Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think its morally poor not to provide ANY childcare whatsoever as a grandparent, if you are retired and in good health?

957 replies

uniformotxa · 13/04/2023 11:21

I have young dc and no childcare issues aside from the horrendous cost. My parents, like many others I know, enjoy being with dc but it’s pretty much always on their terms. They would take them for a day but it wouldn’t be consistent or reliable so couldn’t make it a regular thing.

Im not sure how I feel about this and on balance I think it’s pretty morally dire. Luckily I can afford childcare and nursery but I perhaps would feel more strongly if I couldn’t. However, whilst it’s easy for me to say this now, I do think I would step up and do some childcare for my dc if they had children. I can’t imagine just letting the days roll by leisurely and not setting aside even one day a week to be a reliable help.

I know in other cultures this is standard and families pull together much more. AIBU to think there is actually a moral obligation here, to make some form of childcare contribution, however small?

OP posts:
JustMarriedBecca · 13/04/2023 14:30

My parents had my eldest for two days a week regularly straight after retirement. It was almost a semi retirement for them. Their rules about what they did and we gave them money for travel and spends to do things with her. If they wanted to go on holiday in term time, we facilitated that without complaint. They stopped for a year when I was on mat leave for 18 months and they gave us plenty of warning when they wanted to stop when my youngest started 5 days of pre-school at age 4.

They now help out in school holidays - usually only for a day or two per holiday. They have them for longer at their house over the summer. We take them there and bring them back.

My in-laws also help out for maybe 4-5 days a year. But in all instances we take the kids to their houses and give them free reign over activities.

Moral obligation, no.

Would I be upset if they didn't want to be involved, yes.

My parents nor my in-laws are local. If they were local, I'd probably ask for odd bits of babysitting more frequently to be able to go out.

BellaJuno · 13/04/2023 14:30

SchoolTripDrama · 13/04/2023 13:01

How selfish Hmm

Thanks for your feedback 😁

Hont1986 · 13/04/2023 14:29

I don't really see where the 'moral obligation' comes in. If there was some reciprocal arrangement like you are going to care for them in their old age by taking them into your home, etc. then yes.

Orangebadger · 13/04/2023 14:28

It's very dependant on your culture. In some cultures, grandparents absolutely take an integral role in caring for their grandchildren but in return, they will be more involved in how they should be brought up. Also in these cultures it's very much expected that children look after their elderly parents. I think a 2 way relationship like this is lovely but many British people want the childcare without the extra caveats and responsibilities that come with it so paying childcare is preferable. You can't expect grandparents to put in more work and not receive any support themselves when they need it. I don't think that's a fair balance.

Sceptre86 · 13/04/2023 14:27

Yabu. The cultures you are referring too often expect children to live in a multi generational household (or at least close by) so all burdens can be shared that includes finances, cooking, cleaning, childcare and caring for the elderly. They aren't so one-sided that they will take care of grandkids and expect nothing back, it's based on a reciprocal notion. So you can't unstick 3 hours away and expect childcare or even if you're down the road expect it if you aren't going to help when parents get sick or elderly.

Wexone · 13/04/2023 14:27

Sorry no. It has been known for years how much childcare costs. These are things that need to be factored in when you decide to have children. Don't have children but have many nieces and nephews and neither have been looked after every week by Grandparents on either side of family. My own parents are in their early 70s both still work only recently moved to part time. The are not physically able to look after a couple of kids every week. yes they look after some evenings when parents go out and have stepped in in emergencies same as i have however my siblings have paid for proper childcare every week. I ahve a few friends that i am have to say take the piss. Tow i know of live in the city and their parents live 2 hour drive away ( both parents in 70s retired father has heart problems and mother has problems balancing so has fallen a good few times)they make them drive up nearly every day to mind children or collect from school or crèche , that is shocking. They all earn very high salaries, can well afford childcare. One actually made her mother travel the country and sit with the baby while she went to meetings as she was breastfeeding - i was like WTF ?? They regularly bring them on hols too so they can babysit the children. Another friend made her mother change the dates of a holiday she booked as she couldn't or wouldn't get childcare. People are working longer and longer now. They have done their job rearing their children the are not their for unpaid babysitting. They are there for days out, birthday party's xmas extc to share in the moments of their GC and they enjoy their lives, as they have damn well worked hard enough for it, when they retire

CMVB · 13/04/2023 14:27

No your parents don’t owe you any childcare help it was your decision to have children therefore it’s your responsibility to care for them. I say that as someone with 4 children who has no family childcare help whatsoever not even the odd day here and there for just one of them. But having experienced a complete lack of help I know for sure I will absolutely help my children by providing them childcare when they need it. I do think it’s shitty how little help people want to give and I don’t want my children to experience that too

Oneandonly22 · 13/04/2023 14:25

Meandfour · 13/04/2023 13:59

When they’re on holiday or have appointments or their own plans, how do you cover the childcare? Asking as my SIL has asked the in laws to do 2 days a week childcare and her mum is doing 2 days. As they have no nursery, I have no idea how they will cover all the holidays with just their A/L.

When my parents decide to go away for a week, we either try to adjust our working days between me and DP to use some annual leave. Some occasions if they have went and kids are off school with it being school holiday. I’ve watched my nieces and nephew when I’ve been off watching my children and then my DB/SIL has watched mines for day or two here and there too. With it being school holidays now some days my parents will have 1 or 2 GC a day here and there and others 4 GC it just varies. GC range in age from mid 20’s to 4 years old so often older kids help too if they want too.

Berklilly · 13/04/2023 14:24

Easterfunbun · 13/04/2023 11:23

Hmm, I’m on the fence. I didn’t receive hardly anything from both sets and it did sting. What I will say is, you reap what you sow. I don’t think my kids will be overly close to their grandparents in adulthood and that’s probably a factor. I already see loneliness on both sides. I do hope to be involved more in childcare to my own grandchildren. My Nan was and we adored her right until she took her last breath.

I personally agree with this. We don't get any help and fair enough they don't have to, but it would be very helpful to us and it will impact their relationship. A day here and there is not the same as regular 1-1 contact or few days holidays, and that's the memories I have of my grandparents.

Hopefully they will be more involved as the kids get older...

1stTimeBoyMumx · 13/04/2023 14:22

I think this is a weird one I agree with you however I’m from a family where grandparents always mucked in and helped (on one side of the family) those same grandparents that looked after me also look after my son for me one day a week! Along with my dad (mum can’t due to hours in work) my dad quite literally dropped a day in work to have my son and both my parents would do absolutely anything to help! My mum has taken annual leave so I didn’t have to when family who usually have him have been on holiday or sick! He’s in playgroup now so they only have to pick up and have him for 2 hours and a full day in half term etc. my MiL and FiL also do one day and help cover holidays etc of other family members. If my mum and dad had retired they would have 100% had him every day I needed. So I struggle to understand why other parents wouldn’t do this too however I completely understand it isn’t a given and we are lucky! But all my friends with children have a similar set up to us so it does baffle me when people struggle to get family help!

Talapia · 13/04/2023 14:20

It's morally wrong to have kids, and 'expect' grandparents to look after them.

You are very fortunate, if you have healthy Grandparents, who are willing and able to help out.

wingingit1987 · 13/04/2023 14:18

i don’t think grandparents should have to help with babysitting. We do ask for help in certain situations (when I was in labour, when my friend had an emergency and needed me there recently etc). But it’s not often. And it’s never my mum that I ask.

whoamI00 · 13/04/2023 14:17

Do you live with your parents?
I couldn't disagree more with your post. For me it's even totally acceptable not to love their grand children let alone not to provide childcare.

aloris · 13/04/2023 14:16

One regular day of childcare for a young child/children per week is a HUGE amount of childcare for a grandparent to provide. I've done backup babysitting for friends, and after 2 hours with their child, I'm exhausted.

One thing I dislike is grandparents who (understandably) don't wish to provide any childcare, but who also expect the mother (never the father, it's always the mother) of the children to run herself ragged bringing the child to them, on a schedule of their choosing, so they can see their grandkids without lifting a finger.

Xenia · 13/04/2023 14:16

No. My mother didn't (my father worked until he died just about) and that was fine - she had done her bit when we were young and had at long last been free of us so why not enjoy it until her death at 75? Our parents lived hundreds of miles away too.

I am a grandparent with 2 young adult children at home and I work full time as I will until I die probably and I have had almost 40 years of looking after and paying for 5 children so will be looking forward to when it ends.

greyhairnomore · 13/04/2023 14:16

Twike · 13/04/2023 11:26

@Goodoccasionallypoor That's a pretty generous offer! Half a week of childcare would save you a ton of money and be so nice for your kids. Do you think she should work full time for you and offer a full week!?

Half a DAY a week. Not half a week

JudgeRudy · 13/04/2023 14:14

Yes I think it would be wrong not to provide ANY childcare - unless you didn't get on, it was impractical or you thought you couldn't cope......but does that happen much?
Your post then goes on to say your parents didn't offer any regular childcare you could rely on. That's totally different. I think all childcare should be on grandparents terms. I'd never expect my parents to 'give' a regular day/time to facilitate me going to work for example....and I wouldn't do it for a grandchild.
Committment is not really something you ask of someone, it's something they offer.

I could add up all the money I've spent on my adult children in the last year but I would not set up a monthly direct debit up for same amount this coming year.

soreknee · 13/04/2023 14:12

I think there's a big difference in Grandparents being criticised for not offering/providing regular childcare on certain days and Grandparents who show little to no interest in their Grandchildren generally (which is more reasonable to feel upset about). Personally, If I have Grandchildren, I will want to spend time with them to build a relationship. I will also want to help out my adult DC and give them a break/allow them to have an evening out or even a few days away from time to time. If I had, say, one or two Grandchildren and I was fit/healthy enough I would probably commit to a small amount of regular childcare as well (as long as there was flexibility if I wanted to go away for eg). But if more Grandchildren came along and I felt it was too much to do regular childcare, or if I wasn't up to it health wise, I'd be very hurt if my DC complained/criticised if I was otherwise an interested and loving Grandparent.

Escapetofrance · 13/04/2023 14:11

In an ideal world families would pull together. Helping elderly relatives as well as having support with young children.
I can’t wait to support my children with their children.

Movingonupi · 13/04/2023 14:11

I don’t get any help with childcare, to be fair grandparents live far awah and they haven’t asked. But when (if) I have grandchildren I’m going to be honest, I don’t want to be doing regular childcare - I mean, I would do the odd babysitting and weekend stint here and there but not daily school runs, all day caring for a toddler while the parents work. I’ve done that and want to enjoy my retirement. However, if my DD’s were really struggling I would help them
come up with a solution, and if childcare is still as extortionate as it is now (hopefully not if the 30 hours free is still in place!) I would help them out in terms of money, as a last resort. I’ll be (subtly) instilling into them early that they need to have thought of all this ‘before’ deciding to have children..

SouthLondonMum22 · 13/04/2023 14:11

I disagree. Childcare is the parents responsibility and theirs alone.

We did have both sides offer a few days each which we were grateful for but ultimately decided that full time nursery would be best with professionals who we can draw a professional line with. I didn't want to have an awkward Sunday lunch with MIL sulking because we had asked her to please not do something regarding childcare during the week which is obviously not a potential issue with someone outside of the family.

They do the typical fun Grandparent things like have him for a sleepover instead. I think using family as childcare often doesn't end well.

puttinoutfirewithactimel · 13/04/2023 14:10

Not a hope in hell would I offer regular childcare having raised my own kids. I would however offer babysitting and sleepovers at weekends regularly. There is no way I want to be tied down minding kids during the week, not fair to ask any grandparents to do that. Now is their time to enjoy life without the burden of small children. I have seen so many harassed older people trying to wrestle a screaming 2 year old into a trolley in Tesco, too much and not fair.

If they offer that's different.

PurplePineapple1 · 13/04/2023 14:09

champagnedates · 13/04/2023 12:32

Take the positives....at least you know they won't expect any regular care from you when they get too old to manage independently. They can go in a care home as you won't be expected to give them any regular help.

Silver linings and all that Grin

I find this absolutely vile to be honest.

So in your world, if the OPs parents want help in their old age, then they have to not only raise OP, but also raise OPs children and if they don't then fuck em. Disgusting.

DrPrunesquallor · 13/04/2023 14:09

Completely unreasonable
Completely titled
If I was the grandparents of someone with this attitude I’d move abroad .

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 13/04/2023 14:09

@uniformotxa how does this actually work in the real world? We live in town A my bil and Sil live in town B my PiL are in town C my mum in town D my dad in town E and my brother in town F. The nearest anyone lives to anyone else is about an hour's drive. Should my in laws or one of my parents move to supply childcare to me? If they do how would they also support bil/my brother as we are 100s of miles away. Should DH and I both quit our jobs and move so we have child care on tap (but no jobs or house as we can't afford one near my in-laws especially as we would both be unemployed!). DM is fit and well but her husband isn't so is DM exempt from your plan or does she need to look after grandchildren and care for her husband. If parents supply help to one child should they pay their other child/rens childcare costs to balance things up?

Swipe left for the next trending thread