Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Strangers buying us things!

159 replies

ChristmasJumpers · 13/04/2023 10:29

I am going to sound so ungrateful but please stick with me...
We had a baby 4 weeks ago and people have been so generous with giving us hand me downs including bouncers, clothes, a moses basket etc. And we got lots of presents of clothes/medicine/toys/books at her baby shower and from visitors since she was born. I'm really grateful for that and we have been taking pictures of DD in her clothes/with her toys and sending thank yous. We're lucky to be surrounded by people who love us and DD.

The problem is that we also have total strangers buying and giving gifts to us!!! DHs mum works in a big office and her colleagues who we never have and never will meet have been buying and making things for DD like crazy! She now has about 40 hand knitted cardigans, 15 (yes really) chunky blankets, 2 bouncers and so many teddies. We've nowhere to put it all but it just keeps coming! I've just had a message from DMIL with a picture of a pop vinyl toy that someone at work has bought for us and a personalised cushion with her name, DOB etc. on. I'm honestly grateful but it's never ending and we're just getting repeat presents and things we can't or won't use as they don't know us or what we already have. The house is full but DMIL thinks it's lovely of them so I can't ask her to pass on the message to stop. AIBU that it's a bit odd, they'll never meet us or DD. They clearly love DMIL but why not one collection and pass on a voucher or just the one thoughtful gift?

AIBU - People are being kind and I should just accept the gifts and be grateful
AINBU - it's a bit much for total strangers to be showering us with so many gifts

OP posts:
Barbecuebeans · 14/04/2023 10:28

SparkyBlue · 13/04/2023 10:56

I get it OP and that why when baby gifts are mentioned on here I always say give a voucher. No one needs more stuff in the house. Pack it up for the charity shop and don't feel guilty. It's lovely your baby is so welcomed I had a similar situation.

I totally get it too.

I agree with this poster. Don't feel guilty about passing it on.

Unfortunately knitted stuff is a pain. I didn't want it and was a bit irritated as I didn't have time to hand wash a load of stuff. I know it was a very kind thought though but someone with a nanny might love them.

swayingpalmtree · 14/04/2023 10:27

I think you are over thinking this a bit. Its not a big deal. Your MIL is clearly very popular and is excited and people are loving that and wanting to contribute.

I'd just be asking MIL to thank them on your behalf and then I'd donate most of them to charity for people who need it. You probably cant practically use that amount of stuff anyway so give to people who need them. Telling your MIL to tell them to stop comes across as petty and a bit mean spirited- their intentions were to do something kind and nice for someone else and telling them to stop is kinda like throwing it back in their face. Allow them to feel happy that they've helped someone.

Wondering why they are doing it is a little pointless- they are just trying to help. Thats all. No more, no less.

Uokhon · 14/04/2023 10:21

People just love to gift for babies. We have received knitted items from my mum’s neighbours 400 miles away that I have never met!

My baby is also the smallest of our group of friends so we get hand me downs from them too, sometime 2-3 bin bags full. It really can be overwhelming but I have saved a lot of money and do appreciate it.

second hand stuff, pull out what you want to keep and pass the rest on to charity or sell on Vinted.

personalised items put in a memory box or on shelves in babies room and decide at a later date.

blankets, you can never have too many! I keep one in the pram, one in the car, use a couple on the floor to lie on, some in the lounge for lap naps and rotate as they get puked on.

Strawberrydelight78 · 14/04/2023 10:21

If you have a spare room put everything you know you won't use in there. Wait a few months then see if there's any baby bank's, clothing bank's or woman's refuge you can donate to. The novelty of a new baby will soon wear off. Sometimes you have to put your foot down and say no more you don't want them to grow up spoilt.

Snaaaaacks · 14/04/2023 10:21

I had gifts from people I've never met (and still haven't met) for each of my children, it's simply a nice thing to do. There's no need to be ungrateful. Funny actually we were given this hideous knitted Teddy that someone my mil worked with made, they obviously put a lot of effort in so I hadn't the heart to chuck it/donate it. Thing is our daughter grew rather attached to this toy and so 7 years later we still have the bloody thing 😆. Would make me cringe if she wanted to take it out in the pram with her lol. People are kind when you have a baby, if you can't make use of things just give them to someone who will, there's plenty of people out there with nothing. Gift givers do not need to find out and they will still make their way to a small baby who will make use of them, win win.

Sugargliderwombat · 14/04/2023 10:19

Find a baby bank near you, get OH to drop a big bulk of it all there. Someone who needs it will have it then 😄

LoveQuinnOhDearyMe · 14/04/2023 10:17

I think what you”ve likely got here are some people who first off love your MIL and are just excited for her becoming a Grandma - and second it’s likely (this is going to be a stereotype sorry) older ladies who are either waiting on grandchildren themselves and love to knit for pleasure so having a purpose (ie a baby) is something they get a lot of joy out of whilst they wait for their own grandchildren, or they’re not getting any grandchildren and are just enjoying again having this moment of a baby. Some people really do just share the delight of other people’s children and want to do something lovely. I’m sure it will die down as your child reaches toddler hood.

I would start spreading it out of space is an issue. Pack a little selection of blankets, spare jumpers and other random items off to family you visit frequently (assuming this is the case with MIL) and just say it’s easier to have stuff “just in case” at others homes (to be fair my sister has always kept a stash of clothes etc at grandparents houses for this reason, it’s easier). Anything that you’re really not using, pack it up in case for a second DC or to use later as a regifting. An extra present, you know your friend has a baby and you can say “I’ve got all these lovely jumpers if they interest you”. I personally love a knitted jumper on a baby!

LadyEloise1 · 14/04/2023 10:13

I'd just think how lovely, they must like mil, she must be very popular that people are so delighted to gift things to us on her account.
Anything I didn't want or mightn't need in the future I would donate to a charity shop - preferably far from mil's work place, so others might benefit.
I wouldn't sell the items. I'd just think that was bad karma.

KillerSandy · 14/04/2023 10:12

You must be English? In Scotland this is to be expected - It's called a "minding" and is a hangover from days when people didn't have much. Every area will have a baby charity organisation so pass on to people less lucky than yourself.

crochetmonkey74 · 14/04/2023 10:11

It's lovely, a way for people to express joy and love. Just count yourself lucky to have a baby welcomed into a world like this. Spread the joy and love by being equally generous and passing things on with joy to others. This is going to be a rare thing in your life so remember it fondly, rather than letting it annoy you

MarvelMrs · 14/04/2023 10:11

If you do give any away to charity shop or to a charity like Baby Basics, be aware of doing it locally. If your MIL or her workplace is local to you then you could end up putting a unique/easily recognised item in view and causing great offence. And your MIL would have to deal with that. Perhaps ask her to have a few
blankets at hers and box up other items for the loft and charity shop them in a year.

Olios · 14/04/2023 10:11

They are gifts to your mil from her friends as she probably talks lots about excitement of being a grandma, for her new family member

greenlychee · 14/04/2023 10:07

you need to be fairly ruthless about getting rid of stuff. Practice the Kondo method: thank the item, and then put it in the recycling or charity bag (you'll feel better about getting rid of them).

I had this when I had a baby. I was overwhelmed with being a new mum and did not need the tens of bags of clothes that I was suddenly inunddated with. I also felt guilty about getting rid of them! Looking back now I wish I had been more ruthless about it rather than waiting!!

Stick a note on facebook to say they are free to a deserving home and you'll shift them quickly.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 14/04/2023 10:06

Humans evolved living in tribes, and babies would have belonged to everybody in the tribe - they would all have been responsible for looking out for that child. At heart, we are all still wired that way, and when we have the chance, love to be connected. Donate or store what you cant use, its lovely that you are doing thank yous, but maybe do a bunch at a time, rather than as things are coming in. And appreciate being cared about, because there are a lot of people who are completely isolated. Could you call your local social services and see if they can use any of the surplus?

KettrickenSmiled · 14/04/2023 10:06

The house is full but DMIL thinks it's lovely of them so I can't ask her to pass on the message to stop.
Sure you can.
Why does MiL's idea of how much baby stuff you can accommodate in your house trump yours?

AIBU that it's a bit odd, they'll never meet us or DD. They clearly love DMIL but why not one collection and pass on a voucher or just the one thoughtful gift?
Totally odd.
Is MiL popular & well-liked generally?
Or is she so excited about her new GC that she's talking about not much else at work?

Either way - tell her "enough".
You're going to have to sell or donate SO much stuff now!

lostinfusion · 14/04/2023 10:02

the hand knitted cardigans & blankets I would say are just being done by people that enjoy knitting as a hobby & likely already have a house full of cardigans & blankets for themselves

Finchgold · 14/04/2023 10:01

I had this, it was insane. I was a single mum so I think people wanted to help even more. I sent my mum to M&S, Boots and Next with bags full of clothes to swap for vouchers or bigger sizes. I had also been given huge amounts of second hand clothes which I just passed on to charities.

I appreciated the thought but it was nuts.

sweetdreamstenasee · 14/04/2023 09:58

I’m expecting and dreading this a bit, our house is lovely but small and low on storage and I prefer a more minimalist approach (don’t worry, baby will have plenty of clothes, toys and books!)

my approach would be to photograph baby in every item / with every item and send to gift giver ( if you feel comfortable, understand if not when strangers are involved obviously) send pictures on with thanks or thank you notes, keep the a few bits and sell the nice stuff and charity bag the rest.

alyceflowers · 14/04/2023 09:54

People love buying baby gifts, and knitters/crafters are just pleased to have a reason to make something!

I'd keep anything personalised and take everything else straight to a charity shop.

Send one thank you card and a baby photo to your MIL's office thanking everyone for the gifts. They can stick it up on the notice board.

Optionshighlights · 14/04/2023 09:51

This happened, and is still happening, to me! Gave birth to twins and both my DM and DMIL have a constant stream of hand knitted clothes, personalised quilted blankets, teddy bears, paintings etc. etc. from friends and friends-of-friends I have never met. I do feel incredibly grateful that people I have never met want to keep doing this for my children (who are now not babies 😂) even though it is a bit weird.

Accept with grace, these gifts are making their donors very happy indeed 😊

Sugarfree23 · 14/04/2023 09:43

liveforsummer · 14/04/2023 09:00

Get MIL to keep some of the stuff at hers. Mention that you have too much now and rehome some unpersonalised stuff. I guess your MiL has lots of friends at work and is very proud and talking a lot about her dgc

Don't do that, that's very rude, it's not like MIL is buying this stuff.
Accept with grace and pass on what you don't need

BigTedLittleTedCardboardBox · 14/04/2023 09:40

Oh my mother is guilty of doing this. She absolutely loves knitting baby blankets, it's just what she does when watching TV of an evening. Any sniff of someone having a baby and, yes, she sets about with renewed purpose.

She's made dozens and dozens of blankets, of which only about three have gone to family members. All the rest went to friends and relatives of friends and colleagues. All unsolicited, all most likely unwanted.

When I had my child many of her friends who I'd never met knitted me blankets or cardigans, with varying degrees of talent and taste, plus I had teddy bears, socks etc etc from them. Utterly overwhelming. Writing thank yous, storing it, the guilt of not using them (most were pretty awful), the guilt of eventually charity shopping things when I finally felt I could, the guilt of not still having them when my mum mentions the friend (and their blanket). The guilt when one of my mum's friends died and she was hoping to see her blanket and I didn't have it.

I hate gifts and this is a prime example of why.

Shinyandnew1 · 14/04/2023 09:30

We just wouldn’t have had room for all that stuff in our little flat when DC1 was born! Space was so limited. Can you say something about space to MIL and ask her to keep it all at hers? She might see your point then!

Whyamiherenow · 14/04/2023 09:26

This is so normal. We have a ten month old. We were totally overwhelmed by all the gifts we received. People are just being kind but we honestly received so many gifts and still do. Christmas and Easter and any other occasion were completely overwhelming. We just said thank you. Worked out what we needed and wanted to keep and repurposed other things.

we received gifts from many unexpected places, DH ex-wife and her family - they are lovely to us but this was a big thing; MIL’s friend’s mum; MIL’s neighbours; my dad’s cousins’s husband’s sister; my work had a collection and thankfully gave us the cash rather than a gift (they asked) etc.

so much and so unexpected. People do really just go mad for babies. It is a kindness but it’s overwhelming when you already have a lot to deal with.

just keep the things you need / like and pack the other things away for when you feel strong enough to work through repurposing them.

the thing I struggled most with was writing all the thank you cards!

AmberGer · 14/04/2023 09:19

My own experience was pretty similar to yours.
1st DC. People went OTT. Gifts, flowers (I had so many flowers I could have opened a shop! I had to buy so many vases to accommodate them and was running out of room to put them), cards, hand me downs. Massive collection at work, vouchers, mummy and baby manicure and massages.
And visitors that I'd never seen before! Dh and I had been together almost a decade before ds was born, I had met most of his relatives but as soon as ds was born, long lost relatives all coming out of the woodwork, knocking on our door and I hadn't got a clue who they were.

When dc2 was born, hardly any acknowledgement from anybody.