Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why parents feel they don't need to financially help their kids after a certain age because they must ‘struggle like we did’ ?

289 replies

whatistuesday · 13/04/2023 10:42

I understand some people literally cannot do this but many can, even if it means a detriment to their own life, for instance one less holiday, a cheaper car etc etc.

But I do not understand why those who can, don’t. People who moan about supporting kids through university, making them take (full) loans that take so long to pay back, making them move out before they’ve had chance to save, charging them rent… the list goes on. The argument always seems to be that the DD or DS needs to learn the value of money or stand on their own two feet… of course, but does that mean you, as a parent, have no responsibility when they turn 18? Are they supposed to magically have money to start out? Even renting you need a deposit, let alone the idea of saving for a mortgage. There’s this idea that ‘well if i suffered, you must too.’ It’s your child!

For context I have had help from my parents but also know they could have done more. I now have dc and would do everything possible to ensure they were financially comfortable as a young adult. And no… I’m not bringing up brats, I work hard and will expect them to, too. But I also don’t want them to launch into debt to get started in life, because I think I deserve a nice holiday or a new car or to order what I want in my weekly shop. I will always make sacrifices where needed, it won’t suddenly end at 18.

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 14/04/2023 10:48

I can’t imagine expecting my parents to have a mortgage until they are 80 to help finance me

DoNotWorryBeHappy · 14/04/2023 10:45

Ted27 · 13/04/2023 22:30

@DoNotWorryBeHappy

I am staggered that any adult would sit back and see their parent remortgaging their own home and paying a mortgage until they are 80, so they could buy a home
He could just buy a one bed for a lower cost then he wouldn't need a second bedroom for a lodger to help with costs.

It's about affordability and planning. Mortgages are a tool, on a 5 year fix with a review then to adjust, downsize, etc. Money taken out of my estate to help my son now will ease his financial situation, no need to wait for me to die - he can benefit now and that gives 5me joy. It's a compromise, I don't need to spend that money on luxury goods and holidays, but he would like a secure home. Of course this option is not for everyone. I live frugally with a modest income and my life won't be significantly impacted, although it is a substantial mortgage.
Accounting for the comparative costs of a 1 or 2 bed and the amortisation of purchase costs and taxes over 5 years, the 2 bed works well for us with a flatmate around 9 months per year. It will be a nicer flat in a nicer area, better WFH environment.
With no expectation of inheritance for me or my DH, and never any financial help from family, my life plans have evolved to wish to use my financial leverage to help my son to get started, after his several years of renting (uncertain, expensive and restrictive). My point in sharing was to highlight this as an option for those for whom it could be a possibility, and also to express my own disbelief at parents who are in receipt of significant inheritances/high incomes yet ignore the plight of their children from the deck of yet another expensive cruise ship.

ArcticSkewer · 14/04/2023 10:27

Ted27 · 13/04/2023 22:30

@DoNotWorryBeHappy

I am staggered that any adult would sit back and see their parent remortgaging their own home and paying a mortgage until they are 80, so they could buy a home
He could just buy a one bed for a lower cost then he wouldn't need a second bedroom for a lodger to help with costs.

It's financially a better option in some cases. May reduce inheritance tax for example, and allows better property investments.

I think of my family a bit like a business I suppose - we are one financial unit in some ways. Part of the business cross subsidises the other, loans can be taken out from collateral to support another part, profit against loss to pay less tax overall etc.

ssd · 14/04/2023 10:08

I remember going to a parents day before dc started uni and the lecturer saying how important it was for students to get a part time job, any job, just to show future employers they are employable and have gained skills through working.
Greggs and tesco do either 4 hours or 8 hours contracts, they don't need to do loads, just enough for their cv to show they worked.

Noodles1234 · 14/04/2023 09:36

I don’t disagree with OP, you may need a hard hat I liked that from a previous person!
Working in a shop taught me valuable social skills and etiquette, skills that would be handy for some now (not their fault, under 18 it’s VERY hard to get retail / any paid work).

I worked some afternoons every week and weekends. I also had a lot of homework, I was perpetually exhausted.

A Saturday job would have done this fine, but midweek I think was too much (my own choice to work, as I needed some money). A Saturday alone would have been the ideal balance.
Midweek I should have spent more time doing my homework / revision so I wasn’t up till midnight and too exhausted to revise to what I should have been, and possibly better grades in places. I hold no grudge, again my own choice.
I think a little does no harm, but too much can be counter productive.
I won’t be pushing my own DCs into work, if they choose this it will teach them valuable social skills and I will ensure a limit until they have finished their studies. I will pay them maybe to wash the cars etc instead or alongside.

Bayleaf25 · 13/04/2023 22:58

I agree with you op. We are certainly not well off but I recognise that young people have it much harder in terms of house prices, pensions, cost of living. And quite frankly I love them and therefore if I can help them out I actually want to.

I will also add that I’m immensely proud of the way my kids have grown up with a great work ethic and sense of their own responsibility. They don’t feel entitled to anything but if I can help I will.

proppy · 13/04/2023 22:51

Your wages will rise as your careers progress and your expenses will decrease as your responsibilities reduce.

Err have you seen what's happened to wages over the last 15 or so years?

proppy · 13/04/2023 22:46

What's so difficult these days for young people is if they don't have help they are often left behind. There is huge inequality because of wage stagnation & high house prices.

LolaSmiles · 13/04/2023 22:38

I agree with you OP

The 'I suffered and if you don't then you'll never learn the value of money' always makes me think less of the parent to be honest.
Why would any knowingly and willingly want to make their children struggle financially in early adulthood? (Assuming no back story)

Justgorgeous · 13/04/2023 22:33

My son is 20 and works full time. He pays me rent and is saving for a house deposit. I’m certainly not paying for everything.

Ted27 · 13/04/2023 22:30

@DoNotWorryBeHappy

I am staggered that any adult would sit back and see their parent remortgaging their own home and paying a mortgage until they are 80, so they could buy a home
He could just buy a one bed for a lower cost then he wouldn't need a second bedroom for a lodger to help with costs.

ssd · 13/04/2023 22:22

Quveas · 13/04/2023 21:02

Who are "we"? I'm 65. My parents were working class and had fuck all. When I was young I had fuck all too. Are "young adults" today incompetent or incapable?

So @Quveas have you got fuck all now? Probably not

RollingInTheCreek · 13/04/2023 21:29

@Beenalongwinter theyve told me. Retired GPs, pensions £60k or so each.
I don’t begrudge them but they have benefitted from an amazing pension, huge house price increase, enormous inheritance. I just like to think if I was in that position and my kids were struggling like we are despite working very hard I would help out 🤷🏼‍♀️

thatsn0tmyname · 13/04/2023 21:13

My parents always said they wanted to see me enjoy the inheritance whilst they were still alive. They didn't give me a huge amount of money but enough to get me on the property ladder when I was starting out. I will do everything I can to help my children (and not the tax man).

YellowGreenBlue · 13/04/2023 21:06

I am surprised you know how much pension your parents receive - I'm not the poster you quoted, but I know more or less how much my parents' pensions are because they were both in public sector jobs (so on a standardised salary scale) and their pensions are final salary pensions so are a specific percentage of their final salary. Not difficult to estimate.

Quveas · 13/04/2023 21:02

Nimbostratus100 · 13/04/2023 10:44

Of course young adults need support, and more these days than when we were young.

Who are "we"? I'm 65. My parents were working class and had fuck all. When I was young I had fuck all too. Are "young adults" today incompetent or incapable?

malificent7 · 13/04/2023 20:57

I think it depends on the attitude. If mine had taught me about mortgages and budgeting growing up and actually spoke to me openly about money whilst growing up, rather than hoping their ( rather strange) attitude to money would rub off on me, then maybe i'd feel less resentful now.

By rather strange, I don't mean being careful, I mean refusing us kids lunch out...not even a packed lunch.

My dad is loaded,some earned but a load of inheritance. He always lectured me about budgeting but was happy to spend hundreds on a souvenir recently that turned out to be a knock off rather than a real item.

Beenalongwinter · 13/04/2023 20:47

RollingInTheCreek · 13/04/2023 10:52

I agree. We are dropping more and more into debt with rising costs. When we had our second 4 years ago we were in a totally different financial position and now what we could easily have afforded before is crippling us. Meanwhile my parents go skiing, on numerous hot holidays, weekends away and spend like there’s no tomorrow. Their pensions are twice our annual salaries. Most people will claim we are entitled and I’d never say anything but I know for certain if my kids struggle like this and I’m more financially comfortable I will be helping them as much as I can.

I am surprised you know how much pension your parents receive.

Pensions are relatively static while expenses are continually rising. Your wages will rise as your careers progress and your expenses will decrease as your responsibilities reduce.

Newly retired pensioners expenditure is usually higher in the first 10 years of retirement, expenditure in the middle years decreases but expenses often escalate in the final years of retirement due to declining health and nursing and care costs.
Do you really begrudge your parents a few years of enjoyment in retirement while they have relatively good health?

WhenisitmyturntobePM · 13/04/2023 20:34

@ChiefWiggumsBoy don’t forget that you need enough money left at the end to you can pay carers and not rely on your children. And you should have plenty to leave as inheritance so they don’t squabble.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 13/04/2023 20:24

I will help my children as much as I am able - to a point.

As a parent, I make a lot of sacrifices for my children while they live with me, I think that maybe I should be able to take a step back once they are adults?

I mean, where does it end? I'm expected to fund my child until they are completely independent, then I'm expected to look after their kids to save THEM money and time, all the while making sure I'm saving enough money to both fund my own retirement but also have enough to ensure my kids get a good leg up? Am I supposed to extend the time I work past retirement age just so my kids don't have to? And how do I balance that between the three children I have so one of them isn't bitching about how unfair things are twenty years from now?

whathaveidonetomydc · 13/04/2023 19:02

I used to think you should help them at all costs, but one of mine makes poor choices with money (eg would upgrade phone/car when new model comes out) even if it means not having enough for necessities. There is no way I'm going to enable that behaviour.

BananaPalm · 13/04/2023 19:00

My PIL went the other way... demanding money from us because "they raised my DH". Nice to see that other people not only wouldn't take money from their kids but actually offered to help them...

RJnomore1 · 13/04/2023 18:53

I’m horrified your son would let you put yourself into debt right into seriously old age to allow him to have an extra room and live somewhere expensive. What if you are unwell and need care and support, or adaptations to your home? Will you be ok?

My mother tries to be overly generous but it causes me more worry at the thought of her being in need. I’d never accept her getting into debt for me.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 13/04/2023 18:49

The grants only stopped a few years before I went to uni and I’m not that old. Lots of them got full grants and didn’t have these massive loans.

malificent7 · 13/04/2023 18:47

I should rewrite that!