Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why parents feel they don't need to financially help their kids after a certain age because they must ‘struggle like we did’ ?

289 replies

whatistuesday · 13/04/2023 10:42

I understand some people literally cannot do this but many can, even if it means a detriment to their own life, for instance one less holiday, a cheaper car etc etc.

But I do not understand why those who can, don’t. People who moan about supporting kids through university, making them take (full) loans that take so long to pay back, making them move out before they’ve had chance to save, charging them rent… the list goes on. The argument always seems to be that the DD or DS needs to learn the value of money or stand on their own two feet… of course, but does that mean you, as a parent, have no responsibility when they turn 18? Are they supposed to magically have money to start out? Even renting you need a deposit, let alone the idea of saving for a mortgage. There’s this idea that ‘well if i suffered, you must too.’ It’s your child!

For context I have had help from my parents but also know they could have done more. I now have dc and would do everything possible to ensure they were financially comfortable as a young adult. And no… I’m not bringing up brats, I work hard and will expect them to, too. But I also don’t want them to launch into debt to get started in life, because I think I deserve a nice holiday or a new car or to order what I want in my weekly shop. I will always make sacrifices where needed, it won’t suddenly end at 18.

OP posts:
Kazzyhoward · 13/04/2023 13:07

YANBU. My parents gave us no help at all, always pleading poverty, etc., which meant we got married later, bought a house later, only had one child, etc., as we really struggled financially in our 20's, both having longer term "trainee" jobs where it took us several years to qualify and finally get decent wages after years of very low earnings. We inherited in our late 40s by which time we were settled financially ourselves and didn't need it anymore! Although grateful for the inheritance, it was also very annoying to discover the amount of money they had, and we could work backwards to how much they were sat on when we were really struggling in our early 20's when they were pleading poverty and that they had no money to help us!

We've therefore "ring fenced" that inheritance for our son. He doesn't know how much money there is and isn't expecting much from us. But we're adopting a kind of 50:50 policy with him, so drip-feeding him the money when he wants to pay bills, buy things, etc. During his uni years, he has been financed 50% by student loan and the other 50% by us, so we've matched his student loan, which has given him enough to live on without having to take a part time job (we'd rather he concentrated on getting a degree!).

He's got a job starting this Summer in a different city, and we've already told him we'll match him 50:50 when he buys a car, and for his living costs as he'll be on "trainee" wages for around 5 years, which won't pay for his rent, utilities, food, petrol, etc., etc. He doesn't know it yet, but we'll match him 50:50 for a house deposit in a few years time. He wouldn't have been able to accept the job if we weren't going to help fund his living costs etc. It's an investment in his future (i.e. time and effort in taking around 15 professional exams over several years!), as once he's qualified, he'll be on BIG money and have brilliant career prospects, so we need to help him get there, and taking away his money worries will be a big part of that.

Comefromaway · 13/04/2023 13:06

The fishing analogy was good.

I did go without so my kids could have certain educational things growing up eg music lessons. Ds is now at conservatoire and already starting to earn money through his music. I helped him with equipment/musical instruemts for this, I also helped dd with rent when she moved to London to further her training/career.

The things I help with are things that will ultimately help them to progress and be able to support themselves.

toomuchlaundry · 13/04/2023 13:06

@tinytemper66 but that's £10k they don't need to spend.

It's interesting how there re quite a few threads at the moment where people are saying parents aren't helping their adult DC enough eg financially, complaining about being charged nominal amount for a holiday, being morally obliged to provide free childcare. I wonder if all these posters will be providing everything to their DC when they are adults, that they are complaining their parents aren't providing

Queryer · 13/04/2023 13:06

I agree. Parents should help their adult children if they can - and at the very least they should teach them about borrowing and not favour one child over the rest. Unfortunately I was not on the receiving end of my parent’s generosity but my estranged sibling was yet wasted it all and became a thieving scum queen.

Nordicrain · 13/04/2023 13:06

Of course they need help and support. But I don't agree with your examples buying them a car if they could save for it themselves, at the cost of your own holiday, doesn't really help them stand on their own two feet. I wouldn't do that. Not to punish them, but to teach them financial indepedence and responsibility. I would probably offer them a loan though so they didn't waste money on high interest.

I will support my children to get jobs so they can support themselves and help them out. But I won't be spending my golden years on tesco value meals, counting pennies and sitting at home in the cold to ensure they can have everything they desire without working for it.

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 13/04/2023 13:02

Honestly, whilst I'll always have a safe place for my children to live at any point in their lives (as long as I have a roof over my head), I'm not going to continue to financially struggle to fund their choices as an adult. Living with me will mean they pay a fair contribution towards living expenses and they share the load of being an adult in a working household.

It's not about "I struggled so you have to too" but more "Why should I continue to struggle now you're an adult?"

Surely at some point I'm allowed to take the pressure off my shoulders and live a little, God forbid have a holiday somewhere?

There's a balance between being your children's security and letting your children take advantage of your kindness...which frankly does them no favours in the real world.

Foodie6 · 13/04/2023 13:02

There's a difference between letting your kids struggle and encouraging them to get jobs and stand on their own feet.

I also am from a background that had zero money but have managed to dig myself out of it. It means I'm now an avid saver for a rainy day and a great budgeter. Those are valuable life lessons you don't learn when you always have the "oh mum and/or dad will just pay for this" option.

I expect my children to at least attempt to be financially independent. This is lost sometimes when they have the bank of mum and dad. If my kids fall on hard times and can't afford basic necessities of course I'm going to help them financially if I'm able. I don't think they should expect an entire house deposit from me though, especially if they spend their youths pissing money down the drain and saving absolutely nothing.

Ponderingwindow · 13/04/2023 13:01

I will keep financially supporting my teen as a young adult as long as she keeps working hard. If she isn’t in full time education or isn’t working on her career then she would be hurting her own future. Supporting her financially while she languished and did nothing or only worked part-time would not be in her best interests.

tinytemper66 · 13/04/2023 13:01

toomuchlaundry · 13/04/2023 12:57

@tinytemper66 what sort of wedding are they having? No-one should get into debt for a wedding (but that doesn't mean they should get family to pay for it). Petrol is more important than what in the end is a fancy party. They could go to the registry office and have meal afterwards with £1k you are giving them.

This is one of the issues, when my parents got married and had their first house, it was teeny, would have had second hand white goods (if any), no tv. DM would make some of her own clothes and all curtains etc. They had a small wedding and gifts would have been things for their new house, but practical not a fancy dinner service. They scrimped and saved for other things they needed.

Now couples expect a lot more and want everything now

In a house with nice grounds. They are paying for it monthly. Her parents are not giving them anything. It is nothing fancy and costs less than 10K I believe. He doesn't say much about the wedding. I gave him money there and then to fill up his tank. I don't think they are struggling like some but he says it has gotten tight a couple of times.

gamerchick · 13/04/2023 12:59

So parents have to struggle and then carry on watching the coin so their adult kids are financially sorted?

People need to be able to enjoy life later on. They're not obliged to help pay for house deposits or other shite for their grown up kids.

DisquietintheRanks · 13/04/2023 12:59

..doesn't mean I'd never help...

DisquietintheRanks · 13/04/2023 12:58

Well I'm raising adults not parasites. That doesn't mean I'd ever help in any circumstance but I'm damned if I'm going to live a miserable old age so my kids don't have to experience a drop in living standards, or move straight from home into their own homes.

toomuchlaundry · 13/04/2023 12:57

@tinytemper66 what sort of wedding are they having? No-one should get into debt for a wedding (but that doesn't mean they should get family to pay for it). Petrol is more important than what in the end is a fancy party. They could go to the registry office and have meal afterwards with £1k you are giving them.

This is one of the issues, when my parents got married and had their first house, it was teeny, would have had second hand white goods (if any), no tv. DM would make some of her own clothes and all curtains etc. They had a small wedding and gifts would have been things for their new house, but practical not a fancy dinner service. They scrimped and saved for other things they needed.

Now couples expect a lot more and want everything now

QueenCamilla · 13/04/2023 12:55

@NeverEverA

Is your husband misery-tight too?
Your inlaws are like mine (ex-inlaws and I went no contact with them whilst married ) , but my ExH was generous to a fault. Still is.
FIL lent 1.5k to my ExH to divorce me and then put interest on it 😂 Creeps 🤷‍♀️

buckingmad · 13/04/2023 12:53

I'm somewhere in the middle. My parents had less money when I was growing up compared to my siblings (big age gap) and I am the best with money out of all of them. It taught me to budget, where to save costs and where to spend a bit more, what is essential and what isn't.

So whilst yes I wouldn't let my children go homeless, I wouldn't throw them £100 just so they could afford netflix or the newest phone contract etc.

Also re taking out the student loan - often this makes the most financial sense, especially for women if they are going to take career breaks or go part time to have children. I'll never pay my loan off so instead I just pay an extra 9% tax over a threshold. Much cheaper than paying £50k up front.

HexagonalHorris · 13/04/2023 12:53

It’s about balance. Helping them with their education so they can help themselves has been our main goal. We are trying to squirrel money away for dc house deposits where we can but it’s not easy while paying for uni and travel costs despite both of our dc have pt jobs to supplement their income. That’s just the reality nowadays.

You are not doing your adult child any favours if you are constantly subsidising nights out and manicures.

Everyone has different priorities but adult children sometimes forget that it might be a last chance for older working parents to get that new kitchen or go on a last holiday - things they won’t be able to afford to do once retired - and adult dc still have time to build up savings.

I know a couple who bought a tiny boat for themselves for their retirement after a lifetime of dreaming about it, working ft, and raising three dc. One of their dc got in to ridiculous credit card debt and the boat has now been been sold.

Another friend with an only child is extremely well off with a large inheritance from her parents, but she would have far preferred to have been able to give her only child a sibling rather than financial help.

WhatWhereWhenHowWhy · 13/04/2023 12:52

Hmmmm, I agree but I have a caveat.
I think that with rights and support comes responsibility.

I believe that when the next generation grows up they should support their parents in older age where possible. I don't subscribe to the Mumsnet idea of not owing your parents anything, especially if they were decent parents. Notwithstanding abusive childhoods/neglect/trauma etc, I expect a level of care and support from my children if I'm going to be sacrificing into adulthood.

Parental responsibility stops at 18, but young people do need a lot of support going forwards especially now. I will support my daughter but I expect her to step up and be decent to me/her siblings when needed (within reason)

TollgateDebs · 13/04/2023 12:51

My parents didn't have much to give, but would beggar themselves to help us, their children and so, when I could, and because I wanted to and not felt I had to, I helped them happily. I never expected anything, from anyone, so anything given with love was a bonus. I now support my nieces and nephews where we can and even friend's adult children, so treat them / support where able. People do what people want to and it has always been the way that some give and others keep to themselves. Not just about the here and now, but the person and there wanting to help others.

NeverEverA · 13/04/2023 12:48

Just had the in-laws here. Honestly I'm disgusted by them.
I've known them 25 years, remember them working. They are mid 80s and think they will live for ever, no power of attorney, no medical direction. Their capital is tied up in a Buy to let that is really shabby but because it's below market rent that's apparently ok plus a generous final salary pension. There will be inheritance tax to pay. The cost of living has not affected them.
I'm busting a gut, carrying the family mental load whilst their son climbs the career ladder, worried about uni costs for my teens.
And DD is getting just a token for her 18th from them.
They have inherited several houses over the years but the wealth has not trickled down. What are they saving it for? They judge every time we spend money, resent people having a better pair of Wellington's or a nicer garden furniture and have spent more on second kitchen appliances then I did buying midrange once.
They have totally done my head in and I'm considering divorcing DH cos I have seen the future.

QueenCamilla · 13/04/2023 12:46

There definitely is a middle ground between standing by and watching your children homeless vs. OP's "would do everything possible to ensure they were financially comfortable as a young adult".
**
The latter makes it sound like at least one party will be uncomfortable, which I do think is a step too far to make a young adult financially comfortable.
The so called "unearned income" is still a very new concept for the young and in every instance I've observed where this support is substantial, it has resulted in considerable educational and career under-achievement. The career one in particular, as guaranteed money-flow creates plenty of "Forever a Student".

Can't blame the young uns', I'd coast too with a guaranteed stipend from parents and a 1.2mil house coming my way in the form of inheritance from Gran.

I'd support my child but not "with everything possible". And what is possible, would be managed in terms of what for. Not all causes are equal.

lucylantern · 13/04/2023 12:46

YellowGreenBlue · 13/04/2023 10:52

I agree OP. My MIL has used the phrase "well we didn't get any help from our parents", but she seems to be missing the point that their parents didn't have the means to help, which is different to choosing not to.

My MIL has said this in the past too, not in a spiteful way more just a reflection.

I find it really weird, I want my kids’ lives to be better than mine, so I want them to have things we didn’t have e.g. house deposits and some childcare from us, where possible.

But there is definitely a school of thought that “we suffered and therefore that is how it must always be”, which is very odd to me

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 13/04/2023 12:45

I’d give my children everything if l had it. They are my most important life’s work.

CreepyDibillo · 13/04/2023 12:41

I agree with you, OP. My parents are far from wealthy but they are fairly comfortable in retirement.
I am 41 and my dad still offers me money occasionally based on a glib comment I may make about money - I don't take it but its nice to know he has my back if I really truly needed help.

tinytemper66 · 13/04/2023 12:40

My son admitted that one day he didn't have enough money for petrol ⛽️ and only just got to a petrol station as he had to wait until he was paid to fill up. I told him off and said he should contact us if it happened again.
They have good jobs but are struggling on times as they are paying for their wedding. We have them £25K to buy their house and will give 1K for the wedding.
I always buy them food when we visit. (They live 5 hrs away from us.)
I will also give them some money for their honeymoon.

BritishDesiGirl · 13/04/2023 12:39

I didn't add. My husband is in the exact same position as me.

My father was left millions by his father which have given my in-laws a very comfortable life.

They took out loans on behalf of my husband so that he could pay for his wedding.

They have never helped my husband.

Swipe left for the next trending thread