Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Strangers buying us things!

159 replies

ChristmasJumpers · 13/04/2023 10:29

I am going to sound so ungrateful but please stick with me...
We had a baby 4 weeks ago and people have been so generous with giving us hand me downs including bouncers, clothes, a moses basket etc. And we got lots of presents of clothes/medicine/toys/books at her baby shower and from visitors since she was born. I'm really grateful for that and we have been taking pictures of DD in her clothes/with her toys and sending thank yous. We're lucky to be surrounded by people who love us and DD.

The problem is that we also have total strangers buying and giving gifts to us!!! DHs mum works in a big office and her colleagues who we never have and never will meet have been buying and making things for DD like crazy! She now has about 40 hand knitted cardigans, 15 (yes really) chunky blankets, 2 bouncers and so many teddies. We've nowhere to put it all but it just keeps coming! I've just had a message from DMIL with a picture of a pop vinyl toy that someone at work has bought for us and a personalised cushion with her name, DOB etc. on. I'm honestly grateful but it's never ending and we're just getting repeat presents and things we can't or won't use as they don't know us or what we already have. The house is full but DMIL thinks it's lovely of them so I can't ask her to pass on the message to stop. AIBU that it's a bit odd, they'll never meet us or DD. They clearly love DMIL but why not one collection and pass on a voucher or just the one thoughtful gift?

AIBU - People are being kind and I should just accept the gifts and be grateful
AINBU - it's a bit much for total strangers to be showering us with so many gifts

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LBMBH · 17/04/2023 14:17

Regift, regift, regift (or if it’s really crap - charity shop)! I had the same experience - MIL, distant family & even people from my sisters work buying me stuff, some tat from £land etc.
Some of it was spot on, some of it was great but not my style, some of it we already had. I now have a huge bag full and when people I know have fallen pregnant or had babies, the bag has come in so useful. I have a cousin who has a really whacky style so I had loads of loud clothes i didn’t like that I could send…. My close friend is having a girl so I passed on loads of bits that felt too girly for my little boy. Saved me a fortune!! Win, win 😃😃😃

Ibizamumof4 · 16/04/2023 22:13

Just give them away don’t feel guilty about this. I have found lots of people enjoy knitting so just want a baby to knit for.

Ilovecleaning · 16/04/2023 21:16

Keep for Baby Number 2 and/or donate to women’s refuges. Women’s refuges need this kind of stuff. Women often arrive with new/ small babies with literally nothing because they have escaped terrible domestic abuse..

Ilovecleaning · 16/04/2023 21:14

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 13/04/2023 11:29

Do you think the MIL is buying them and blaming the colleagues?

That sounds a daft suggestion.

londonrach · 16/04/2023 21:09

DH work did this...they knew we been trying for abit. I send a lovely thank you letter to everyone and sold, passed on bits we didn't use...kept all the cards. I was vvv grateful for everything even if not useful as saw it an appreciation of kindness to my husband.... We did have alot of random gifts from neighbours we not spoken too either...again thank you card and redirected if not needed ..three dolls house a for a newborn baby isn't needed but I appreciate d the thought

T1Dmama · 16/04/2023 21:05

I would be gracious and thank them all and anything you have too many of donate to a womens refuge or similar

Tillie12 · 16/04/2023 21:02

Haha this sounds the same as when we had our first (we’re now on third child and it didn’t continue for second two, obviously wasn’t as exciting second and third time 😅)
write thank you notes but don’t think anyone you’re not close with needs a picture of the item In use!
we took back anything with a tag in exchange for a gift voucher to save for when we actually needed things as they get older.
i think hospitals are grateful for knitted bits, does sound like you have a lot!!
Offer anything else free on Facebook/ women’s shelters or sell and save the money for when you actually need things
I wouldn’t personally ask them to stop just because I wouldn’t want to upset anyone, but they don’t have to know you’re passing it on x

Sennelier1 · 15/04/2023 22:33

We (early 60s) have now 3 grandchildren. When the forst GC was born my MIL was still alive. Her neighbours insisted on buying gifts for the new baby, gifts we then needed to take with us abroad where our DC and DGC live. I still hear her "suggesting" her neighbours "if you don't know what to buy just go for a soft toy". Needless to say a bunch of teddies, rabbits and other fluffy creatures never made it to the booth of our car.

BigTedLittleTedCardboardBox · 15/04/2023 16:50

thecatsthecats · 15/04/2023 11:39

If you like to crochet, my recommendation would be to stick to crocheting for a) people you could directly text or phone right now - i.e. people you have a direct relationship with with, and b) people who ask you to crochet something on their behalf.

My MIL couldn't craft to save her life, and would happily commission something for the grandchild she's about to find out she's getting.

Oh, and also, just crochet bigger things! My local cat shelter gets old baby blankets, I suspect because they're teeny weeny and stop being useful almost immediately.

Yes to this. A lot of the things we got were very small and quickly outgrown, or just weirdly sized, with tight arms, small head holes etc so they never actually fit at all. In some ways this was a relief. Most were made with cheap acrylic wool in pale brown or various pastel shades (especially mint green and lemon!) that I just did not like at all, and that washed incredibly badly and went bobbly. It might have been different if they'd been more skillfully made in better yarn in tasteful colours.

There was also a crochet baby blanket that someone had hand stitched glass bugle beads all over. They were sharp and scratchy and made the blanket unsafe to use.

I honestly had so much stress trying to be thankful for these many, many gifts, which were all made and given with good intentions, whilst almost universally disliking them and not having anywhere for them in our tiny house and being expected to use them and 'show them off' by my mum.

THEDEACON · 15/04/2023 14:06

YABU and ungrateful It's not unusual in Scotland to give "a wee minding" to the new grandchild of a work colleague or friend your MIL clearly 8s popular and you're benefitting Pass if forward if you don't want it

Leicestershiremum · 15/04/2023 13:02

misslaa · 13/04/2023 11:37

I completely get this, it can be so overwhelming. I ended up get 50 thank you cards printed from snapfish with a picture of my baby saying thank you for the lovely gift and sending them via grandparents etc to people i didnt know well. Not as personal as the ones i gave to close friend and family but when you have a newborn it can get too much. I also asked my health visitor if she knew of anyone not as lucky/ with as much support as us that could use some of it. She was so grateful and it made me feel good that it would be going to good use. Congratulations on the birth of your baby!

This is such a good idea to ask the health visitor. Its so hard to be able to pass on things to people really in need without insider knowledge.

thecatsthecats · 15/04/2023 11:39

If you like to crochet, my recommendation would be to stick to crocheting for a) people you could directly text or phone right now - i.e. people you have a direct relationship with with, and b) people who ask you to crochet something on their behalf.

My MIL couldn't craft to save her life, and would happily commission something for the grandchild she's about to find out she's getting.

Oh, and also, just crochet bigger things! My local cat shelter gets old baby blankets, I suspect because they're teeny weeny and stop being useful almost immediately.

neverendinglauaundry · 15/04/2023 09:17

Ah, everyone loves your MIL and she is obviously really excited about the baby. Just take the stuff, say thank you and box it up. Loads of places will have it off you. Charity shops, local groups or a women's shelter or something.

LadyEloise1 · 15/04/2023 09:13

The cupcakes sound like a really lovely thank you treat @ChristmasJumpers, how thoughtful of you.

swayingpalmtree · 15/04/2023 08:00

I'm a baker so I will get a card with a picture of DD on and ask DMIL to take it into work with some cupcakes for everyone to share as a thank you

This is a really lovely gesture!

Doone21 · 14/04/2023 22:11

It's pretty normal. I literally did not buy 1 thing for my kid for like a year. Just recycle, regift, resell .

GoodChat · 14/04/2023 19:04

I'm a baker so I will get a card with a picture of DD on and ask DMIL to take it into work with some cupcakes for everyone to share as a thank you.

That's a lovely idea OP!

pilates · 14/04/2023 18:47

It sounds like DMIL is popular at work and they are pleased she has a longed for grandchild. Perhaps a gentle chat saying you are overwhelmed with the generosity but you are running out of storage room.

bluebeardswife7 · 14/04/2023 18:20

Even I want to buy your baby a gift now and I don't even know where you are. <peri menopausal twitch>

ChristmasJumpers · 14/04/2023 18:08

Thanks all, I've read every response and I feel much less guilty about passing some of the extra cardigans and blankets on to a charity or refuge now, I honestly thought it would be rude to do so as they have been knitted especially for us! The spare bouncer and a few spare blankets and outfits can live at DM and DMILs houses for when we visit 🥰

I'm a baker so I will get a card with a picture of DD on and ask DMIL to take it into work with some cupcakes for everyone to share as a thank you.

OP posts:
LetsBekindx · 14/04/2023 17:38

i think be grateful and anything you dont want wont use donate to someone in need.

Mumma212 · 14/04/2023 17:29

Tontostitis · 14/04/2023 10:43

As a crochet blanket maker I'm gutted to read this

I think it’s just typical MN ungratefulness on this thread.
I honestly think most people that receive hand made gifts would be really appreciative.
Even if maybe they do end up with more than they think they need.

My daughter, who was born last year was gifted lots of lovely hand made things.
Some made by close family and friends and some by friends of family members that I don’t know personally.
I’m grateful for them all and wouldn’t part with any of them.
I really appreciate the time and effort that’s gone in to choosing patterns, colours and crocheting/knitting something unique specially for my baby.
They’re definitely the items I’ll hold on to even when they’re outgrown.
There’s plenty cheap mass produced stuff from shops I can pass on.

Mumma212 · 14/04/2023 17:12

Charlottewebsbabies · 13/04/2023 11:26

I remember 23 years ago,I gave birth to ds (no 3 baby)

Single mum with little money at the time

I didn't know I was pregnant until the Monday and gave birth on the Saturday

I had loads of baby stuff due to the other two-then aged 2 and 1

Everyone I knew (and a lot I didnt) sent so much stuff,I couldn't move in my lounge and bedroom

At one point I had 5 cots,3 highchairs,over 50 bags of baby clothes (both for a girl or a boy),two travel cots,6 baby baths,a toddler bed,2 carrier bags of hand knitted baby cardis,4 carrier bags of baby hats/socks,half of boots baby department and 8 changing bags

Oh and someone very kindly gave me 4 packets of newborn baby nappies and a bag full of wipes-all in those 6 days before I gave birth

I dreaded opening the door at one point

I was (still am) amazed at people's generosity but I still feel a bit overwhelmed at how much stuff we got

I know everyone meant well,it was just a bit,well,much

I ended up calling a charity shop and they came and took a lot away for me-i still feel guilty but it was overwhelming at the time

I think it's just because people love a new baby (I know I do!) And to them it's just a baby blanket and best wishes on your baby

But to you,it's another baby blanket that you have 15 of already!

I’m impressed you can remember all that from over 20 years ago.
It does sounds like an awful lot.
I’m not sure I’d even fit all that in my little house.

swayingpalmtree · 14/04/2023 17:04

YANBU. I've been in tears before as I was just buried with all the clutter of the random crap people were giving us. It's not very kind to cause a new parent that much extra stress even if it was well intentioned

This is a really unkind thing to say- this isnt "random crap" they've been meaning to throw out- these are things they have bought as gifts or hand made themselves by knitting them- calling it crap is incredibly mean spirited and nasty

Sugarfree23 · 14/04/2023 16:01

Loveyou3000 · 14/04/2023 15:56

YANBU. I've been in tears before as I was just buried with all the clutter of the random crap people were giving us. It's not very kind to cause a new parent that much extra stress even if it was well intentioned.

This doesn't sound like 'random crap' that people have passed on because they no longer need it.
This sounds like gifts that people have spent money on and possibly a lot of time on too if they are knitted or crocheted.

Op I would as someone else suggested take anything from M&S or Next back and get a gift card. I exchanged loads of baby stuff for gift cards and then bought stuff as I needed it in bigger sizes.