Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why parents feel they don't need to financially help their kids after a certain age because they must ‘struggle like we did’ ?

289 replies

whatistuesday · 13/04/2023 10:42

I understand some people literally cannot do this but many can, even if it means a detriment to their own life, for instance one less holiday, a cheaper car etc etc.

But I do not understand why those who can, don’t. People who moan about supporting kids through university, making them take (full) loans that take so long to pay back, making them move out before they’ve had chance to save, charging them rent… the list goes on. The argument always seems to be that the DD or DS needs to learn the value of money or stand on their own two feet… of course, but does that mean you, as a parent, have no responsibility when they turn 18? Are they supposed to magically have money to start out? Even renting you need a deposit, let alone the idea of saving for a mortgage. There’s this idea that ‘well if i suffered, you must too.’ It’s your child!

For context I have had help from my parents but also know they could have done more. I now have dc and would do everything possible to ensure they were financially comfortable as a young adult. And no… I’m not bringing up brats, I work hard and will expect them to, too. But I also don’t want them to launch into debt to get started in life, because I think I deserve a nice holiday or a new car or to order what I want in my weekly shop. I will always make sacrifices where needed, it won’t suddenly end at 18.

OP posts:
taxguru · 12/06/2023 11:04

Today's youngsters need money when they're young. Them getting an inheritance when they're 40 or 50 is too late to make much difference. That's what happened to me, when my mother died when I was mid 40's I'd already sorted out my life by then, settled in a good career, family, "forever home". Whilst an inheritance was nice, it's just sat in a bank account earning interest for the last 15 years! Hasn't changed my live at all.

That's where the money is coming from for my son - we're drawing down from that account to help pay his university accommodation and living costs, we'll be paying his first years' rent from it for his first job, buying him a car if he needs one for work, helping him furnish his first flat. He knows all this, he knows we've ring-fenced my inheritance from his grandmother for him, but just doesn't know how much as we don't want him getting silly ideas and going mad, or putting pressure on us to fund things for him. He's not "demanding" or "needy" at all, never asks us for anything, but we always talk things through, plan things out, and offer to finance things or go halves with him for major costs.

Morestrangerthings · 12/06/2023 10:57

I must live in a bubble. I don’t know one person that has kicked their kids out at 18. I’m sure it happens. But surely not the norm?

taxguru · 12/06/2023 10:57

TheSnootiestFox · 12/06/2023 10:49

It doesn't make any sense to saddle your kids with a shed load of debt if you're in a position to save then from it. I paid my final installment for my degree the week before I turned 36. Paying that off (and my payments were over £120 per month 15 years ago!) impacted me affording other things and I never have caught up with my parentally supported peers financially. Why wouldn't help your children?!

Yes I agree. We've told our son, very clearly, that upon our demise (very likely as we both have life limiting health conditions) to use his inheritance to firstly pay off his student loan, then pay off any other debts/loans (inc mortgage), and then to sit back and take stock of what's left which should still be a decent amount.

Pointless to continue racking up interest on the student loans, especially as he's likely to be earning well above average within a few years, so will be liable to student loan repayments from his first payslip. I did a spreadsheet with him showing how the interest racks up on his student loan, and we flexed it at various income levels throughout the next 30 years, and it brilliantly illustrated how much interest he'd end up paying. He is now firmly agreeing with us that he needs to pay it off as soon as he can!!

Proudofitbabe · 12/06/2023 10:54

Your kids are always your kids. My parents had a leg-up, and were then very generous with us, and I'll do what's possible for my children to set them on their way. Get the first car, help them onto the property ladder etc. I consider that my duty, if I can.

I absolutely wouldn't then expect to support their lifestyle as adults, they'll need to crack on. But i like to hope I'll continue to be a generous parent, and I'd want my kids to always feel able to come to me for money in an emergency.

The way I see it is, as long as they work hard and are good people they'll deserve any help. (The wasters/lazy/spoilt are a different question!)

taxguru · 12/06/2023 10:52

I think my eagerness to help DS is also borne out of a very "poor" upbringing, where it was made clear from an early age that I wouldn't be going to Uni because my parents "couldn't" afford to fund it, we never had holidays, parents drove around in old rust bucket cars that constantly broke down - my "memories" of the occasional days out we had was usually of waiting for the recovery truck to tow us home. When I got my first job, I was expected to give half of the wages to my parents for "rent", but also to buy my own clothes, etc., and to buy my own study books/resources out of the other half of my very small wage (less than a pound per hour in the 80s!). If I used my parents car, say to go to college evening classes, I had to put a few quid of petrol in it!

My teenage years and early 20's were dictated by lack of money, and I missed out on a lot. It wasn't until my mid to late 20's that I qualified and started earning good money that I started to actually "live a life", which meant being late to have relationships, late to marry, late to buy a house, late to have a child, etc.

I didn't want my son to struggle like that as it makes things so much harder, and in my case, it meant we only had one child as we were so late that time ran out for a second.

The ironic (and very annoying) thing about all that penny pinching, etc., is that my parents DID have money after all, but just chose not to spend it. When they died and I went through their paperwork, it was clear that they had healthy savings right back to the 70s and 80s, but wouldn't even spend it on themselves, let alone their children! I just find it unfathomable they they're prefer to drive old unreliable rust buckets of cars that kept breaking down rather than buying something more reliable. And that was just one example of not spending. But the killer was my mother whingeing that we'd only given her one grandchild - well if she'd not been so tight and restrictive, I'd have probably got my career sorted a few years earlier which would have led to marriage sooner and child(ren) sooner before time ran out!

That's part of why I've been so keen to finance my son on what I consider to be "the right lines" as regards his education and career. The sooner he has his feet under the table with a decent employer in a job with prospects, the sooner he can "live his own life" and pay for it himself!

TheSnootiestFox · 12/06/2023 10:49

Neededanewuserhandle · 13/04/2023 11:03

It doesn't make any sense not to take the full student loan if it's available.

It doesn't make any sense to saddle your kids with a shed load of debt if you're in a position to save then from it. I paid my final installment for my degree the week before I turned 36. Paying that off (and my payments were over £120 per month 15 years ago!) impacted me affording other things and I never have caught up with my parentally supported peers financially. Why wouldn't help your children?!

HidingInAForest · 12/06/2023 10:18

My father was so miserly when I was growing up I didn't have enough food, relied on friends for hand me down clothes, school uniform came from new2you box at school as school felt sorry for me.

Turned out he was investing it all in stocks and shares so I had a very difficult teen period thinking he was broke. I'm much older now but struggled through life with various difficulties.

His pension and rental income is more than our family income, plus his new wife is quite well off. They holiday a couple of times a month, multiple ski trips, long haul, weekends away, posh meals out etc.

We struggle and although old enough not to expect anything would love it if he was more generous tk the kids than 15£ for birthday etc. It would make out quality of life so much better if they occasionally contributes to music lessons or took the kids out for the day or gave them a bit of pocket money. Not in a subsidising our lifestyle way but just where the disparity between our lifestyle/my childhood and their income is hard to manage sometimes. And it wouldn't cost them much to occasionally be genour to the grandkids.

dentydown · 12/06/2023 10:17

YANBU. I was expected to pay the full “commercial” rent for my room once I worked. i found out I was paying the rent for the whole flat. I was also not allowed to move out because “it would ruin them”

when family tried to discuss it I wasn’t to talk about finances and insist I was happy with the arrangement.

from the age of 16, I was expected to pay for my own clothes out of a Saturday morning job. Apparently the child benefit 16+ “was her reward for raising me”.

At 18 I had to pay for my food, which was regularly used.

Singlespies · 12/06/2023 10:12

BananaBum · 12/06/2023 07:58

I very much believe in “our kids doesn’t owe us anything” in that they didn’t ask to be born and it is our responsibility to do what we can for them.

my parents paid my rent while I was at university while I had a student loan & part time job to live on. I will be eternally grateful for this as it took a huge pressure off. I don’t think you have to do EVERYTHING for them but if you do show them the support you can most people grow up to be kind and grateful if you bring them up well.

and while my parents are wonderful, they are not perfect. Materially there was little I had to want for but they were not always great at handling things emotionally… I think that this counts for just as much and as long as your children feel you’ve “got their back” that will count for everything.

I think that feeling your parents "have your back" is the key. And possibly, we focus on lack of financial support of something else not being provided if we don't actually feel they have our backs.

taxguru · 12/06/2023 09:58

onefinemess · 12/06/2023 09:18

Where does a small amount of assistance end?

"Well you paid for Uni, all I'm asking for is a few thousand to buy a car"

"Well you paid for Uni and my car, all I'm asking for is 50k for a deposit on a house"

"Well you paid for my deposit, can't you just pay a few months mortgage for us so we can go on holiday"

It's just like giving to a beggar, it doesn't help them in the long term, just enables them to continue doing what they have become accustomed to doing.

That's the difference between a hand up and a hand out.

Or put another way, give a man a fish and he'll eat for a day, teach him to fish and he'll eat for his lifetime!

The contributions we've made for our son have enabled him to put himself in a better position to become a functioning adult with ability to get a decent job and earn a decent living.

We've contributed towards his education, his University degree, travel to interviews hundreds of miles away, paid for him to learn to drive and pass his test and let him borrow one of our cars. He's starting a graduate job with a blue chip employer this Summer, not only can he not afford to rent a flat in a very expensive city on his graduate salary, he can't even rent a property because he has no references, etc., so we have to step in, rent a property for him for the first year. Once he's been there a few months, if all goes well, he'll get the first of many pay rises, be able to prove employment history to rent his own flat next year, etc. What we've never, and won't ever pay for are discretionary costs, such as he'll have to buy his own car, pay for his own holidays, pay for his own wedding, we don't pay for hobbies, eating out etc etc etc. The money we've paid was all aimed at getting him in a position to live his own life and earn his own money - we've had many discussions about this over the years, starting as far back as when he was leaving primary school and starting secondary, so none of it is a surprise to him! And he is more than aware that his first year earning his own money in the graduate job is his "make or break" year - he sinks or swims on his own now.

Mischance · 12/06/2023 09:55

I have 3 DDs and 7 GC - that's 10 people - which one should I help?

I supported the girls through university and they left with inly small loans to pay back. I have passed on cars, have paid for wedding dresses, and a small donation to a house deposit when it was needed, and paid for a big family holiday. I also provided free child care when it was needed so that DDs could work.

I do have a bit of money behind me and could help them more, but they feel that if I spend my savings on them I would have no money to pay for any care I might need and could finish up in crap care, which they do not want to happen. We know all about this as we had to struggle to pay for my late OH's nursing home fees.

Things are never quite as simple as they look - a chunk of my savings has gone on 3 different private surgeries without which my life would be very difficult and I would have had to wait months/years to get them done on the NHS. As it is my quality of life has increased and I am able to help with child care. My DDs are happy about that - about me being well and also the child care.

I do not take the view that I "had it easy" and therefore want them to suffer too! I did have it easier I know - I left university with no debts after degree and post-grad - I had maintenance grants and all fees were paid. It was a different world then when only 2% of the population went to university, so government support was affordable.

Also one of the DDs is far far richer than the others - how should I deal with that when considering any help I might give?

onefinemess · 12/06/2023 09:18

LolaSmiles · 12/06/2023 08:57

It's called being an adult.

If your kids need your help financially when they are adults, then either you failed to raise them or they failed at managing their own life.

Helping grown adults by giving them money so they can get something they can't afford on their own, is just enabling their helplessness

How is it enabling helplessness to be kind and support your children?

One of my parents has the same attitude as you and now I'm a parent myself I just don't understand it. It seems to come from a "if I struggled you should too" mentality, which I don't get.
Why would I not want to help my DC get established in adulthood?

Why on earth would I want to see them struggle needlessly when a small amount of assistance that I can provide would make it easier for them?

DH's family has the mindset that family helps family and it's much healthier in my opinion.

Where does a small amount of assistance end?

"Well you paid for Uni, all I'm asking for is a few thousand to buy a car"

"Well you paid for Uni and my car, all I'm asking for is 50k for a deposit on a house"

"Well you paid for my deposit, can't you just pay a few months mortgage for us so we can go on holiday"

It's just like giving to a beggar, it doesn't help them in the long term, just enables them to continue doing what they have become accustomed to doing.

LolaSmiles · 12/06/2023 08:57

It's called being an adult.

If your kids need your help financially when they are adults, then either you failed to raise them or they failed at managing their own life.

Helping grown adults by giving them money so they can get something they can't afford on their own, is just enabling their helplessness

How is it enabling helplessness to be kind and support your children?

One of my parents has the same attitude as you and now I'm a parent myself I just don't understand it. It seems to come from a "if I struggled you should too" mentality, which I don't get.
Why would I not want to help my DC get established in adulthood?

Why on earth would I want to see them struggle needlessly when a small amount of assistance that I can provide would make it easier for them?

DH's family has the mindset that family helps family and it's much healthier in my opinion.

onefinemess · 12/06/2023 08:37

It's called being an adult.

If your kids need your help financially when they are adults, then either you failed to raise them or they failed at managing their own life.

Helping grown adults by giving them money so they can get something they can't afford on their own, is just enabling their helplessness.

BananaBum · 12/06/2023 07:58

I very much believe in “our kids doesn’t owe us anything” in that they didn’t ask to be born and it is our responsibility to do what we can for them.

my parents paid my rent while I was at university while I had a student loan & part time job to live on. I will be eternally grateful for this as it took a huge pressure off. I don’t think you have to do EVERYTHING for them but if you do show them the support you can most people grow up to be kind and grateful if you bring them up well.

and while my parents are wonderful, they are not perfect. Materially there was little I had to want for but they were not always great at handling things emotionally… I think that this counts for just as much and as long as your children feel you’ve “got their back” that will count for everything.

Kazzyhoward · 12/06/2023 07:41

TodayInahurry · 12/06/2023 06:45

Surely most young people would be better off doing a modern apprenticeship, and getting paid, rather than borrowing to study?

In theory, yes, but thanks to Blair, we now have a skewed education/employment situation where there are ridiculously few decent apprenticeship schemes and ever-expanding universities.

A lot of school leavers have no choice but to go to Uni as that's where they can get a place, whereas employers don't and can't offer ever increasing numbers of training places. In some regions, there are remarkably few larger employers, so virtually no decent apprenticeships.

Because there are so many "graduates" these days, employers use a degree to weed out the number of job applicants, even where the job doesn't need a degree - it's a good way of reducing the number of applicants rather than them having to sift through hundreds or even thousands! At least, recently, we've seen a new surge in apprenticeship schemes, due mostly to the new apprenticeship levy on bigger employers, so the sands are shifting at last.

Having said all that, though, there are still plenty of jobs that really do "Need" workers with degrees, especially in scientific, technology, and Maths where academic knowledge/interest/research continues to be essential.

I do think most people now realise that Blair's aim of 50% of school leavers going to Uni has been a bad mistake, although lots of people knew it at the time but were ignored. It's also screwed up local housing markets in Uni towns due to the doubling/trebling/quadrupling of students, it's put massive strain on local housing, pushing out low earners and families, increasing rents, family homes being converted into student multi-occupancy, etc - with the money supply from student loans financing the demand led rent/house price increases. It's a shame Blair didn't think through his plan and realise that students at Uni need somewhere to live!

None of it is the student's fault, but they get the blame and they're the ones leaving Uni with a potentially/sometimes worthless piece of paper and £50k in debt. The whole Uni expansion policy has been a shambles and has done so much harm in so many ways. But none of it is the student's fault.

MushMonster · 12/06/2023 06:47

I do recognise OP that some people go well OTT and kind of abandon their children when they are adults.
But the examples you give on your first post (I confess I did not read the rest) do not sound unreasonable from their part.
So, they have worked hard, raised children, supported them till they are adults and now want to have some holidays before getting too old, shopping without the need of budgeting each penny or want to have a comfortable reliable car. I think that is more than fair enough.
If you had said that they had millions in the bank, or have mahoosive pensions and still did not pay for their children's uni or help them with a deposit and the children are living on unsuitable accomodation, or cannot afford toys and clothes for their children or to keep the heating on at home, or buy ice cream as a treat, then yeah, the parents would be unreasonable.

TodayInahurry · 12/06/2023 06:45

Surely most young people would be better off doing a modern apprenticeship, and getting paid, rather than borrowing to study?

Amore2023 · 12/06/2023 06:13

As long as our DC are trying to support themselves eg by studying or working, we will support them as much as we can. I am hoping this won’t be needed beyond 25 as I think it’s better for them to feel independent but we they will always be my children. I can’t understand the mentality of ‘we suffered so they should too’. Saying that, it is really important they have a work ethic and aren’t lazy but life is complicated and renting/buying a house so expensive in many areas, they will possibly need our help. I just hope we are able to give it then!

Singlespies · 12/06/2023 06:01

There is a balance when it comes to helping your children. That may include money but also include how to help them learn how to make money.

My parents have been spectacularly ungenerous for wealthy retirees. Despite living in the same town they would do one days childcare in the whole summer holiday... For some reason they always booked their holidays during school holidays.

It is who they are. But, the other day I realised that I was the only person I know who had not received any financial help from parents. My mother does talk about how little she had in the 1950s, despite then enjoying free University and retirement at 60.

The positives are that, because I have always known there would be no help, I have always been very considered and hardworking and have just realised that I will be able to retire at 60.

The downside is that I feel sad about their inability to help when they could have done.

taxguru · 15/04/2023 18:38

toomuchlaundry · 15/04/2023 13:50

@taxguru why will you be financing so much if he is going to be earning more than you?

To get him into that position.

Cosyblankets · 15/04/2023 17:05

I think the word struggle means different things to different people.
To meet it means difficulty putting food on the table or paying for the roof over your head.
To others it means difficulty finding money for car payments / mobile phone contract renewals and holidays etc. Yes we need cars and phones etc these days but we don't need a lease car every few years and we can go sim only on the phone contract to avoid going to parents to ask for help.

toomuchlaundry · 15/04/2023 13:50

@taxguru why will you be financing so much if he is going to be earning more than you?

taxguru · 15/04/2023 13:25

@OhSmitty

DC need to be able to budget and manage their money.

They can still do that with parental help. We have never given DS any money directly, we've always bought things for him and will continue to do so until he is established in his career. That way, we are in control and he can't squander it. Even though we have 100% confidence in him, we'd never give him a lump sum.

To my mind "managing his money" means staying within his bank account balance and no randomly wasting money. He has no problem doing that. The only money we think he "wastes" is on a couple of football shirts and a couple of xbox games each year and maybe a takeaway once a week with his flat mates! They're his hobbies and pretty cheap really. When he goes food or clothes shopping, he's notoriously tight and constantly buys reduced items.

We do the Philip Jones method of giving matching whatever he spends, so when he buys a car this Summer, we'll pay half, he will pay the other half, same with his flat, we'll pay half his deposit and half the costs of furnishings etc. During Uni, we've paid half his rent and living costs (other half from student loan). We'll also contribute to his deposit when he buys a house.

But there's no way we'll be paying anything towards holidays, weddings, or living costs once he's working. We'll help set him up for the essentials but won't finance any discretionary spending once he's working as he's got a very good job with excellent prospects so won't need help once he's moved and settled in (he'll be earning more than us!).

LBFseBrom · 15/04/2023 10:52

toomuchlaundry · 15/04/2023 10:00

@TheHoover I wonder if the people who were helped substantially by their parents, will then help their parents if their parents are then left without enough finances to cover them in their final years

I think so, depending on circumstances. I was happy to look after my mother in law and helped to look after other elderly relatives when they were in need. My mum, who was always generous, died quickly; she was taken to hospital on the Thursday and died of burst aneurysm on the Saturday morning so I didn't have to look after her but I (and husband), always looked out for her while she was alive and did any jobs she needed.

My only child who, in forties, always says I need have no worries and will be taken care of. However I aim not to need that :).