Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wonder why parents feel they don't need to financially help their kids after a certain age because they must ‘struggle like we did’ ?

289 replies

whatistuesday · 13/04/2023 10:42

I understand some people literally cannot do this but many can, even if it means a detriment to their own life, for instance one less holiday, a cheaper car etc etc.

But I do not understand why those who can, don’t. People who moan about supporting kids through university, making them take (full) loans that take so long to pay back, making them move out before they’ve had chance to save, charging them rent… the list goes on. The argument always seems to be that the DD or DS needs to learn the value of money or stand on their own two feet… of course, but does that mean you, as a parent, have no responsibility when they turn 18? Are they supposed to magically have money to start out? Even renting you need a deposit, let alone the idea of saving for a mortgage. There’s this idea that ‘well if i suffered, you must too.’ It’s your child!

For context I have had help from my parents but also know they could have done more. I now have dc and would do everything possible to ensure they were financially comfortable as a young adult. And no… I’m not bringing up brats, I work hard and will expect them to, too. But I also don’t want them to launch into debt to get started in life, because I think I deserve a nice holiday or a new car or to order what I want in my weekly shop. I will always make sacrifices where needed, it won’t suddenly end at 18.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LolaSmiles · 12/06/2023 18:13

If by "struggle" you mean "learn to budget, learn to save and/or work for what you want and learn that sometimes you need to do without or make choices" then I'm all for mine struggling a bit tbh
Why would helping a child out in early adulthood not be compatible with teaching budgeting and saving etc?

Hypothetical situation and two responses.

Child's graduated from university, is 21, has worked hard for 3 years, is ready to fly the nest and has got themselves a good job that will offer progression long term. They're now looking at moving out to their own place.

Parent 1: "well done, but don't expect anything else from me. If you wanted a car you should have done extra shifts during your final year at university. I'm not giving you a deposit on a car or offering to loan you the money for your insurance. It's like giving to beggars. You'll only want a house deposit next. Nope not a chance. You need to find an area, however crummy, to rent in so you can pay your flat deposit, but don't expect help from me. You better find that cash. And if you're living at home, expect that I'll be also taking cash off you for living here. You're an adult now. So you can live here, pay me money and I don't care if that means it's 2 or 3 busses in each direction because you chose the job and I don't care if you don't want to spend hours each day commuting. Sure I have the means to help you, but I'd rather you spent months giving me money living at home, spending hours commuting on busses trying work and save up a deposit for a crap flat in a crap area. That's going to teach you to budget and teach the value of money. You'll thank me later"

Parent 2: "well done. You've worked really hard and I'm so proud you've got a good job with prospects. I know you can budget and do research so how about you have a look at transport options and some flat locations and then we'll go through them together and make a plan to get you on your feet. Chip in to the food shops whilst you're at home and don't take the piss out of our help. Right, it looks like your best option is living here but a car would be much easier and more reliable. Obviously we aren't bankrolling you for life, but it's a big move setting up your own home so how about we find a decent finance plan for you, we'll loan you a small deposit and you can pay us back over the year. We'll happily pay your insurance this year whilst you get established because we can and we appreciated a bit of help when we started out".

Does parent 1 seriously think their "I struggled too, you need to struggle, school of hard knock" mentality is actually going to teach their child anything?

ReachForTheMars · 12/06/2023 14:15

taxguru · 12/06/2023 11:35

Yes, but even "management" in lots of employers is still pretty low/average wages. That's fine if you don't have high aspirations. You also need a good choice of local employers/businesses where you can climb the greasy pole if you want. If you live in a run down regional area which basically has nothing but a few supermarkets, independent retail, a couple of fast food outlets, charity shops, a few workshops and the odd garage business, you're options are really restricted. Not everywhere has big employers with progression opportunities within realistic commutes.

I think it depends what your aspiration is. Mine has always been to be a homeowner and get off the stressful career ladder as soon as possible. So I've chosen to progress (in the South East where houses arent cheap) with the stress that comes with management in order to pay off the mortgage and start some investments. Plenty of people do apprenticeships and build a career on trades and these jobs are everywhere. I think parental support comes in many formats, not just supporting uni for the sake of it. My cousin has started working with his dad in his building company and is doing an apprenticeship. If he does as well as his dad he will have his own company and earn well but it wont be a "status" job. He has been gifted driving lessons and a car so that he can do his apprenticeship but I expect once he is working full time he will be expected to pay rent. Had he gone to uni they would likely have supported him well financially, but he wont be getting a cash equivalent to 3 years if uni.

DisquietintheRanks · 12/06/2023 13:18

If by "struggle" you mean "learn to budget, learn to save and/or work for what you want and learn that sometimes you need to do without or make choices" then I'm all for mine struggling a bit tbh

LBFseBrom · 12/06/2023 13:15

I always helped mine, still would and still do a bit but not really needed now. I am pleased to have raised a hard-working child who is, discreetly, a good help to others in need and who I have no doubt would help me financially if necessary (God forbid).

When I was a young, married woman, before and for years after having a child, I could have done with parental help; I should say 'we', including my husband in that. We were often in dire straits :-). My mother used to bung me a few quid every now and then which was very much appreciated but she wasn't well off. My inlaws would sometimes pay for things for our son but they were of the belief that we should be able to manage. They were good in other ways, I'm not complaining, and eventually we inherited from them.

However, I was always determined that any children of mine would be helped by us financially, at the same time encouraging them to work towards a career and be reasonably sensible as they got older.

LolaSmiles · 12/06/2023 12:34

Where does a small amount of assistanceend?

"Well you paid for Uni, all I'm asking for is a few thousand to buy a car"

"Well you paid for Uni and my car, all I'm asking for is 50k for a deposit on a house"

"Well you paid for my deposit, can't you just pay a few months mortgage for us so we can go on holiday"

It's just like giving to a beggar, it doesn't help them in the long term, just enables them to continue doing what they have become accustomed to doing.

Thankfully I'll never view helping my children as giving to beggars. What a strange outlook. I can't imagine thinking "DC, I know I COULD support you and help you be in a good position long term and help you as you move to independence... But nahh I won't because showing you any financial generosity is just like giving to beggars. You should struggle."

The examples you give have nothing to do with helping your children. They're examples of poor attitudes and entitlement.

An adult child with a sense of entitlement is not the same as parents choosing to help and support their children within their means.

Some of my friends have had vastly more financial help from their parents than I did, but they aren't entitled. In fact they're very aware that they're in a fortunate position and are now seeking to have the same culture in their own families and towards their own children.

Wasitworthitreally · 12/06/2023 12:27

I Will help my kids as much as I can when I can. I am from a culture where it’s almost unheard of to charge kids rent. It’s also a culture that largely values education and hard work. I have no intention of changing things and hopefully my kids will feel the same when they have kids of their own.

I had family help with a deposit and work hard. 25 years and counting since my last sick day as a public sector full time worker! I might feel differently if my kids grow up to be lazy layabouts ;-)

HidingInAForest · 12/06/2023 12:18

Never similar feeling here. The pp who said they'd buy the odd meal out or a weekend away does at least demonstrate some generosity. Its the rolling in it and yet not sharing a penny when kids aren't ever going to be in the same income bracket that I find so hard to get my head around at the moment.

NeverEverA · 12/06/2023 12:04

I don't expect handouts but I hate the extreme pride in their income coupled with the 'we had it hard' for a few years rhetoric.

When I inherit their photos from the many cruises - £40k going round the world plus a serious three weeks every year along with short breaks. - I 'm going to burn them. I don't find the acronym skiing spending the kids inheritance, as funny as they do when we were on long weekends away, once a year in the UK. I even more angry that I invited them to two of those precious weekends because they didn't see much of the grand kids and then they moaned all the time.

Thesharkradar · 12/06/2023 11:59

onefinemess · 12/06/2023 11:46

It isn't bullshit.

If your kids can't find a job that pays well, they could move to where the work is. Lots of people do it, some even move to other countries.

A grown adult, taking their parents money is mildly pathetic.

"But they can't afford to save a deposit, even on a graduate salary"

If their Degree can't even get them a well paid job, why did they bother with it in the first place?

Uni was clearly a waste of time.

An adult who takes money from their parents demonstrably cannot live independently. In other words, they aren't mature enough to fend for themselves out in the real world. That's the parents fault. They failed at the first hurdle. The people who built the rocket are the ones responsible for any failure to launch.

Oh yes silly me.... humans are just the same as rockets aren't they 🤣

Proudofitbabe · 12/06/2023 11:52

To me it's probably quite simple. If your kid is a good one and needs something, you should help to the extent you can. At any age.

Doesn't mean funding their lifestyle, absolutely not. For me it might mean helping with a deposit, contributing to a wedding, treating them to a weekend away for their 30th, having the kids if/when available. Others might be able to do less, or more.

I think there's an element of what you're able to do, and also what the kids themselves deserve. If they are lazy/irresponsible I'd be inclined to do very little. It's pointless. If they're hardworking, responsible and generous, I know I'll WANT to indulge more.

I know hard-working adults struggling to rent in a crap area while mortgage-free retired parents in the affluent bit watch on. At the other extreme I've seen lazy losers get more parental help than MOST, while doing nothing to help themselves, or reward their parents with any sense of satisfaction or pride. Neither is normal to me.

onefinemess · 12/06/2023 11:46

Thesharkradar · 12/06/2023 11:35

Simplistic bullshit

It isn't bullshit.

If your kids can't find a job that pays well, they could move to where the work is. Lots of people do it, some even move to other countries.

A grown adult, taking their parents money is mildly pathetic.

"But they can't afford to save a deposit, even on a graduate salary"

If their Degree can't even get them a well paid job, why did they bother with it in the first place?

Uni was clearly a waste of time.

An adult who takes money from their parents demonstrably cannot live independently. In other words, they aren't mature enough to fend for themselves out in the real world. That's the parents fault. They failed at the first hurdle. The people who built the rocket are the ones responsible for any failure to launch.

nibblethekibble · 12/06/2023 11:37

Well, I could have a brand new Mustang in my driveway..

But I'd rather my children have their mortgage deposits. They'll have them, and inherit well when we die - although I'm 32 so they've a good while to wait for that, hopefully.

I don't want to be the goose that sits on the golden egg though, so I try to make sure we have amazing holidays.

Trying hard not to bring up brats though. That's the last thing I want.

Thesharkradar · 12/06/2023 11:36

Moving out isnt even an entitlement. In many cultures people live with their family for years with intergenerational living
I can't imagine how awful that would be 🤯

Thesharkradar · 12/06/2023 11:35

onefinemess · 12/06/2023 08:37

It's called being an adult.

If your kids need your help financially when they are adults, then either you failed to raise them or they failed at managing their own life.

Helping grown adults by giving them money so they can get something they can't afford on their own, is just enabling their helplessness.

Simplistic bullshit

taxguru · 12/06/2023 11:35

ReachForTheMars · 12/06/2023 11:30

You can train for management in minimum wage jobs. I did and I will have paid my mortgage off by 40 and will be able to fully fund my child through uni, driving lessons and set her up with a home when she is ready.

I will still wont pay more than pocket money for luxuries like fancy phones and make up. If she wants extras she needs to earn a disposable income.

Yes, but even "management" in lots of employers is still pretty low/average wages. That's fine if you don't have high aspirations. You also need a good choice of local employers/businesses where you can climb the greasy pole if you want. If you live in a run down regional area which basically has nothing but a few supermarkets, independent retail, a couple of fast food outlets, charity shops, a few workshops and the odd garage business, you're options are really restricted. Not everywhere has big employers with progression opportunities within realistic commutes.

taxguru · 12/06/2023 11:31

ReachForTheMars · 12/06/2023 11:22

Ita a bit weird that you think this is the only generation to struggle.

We dont live in a world where you move out and your parents subsidise a second household for each child.

Moving out isnt even an entitlement. In many cultures people live with their family for years with intergenerational living.

Other people have it a lot harder than 18 year olds that want to move out and buy a new home, have a good car and good clothes and holidays, gadgets and tech, and still have a chunk of disposable income.

That standard of living comes from building a career and a 30/40yo salary, not an entry level job with a salary topped up by mum and dad. Youth need to adjust their expectations.

Unless you live in one of few big cities, things have changed radically over the past two or three decades and there simply aren't the jobs in lots of regional/rural areas anymore, so yes, moving away, renting their own flat, etc is pretty much essential for huge numbers of youngsters these days if they want a decent job/career/profession. Ever increasing numbers of youngsters go off to Uni and never return to live/work in their home towns, simply because there are few, if any, decent jobs there.

My son would have loved to stay living in his home town, but given his chosen career/profession, the nearest job he could get is 200 miles away - that's the closest firm who offer his profession. There used to be such firms with regional offices all over the UK, we had two large regional offices in a nearby town just 20 miles away, but both closed down 20 years ago and relocated/centralised all their offices into their London head office.

You're OK if you want to be a teacher, nurse, doctor, etc., as there are schools and hospitals all over the UK. Not the same if you want to be an engineer or actuary where local/regional opportunities are basically non existent for vast swathes of the country!

ReachForTheMars · 12/06/2023 11:30

taxguru · 12/06/2023 11:25

Perhaps parents would prefer their kids to be in education/training rather than a dead end minimum wage job? Far better to be learning/training towards getting a higher paid career/profession, and for that, they need support. Yes, they can be earning £750/£1000 in a full time minimum wage job, but chances are if they go down that route, they'll still be on minimum wage in 5/10/20 years' time. You need to "speculate to accumulate" especially in modern days, when it's more important than ever to get qualifications, skills, etc to enable you to get into decent careers/professions with more options for advancement, flexibility, etc.

You can train for management in minimum wage jobs. I did and I will have paid my mortgage off by 40 and will be able to fully fund my child through uni, driving lessons and set her up with a home when she is ready.

I will still wont pay more than pocket money for luxuries like fancy phones and make up. If she wants extras she needs to earn a disposable income.

BeachBlondey · 12/06/2023 11:29

I agree with you. I sent money to both of my children through their Uni years. Thankfully they are now both in good jobs and don't need any further support. However, I do still pay for any meals out and regularly treat them to things. I am also paying for half my DD's wedding (and will do the same for DS when the time comes).

FIL is a multi millionaire and does not help SIL, who is on the breadline. I just can't understand it. They have a good relationship, so it's not that they have fallen out.

taxguru · 12/06/2023 11:25

ReachForTheMars · 12/06/2023 11:13

Are they supposed to magically have money to start out? Even renting you need a deposit

A 16 year old on minimum wage can earn over £750 a month on full time hours.

An 18 year old on minimum wage working full time earns £1000+.

Assuming they live at home do you think it's reasonable for them to spend that each month? Why shouldn't they pay rent if they are earning? That's more than a lot of people have in take home pay. Do you honestly think parents who can afford a holiday should top up their childs moneyand go without a holiday so their kids can have more disposable income?

Perhaps parents would prefer their kids to be in education/training rather than a dead end minimum wage job? Far better to be learning/training towards getting a higher paid career/profession, and for that, they need support. Yes, they can be earning £750/£1000 in a full time minimum wage job, but chances are if they go down that route, they'll still be on minimum wage in 5/10/20 years' time. You need to "speculate to accumulate" especially in modern days, when it's more important than ever to get qualifications, skills, etc to enable you to get into decent careers/professions with more options for advancement, flexibility, etc.

ReachForTheMars · 12/06/2023 11:22

Ita a bit weird that you think this is the only generation to struggle.

We dont live in a world where you move out and your parents subsidise a second household for each child.

Moving out isnt even an entitlement. In many cultures people live with their family for years with intergenerational living.

Other people have it a lot harder than 18 year olds that want to move out and buy a new home, have a good car and good clothes and holidays, gadgets and tech, and still have a chunk of disposable income.

That standard of living comes from building a career and a 30/40yo salary, not an entry level job with a salary topped up by mum and dad. Youth need to adjust their expectations.

TheSnootiestFox · 12/06/2023 11:19

taxguru · 12/06/2023 10:52

I think my eagerness to help DS is also borne out of a very "poor" upbringing, where it was made clear from an early age that I wouldn't be going to Uni because my parents "couldn't" afford to fund it, we never had holidays, parents drove around in old rust bucket cars that constantly broke down - my "memories" of the occasional days out we had was usually of waiting for the recovery truck to tow us home. When I got my first job, I was expected to give half of the wages to my parents for "rent", but also to buy my own clothes, etc., and to buy my own study books/resources out of the other half of my very small wage (less than a pound per hour in the 80s!). If I used my parents car, say to go to college evening classes, I had to put a few quid of petrol in it!

My teenage years and early 20's were dictated by lack of money, and I missed out on a lot. It wasn't until my mid to late 20's that I qualified and started earning good money that I started to actually "live a life", which meant being late to have relationships, late to marry, late to buy a house, late to have a child, etc.

I didn't want my son to struggle like that as it makes things so much harder, and in my case, it meant we only had one child as we were so late that time ran out for a second.

The ironic (and very annoying) thing about all that penny pinching, etc., is that my parents DID have money after all, but just chose not to spend it. When they died and I went through their paperwork, it was clear that they had healthy savings right back to the 70s and 80s, but wouldn't even spend it on themselves, let alone their children! I just find it unfathomable they they're prefer to drive old unreliable rust buckets of cars that kept breaking down rather than buying something more reliable. And that was just one example of not spending. But the killer was my mother whingeing that we'd only given her one grandchild - well if she'd not been so tight and restrictive, I'd have probably got my career sorted a few years earlier which would have led to marriage sooner and child(ren) sooner before time ran out!

That's part of why I've been so keen to finance my son on what I consider to be "the right lines" as regards his education and career. The sooner he has his feet under the table with a decent employer in a job with prospects, the sooner he can "live his own life" and pay for it himself!

Exactly this! I had a very similar teenage and young adult experience and it's completely messed my life up. I am very angry with my parents for not what I call putting me on the right 'path.' I did no extra curricular activities and had one pair of jeans that I sewed up at least once a week, and then going for uni interviews with these well travelled kids with their gold D of Es and sporting achievements opened my eyes completely! I always thought we were poor but she always had a lovely collection of antiques on display that were bought from little fairs and shops and always immaculate short hair cuts every 6 weeks. I didn't see a hairdresser at her expense from the age of 12! I bust a gut to make sure my kids have that cultural capital that I lacked and even of they don't make it to university will have the confidence and social skills to excel at whatever they do. Because it's my job as their mother. If you don't want to do this for your kids, then don't bother having them.

taxguru · 12/06/2023 11:18

@Proudofitbabe

The way I see it is, as long as they work hard and are good people they'll deserve any help. (The wasters/lazy/spoilt are a different question!)

Same with us. We'd be very different with him if he constantly caused us problems, argued with us, showed any signs of aggression, or was getting mixed up with problematic drink, drugs, etc. But he doesn't. So we're pretty confident he's not going to do anything stupid with any money/financial help we give him. He's always been grateful for whatever we've given him and has shown common sense and financial awareness far in excess of his age!

He knows full well not to ask for hand outs for frivolities like holidays, hobbies, weddings, etc. He barely even asks for help for more important things like study text books - he seems slightly embarrassed to mention things like that, which we've always been happy to pay for. Now he's finished Uni, he's a couple of months before he starts his first proper job, and has already shared his plans with us as to how he's going to finance numerous days out with his Uni flat mates to theme parks, zoos, and various outdoor pursuits (segway, kayaking, water-skiing, etc) - none of which involve the begging bowl for us to finance them! He saved a few hundred pounds towards it by walking to the Uni rather than buying bus passes, and just paying ad-hoc for buses on the few heavy rainy days! Also saved a small fortune by making packed lunches instead of buying lunch in the Uni canteens - that's another few hundred.

ReachForTheMars · 12/06/2023 11:13

Are they supposed to magically have money to start out? Even renting you need a deposit

A 16 year old on minimum wage can earn over £750 a month on full time hours.

An 18 year old on minimum wage working full time earns £1000+.

Assuming they live at home do you think it's reasonable for them to spend that each month? Why shouldn't they pay rent if they are earning? That's more than a lot of people have in take home pay. Do you honestly think parents who can afford a holiday should top up their childs moneyand go without a holiday so their kids can have more disposable income?

Throwncrumbs · 12/06/2023 11:13

You had help but your parents could have done more….and there it is, the sense of entitlement that young people have nowadays!

ReachForTheMars · 12/06/2023 11:06

A different viewpoint

People who moan about supporting kids through university, Making them take (full) loans that take so long to pay back

Depends on the course and child. A course which will reasonably result in employment and doesnt reasonably facilitate part time work - happy to fully fund it as best I can so they have a clean, warm, safe place to live and do well at their demanding course.

A course that can be done with a part time job or is being done by choice without a job and going out drinking every weekend - not on my dime.

Making them move out before they’ve had chance to save, charging them rent
Are they saving? I used to earn £800 take home at 16 and moaned about paying my mum £100 a month when she clearly could have done with it. I spent every penny.

When my child is old enough to pay rent, I will charge them and it will go into their savings so when they are ready to buy a home they have an extra nest egg. I'm not going to tell them it's there until they are ready to buy because I want them to understand that housing has a cost, not see it as extra savings.

Does that make it ok for me to charge them rent? Realistically why should an 18-25 year old living at home bot be able to afford rent? Most dont have kids. The only mandatory bill should be their rent; their iPhone and social life should be budgeted for.