Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think its morally poor not to provide ANY childcare whatsoever as a grandparent, if you are retired and in good health?

957 replies

uniformotxa · 13/04/2023 11:21

I have young dc and no childcare issues aside from the horrendous cost. My parents, like many others I know, enjoy being with dc but it’s pretty much always on their terms. They would take them for a day but it wouldn’t be consistent or reliable so couldn’t make it a regular thing.

Im not sure how I feel about this and on balance I think it’s pretty morally dire. Luckily I can afford childcare and nursery but I perhaps would feel more strongly if I couldn’t. However, whilst it’s easy for me to say this now, I do think I would step up and do some childcare for my dc if they had children. I can’t imagine just letting the days roll by leisurely and not setting aside even one day a week to be a reliable help.

I know in other cultures this is standard and families pull together much more. AIBU to think there is actually a moral obligation here, to make some form of childcare contribution, however small?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
blahblahblah1654 · 24/07/2023 08:09

The posters not players!

blahblahblah1654 · 24/07/2023 08:08

I hope to provide childcare if my DS does have children one day, perhaps a day a week and babysitting some evenings. My mum is only 59 but works a lot and lives a couple of hours away. In laws live 4 hours away. Me and DH both work full time and we have a great childminder. I wouldn't expect grandparents to do loads. I know my FIL would love to if location slowed though. We wouldn't be able to provide elderly care with working full time anyway but I also don't expect much inheritance if elderly care does need to be paid for. The players who refuse to help when parents are elderly may need to accept this too.

cptartapp · 24/07/2023 07:53

My DM didn't enjoy babysitting. It was rare. No sleepovers in 17 years. That's fine, we paid for childcare. I certainly wouldn't enjoy being tied to elder care. I see so many friends on antidepressants because of this burden. Unable to live their lives. I want to travel like she did whilst in my prime.
If everyone does what makes them happiest and pays for the help that they need when needed then everyone knows where they stand.
Emergencies aside of course.

Goldencup · 24/07/2023 07:01

Blimey these " frail" grannies, my DM was 54 when DS was born she was in no way frail or unable to care for him or his sister when she came along 2 years later.

She was however still working ft so her support was limited to weekends . Once she had retired and they were at school she tended to do the inset days and a week in the long summer holidays ( aged 60 something). She is now 74 and I think she will be too old to care for DS's DC if he has any.

Carsarelife · 24/07/2023 07:01

My parents are in good health and early 70's. My eldest DD is 18 and my parents have never babysitted once and my DD has never slept over there. In 18 years. I think it's incredibly sad. She used to experience friends sleeping over at their grandparents etc. They've always made excuses.
Now my youngest DD we've never even asked. They only live 30 mins away too. I know it's not tit for tat but I only visit around once a month. As they get older I will not be travelling there daily like they expect me to. I feel very hurt about it. In a real emergency I wouldn't even call on them. I just learnt to deal with everything myself

Toooldtoworry · 24/07/2023 06:55

Iateallthechocolate · 23/07/2023 20:38

In this country no one is obliged to help their grown children and in turn those grown children are not obliged, down the line, to help their aged parents.

It's a bit shit though. People left to struggle alone at every age. There must be a better way. I wonder what it is?

The thing is that most grandparents are still working, and especially now that the cost of living has increased so significantly.

Freshair1 · 24/07/2023 06:54

Haven't read the full thread but absolutely not. They're not defacto babysitters. Mind you, at the other end of the scale I refuse to care for them as they get elderly. Take responsibility for your stuff and people.

Toooldtoworry · 24/07/2023 06:51

LuckyPeonies · 23/04/2023 18:16

I agree with Lois that it would be initially painful, but eventually humanity (and the entire planet) would be better off.

And I also believe (caution, unpopular opinion) that forcing old people who have zero quality of life, and/or no awareness, to linger/vegetate for months or years in substandard care homes is cruel and inhumane. Thankfully, some countries are recognizing this and allowing people to ‘check out’ when they want.

I agree

Mari9999 · 24/07/2023 01:03

@Iateallthechocolate
The better solution is responsibility at every age

Iateallthechocolate · 23/07/2023 20:38

In this country no one is obliged to help their grown children and in turn those grown children are not obliged, down the line, to help their aged parents.

It's a bit shit though. People left to struggle alone at every age. There must be a better way. I wonder what it is?

LuckyPeonies · 23/04/2023 18:16

Badbudgeter · 23/04/2023 07:44

We have such a large, elderly population. It’s an enormous burden to place on a shrinking young population. Isn’t this the problem with China who are now trying to encourage residents to have more children?

I agree with Lois that it would be initially painful, but eventually humanity (and the entire planet) would be better off.

And I also believe (caution, unpopular opinion) that forcing old people who have zero quality of life, and/or no awareness, to linger/vegetate for months or years in substandard care homes is cruel and inhumane. Thankfully, some countries are recognizing this and allowing people to ‘check out’ when they want.

MsRosley · 23/04/2023 16:47

@Mari9999 Amen!

Mari9999 · 23/04/2023 14:31

@qpmz
People who are fully capable on their own of meeting and providing for the needs and expenses related to having a child really do not need to consult anyone prior to having a child.

People who are unable on their own of meeting all of those needs should consult anyone and everyone that they expect to step in and meet needs or expenses related to the caring and preparation of that child.

Unfortunately, many people put more planning, research, and exploration into the purchase of a vehicle than they do into the decision of their readiness to meet the obligations that come with parenthood. You would never arrive at a dealership to purchase a vehicle without money in hand or a clear and articulated agreement or contract specifying the time and terms of payment, but the same people are willing to bring a life into existence without having made any specific and agreed upon plans for important aspects related to caring for the child.

The auto dealer who sends you away when you come unprepared is considered a wise and prudent business man or woman. The parent who sends you away when you want to out source your responsibilities to them without having involved them in any of the prior planning is considered a mean and indifferent grandparent. The truth is that it was the child's parents who approached parenthood with an indifferent attitude and an it is someone else' s responsibility to be available to bail them out upon demand. Better they should have become car owners than parents.

Liorae · 23/04/2023 11:01

ReadersD1gest · 23/04/2023 09:54

I think you've missed the point, rather...

Which would be a mumsnet.com norm.

ReadersD1gest · 23/04/2023 09:54

qpmz · 23/04/2023 09:46

Who seriously consults their parents when trying for a child?. Mumsnet at its finest!

I think you've missed the point, rather...

qpmz · 23/04/2023 09:46

Thefrogwife · 13/04/2023 11:24

Erm, I'm expecting my first child and my parents and my husband's parents all live three hours away, so maybe my perspective is a bit different here but...unless your parents were actively involved in your decision to have a child, I.e. you consulted with them when you were thinking of becoming pregnant, I would say no. By having my baby, I don't feel I'm signing up for childcare duties in 30 years time- what if they have 5 kids and I want to live abroad in my old age?

Who seriously consults their parents when trying for a child?. Mumsnet at its finest!

Thighlengthboots · 23/04/2023 09:00

hiredandsqueak · 22/04/2023 09:40

@Thighlengthboots but you are talking about different people. I’m assuming your Nan looked after you because she was happy to. It doesn’t leave your parents under any obligation to do the same just because they previously benefited from childcare from grandparents. I didn’t get any childcare that I didn’t pay for, my parents had died in laws were unwell yet I still care for dgs.

I wouldnt have said she was "happy" about it, it was just assumed this would happen by everyone in the family. For my dad to then not offer even an hour's help, in a blue moon or an emergency to help us makes him selfish in my opinion. When he got ill with dementia, I got carers in and then he went into a home because I applied the same logic regarding helping out that he did.

Goodoccasionallypoor · 23/04/2023 08:17

@LuckyPeonies

What kind of population control are you suggesting?

Do you really believe that people in the UK are having too many children for the country to support? I'm surprised if you do as we actually have the opposite problem.

Badbudgeter · 23/04/2023 07:44

LuckyPeonies · 22/04/2023 18:06

I wish population control would become public policy, but capitalism, religion, and ‘I am entitled to have as many kids as I want’ selfishness are big stumbling blocks.

We have such a large, elderly population. It’s an enormous burden to place on a shrinking young population. Isn’t this the problem with China who are now trying to encourage residents to have more children?

Catsmere · 23/04/2023 07:28

JenniferBooth · 22/04/2023 14:23

And its usually the "it takes a village to raise a child" brigade who get the hump when you tell their child off for running around a coffee shop.

Yes, they seem to think it means unasked strangers are required to gush over their children and look after them in public places.

LuckyPeonies · 22/04/2023 18:06

loislovesstewie · 22/04/2023 14:51

Actually I think it would be a good idea if the population generally decreased both in the UK and elsewhere. Many countries are overpopulated, we can't carry on building houses for ever, we can't feed ourselves on the land we have, we are running out of resources. I agree that will cause a huge problem for some while but eventually we would be better off.

I wish population control would become public policy, but capitalism, religion, and ‘I am entitled to have as many kids as I want’ selfishness are big stumbling blocks.

Scalottia · 22/04/2023 15:19

Agree @loislovesstewie. Fewer humans would benefit the planet in the long run.

loislovesstewie · 22/04/2023 14:51

Actually I think it would be a good idea if the population generally decreased both in the UK and elsewhere. Many countries are overpopulated, we can't carry on building houses for ever, we can't feed ourselves on the land we have, we are running out of resources. I agree that will cause a huge problem for some while but eventually we would be better off.

Liorae · 22/04/2023 14:26

Thesharkradar · 22/04/2023 13:54

I completely agree with you, however the problem with this is it will lead to the birth rate dropping far below replacement rate, it takes a village to raise a child but the village is too busy to help.

And yet so many have an issue with the immigration that will solve the replacement rate issue.

JenniferBooth · 22/04/2023 14:23

And its usually the "it takes a village to raise a child" brigade who get the hump when you tell their child off for running around a coffee shop.