for whom they are expecting support ,etc.

It is very selfish and short sighted to choose to have children to satisfy your maternal instincts and yet assume that you have a support network that should just adapt their life to fit in with your needs and expectations.

This is truly one of those " if YOU can't do the time, you should seriously consider not doing the ....

JaneFondue · 20/04/2023 11:14

Thighlengthboots · 20/04/2023 11:09

Hmmm, I was the one who mentioned culture and H's family dont work like that at all. Seems you are stereotyping more than a little here.

You should have a look at the Brown MN forum sometime to see many posters who rushed to enter joint families because they thought intergenerational living would be great and found it didn't work for them. It's very romanticised on the rest of MN.

Thighlengthboots · 20/04/2023 11:09

JaneFondue · 20/04/2023 10:56

I notice that pp are very keen on grandparents providing regular childcare like " other cultures" but would you be so keen if your parents told you whom to marry and what to study? Because that's how many other cultures work. The entire family thinks as one.

Hmmm, I was the one who mentioned culture and H's family dont work like that at all. Seems you are stereotyping more than a little here.