Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why parents feel they don't need to financially help their kids after a certain age because they must ‘struggle like we did’ ?

289 replies

whatistuesday · 13/04/2023 10:42

I understand some people literally cannot do this but many can, even if it means a detriment to their own life, for instance one less holiday, a cheaper car etc etc.

But I do not understand why those who can, don’t. People who moan about supporting kids through university, making them take (full) loans that take so long to pay back, making them move out before they’ve had chance to save, charging them rent… the list goes on. The argument always seems to be that the DD or DS needs to learn the value of money or stand on their own two feet… of course, but does that mean you, as a parent, have no responsibility when they turn 18? Are they supposed to magically have money to start out? Even renting you need a deposit, let alone the idea of saving for a mortgage. There’s this idea that ‘well if i suffered, you must too.’ It’s your child!

For context I have had help from my parents but also know they could have done more. I now have dc and would do everything possible to ensure they were financially comfortable as a young adult. And no… I’m not bringing up brats, I work hard and will expect them to, too. But I also don’t want them to launch into debt to get started in life, because I think I deserve a nice holiday or a new car or to order what I want in my weekly shop. I will always make sacrifices where needed, it won’t suddenly end at 18.

OP posts:
honeylulu · 13/04/2023 12:36

I agree with you OP to some extent. My parents for example take the "No one helped us, we had to work and save up" attitude but completely ignore that they benefited hugely from low house prices (their four bedroom detached seaside home was bought for just £14k) and "free" degrees. I don't want to make life too easy for my own kids so that they think they needn't try but provided they show the right attitude to work I will be helping them with house deposits etc. My son is about to go to uni and only qualifies for the minimum loan (tuition only I think) and we're happy to support him as he is passionate about his subject and has no other way of funding himself (he can get a part time job for any extra spends but he needs to spend most of his time actually doing the degree!). We won't be paying the tuition fees as even Martin Lewis advises borrowing it as it may never need paying back. If/ when it does and its hampering him getting a mortgage we can look at helping him pay it off then if it seems fair in the circumstances. However my in laws spoilt their two youngest children rotten - private education, cars, properties, thinking they were giving them a good start in life. In reality it meant they were entitled and bone idle because everything was provided, so they didn't need to bother making any effort. Wasted lives ...

TeaCosyApplePie · 13/04/2023 12:26

I don't get the mentality either... my parents were helped with their first house purchase, have been helped by relatives and left huge sums of money in wills. They in turn charged me full rent/bills, first car and driving lessons were paid for by me (car was bought as a surprise by them and I was then handed a payment schedule to repay!) and they haven't helped at all with my house purchase. I was skint and in debt for years - we have only just gotten on our feet in reality. No way will I subject my kids to the same if we can help them.

anon2022anon · 13/04/2023 12:25

Well it's swings and roundabouts between what you can afford, and what you are suggesting should be provided to them, surely? And also, personality of the young adult has an impact too, i.e. are they the type who demands that others have to support them? Helping them out by lending a deposit for a room in a shared house is one thing, but providing a house deposit is another. Or allowing them to live rent free, while they are happy to spend money on keeping up with friends.

DD is at uni. She gets a loan, which covers accommodation. She also gets given a monthly amount from us, but it doesn't take her up to what the full loan would be if she qualified. She needed a good talking to to go get a part time job, as she didn't see why she should have to. Not because it would interfere with uni, but with her social life. The money we were giving her to live on was funding 3 nights out a week.

She's now got a weekend job, as well as what we gave her. She was complaining the other day of not much food in the flat. If I'd just heard that with nothing else, I might have paid for an extra food shop. However, within the last month, she had paid to get her nails done, had at least 3 nights out that she's mentioned and been on a 5 day trip abroad with friends. Her priorities aren't there yet (and yes, I've offered several times to sit and do a budget with her).

I can and will make sure that she has enough so she has a good standard of living, but I can't ensure that she spends it wisely, and I definitely don't agree with keeping on topping her up so she can keep up a lifestyle that's not within her budget if she blows it.

We also won't be providing a deposit/ car for her. We're still paying our own mortgage, and will be for the next 25 years. She was encouraged to work from being 14, by the way, to pay for the luxuries she wants in life, and in general has worked from then, even if only a shift a week.

Ted27 · 13/04/2023 12:21

I had no ‘help’ from my parents because there was nothing for them to give.

I imagine there are many families like mine, ordinary working class families, dad working, mum part time working until the kids were older, not poor but far from rich, or even comfortable,
There was money for what was needed and two weeks in Wales in the summer, and Sunday school outings. My mum shopped in Kwiksave and the local shops. I wouldnt say we had any luxuries.
When my father died my inheritance was £2000. It paid off a small credit card debt and I bought a table and chairs for the garden.
I don’t anticipate anything from my mother as they have had to release equity from the house to pay for adaptions so they can live in their home as long as possible. Anything left would be split 4 ways so not exactly life changing.

I am in a better position than my parents. Better pension provision, but far from multiple luxury cruises/expensive holiday territory.

My son, at 18, does need to contribute to the household budget, if he wants to enjoy the same standard of living. He is going off to university and I will kit him out with what he needs. I’m taking redundancy in 7 weeks and can give him a few thousand for a car and new laptop.
When I take a pension in three years I have earmarked about £10k for him from my lump sum.
But thats it, I need the rest because my house needs some work and for an emergency fund. I will probably treat us to a big holiday. Not do I intend to spend my retirement penny pinching so I can subsidise a working adult.

So I am far from poor, a bit more comfortable than my parents were at the same stage in life, but much as I would like to, I don’t have thousands of pounds sitting around to fund uni, weddings and house deposits.

RudsyFarmer · 13/04/2023 12:20

Sundaefraise · 13/04/2023 12:07

I just don't think the situations are comparable. When I went to university there were no tuition fees, and when my mum was there she got a grant for living costs as well as no fees. Houses could be bought on a single wage, its just not a level playing field. I think you can still raise independent young people while accounting for the fact that it just was easier when we were younger.

But that’s based on your personal experience, not everyone’s. Life can be very difficult financially for all sorts of reasons. My life was exceptionally hard financially because of health problems preventing me working. Everyone has their own sack full of problems.

I’m raising my kids to be frugal individuals and value money. I probably will help them later if I can but my philosophy is that money isn’t what makes you happy. It’s being productive, having a sense of community surrounded my people who love you. That’s where the value is.

I don’t even think University is necessarily the answer for so many of our young folk. Yes there are careers where you have to go to Uni but there are plenty of careers where you can work and climb the ladder career wise. Similarly with ridiculously over priced boxes.

Maybe there are other ways to be housed in the future. It might become more common to live communally for example. I’m raising my kids to think out of the box a little more and not think they have to go to Uni, get married, but a property, have kids. For so many people this is all societal expectations and nothing to do with what we actually want.

Tarantullah · 13/04/2023 12:15

Parents are just regular people, some are selfish and some are not, some have misplaced views on stuff and others don't. I do think a balance is good personally. I went to university with someone from unimaginable wealth, their parents paid their fees and rent but they got a part time job (which the rest of us also had alongside studying) for money for going out, food, clothes etc. They could have afforded to give them a generous allowance but I thought that was brilliant really- appreciate the value of money by earning it with a safety net knowing they'd always have a home and didn't have to take a loan.

Thesharkradar · 13/04/2023 12:11

millymollymoomoo · 13/04/2023 10:54

And to PP I’d never be comfortable having pots of cash knowing my children were struggling
( as long as they were working/being responsible )

Same here, but my parents clearly didn't feel like that about me, they were comfortable lived in big heated houses always off on holidays, while I struggled.
At the time I didn't think anything of it I never expected anything from them, but when I had my own children I felt very different and couldn't see them struggling while I was comfortable.
I once repeated the quip that 'you are only as happy as your unhappiest child' to one of my parents and they looked at me blankly, I realized that they just don't identify with me or feel my pain at all whereas I feel acutely the pains and sufferings of my children.
But hey ho, what goes around comes around!
my parents didn't care about me so I don't have to care about them, now that they are elderly I can relax and not think about them 🤷
I feel a strong sense of duty towards my children but none whatsoever towards my parents. Looking back it seems to me that they felt a strong sense of duty towards their parents but very little towards me and it ended when I reached 18.

toomuchlaundry · 13/04/2023 12:09

@Regretsandregrets doesn't your DD feel that she should be contributing to the household. I can't imagine being in my 30s and sponging off my retired DM

flapjackfairy · 13/04/2023 12:08

@TriggeredByGravy
What do you mean by full support ? that suggests you will bankroll your kids indefinitely ? ?

Sundaefraise · 13/04/2023 12:07

RudsyFarmer · 13/04/2023 11:21

Because there are life lessons in the struggle which equip your young adult as they mature.

I just don't think the situations are comparable. When I went to university there were no tuition fees, and when my mum was there she got a grant for living costs as well as no fees. Houses could be bought on a single wage, its just not a level playing field. I think you can still raise independent young people while accounting for the fact that it just was easier when we were younger.

toomuchlaundry · 13/04/2023 11:59

My MiL was discouraged from doing well in 11+ and left school at 15 to go into full time work and contributed to household income. Her parents couldn’t afford for her not to be working.

When she married she wouldn’t have expected her home to have all the ‘luxuries’ we now expect.

@LadyCreampuff are your parents both retired?

tigger1001 · 13/04/2023 11:58

I doubt we will be in a financial position to give our kids deposits for houses etc, and not entirely sure I would do it even if we were in that position.

My parents are comfortably off but I don't expect help from them. I would be horrified if they were to do without a holiday to give me money. They have worked hard their entire lives and deserve holidays in their later years.

The reality is these days it's not just younger people struggling. Older parents maybe want to keep some money aside so they can afford home assistance or be able to choose a care home that they like for example.

StrawberryWater · 13/04/2023 11:58

I fully expect ds to take out a loan for uni if he goes. There is just no way I’m paying those exorbitant fees. Yikes.

That said I will help out with other things and he’ll always have a roof over his head here. This is his home and there’s no way I agree with kicking someone out as soon as they turn 18. My mother did that while I was still doing my A-Levels and it was hard. I had no money, no savings (as one of my scummy brothers raided my bank account and I only found out when I was being kicked out) and had to rely on friends. I had to couch surf for an entire year while I worked like a dog for a pittance and a deposit on something that wasn’t a crummy bedsit in the rough end of town. I had to put of going to university for 3 years. 😡

It really irked as my mum could afford to let me stay a little longer. She thinks it was a good life lesson. I think she was unnecessarily cruel.

WhatALightbulbMoment · 13/04/2023 11:56

OP this is a very common attitude in many areas of life, I see it very often. "I had a hard time so I'm not going to help others." it's bad enough when people treat strangers with this kind of cruel indifference but it's even worse when it's your own kids!

Albiboba · 13/04/2023 11:54

But I also don’t want them to launch into debt to get started in life, because I think I deserve a nice holiday or a new car or to order what I want in my weekly shop. I will always make sacrifices where needed, it won’t suddenly end at 18.

I’ve never heard anyone say their kids should suffer as they did as young adults but I find your post really dramatic. So someone is never allowed a holiday or to buy what they want on their food shop because that could go to their adult children?

There is a line between helping your children because you can and also teaching your children to stand on their own feet financially.

BritishDesiGirl · 13/04/2023 11:53

My parents never helped me or my sister's. From the age of sixteen when l got my first weekend job l contributed to the home. My parents never paid anything towards my university. Clothes, driving lessons and anything other than food and utilities l have paid for myself.

I even paid for all of my wedding stuff which parents are supposed to do, it's one of the obligations as parents in my religion.

On the other hand they have given my brother's everything including money, paid for my brother's wedding.

I see my situation as favouritism.

emituofo · 13/04/2023 11:53

Im with you OP. I know my parents would always do anything ( money, time, childcare etc) they could to help me, im in my 40s, this hasnt changed a bit. I would also do the same for my kids. My inlaws on the othet hand never helpped my hubby since he turned 18. They never want to spend money or effort on him or our kids.

When my parents helpped us with a deposit to buy our first house, my inlaws were shocked and angry, because they think my parents are trying to control us.... sigh, people who are selfish dont understand why others would happily help (sometimes even sacrifice for) their kids with no expectations at all. Sometimes I wonder what kind of love there is between them? They kiss hug all the time and say "love you" often, but when something happens they are not willing to sacrifice any of their comfort, time or money. The bond between them feels lile plastic to me.

Tiredalwaystired · 13/04/2023 11:50

Because we need to look out for our own retirement. Especially if we need a care home. That money isn’t elastic.

LadyCreampuff · 13/04/2023 11:49

I have noticed a huge degree of selfishness in my parents generation (I'm 37, they're in their late 50s and early 60s).

I remember my parents eagerly grabbing any help and support that they could from my grandparents, us staying overnight every week with grandparents etc, but now we are all grown up they seem to feel they've done their part and aren't quite so keen reciprocate the help they had onto their own children and grandchildren.

It's very much an attitude of "I've done my childrearing, you're turn" whereas I'm sat there thinking "You didn't do it alone! You are way too quick to conveniently forget that!".

Delectable · 13/04/2023 11:47

Most wealthy people, the RF, celebrities, CEOs, senior politicians not only help their children out, bequeath property, shares etc but also secure and propagate nil IHT for their children and generations unborn, use incorporation and trusts to pay as little tax as possible even though if they paid these taxes their great great grand children will not taste poverty.
Somehow the commoners have been brainwashed that their children must struggle and continue to romanticise poverty to their own detriment.

RJnomore1 · 13/04/2023 11:46

Well it very much depends on the circumstances doesn’t it?

Some (many) people just can’t afford to, full stop.

And there’s a massive shock in store if you’ve been living cozily at home with all your money to spend as you like then suddenly you have bills, which ime is WHY some young people get into debt for stupid things like cars etc. I’ve seen it repeatedly.

On the other hand, there’s refusing to help with the basics eg a deposit, etc if you are in the privileged position to do so for your children. But subsidising a life of partying and vacuous spending is just as damaging.

My two are both at home at the moment and working part time, I’m not taking rent because the oldest is saving (and has successfully lived independently for a few years) and the youngest very part time as at college and I can afford not to but at the same time if they weren’t saving/had more income Damn tooting id take reasonable amounts of rent. And if I wasn’t in the privileged position I’m in damn tooting they’d be contributing to household costs. I’d save it for them in my position but getting into the responsibility of paying your living costs before anything else is a life skill.

Financially crippling them when you can afford not to is wrong I agree; but parents financially crippling themselves so their children can live a lifestyle the parents can’t afford, which I see a lot, is also wrong.

Hongkongsuey · 13/04/2023 11:46

I can see both sides. I absolutely will help my children with big purchases. Bit to subsidise their lifestyle if they decide to have more children than they can afford? Absolutely not.

Regretsandregrets · 13/04/2023 11:41

I will do anything to make sure my daughter is comfortable. She is 32, lives with me and earns a decent wage. She contributes NIL to the household bills and I will not have it any other way. Any savings she makes are added to her private pension. I would like to continue like this for as long as she lives with me. That is how I was looked after as a young adult. It does not matter what others think about it but we are both happy and she is making good progress in her career, free from financial stresses faced by some of her peers.
I am retired and by no means rich. I just prioritize her comfort over anything else.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 13/04/2023 11:36

We are older than you and struggled when young despite both coming from comfortable backgrounds. It was shit and we are making sure our kids have a better life than we did.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 13/04/2023 11:36

You can tell the posters commenting who still have preschool/primary aged kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread