Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think its morally poor not to provide ANY childcare whatsoever as a grandparent, if you are retired and in good health?

957 replies

uniformotxa · 13/04/2023 11:21

I have young dc and no childcare issues aside from the horrendous cost. My parents, like many others I know, enjoy being with dc but it’s pretty much always on their terms. They would take them for a day but it wouldn’t be consistent or reliable so couldn’t make it a regular thing.

Im not sure how I feel about this and on balance I think it’s pretty morally dire. Luckily I can afford childcare and nursery but I perhaps would feel more strongly if I couldn’t. However, whilst it’s easy for me to say this now, I do think I would step up and do some childcare for my dc if they had children. I can’t imagine just letting the days roll by leisurely and not setting aside even one day a week to be a reliable help.

I know in other cultures this is standard and families pull together much more. AIBU to think there is actually a moral obligation here, to make some form of childcare contribution, however small?

OP posts:
MaroonCow · 13/04/2023 12:06

I'm not sure it's moral to choose to have a child and then decide it's someone else's moral duty to look after them when you want them to. You can't place moral obligations on other people with your life choices.

annonymousse · 13/04/2023 12:06

You sound very entitled OP. It was your choice to have children and you are responsible for them.

Speaking as a grandparent I feel I have done my child rearing and now I'm retired I want the freedom to go away at any time. I've worked hard and have earnt my retirement.

I love my grandchildren and do have them to stay for holidays and we have great fun but I will not commit to regular childcare. I want to be nana who spoils them and I don't want to have to discipline them or bring them up.

breakingintopieces · 13/04/2023 12:06

Plenty of parents became parents because it was expected of them, and dutifully raised their children because they had to. People these days have more choices and more freedom.

Do you really want to push your own parents into admitting they had you out of societal obligation and don't really want to go through the toddler stage again when they didn't enjoy it the right time round...?

Being a grandparent does not mean you love children. Doing a competent job of raising at least one child the first time round doesn't mean you enjoyed it, just that you did it.

People these days also have children later in life, so by the time someone becomes a grandparent, they might not be in the best of health (and they shouldn't feel obliged to admit every single health trouble to anyone, not even their children).

There's also Covid. Most people pretend it doesn't exist anymore, but it does, and with grandparents being older than parents, they're at a higher risk of getting ill badly or worse. A lot of people on MN seem to think grandparents are a great option when their children are sick. Why would you send contagious children round to older people with a higher risk of catching it and getting complications?

And then you have the old chestnut of rights and obligations. As a parent, you're obliged to look after your child... but you also have the right to see your child. If you're an engaged parent, in theory, you should always have that relationship. Engaged grandparents have no such rights - all they have are obligations. If they fall out with the parents of the grandchildren, they can have that relationship suddenly cut off.

There are so many reasons why grandparents shouldn't have to provide regular childcare.

saraclara · 13/04/2023 12:06

Well I'm a grandparent. My DD never had any expectation of me doing committed and regular childcare, because she knew that I'd retired in order to travel and have a more spontaneous lifestyle, having been constrained by my career for four decades.

I will always do random childcare and sleepovers for specific reasons/emergencies/because it's helpful (or just because DHD wants to play with grandma, and it will give DD a break). But committing to cover work related childcare would leave me as constrained as my job did.

And yes, I'm in my 60s and reasonably fit, but to be honest, it's absolutely exhausting and when she goes home I really need recovery time. I have friends who do a couple of days a week childcare for their DGDs. and it's killing them. They simply don't have the energy for it, and there are two of them (I'm widowed). But they feel they have to in order to see their DGCs a all, as their DIL would otherwise have them spending all their time with her parents (and their son does whatever she says)

The change in motherhood demographics means that people become grandparents at a later age than they used to. Which might seem great because they're retired and available, but it also means that, however well they are, they simply don't have the energy for full time (or even part time) childcare.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/04/2023 12:06

The way many parents talk is so entitled. "They have no interest in looking after my kids!"

Why would they automatically have an interest in doing that? They're not their kids!

YABU. Nobody is under a moral obligation to help you raise your own children except the other parent.

Spacie · 13/04/2023 12:05

It occurs to me that one of my friends who is in her early 60s and could probably afford to retire (long service public sector pension, recent inheritance) is not doing so precisely to prevent her having to deal with the expectation that she should provide childcare. She is already frequently called on at weekends.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 13/04/2023 12:05

I think regular and consistent is hard to promise especially if there is more than 1 set of GC involved. If DC1 required a Weds all day, DC2 required a Friday and DC3 all morning drop offs, suddenly GPs week is over

GlassBunion · 13/04/2023 12:04

None whatsoever.

Jenasaurus · 13/04/2023 12:04

It depends on a lot of factors really, the age of your parents, their health, whether the DC are very active and they would struggle keeping up with them on a regular basis. Also if they are retired and have their own plans, its important for them to be able to enjoy their later years, but I would also count spending time with grandchildren as enjoyable.

I was lucky, when I had my DC, I lived in the same road as my parents, I was a SAHM for 9 years and looked after my sisters 2 DC along with my own 3, so had 5 under 5 in my care for a lot of time. My parents were brilliant, and always helped out, came on holiday with us etc. My DF was an older grandparent as he had me when he was 37 (my DM was 28) but he had retired when I had my first and used to take my youngest a lot so I could take the older ones out. I appreciate I was lucky and it was in different times, when childcare costs were lower. When I went back to work my youngest was 2, nearly 3 and my DM suggested I get a part time job and she would look after her, it did work well.

I am not a grandparent myself (I am 58) but when/if the time comes I would happily offer myself up to help with childcare, but if I have health issues when the time comes I may not be able to help as much, so a lot of factors to consider.

Wishawisha · 13/04/2023 12:04

I think it sounds like they do provide childcare as you said they’ll have them for the day every now and then. So they are helping.

Helping every week so you can work in lieu of childminder / nanny is a much bigger undertaking IMO. I know someone who does one day a week looking after GC and it is a big deal and everyone seems to think what they’re doing is very helpful (rather than something that should be expected) - for instance, they can’t just not feel like it one week or plan holidays or things to do on that day, it’s basically their job though they are long retired.

My parents and ILs babysit every now and then ie a few times a year, and yes it’s on their terms. I’m grateful for what I can get.

Mari9999 · 13/04/2023 12:03

What moral obligation does the parent have to be able to fully provide for the child before they decide to have a child?

dameofdilemma · 13/04/2023 12:03

There's no moral obligation on GPs to provide childcare.

And there's no moral obligation on offspring to care for elderly parents, invite them over for Xmas etc.

It works both ways.

(The Tory party however thinks GPs should provide free childcare so everyone can get out there and work, without subsidised childcare, whilst also being carers for the elderly, for whom there is inadequate state social care. Moral? I think not).

stargirl1701 · 13/04/2023 12:03

I would not expect grandparents to provide the equivalent of a childminder or nursery in terms of childcare. That's a cost you factor in before you start a family.

I do expect help in an emergency. They are family. I would expect them to drop their plans and help out just as we would for them. DD2 was in hospital for a weekend and PILs took DD1 to theirs for that time. That's the role of family.

Nismet · 13/04/2023 12:02

A few ad hoc days are actually really helpful once children are at school. Schedule those days for weekdays in the school hols, it'll really help cover them.

I can see why a commitment every week is far too much for some GPs, especially if they have multiple grandchildren, or work, or gave up work because it was too damned tiring, or live any sort of distance away.

Greybeige · 13/04/2023 12:02

As long as they don’t expect help in old age/Ill health then it seems fair …

Esmereldapawpatrol · 13/04/2023 12:01

I don't know if it's morally poor but it's a bit selfish, I don't understand why a Grandparent wouldn't WANT to spend time and develop a relationship with their DGC.

I am lucky that I have help with childcare, from my in-laws, my DSIS and my DD's Godmother. They spend time with them after school as I work FT. It means that my DC also get time with their cousins. It has a 'takes a village' vibe about it that I love, part of the reasons we moved home was so that our DC would grow up surrounded by people that love them and want to spend time with them. We all help each other out in holidays etc as well.

I feel that our society is becoming so selfish and only doing things that benefit us directly, how about helping out loved ones to make things easier for them? Especially if you are in the position to?

I spent time with my Grandparents after school and holidays as a child. I adored that time and adored my Grandparents as well. Grandparents that want a hands off approach to their DGC will never have that and I think that's a bit sad.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 13/04/2023 12:01

The breakdown of 'community' - having family and friends closeby, having family support, is why so many mothers struggle terribly despite all the gadgets and devices we have that previous generations dont. It takes a village etc.

I dont think grandparents are OBLIGATED to provide childcare, however it would leave a bitter taste in my mouth if grandparents never try and help the family out if and when they can.

RisingSunn · 13/04/2023 12:01

I don’t see this as being a grandparent’s role at all. If they want to - fine. But definitely not an expectation here.

I am more than happy with them taking them for fun days out, presents, visits etc.

I have 4 children and never factored in grandparents as possible formal childcare.

BigglyBee · 13/04/2023 12:00

I think it's just as morally poor to deliberately have children when you know that you will depend on someone else's (probably unpaid) labour to care for them.

My husband is retired and in good health, but his health would soon suffer if he had to look after small children. With older people, there can be quite a delicate balance between being active enough to maintain health, and resting enough to prevent undue stress or exhaustion/wear on already arthritic joints etc.

Verv · 13/04/2023 12:00

So having already done their time raising a child/children and working, you feel that your parents should be obligated to resume childcare in lieu of freedom in retirement, and failure to do so is "morally dire".

Crikey.

Dowellif · 13/04/2023 11:59

Paid my mother to cover one after school slot a week - the going rate; her time is valuable like everyone else's. She very kindly helped out in emergencies.

LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 13/04/2023 11:59

BIWI · 13/04/2023 11:49

So basically, @uniformotxa, you're calling your parents (and any other retired grandparent) immoral. Because they won't drop everything for you and your children.

Not nice. Really not nice.

I don't have grandchildren (yet) but if and when they come along I'm prepared to help out if needed, but I absolutely will not promise to commit to frequent or consistent childcare. All through my working life, since the age of 16, I've been beholden to someone else's timetable. Now I'm retired, my time is (very much) my own.

To say that's immoral is actually pretty offensive - as well as entitled.

This. I’ve been working and caring for decades, prioritising putting my time and money into giving my children whatever I can. Big sacrifices.

That’s fine, and I love them so much. But once they’re adults I’m looking forward to a bit of freedom and to putting my own dreams and interests and projects first for a bit, before I drop dead.

purplecorkheart · 13/04/2023 11:59

Did you include your parents in the decision to have children? No?

My Grandparents told my parents that they had raised their own children and that they would not be providing regular childcare for their Grandchildren long before my mother or her siblings had kids. They both worked hard all their life and wanted the freedom to travel at a drop of a hat, go see a movie etc.

Bullshot · 13/04/2023 11:58

I am not a grandparent yet - but do have adult DC. I very occasionally look after a 7yo family member and that's enough for me. It is tying and tiring - and simply makes the other days of the week busier to catch up on the tasks which I should have been doing.

When/if I get to retire (at 67) and any of my DC have children then I am sure I won't want to give up a regular day/days for childcare. That's surely my time to be as free as a bird and do whatever the heck I like.

For reference my parents didn't offer regular childcare either and I didn't expect it. I paid for childminders, nursery, wrap around care. In the school hols I would ask for the odd session but other than that it was down to me and DH to sort it.

I voted that YABU

twistyizzy · 13/04/2023 11:58

Comedycook · 13/04/2023 11:56

I knew a grandmother at my dcs school who did the school run every day for her DDS two primary age kids. Then her dd had a third baby and instead of just doing the school run, she'd be doing the school run with a baby in tow and looking after it all day whilst her DD worked. I was utterly appalled that her dd had had another baby and expected her ageing mother to give up her days to look after it. The grandmother was pretty pissed off too.

Sounds exactly like my SIL 🙄