Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think its morally poor not to provide ANY childcare whatsoever as a grandparent, if you are retired and in good health?

957 replies

uniformotxa · 13/04/2023 11:21

I have young dc and no childcare issues aside from the horrendous cost. My parents, like many others I know, enjoy being with dc but it’s pretty much always on their terms. They would take them for a day but it wouldn’t be consistent or reliable so couldn’t make it a regular thing.

Im not sure how I feel about this and on balance I think it’s pretty morally dire. Luckily I can afford childcare and nursery but I perhaps would feel more strongly if I couldn’t. However, whilst it’s easy for me to say this now, I do think I would step up and do some childcare for my dc if they had children. I can’t imagine just letting the days roll by leisurely and not setting aside even one day a week to be a reliable help.

I know in other cultures this is standard and families pull together much more. AIBU to think there is actually a moral obligation here, to make some form of childcare contribution, however small?

OP posts:
Nimrode · 13/04/2023 12:31

You got me at the, 'moral obligation', so in other words its immoral of them not to offer regular childcare. What an entitled madam you are! their moral obligation was to look after you, their dc, not their grand children, that is YOUR moral obligation.

horridjobescapee · 13/04/2023 12:30

I have 3 kids. They are all in different parts of the uk. (England, Scotland, Northern Ireland)

Which one should I do childcare for?

StrawberryWater · 13/04/2023 12:29

I fully intend to politely decline to provide regular childcare for any children my son might have in the future.

In an emergency I would be there in a heartbeat and will even take the grandchildren for sleep overs and days out but otherwise I fully intend to enjoy my retirement. DH and I have plans to go travelling.

InsertMoniker · 13/04/2023 12:29

What I will say is, you reap what you sow. I don’t think my kids will be overly close to their grandparents in adulthood and that’s probably a factor

My children are adults and very close to their grandparents. They spent a lot of time with them as children and have a lovely loving and caring relationship.They just never looked after them alone or 'provided regular reliable childcare'. That's more of a job than a relationship.

CandleInTheStorm · 13/04/2023 12:29

ReadersD1gest · 13/04/2023 12:23

But the parents, living in the here and now and aware of all the constraints you describe, still chose to have children.

Why is that on the grandparents?

That argument is like the people saying on the Jr doctor thread that they knew the conditions beforehand so why did they become a doctor?

The point was, people saying "but they've done their child rearing" don't take into account how much help they had from either their own family or kicking the kids out all day. A little empathy wouldn't go amiss for today's family.

Thesharkradar · 13/04/2023 12:28

I spent so much of my childhood with relatives so my parents could socialise/have free time, so it felt weird that my parent wouldn't think that I might want a small bit of that sometimes
@bunhead1979 you think it's weird because to you if someone does you a favour you owe them a favor back.
I would say that your parents have a very different mindset, ie they are at the top of the hierarchy and are entitled to have everything on their own terms. Therefore when you were a child they got their parents to do the menial work of looking after their children. They still see themselves as being at the top of the hierarchy and they do not see it as their job to do any of your menial work.
Obviously you are the right and the moral one but you've lost out because you assume that other people share your values when they clearly don't!

vivainsomnia · 13/04/2023 12:27

@CandleInTheStorm, both my parents worked FT, we always worked FT. Many parents did even then. One thing 6ou have forgotten from your list is that parents were much likely to have to support THEIR parents rather than the other way around.

MyMarmite · 13/04/2023 12:27

Only read your OP but no, grandparents are not under any obligation to provide free childcare. Why should they? I’ve done my time, I want to enjoy my retirement!

Mummysalwaysright · 13/04/2023 12:27

Has the OP actually asked their parents to help? Or are they just assuming they will offer? The parents may think everything is already taken care of?

LeatherSkirt82 · 13/04/2023 12:27

I come from a culture where grandparents helping is a norm rather than a favour. This comes from poverty and lack of adequate infrastructure but also has roots in the ways family is perceived (in my culture - it is way more about the 'village' than about an individual, like here). Because of our jobs and lifestyle - we weren't really sure we'll be anywhere near either set of grandparents so all our plans were based upon only what the two of us, as parents, can provide.

We ended up living close to DHs parents and I am very very grateful that they are able AND WILLING to be engaged with our child. We do pay for nursery but send them 'school hours' and grandparents pick them up and spend time with them until we're done with work (so about 2-3h per day).

I don't think grandparents are morally obliged to contribute. I do feel that like with any human relationship - whether they are or not involved is related to their desire for a certain quality/depth of a relationship with the 'next generation'. It is not an obligation for grandparents, much like it is not an obligation for those children later in life to socialise with those grandparents beyond elementary family gatherings.

I had a very involved set of grandparent and a very disinterested set myself. There is literally nothing I wouldn't do for the first... and I barely consider myself related with the second. But I do not judge them - I just don't have an interest in them.

maddening · 13/04/2023 12:26

Well I think that it is swings and roundabouts, what you give you receive and in the circumstances laid out in the op title if the gp does not help then they would have a job asking for help in their old age.

I would discount any obligation due to care of the OP as a child as that is not the OPs responsibility, but as a family once you are all grown up it is a case of pulling together and helping out - and that goes both ways.

OMGitsnotgood · 13/04/2023 12:26

Some Grandparents choose to look after their grandchildren and if it works for everyone then great.

But to suggest that they have a moral obligation to look after them is beyond ridiculous and entitled.

latetothefisting · 13/04/2023 12:26

But your op is contradictory
You're saying it's only unreasonable if grandparents refuse to do ANY childcare - but then say your dps would be happy to take kids for a day on the odd occasion (so arent refusing to do any childcare) but what they are offering is of no use to someone needing regular childcare.

So what you're actually saying is are grandparents who don't commit to regular childcare unreasonable which is a completely different question -particularly because by "regular" I assume you mean at least once a week to be of any use in terms of nursery etc.

You can't expect grandparents to provide childcare for a multiple of reasons, even if most people on good terms with their dc would want to help out when they can. But expecting them to commit to regular childcare is a lot to ask - and in many cases inpractical even if they wanted to - e.g. if the GPs still work full time themselves, if they live too far away to make a weekly trip, if they have poor health etc.

Pluvia · 13/04/2023 12:24

People looking back at grandmothers who looked after them are forgetting that many of us had grandmothers who didn't have a life of paid work outside the home. Their lives were largely organised around looking after their family and so grandchildren were a part of that. But many women now in their 60s and 70s have been in paid employment as well as raising their own children while shouldering the majority of domestic work and looking after their parents. They really prize their retirement, particularly those early years of retirement when they're fit and able to travel and do what they want freely. And you will likely feel the same way after you've worked for 40 years.

xogossipgirlxo · 13/04/2023 12:24

Comedycook · 13/04/2023 12:11

I think there's a middle ground between providing full time childcare and doing absolutely nothing.

So if grandparents are healthy and local I think help in emergencies is good. The odd night so parents can go out and enjoy themselves. Helping out on an inset day. That sort of thing.

My own parents are dead but my mil is a very disinterested grandparent. Loads of money but wouldn't even stick a tenner in a birthday card let alone look after one of her grandchildren. She doesn't even have family over...it blows my mind that our DC have never eaten a meal cooked by granny. Dh says nothing. I find it perplexing. If my parents were alive and had zero interest in my kids, I'd have told them to fuck off quite honestly.

My thoughts exactly.

Skybluepinky · 13/04/2023 12:24

What a ridiculous post, they r yr kids, so therefore yr responsibility not the grandparents.

OnATrolley · 13/04/2023 12:23

There's no moral element to providing childcare.
There's possibly a moral element to having a relationship with their grandchildren, making an effort to get to know them and spend time with them.
But no. Grandparents are not morally obliged to provide childcare. That's for parents, nurseries, childminders etc

ReadersD1gest · 13/04/2023 12:23

CandleInTheStorm · 13/04/2023 12:21

People always say, "But why should they? They've done their child rearing." Well, yes, they have, but they had it much easier than parents do today (hear me out...)

  1. They didn't have today's ridiculous living costs (even before the col crises) to just rent or buy a home.
  2. Nowadays, both parents have to work to afford said rent or mortgage if they were lucky enough to buy.
  3. They didn't have the ridiculous childcare costs we have now to put your dc in nursery to keep the job to pay your ridiculous rent or mortgage.
  4. Kids were far more "free" to play out in the neighbourhood. Nowadays, you can't just kick your dc out of the house and tell them to be back by teatime.
  5. A lot of families lived closer, and friends/family/neighbours were allowed to tell dc off and helped out, hence the saying, "It takes a village to raise a child."

You only have to read the thread going at the moment asking what your parents do back then that social services would be involved now? It's full of stories about how parents basically neglected their kids all day, whereas now the expectation is you actually have to look after your own kids! Parenting is hard, but they certainly didn't have it harder, and a little empathy for today's parents who can't just kick the kids out all day to do what they want no matter how dangerous roam the streets wouldn't go amiss!

But the parents, living in the here and now and aware of all the constraints you describe, still chose to have children.

Why is that on the grandparents?

raincamepouringdown · 13/04/2023 12:23

Most grandparents I know work.

And they'll have to keep working well into their 60s.

They can't afford to give up work and look after someone else's choices!

When I do eventually retire, I hope to travel. I won't be committing to a regular pattern of childcare for anyone. And I won't feel guilty about it as we did it all on our own as well without any help from anyone.

The only people I view differently are those that insisted upon/accepted loads of regular free childcare from their own parents and extended families, now don't work and are perfectly fit and healthy and nearby, and don't give back. I do view that differently as the hypocrisy is amazing.

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 13/04/2023 12:22

No, there is no moral obligation. The grandparents have no say in your decision to have children.

Of course, they would do well to consider this cuts both ways and a time might come where the grandparents need support from their children, which the children are under no obligation to give.

vivainsomnia · 13/04/2023 12:22

Like absolutely everything in life, wait till you've walked in their shoes before casting judgement
This 100%. I work FT my entire career, even when my kids were small and we're in nursery.

I have 8 years to go before retirement and I can't wait to finally have the freedom to do all the things Ive always wanted to do. I don't plan my retirement to be at home doing nothing. I intend on travelling a lot, do many activities, get with my friends, sport, etc....

I do intend to dedicate time to my future grandchildren and to help my kids and family, but not on a regular basis. I don't want to only be able to travel when they take holiday time or later during school holiday time. Thankfully, I know my kids wouldn't expect it and any help I do provide will be a bonus.

CandleInTheStorm · 13/04/2023 12:21

People always say, "But why should they? They've done their child rearing." Well, yes, they have, but they had it much easier than parents do today (hear me out...)

  1. They didn't have today's ridiculous living costs (even before the col crises) to just rent or buy a home.
  2. Nowadays, both parents have to work to afford said rent or mortgage if they were lucky enough to buy.
  3. They didn't have the ridiculous childcare costs we have now to put your dc in nursery to keep the job to pay your ridiculous rent or mortgage.
  4. Kids were far more "free" to play out in the neighbourhood. Nowadays, you can't just kick your dc out of the house and tell them to be back by teatime.
  5. A lot of families lived closer, and friends/family/neighbours were allowed to tell dc off and helped out, hence the saying, "It takes a village to raise a child."

You only have to read the thread going at the moment asking what your parents do back then that social services would be involved now? It's full of stories about how parents basically neglected their kids all day, whereas now the expectation is you actually have to look after your own kids! Parenting is hard, but they certainly didn't have it harder, and a little empathy for today's parents who can't just kick the kids out all day to do what they want no matter how dangerous roam the streets wouldn't go amiss!

TheChoiceIsYours · 13/04/2023 12:20

Honestly I think it’s morally wrong how many adults pressure their aging parents to provide childcare to save themselves money. They are basically expecting older people to work for them for free, it’s gross.

They accuse grandparents of wanting to see the kids on their terms only, but it’s usually the parents wanting to enforce the ‘terms’ by expecting free labour so they can save money on nursery and not have to bother themselves with visiting at weekends. And it is labour - small children are utterly exhausting even when you’re young and fit. I can’t imagine what it’s like when you’re in your sixties - even a ‘fit’ 65 year old is still 65! Parents tell themselves grandparents should want time with their grandchildren but completely overlook the vast difference between spending time with them as part of the wider family and being in sole charge of them and completely responsible, for long days. It’s TOTALLY different.

At school pick up our playground has quite a few regular grandparents and I hear them talking to each other - most are knackered and clearly would rather be somewhere else. My impression is most probably know it’s this or barely see their grandchildren. It really makes me sad.

So really, the idea that it’s the grandparents who are the morally deficient ones is laughable. Try the greedy parents!

Goodoccasionallypoor · 13/04/2023 12:19

saraclara · 13/04/2023 12:17

What really comes across in some the posts in agreement with the OP, is that womens rights haven't progressed much at all. And that other women are complicit in that.

A woman brings up her own kids, has a full timejob of her own for decades, finally retires, and then, because she's female, she has to put away any other plans for her life, and commit to childcare for her GCs?

It's actually appalling that women with children will sacrifice their own mothers' futures.

Op didn't mention her mother, she said parents.

I could well imagine that if we support our son with childcare in future that my husband will take the lead with it - he's fantastic with small children and would absolutely love doing it if time and health allows.

jamsandwich1 · 13/04/2023 12:19

I wouldn’t expect either set of grandparents to provide regular childcare. I’ve 2 small ones and the cost of nursery is crippling but I still think it’s too big an ask. That being said, I’m staying at my parents with the kids for a few nights this week and I’m feeling a bit miffed because I’m still doing EVERYTHING. I’ve taken them out every day on my own to give my parents some peace because I can tell they’re finding it a bit much. I think what I would really appreciate while I’m here is being offered a lie in or an hour to myself but instead my mum is just moaning that she’s feeling tired. They’re both retired and they honestly don’t leave the house most days. They never offer to babysit. I’m venting a bit really because I’ve been feeling annoyed about it all day!

Swipe left for the next trending thread