Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why parents feel they don't need to financially help their kids after a certain age because they must ‘struggle like we did’ ?

289 replies

whatistuesday · 13/04/2023 10:42

I understand some people literally cannot do this but many can, even if it means a detriment to their own life, for instance one less holiday, a cheaper car etc etc.

But I do not understand why those who can, don’t. People who moan about supporting kids through university, making them take (full) loans that take so long to pay back, making them move out before they’ve had chance to save, charging them rent… the list goes on. The argument always seems to be that the DD or DS needs to learn the value of money or stand on their own two feet… of course, but does that mean you, as a parent, have no responsibility when they turn 18? Are they supposed to magically have money to start out? Even renting you need a deposit, let alone the idea of saving for a mortgage. There’s this idea that ‘well if i suffered, you must too.’ It’s your child!

For context I have had help from my parents but also know they could have done more. I now have dc and would do everything possible to ensure they were financially comfortable as a young adult. And no… I’m not bringing up brats, I work hard and will expect them to, too. But I also don’t want them to launch into debt to get started in life, because I think I deserve a nice holiday or a new car or to order what I want in my weekly shop. I will always make sacrifices where needed, it won’t suddenly end at 18.

OP posts:
OhSmitty · 15/04/2023 10:24

I don't fully agree, DC need to be able to budget and manage their money. I'd never dream of asking my parents for money. They did pay for my wedding, I didn't expect them to and we were saving up for it.
I have friends who still go to their parents for handouts in their 40s because they were always bailed out in their young adulthood.
So whilst I'd hate to see my kids struggle, I'd want them to be financially independent and budget accordingly. We're not wealthy enough to give them £££££s without it seriously impacting us.

toomuchlaundry · 15/04/2023 10:00

@TheHoover I wonder if the people who were helped substantially by their parents, will then help their parents if their parents are then left without enough finances to cover them in their final years

TheHoover · 15/04/2023 07:11

I hate that everyone just wants to put young people down on the basis that apparently life was so much harder in the past.

Who has said this? Most people are saying it’s even harder now.. Which is the moot point - I personally think it’s no different for those in their twenties and thirties but due to house prices and student debt plus parents living longer (later inheritances) todays young people will reach the affluence levels of their parents much later in life. The question is whether or not our twenty and thirty somethings should go without, as their parents did, or whether they should be supported to have a better lifestyle by said affluent parents.

I do worry though for some of the parents who say they won’t see their children go without. if you are fully secure till the age of 100 then go ahead but increased life expectancy and care bills are new added costs for the parent’s generation which does not always seem to be taken into account when the younger generation bleat on about how much easier it was without student debt and affordable property.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 14/04/2023 22:07

As long as they are working hard I will support them as much as possible. They have had a miserable time throughout Covid and lockdowns but coped with it all so well. I hate that everyone just wants to put young people down on the basis that apparently life was so much harder in the past. I'm not entirely sure that argument applies anymore.

DoNotWorryBeHappy · 14/04/2023 15:16

Albiboba · 13/04/2023 11:54

But I also don’t want them to launch into debt to get started in life, because I think I deserve a nice holiday or a new car or to order what I want in my weekly shop. I will always make sacrifices where needed, it won’t suddenly end at 18.

I’ve never heard anyone say their kids should suffer as they did as young adults but I find your post really dramatic. So someone is never allowed a holiday or to buy what they want on their food shop because that could go to their adult children?

There is a line between helping your children because you can and also teaching your children to stand on their own feet financially.

I think her point was that if she had a spare £30,000 she would happily use it to help a hardworking child get a decent deposit together rather than buy herself a brand new car, when a ten year old car would do. Not necessarily expecting to pay for a showy wedding or an adventure holiday for workshy, adult kids who want their laundry doing at 36 and their toast cut into soldiers and will never attempt to save money but wish to follow the influencers' lifestyles, but for a home. The workshy adult children might well need support in a different way.

mamabear715 · 14/04/2023 14:30

My Dad was very generous. I managed on my own but he'd think nothing of peeling off banknotes to buy me a washing machine, for example. My mum (widowed fairly young) very much less so. Travelled around the world.. :-0

My kids laugh that my mum couldn't spend money fast enough, (& was in a care home to the tune of about 80K before she died -obvs not her fault) & I rarely spend on myself & try & accumulate savings I can leave to my kids! Mum offered me about £300 when I was 5 months in arrears with the mortgage through no fault of my own. Told her not to bother.

Thesharkradar · 14/04/2023 13:54

Aphrathestorm · 14/04/2023 13:21

I really resented the lack of financial support I got from my parents as an adult. It stopped me doing postgrad and really hurt career chances I had. I felt like my work at school and uni was for nothing.

I've pledged not to do the same fir my DCs.

I'll support them forever. Not to be cocklodgers in the house but with driving lessons, uni, and house deposits.

I really don't think cocklodger is the term you want here, a cocklodger is a man who thinks that sexual favours will suffice in lieu of rent 😬
https://slangdefine.org/c/cocklodger-9ff1.html

Slang Define: What is Cocklodger? - meaning and definition

Cocklodger - 1. A male who lives with his girlfriend without paying rent. Rent and bills are paid by the girlfriend, the cocklodger relies on the fact that the couple are s

https://slangdefine.org/c/cocklodger-9ff1.html

Aphrathestorm · 14/04/2023 13:21

I really resented the lack of financial support I got from my parents as an adult. It stopped me doing postgrad and really hurt career chances I had. I felt like my work at school and uni was for nothing.

I've pledged not to do the same fir my DCs.

I'll support them forever. Not to be cocklodgers in the house but with driving lessons, uni, and house deposits.

DoNotWorryBeHappy · 14/04/2023 12:57

RJnomore1 · 13/04/2023 18:53

I’m horrified your son would let you put yourself into debt right into seriously old age to allow him to have an extra room and live somewhere expensive. What if you are unwell and need care and support, or adaptations to your home? Will you be ok?

My mother tries to be overly generous but it causes me more worry at the thought of her being in need. I’d never accept her getting into debt for me.

Please see my other replies regarding affordability and using a mortgage as a planning tool!

DoNotWorryBeHappy · 14/04/2023 12:51

Wc100423 · 13/04/2023 16:21

I had no help at all but your statement that YOU DID but still feel your parents could have done more is entitled. I will help my children and already have money put aside for them however, I hope they do not turn out like you always wanting and feeling like I could do more more more!

She doesn't sound entitled... In her brief outline, she represents many of us who very much appreciate the bits and bobs of parents' help received - perhaps driving lessons, a puppy, a school ski trip, a library card... But as parents now it is natural to reflect on our own parents' strengths and weaknesses. And we can see clearly. Although we're rarely as hard on our parents as we are on ourselves!

ArcticSkewer · 14/04/2023 12:50

taxguru · 14/04/2023 11:16

@ArcticSkewer

You sound like you've done a great job, and pretty much all the things the op talks about that parents might do to support their kids. The reward is seeing them flourish. Fantastic! I bet once you have grandkids you start it all over again, if you can afford it, with trust fund contributions etc.

Well, we've tried our best as neither of us were helped and we didn't reach our full potential and had to work hard to get where we are the hard way. We both left school with no qualifications (in my case because of severe bullying, in OH's case because parents were in the military and constantly moved around, so no steady education in one school, or even in one country!). So we both had to do I and A levels by self study/evening classes alongside full time low paid work. That's why we were massively "over-invested" in our son's education so that he could flourish without limitations/restrictions.

As for grandkids, sadly unlikely as we both suffer life limiting health conditions, which is why we want to see our son set up for adult life whilst we can see it! We'll be consulting a solicitor about our wills this Summer to put trusts in place for any potential grandchildren, whether we live long enough to see them or not! Highly unlikely our son will need all of our inheritance once he's qualified and established in his new job as he'll be a very high earner in his own right.

@taxguru I'm sorry to hear you both have life limiting conditions. I imagine it does indeed focus the mind on ensuring your son is set up for adult life while you can see it. Wishing you well in seeing him thrive as a result of your efforts.

ArcticSkewer · 14/04/2023 12:48

I like your thinking @DoNotWorryBeHappy .

And of course, as op herself says, we are not talking here about people living in penury to support their adult children.

As you say .... planned debt is a tool

DoNotWorryBeHappy · 14/04/2023 12:29

toomuchlaundry · 14/04/2023 11:30

@ArcticSkewer because I wouldn't want an 80 year old having to pay a mortgage, when they could be spending the money on themselves. I want parents to be able to enjoy retirement not having to limit what they can do, so I could have a nicer flat

I won't need to pay it when I'm 80 unless it is financially advantageous to me... To get a guarantee of being able to "rent" this money longer term is definitely in my interests at the moment, but the 5 year fix gives me complete flexibility and control (money removed from estate simplifies matters on death, son becomes home owner years earlier, income from lodger helps with bills and contributes to my mortgage payments, 5 years to get round to downsizing and new buyers enjoying my underused family home etc). Obviously a five year fix gives me the option to downsize, pay it all off and live happily ever after. I own 2 additional properties that I have bought and rent out - it would be easier to sell one and release that capital, however my tenants pay below market rent and would never find anything like their current homes that they could afford. Would I evict the single dad on benefits or the lady on benefits living with anxiety and depression? As I said previously, it's all about compromise and I have to make certain choices - in my case I'm happy with my choice, which is financially well planned and affordable. And taking others into consideration. This mortgage is a short term tool with option of longer term if I want it, no doom or drudgery. If it doesn't suit you, please don't consider it. My son shares our money-saving values and appreciates that this is finding a way to give him much of his inheritance 20 years early and will make a huge difference to his home owning plans. Planned debt is a tool, like taking a student loan instead of spending your savings on university - though I appreciate it might not be for everyone. No one (?) wants a relative to stack shelves until they are 80 to subsidise them, but sensible refinancing options are available!
Reading so many stories on MN of exploitation, manipulation, abuse, CFery and unhappiness, I thought my story was more in the realm of "ooh, that's worth thinking about..."
In my case, I wouldn't like a cruise anyway...

MrsKeats · 14/04/2023 12:23

I agree totally op. That attitude is so bizarre to me. Surely you want your kids to have a better life than you if possible?
My 24 year old out earns me already thanks to a great degree and her own hard work. We paid her rent through uni and I will retire later as a result. But to me that's worth it. My older one doing very well too.
Do I think they should have struggled more? No. My job is to help them be successful adults. I get the feeling that quite a lot of parents are jealous of their children.

toomuchlaundry · 14/04/2023 11:48

Surely your level of income also impacts whether mortgage payments are stressful or not

ArcticSkewer · 14/04/2023 11:45

toomuchlaundry · 14/04/2023 11:30

@ArcticSkewer because I wouldn't want an 80 year old having to pay a mortgage, when they could be spending the money on themselves. I want parents to be able to enjoy retirement not having to limit what they can do, so I could have a nicer flat

In the cases being discussed here though, it's just a sensible redistribution of assets. What difference does it make if you or they are paying a mortgage if they can afford it and it's a more sensible financial decision?

Mortgages aren't stressful for people with large assets - they are, or can be, sensible investment decisions

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/04/2023 11:42

ArcticSkewer · 14/04/2023 10:57

Why not? What difference does it make if it's all family money anyway.

If you want to make poor financial decisions while your parents are offering a way to save family money, go ahead.

If I thought I actually could remortgage in my 80s (unlikely to be a good deal I'd have thought) I'd do it rather than see my estate go on carehome fees or inheritance tax.

As it is, I plan on giving it all away by 70 and paying the kids rent instead, possibly via a trust.

You can't take it with you. Why die at 80 and leave a big tax bill?

I assume you are taking advice on your plans as it’s increasingly complex.
There are rules around deprivation of capital if you then need support for care home fees.

Similarly some trusts have upfront inheritance tax charge and the 10 yearly charge too.
It’s something we will probably consider but I will be speaking to an advisor if we do.

malificent7 · 14/04/2023 11:33

too*

malificent7 · 14/04/2023 11:32

It's the spirit with which it's done though isn't it.

Not giving your handouts as you want them to stand on their own two feet...great. I really admire the Beckhams making their kids get jobs at teens. My dd has a job too at 14.

Actually sneering at your kids because you had to struggle to( like my family)= unpleasant.

toomuchlaundry · 14/04/2023 11:30

@ArcticSkewer because I wouldn't want an 80 year old having to pay a mortgage, when they could be spending the money on themselves. I want parents to be able to enjoy retirement not having to limit what they can do, so I could have a nicer flat

taxguru · 14/04/2023 11:16

@ArcticSkewer

You sound like you've done a great job, and pretty much all the things the op talks about that parents might do to support their kids. The reward is seeing them flourish. Fantastic! I bet once you have grandkids you start it all over again, if you can afford it, with trust fund contributions etc.

Well, we've tried our best as neither of us were helped and we didn't reach our full potential and had to work hard to get where we are the hard way. We both left school with no qualifications (in my case because of severe bullying, in OH's case because parents were in the military and constantly moved around, so no steady education in one school, or even in one country!). So we both had to do I and A levels by self study/evening classes alongside full time low paid work. That's why we were massively "over-invested" in our son's education so that he could flourish without limitations/restrictions.

As for grandkids, sadly unlikely as we both suffer life limiting health conditions, which is why we want to see our son set up for adult life whilst we can see it! We'll be consulting a solicitor about our wills this Summer to put trusts in place for any potential grandchildren, whether we live long enough to see them or not! Highly unlikely our son will need all of our inheritance once he's qualified and established in his new job as he'll be a very high earner in his own right.

ArcticSkewer · 14/04/2023 11:05

taxguru · 14/04/2023 11:00

We have the "teach a man to fish, not give a man a fish" philosophy. We've always done whatever it takes to put our son in the best possible position to be a successful and competent adult.

That's started from the earliest of ages when we taught him to read, write and basic numbers before he started school so he'd be "ready to learn" when he got there. We've supported him throughout school, not by doing his homework for him nor packing his rucksack, but by ensuring he had all the resources he needed, somewhere to study, access to study books and internet etc. We've always shown an interest in his education, asking him what topics he was studying, looking in his exercise books to see the standard of his work, always attending parent's evenings and other school events. We helped him set up revision timetables and bought him revision materials for his GCSEs and A Levels. Helped him choose a Uni course and Uni, went with him to several Uni open days, discussed future career paths, etc., all paid for by us of course. During Uni, we've paid half his rent and other costs so he didn't have to take out full student loans (interest rate is crippling on them).

We wanted him to be independent, so paid for his driving lessons from his 17th birthday and also took him out practising in our car, enabling him to pass within 3 months of starting, put him on our insurance policies so he could build up his own no-claims discount, encouraged him to drive our cars regularly when he's home from Uni to keep up experience etc ready for when he starts a job and gets his own car.

Over the past few months, we've supported him through his job application processes, including taking him to interviews hundreds of miles away (which we paid for, both fuel and hotels). He's secured a good job (excellent prospects but low-average starting wage) in a different city where he'll need a car and need to rent a flat - we'll be paying his flat deposit and buying him a used car to get him started there, plus setting him up with whatever furniture he needs, a desk/computer for further study/exams, etc., depending on rental costs, we may have to support him maybe 50-50 on his rent for the first year or so.

But that's it basically. It's over to him once he starts. We're not paying towards holidays or weddings or hobbies or food, fuel, clothes, etc. We think our job as parents is over - we've got him to the stage where he has excellent qualifications a job with excellent prospects, help him start out with a flat and car. We've "taught him to fish" as it were and now it's up to him. Obviously, we'll "help" if he needs help in the future for whatever unforeseen reason, but it will be for essentials, not "lifestyle". We've put him into a position where he can fly as an adult and now it's down to him.

You sound like you've done a great job, and pretty much all the things the op talks about that parents might do to support their kids. The reward is seeing them flourish. Fantastic!

I bet once you have grandkids you start it all over again, if you can afford it, with trust fund contributions etc.

taxguru · 14/04/2023 11:00

We have the "teach a man to fish, not give a man a fish" philosophy. We've always done whatever it takes to put our son in the best possible position to be a successful and competent adult.

That's started from the earliest of ages when we taught him to read, write and basic numbers before he started school so he'd be "ready to learn" when he got there. We've supported him throughout school, not by doing his homework for him nor packing his rucksack, but by ensuring he had all the resources he needed, somewhere to study, access to study books and internet etc. We've always shown an interest in his education, asking him what topics he was studying, looking in his exercise books to see the standard of his work, always attending parent's evenings and other school events. We helped him set up revision timetables and bought him revision materials for his GCSEs and A Levels. Helped him choose a Uni course and Uni, went with him to several Uni open days, discussed future career paths, etc., all paid for by us of course. During Uni, we've paid half his rent and other costs so he didn't have to take out full student loans (interest rate is crippling on them).

We wanted him to be independent, so paid for his driving lessons from his 17th birthday and also took him out practising in our car, enabling him to pass within 3 months of starting, put him on our insurance policies so he could build up his own no-claims discount, encouraged him to drive our cars regularly when he's home from Uni to keep up experience etc ready for when he starts a job and gets his own car.

Over the past few months, we've supported him through his job application processes, including taking him to interviews hundreds of miles away (which we paid for, both fuel and hotels). He's secured a good job (excellent prospects but low-average starting wage) in a different city where he'll need a car and need to rent a flat - we'll be paying his flat deposit and buying him a used car to get him started there, plus setting him up with whatever furniture he needs, a desk/computer for further study/exams, etc., depending on rental costs, we may have to support him maybe 50-50 on his rent for the first year or so.

But that's it basically. It's over to him once he starts. We're not paying towards holidays or weddings or hobbies or food, fuel, clothes, etc. We think our job as parents is over - we've got him to the stage where he has excellent qualifications a job with excellent prospects, help him start out with a flat and car. We've "taught him to fish" as it were and now it's up to him. Obviously, we'll "help" if he needs help in the future for whatever unforeseen reason, but it will be for essentials, not "lifestyle". We've put him into a position where he can fly as an adult and now it's down to him.

Dragonfly909 · 14/04/2023 10:59

I agree, I feel like most of my 20s was wasted because I had too little money to do anything. I really struggled to find a job that paid enough to live on and I was renting in a different part of the country so I think partly my parents didn't realise how difficult it was. But I would never let my children struggle like that and waste so many years of their lives just trying to get by.

ArcticSkewer · 14/04/2023 10:57

toomuchlaundry · 14/04/2023 10:48

I can’t imagine expecting my parents to have a mortgage until they are 80 to help finance me

Why not? What difference does it make if it's all family money anyway.

If you want to make poor financial decisions while your parents are offering a way to save family money, go ahead.

If I thought I actually could remortgage in my 80s (unlikely to be a good deal I'd have thought) I'd do it rather than see my estate go on carehome fees or inheritance tax.

As it is, I plan on giving it all away by 70 and paying the kids rent instead, possibly via a trust.

You can't take it with you. Why die at 80 and leave a big tax bill?

Swipe left for the next trending thread