Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think its morally poor not to provide ANY childcare whatsoever as a grandparent, if you are retired and in good health?

957 replies

uniformotxa · 13/04/2023 11:21

I have young dc and no childcare issues aside from the horrendous cost. My parents, like many others I know, enjoy being with dc but it’s pretty much always on their terms. They would take them for a day but it wouldn’t be consistent or reliable so couldn’t make it a regular thing.

Im not sure how I feel about this and on balance I think it’s pretty morally dire. Luckily I can afford childcare and nursery but I perhaps would feel more strongly if I couldn’t. However, whilst it’s easy for me to say this now, I do think I would step up and do some childcare for my dc if they had children. I can’t imagine just letting the days roll by leisurely and not setting aside even one day a week to be a reliable help.

I know in other cultures this is standard and families pull together much more. AIBU to think there is actually a moral obligation here, to make some form of childcare contribution, however small?

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 14/04/2023 08:31

Thefrogwife · 13/04/2023 11:24

Erm, I'm expecting my first child and my parents and my husband's parents all live three hours away, so maybe my perspective is a bit different here but...unless your parents were actively involved in your decision to have a child, I.e. you consulted with them when you were thinking of becoming pregnant, I would say no. By having my baby, I don't feel I'm signing up for childcare duties in 30 years time- what if they have 5 kids and I want to live abroad in my old age?

This ^^

DD categorically doesn't want children, but if she were to get pregnant now I'm not prepared to give up work to provide childcare. Been there, done that and got the T-shirt.

Sorty, I disagree with you @uniformotxa

Carsarelife · 14/04/2023 08:28

I'm with you. My parents are both in extremely good health. My mum has never worked and my dad retired 10 ish years ago. Both early 70's.
Always excuses - first it was no as you are breastfeeding, then it was nappies, then just no.
My eldest is 17 now and never slept over or been looked after by my parents except one time when I had a day operation in hospital but out the same day.
She doesn't have a great relationship with GP really and finds them difficult to talk to.
My youngest doesn't really know them as we've visited less as the years have gone on and my grievances with them have surfaced more.
I know my mum is bored as she says she is. My dad keeps busy with decorating, gardening, washing his car etc
Other set of grandparents don't exist really.

DisquietintheRanks · 14/04/2023 08:27

@Dowellif for which country? In the UK I'd say the whole of the C18 and 19 (all those servants and cotton mills). "Working for pay" is always tricky in UK history because married women and girls didn't own things in their own right so when they worked for the family business they didn't draw wages yet their labour was part of the cash economy.

Obviously a lot of women in the c18 and 19 didn't work for 40 years because they died young. But they certainly worked for their whole lives alongside child-rearing/homemaking.

Thatiswild · 14/04/2023 08:20

The problem with this is that it can blur the boundaries of the grandparent relationship when they become an unpaid childcare provider and create a lot of resentment on both sides.

My friends who get help from parents are in two definite camps 1) moan about their parents and in-laws’ care decisions, are extremely entitled and want to dictate where, when etc and are affronted when grandparents want to go on holiday or ever have a day off or 2) are extremely grateful for the support and never ask them to babysit any other time as they are respectful of their free time. It totally depends on the parent, the grandparents, personalities, the adults’ relationships, distance, so many things.

Personally we live 150-450 miles from all four parents so haven’t had any support but I am absolutely certain I would not have wanted it as I know them well enough that it could have been a recipe for disaster. My kids have lovely relationships with all of their grandparents though so it hasn’t affected that. They obviously don’t see them as much as if they were local but I prefer our set up as the distance works for us.

Dowellif · 14/04/2023 08:19

DisquietintheRanks · 14/04/2023 08:11

@Dowellif do you really think women didn't work before 1970? Ffs women have always worked for pay. Poke your nose out of that middle class bubble.

OK - I'll bite. Please do provide a link to stats showing the years in which the majority of women a) worked for 40 years b) retired in their 60s.

Happy to be proved wrong but think you'll find trends in a) labour market participation and b) life expectancy make this generation's labour market experiences unique.

As to my nose and a middle class bubble, I think you are making some large assumptions there Smile

DisquietintheRanks · 14/04/2023 08:11

Dowellif · 14/04/2023 07:25

Women in their 50s and early 60s would appear to be the first generation of humans to retire in their 60s having worked in paid employment for 40 years whilst also having shouldered an uneven domestic and child rearing burden, and having navigated menopause in the workplace. This generation of women have good reason to feel exhausted at retirement.

OP I think you have little understanding of the toll this takes over the life course and the realities for women of hitting your 60s. At this point you are staring at a finite number of years you can expect to remain in decent health in and up until this stage in life your needs have been sublimated by obligations to kids and the need to earn an income.

@Dowellif do you really think women didn't work before 1970? Ffs women have always worked for pay. Poke your nose out of that middle class bubble.

Daffodilwoman · 14/04/2023 08:06

It will be harder as women have to work until they are 67 before retiring.
This will be me, I can’t afford to retire before then unless I win the lottery. This means I won’t be providing free childcare to my grandchildren ( if I have any). It also means I won’t be providing care for my elderly parents. Those are the facts. The consequence of governments burying their head in the sand over how we provide for parents and the elderly.
I do look back at my ex fil who stopped working at 55 and think what a luxury that was. His wife still did everything around the house. So he didn’t work and he still had wifey as a domestic servant.
Yet we had to pay for childcare.
That’s the crux for me. Most couples will not be like this going forward so most grandparents can’t supply childcare.

BansheeofInisherin · 14/04/2023 07:41

Indeed @Dowellif. I think many posters saying they will help out are possibly not 50 yet. And are not yet exhausted by the mental load and menopause.

My mum comes from a long-lived family so I expect to be looking after her too. Which I will do regardless of her not providing any regular childcare for me. Because she already did her part by bringing me up!

Dowellif · 14/04/2023 07:25

Women in their 50s and early 60s would appear to be the first generation of humans to retire in their 60s having worked in paid employment for 40 years whilst also having shouldered an uneven domestic and child rearing burden, and having navigated menopause in the workplace. This generation of women have good reason to feel exhausted at retirement.

OP I think you have little understanding of the toll this takes over the life course and the realities for women of hitting your 60s. At this point you are staring at a finite number of years you can expect to remain in decent health in and up until this stage in life your needs have been sublimated by obligations to kids and the need to earn an income.

dottiedodah · 14/04/2023 06:41

Readersd1gest mum had to work 9 to 4 with an hour each way commute.late 60s/Early 70s gm did school pick up and weekends a lot as well.dad died suddenly and she was a sm to me.very little state help then.nan even used to take me to work with her in the holidays! She was a tea lady at a garage. The office staff used to give me chocolate bars and pocket money!

ElizaMulvil · 14/04/2023 01:26

I didn't have any help with childcare from my mother 76 and in poor health when my first was born or my m in l similar age 74 - both 1 hour+ away.

But I do appreciate that my mother was the sole earner age 20 and until 30 for her retired father, blacklisted brother, unemployed sister and brother in law which prevented her from marrying until mid 30s. Said b in law provided home for his mother and my mother and children when he got a good job. My aunt providing care for my sister and me whilst my abandoned mother worked. Similarly my m in l as the eldest girl, looked after her 5 siblings while her parents worked, plus 2 cousins.

Going back in time, my gggrand aunt, living in cellars in Manchester took in my ggmother and her 9 children fleeing the famine of 1840s in Ireland.

My eldest aunt, widowed in WW1, bought a house for her disabled brother and then her youngest sister and family when her husband abandoned her. My eldest uncle helped my g father financially to set up his shop.

Now I travel 2+ hours most weeks, unpaid, to look after my granddaughter 3days, in London. Because I want to. I'm 76.

If I was in trouble I could call on members of my family. Isn't this what families do?

girlfriend44 · 14/04/2023 00:32

WandaWonder · 13/04/2023 11:28

So parents can have as many children as they want and grandparents have to put up with it?

Mind you when they do help they are called taking over and controlling

So maybe they need to live in a box and just jump out when their children whistle so they can help?

Good one. Lots of grandparents still have active lives and commitments too.

Liorae · 14/04/2023 00:21

saraclara · 13/04/2023 23:35

'....but of course on her her second turn, she has to do eveything my way. She doesn't get to actually enjoy it'

Both of your posts are very true.

Ivesaidenough · 14/04/2023 00:08

Agree, Sparrow80.

Sparrow80 · 13/04/2023 23:58

Personally I think that everyone who is able to (whether that’s affected by health, disability, stress, money related etc) should do something in their lives to help others. Of course they don’t have to. And what they do will be limited by time available.

For parents this might be caring for their own children and keeping a roof over their heads. It might be that you help others through your job. It might be really supporting a friend who needs it. Just something for other people.

I don’t mean at the expense of your own well-being. I recognise people have hidden disabilities and pressures and don’t mean them. But when you have time and security and space to do so it seems odd not to help others.

I struggle with healthy and able bodied, financially secure retired grandparents in their 60s and 70s not wanting to help, at least on a small basis regularly. As I said, of course they don’t have to but in terms of the bigger picture of family and community and connection, isn’t it good to do something outside of yourself?

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 13/04/2023 23:46

Emotionalstorm · 13/04/2023 23:21

If my parents got sick I would hire a nanny. My daughter is three years old so she's nearly off to school anyway.

My husband has asked for another child though. Our daughter fits into our life so perfectly at the moment that I'm reluctant to have another.

If you can afford a nanny the question doesn't apply to you. It is a question for people who are saying they can't afford to pay for child care. Help from grandparents is great but if you are completely dependent on it there is the potential to come unstuck because no one knows what the future holds.

saraclara · 13/04/2023 23:35

'....but of course on her her second turn, she has to do eveything my way. She doesn't get to actually enjoy it'

saraclara · 13/04/2023 23:34

I've just remembered another MN trope about GMs.

"She's had her turn"

'Oh...but she gets to have another turn whether she likes it or not, when it suits me and saves me money.'

UsingChangeofName · 13/04/2023 23:31

Your title and your opening post are a bit different IMO.

You say 'ANY childcare whatsoever' in your title, and, before opening the thread I was assuming you meant they'd refused to look after your dc whilst you had a dental appointment, or were feeling really ill or had to go to a funeral, or even were in hospital yourself. I was going to agree with you.

But

Your OP is talking about regular, full days of childcare.
You are being ridiculous with your "morally poor" or "dire".

It is nice if Grandparents offer, but there is no expectation anyone should.
I hope, when / if I become a Grandparent I will be able to babysit, and support my dc on occasions when whatever they need to do would be easier without a small child in tow. I hope I can help out if they, or their parents are ill. I hope I will have the energy to take them for the day or even weekend occasionally 'just for fun', but there is no way I'm going to become a childminder in my retirement. It was hard enough looking after little people in my 30s, I'm not going to start all over in my 60s.

YABVVVU. Am surprised that the vote isn't higher.

DisquietintheRanks · 13/04/2023 23:29

saraclara · 13/04/2023 15:05

Basically the message from many MNers on recent threads is:

Grandparents, know your place!

You're not allowed to actually meet your new grandchild for a month because 'baby bubble' and the baby's NOT A TOY TO BE PASSED AROUND!

Your not allowed an opinion, or to buy your DGC a gift that's not on the approved list.

You're not allowed to even mildly discipline your DGC in your own home

You're not allowed to feed them a treat that has 2mg of sugar in it

You're not allowed to communicate outside the approved channels (so only via your son if you have a DIL) nor expect a timely response.

You're not allowed to ask for anything, because that's actually a DEMAND (if you're a MIL, anyway)

...I'm sure regular MN ers can add to those rules...

But you have to be available and committed to putting your own life to one side to carry out regular childcare once the novelty of new motherhood has worn off for your DD/DIL and she's back at work. Even if your energy levels are failing or you have other needs and commitments.
And if you don't, then you're never to expect any help in your old age (not that it would be forthcoming even if you have devoted a decade to your DGDs childcare, of course)

👏 👏 👏

dottiedodah · 13/04/2023 23:27

Readers digest mum was a single parent late 60s.not much help then .worked pt 9 to 4 .an hour each way to work on the tube.dad had died,so was brought up by nan as well

FatFucker · 13/04/2023 23:26

BellaJuno · 13/04/2023 11:27

Nope, totally disagree. In future I will help my children out in emergencies with childcare but won’t be offering any regular childcare, I just don’t want to do it and don’t feel bad about it.

Same @BellaJuno. I've done my bit.

By the time they have kids I will hopefully be retired and out and about travelling I don't want or be stuck at home looking after grandkids!

Fuck that!

PilshardPillToSwallow · 13/04/2023 23:23

Op I've not read the whole thread but in an ideal world yes! Of course some help even now and again every few month's would be fabulous.

All I can say is make it on your terms.

Emotionalstorm · 13/04/2023 23:21

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 13/04/2023 23:12

If your being able to afford DC is dependent on grandparents providing free childcare what happens if the happy willing grandparents suddenly aren't available? If they become ill what will happen, if they die what will happen? I have several family members who went from fit and healthy to requiring care themselves overnight. In one case in their late 50's. If their DC had had children on the presumption of free childcare from them they would have been in trouble when my uncle suddenly had a major stroke and my aunt became his career.

If my parents got sick I would hire a nanny. My daughter is three years old so she's nearly off to school anyway.

My husband has asked for another child though. Our daughter fits into our life so perfectly at the moment that I'm reluctant to have another.

Emotionalstorm · 13/04/2023 23:18

bluebird3 · 13/04/2023 22:52

I agree to an extent although I wouldn't expect full time. But I do judge grandparents who were happy to accept free childcare when they had kids, but aren't willing to give that help to their own children.

To me childcare is something freely offered. So if my parents want to help they can offer. If I don't want to I don't need to offer.

Swipe left for the next trending thread