Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think its morally poor not to provide ANY childcare whatsoever as a grandparent, if you are retired and in good health?

957 replies

uniformotxa · 13/04/2023 11:21

I have young dc and no childcare issues aside from the horrendous cost. My parents, like many others I know, enjoy being with dc but it’s pretty much always on their terms. They would take them for a day but it wouldn’t be consistent or reliable so couldn’t make it a regular thing.

Im not sure how I feel about this and on balance I think it’s pretty morally dire. Luckily I can afford childcare and nursery but I perhaps would feel more strongly if I couldn’t. However, whilst it’s easy for me to say this now, I do think I would step up and do some childcare for my dc if they had children. I can’t imagine just letting the days roll by leisurely and not setting aside even one day a week to be a reliable help.

I know in other cultures this is standard and families pull together much more. AIBU to think there is actually a moral obligation here, to make some form of childcare contribution, however small?

OP posts:
Thesharkradar · 22/04/2023 13:54

Mari9999 · 22/04/2023 11:11

@HoppingPavlova
So many people seem to think it offensive to suggest that women and men should fully prepare themselves to be capable of childcare before they decide to have a child. The notion that I can have a child, because I will.be able to outsource day care or respite care to the grandparents is a sign of entitlement and poor planning. These plans are often made based upon assumptions and with no direct or comprehensive discussion with the grandparents.

I completely agree with you, however the problem with this is it will lead to the birth rate dropping far below replacement rate, it takes a village to raise a child but the village is too busy to help.

Pubesofsoberness · 22/04/2023 13:43

No thanks! I had one of my dgc once a week for 4 months until dil went back on maternity leave but I don't want to have babies regularly. I have them occasionally when they want to go out etc but I'm not signing myself up for regular childcare

And I'm not old I'm 44

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 22/04/2023 13:37

Lonejohny · 21/04/2023 15:02

Sorry to those who say that. But I definitely bring my kids up to be compassionate, kind and helpful. I could never witness another person suffer of I could help and neither could my children. Our children exist because we wanted them but we have an obligation to guide to being good people not selfish ones.
To many selfish, me first people out there. Always shocks me. fitzwilliamdarcyfitzwilliamdarcy

@Lonejohny - yes, it is good to be kind and compassionate, and to bring up children to be kind and compassionate too - but it is also important to be compassionate towards oneself. It is fine to have boundaries, to know your limits, and to say No to things even when it might be the ‘kind’ thing to say yes.

No-one is obligated to work themselves into the ground, to be ‘kind’ to others.

There is a saying - you can’t pour from an empty jug - meaning it is important to care fore yourself so you can care for others.

Mari9999 · 22/04/2023 11:11

@HoppingPavlova
So many people seem to think it offensive to suggest that women and men should fully prepare themselves to be capable of childcare before they decide to have a child. The notion that I can have a child, because I will.be able to outsource day care or respite care to the grandparents is a sign of entitlement and poor planning. These plans are often made based upon assumptions and with no direct or comprehensive discussion with the grandparents.

hiredandsqueak · 22/04/2023 09:40

@Thighlengthboots but you are talking about different people. I’m assuming your Nan looked after you because she was happy to. It doesn’t leave your parents under any obligation to do the same just because they previously benefited from childcare from grandparents. I didn’t get any childcare that I didn’t pay for, my parents had died in laws were unwell yet I still care for dgs.

Thighlengthboots · 22/04/2023 08:52

hiredandsqueak · 21/04/2023 17:02

But surely if your parents outsourced your care to your Grandparents didn't it occur to you that they wouldn't want to care for your children either? I can't imagine that rationally anyone would think "oh well my parents needed a lot of help from my grandparents but of course twenty odd years later they will jump at the chance to do something that they didn't want or feel able to do when they were younger and fitter and had the obligation"

I think the point is- they didn’t worry about their parents chance to relax or their tiredness when they utilised free childcare themselves because it benefitted them.

My dad did exactly this- I spent 4 days a week for years with my Nan when I was a kid so he benefited from loads of free childcare (not one mention of wondering if my Nan was ok with it) yet wouldn’t even help us for an hour! It’s funny how when it benefits you it’s ok and yet when it involves them helping it’s suddenly inconvenient. I never expected anything regular but to refuse to help for even an hour when you had free childcare for years IS a dick move because it’s completely hypocritical/entitled

LouisCatorze · 22/04/2023 08:50

I have seen grandparents out with babies and toddlers who look too frail really to be caring for them alone. Okay, when everything goes to plan but suppose the toddler breaks loose near a busy road? I've often thought that if something happened that required them to run quickly after a child, it just wouldn't necessarily be a happy outcome.

While the DC were at primary school, the only (two in each family) children I recall being minded by quite elderly grandmothers every day (so the mum could work full-time), were quite out of control / spoilt, possibly because they were more indulged? Both grandmas were lovely but they often looked totally wiped out!

You can imagine how much would have been saved on childcare over a ten-year period though!

HoppingPavlova · 22/04/2023 08:18

Some of my colleagues however are working on themselves to the bone in their 60s and have their grandkids every day they're off work. It's not healthy
Yep. But the reality is if they don’t, one of their children or children-in-law’s will start a thread on a site like this and bitch no end about them. My mother/mother-in-law gets 2 days off yet won’t look after my children, the horror. Then everyone will pile on and tell them to go NC.

I just don’t even understand how it’s possible for most people to do. I’ve already ‘retired’ from my job when I got too old for the hours and bullshit. Got myself a cushy desk job, and while I’ve decreased my hours to ‘only’ 60ish hours per week, I’m wfh and only go to my office one day a week so still doable at my age. Basically for me to not be able to continue with this job I’ll need to have significant physical/mental deterioration. If this occurs, I’ll be in no state to look after kids. Who on earth would leave a 3yo with someone who can’t handle a desk job! I’ll never forget on one of these silly threads someone said I should therefore pay the nursery fees for the days that I otherwise could have done. It was moot as my kids don’t have kids as yet, but the entitlement now is just staggering. Fuck that for a joke. Maybe people should take the cost of kids into account before having them. That’s something I taught my kids and I think that’s a much greater gift than forced childminding.

JennyWren87 · 22/04/2023 00:34

I agree with you OP to a point. My father in law watches ours two mornings so I can sleep after my nightshift. I don't earn much as a Band 2 (NHS) and it was clearly a financial decision for us more than wanting childcare to be family. BUT he offered and said to him it's about wanting to spend time with the grandkids. I feel very blessed in that regard.

Some of my colleagues however are working on themselves to the bone in their 60s and have their grandkids every day they're off work. It's not healthy!

Fortheages · 21/04/2023 22:03

Our parents “help” by entertaining our DV once or twice a year (always in our house) for about an hour 😂 PIL will babysit maybe once a year, but only if our DC are already asleep. Helpful? Not really.

I can’t wait to look after my future grandchildren. What I won’t be doing is looking after old grandparents!!

FrodisCapering · 21/04/2023 21:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

JenniferBooth · 21/04/2023 19:51

This is why i (as a child free by choice woman) would never date a man with kids OR with grown up kids because if i became a step grandparent i would be expected to step up.

hiredandsqueak · 21/04/2023 19:48

@FrodisCapering I didn't get any help with mine but dm died when I was a teen and df moved a long way away. I have and still do provide childcare for dd because of her particular circumstances because I won't see her struggle but in an ideal world I would be the Granny who had a weekend visit and took them on the odd day out during school holidays.
I found wrangling my own 5dc (2 ASD) a doddle when I was half the age I am now. I'm exhausted now after a full day of dgs who is nearly four and pretty well behaved so can understand other GP's reluctance.

FrodisCapering · 21/04/2023 19:25

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

phoenixrosehere · 21/04/2023 18:15

I don’t think grandparents do have a moral obligation but I do think many need to be honest about how much family help they had and how much they are actually going to give.

I know too many that will swear up and down they did it on their own and use it as a reason not to help (which they can) yet their adult children know that’s a lie or give loads to some of their children while making others have to ask for a few hours a year.

I’ve also had friends who were nagged to death by their parents wanting grandchildren and asking them when they’ll have children, promising they’ll help, and then once they get grandchildren, they “forget” such promises and can’t be bothered.

Better to expect you’ll be doing it on your own and paying for help when needed. If you get help, great but don’t expect it.

hiredandsqueak · 21/04/2023 17:02

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

But surely if your parents outsourced your care to your Grandparents didn't it occur to you that they wouldn't want to care for your children either? I can't imagine that rationally anyone would think "oh well my parents needed a lot of help from my grandparents but of course twenty odd years later they will jump at the chance to do something that they didn't want or feel able to do when they were younger and fitter and had the obligation"

Newuser82 · 21/04/2023 16:55

I don't think grandparents should be obligated to provide childcare but I do think it's strange when grandparents don't seem that interested in taking the kids out places or having them round to stay now and again.

I think it effects the bond between them and if they don't put in much effort then I think it will come back to bite them in the bum as the kids grow up.

FrodisCapering · 21/04/2023 16:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Scalottia · 21/04/2023 16:28

Nope. You chose to have children. They are entirely your responsibility.

Vee1987 · 21/04/2023 16:26

Disagree. Becoming a parent shouldn’t mean signing yourself up for childcare during retirement. I think it’s nice to think of time spent between grandparents and their grandchildren through rose-tinted glasses but the reality is kids - especially younger ones - can be hard work, hence some women (often) say on here they find actual work a break from being a mum. I’d rather work part-time for longer in my now relatively easy job than retire then provide a few days of childcare a week which I think is far more physical and tiring than a lot of jobs. My eldest needed constant eyes on them as they were non-stop and couldn’t entertain themselves for a little while with a book or colouring or something. They’d try opening cupboards, running near sharp furniture edges… They only stopped to sleep. I have fond memories of my relationship with my grandparents but they didn’t provide childcare. My parents did the discipline and parenting part; my granny did the fun stuff like baking with me and my grandad took us on walks and things. Of course grandparents should be helpful if possible when there’s a childcare emergency.

Mumski45 · 21/04/2023 15:54

"I know in other cultures this is standard and families pull together much more. AIBU to think there is actually a moral obligation here, to make some form of childcare contribution, however small?"

In these cultures it is also normal for adult offspring to look after their parents in old age. Presumably you would also see this as a moral obligation on you when the time comes.

ellie09 · 21/04/2023 15:41

I can see both sides really.

There is an underlying bitterness with me and my mum because of the lack of childcare/help. I understand to a degree, but with the help she received, I thought she would have been a bit more understanding.

When I was younger, me and my sister went to our grandparents house every single Friday night so she could have a night out. We were picked up by my granny from school and kept until lunch time on Saturday. Every week. My granny also picked us up from school everyday, fed us dinner and dropped us back at half 5 or so on weekdays so she could work.

My mum decided when she remarried to have more children in a house that couldn't fit us all. I was moved out of the family home and moved permanently into my grandparents house at 13. It was either that, or share a room with 2 younger sisters. My grandparents provided all my meals, my care right up until I was 18 and moved out.

Fast forward to now, my mum has 2 grandchildren and works part time for 24 hours a week as she's still young (52). She rarely has her grandchildren, even for a couple of hours. She has taken my son overnight for around 3 nights in 6 years. She has a Monday off, and even in an emergency will "compromise" to take him for an hour or so out of an 8 hour working day. She used to help me taking child to school in the mornings as it was on her route, but has since stopped this and told me to put him in breakfast club so I can drop off earlier.

I know that my child is my responsibility, but there is some resentment there and abandonment issues on my side, with how heavily she depended on my grandparents and how little she participates. It has been a long standing issue talked about in therapy and it has impacted my mental health a lot more than I imagined (the living out the family home so young).

My grandparents were fantastic when I was growing up and when my granny died when I was 20, it genuinely was like losing a mum.

I will be 100% up for looking after my grandchildren overnight at weekends etc in the future. Just due to the close bond I had with mine.

Liorae · 21/04/2023 15:41

ReadersD1gest · 21/04/2023 15:27

Interesting take on it. Not everyone who has children are in a state of suffering. We don't all need rescuing.

I am sure @Lonejohny will explain to her children the suffering caused by having kids, and caution them against doing the same.

justteanbiscuits · 21/04/2023 15:31

It's morally wrong to have children and expect free childcare from others. We chose to have children. If someone looks after them for free it's a massive bonus. Otherwise, we pay for childcare.

ReadersD1gest · 21/04/2023 15:27

Lonejohny · 21/04/2023 15:02

Sorry to those who say that. But I definitely bring my kids up to be compassionate, kind and helpful. I could never witness another person suffer of I could help and neither could my children. Our children exist because we wanted them but we have an obligation to guide to being good people not selfish ones.
To many selfish, me first people out there. Always shocks me. fitzwilliamdarcyfitzwilliamdarcy

Interesting take on it. Not everyone who has children are in a state of suffering. We don't all need rescuing.