Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a serious error and the resolution doesn’t really cut it

438 replies

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 08:01

Visited a well known chain restaurant, early in the week so it wasn’t busy, only about six tables tables taken. I was with my daughter, asked if I could have a table instead of a booth, as I have an assistance dog. My dog is a small/medium size, and was wearing his harness. I got asked if he was a guide dog, I said no an assistance dog. He then asked what that meant. I explained that the dog helps me with tasks that help me live my daily life. He then asked what exactly that meant. So I explained I have neurological damage after breaking my neck, and I can’t feel my fingers so drop things and the dog retrieves them. I also explained I have balance issues, so bending down without falling over is a problem. I then got asked if it was a guide dog again. I said no. He then said you can’t come in because it’s not a guide dog and you’re not blind!! I am not a confrontational person so I just said ok, we’ll just go the restaurant next door, (which is owned by the same group) as they always welcome me. The next day I rang head office and they admitted that what he did is unlawful, and they would do some staff training. Turning away a disabled person because of their equipment is a serious issue. Dogs are classed as auxiliary aids same as wheelchairs. I have been offered £20, I think they’ve got off lightly. What do mumsnetters think?

YABU-restaurants can choose who dines
YANBU-it’s discrimination

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
aibuaibuaibu · 13/04/2023 18:50

Go back and tell them what you want,,..

DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 18:17

CurlyhairedAssassin · 13/04/2023 17:19

There is a lot of misunderstanding about blue badges. So many people don't know that the driver themself doesn't have to be disabled, for example. They could easily be dropping a disabled passenger off. They are also only for use for on-street parking. Supermarket and hospital parking will have their own rules (disabled spaces etc).

If the council has issued a blue badge then they have assessed the need for one and approved its use. Why anyone would think they know better than the council I have no idea.

Blue badges are also required to park in disabled spaces in supermarkets, and in hospitals - same rules apply as on street. Where supermarket/hospital car parks are run by independent companies they will fine those parking in disabled spaces without a valid blue badge.

I agree with you about the misunderstandings though. Another one is that the blue badge has to be displayed all the time. I pulled into a supermarket space once, and was rummaging in my bag for the badge and clock - was jolted by a rap on the window and someone pointing out that the space was for badge holders only. When I showed them the badge they were insistent that it should be displayed at all times and in the end I had to show them the handbook which advised the exact opposite, for a number of reasons, including inappropriate use by any other users of the car, and the high number of badge thefts. It should only be displayed once the holder has parked.

I think where people think they know better than the authorising body is when the disability isn’t immediately obvious. I don’t look disabled until I get out of the car - I’m a wheelchair user, and it’s not apparent when I’m behind the wheel. I’ve been challenged many times and some people have insisted I tell them what my disability is, presumably so they can ‘decide’ if I’m worthy of the space !! I actually used to explain, but not any more. I just smile and show them the badge and tell them it’s been legally issued to me and that’s all they need to know, unless they’re traffic or law enforcement. I’ve been told I ‘don’t look disabled’ and my answer is always to ask how they think someone disabled should look. I’m amazed at how persistent some people can be - it’s like they feel perfectly entitled to grill you for every detail.

whyhelloo · 13/04/2023 18:13

alloalloallo · 13/04/2023 15:50

Oh, people do vocalise these thoughts in real life too.

My daughter has a disabled bus pass (unfortunately it’s bright orange and not very discrete) and she’s forever being questioned by randoms as to why she should have it, that she “doesn’t look disabled”, that she’s “too young to be disabled”, that she must be faking, that the bus pass is fake, why can’t they travel for free, etc, etc.

We had to provide proof of her disability to the local authority, they accepted that proof and issued it based on her meeting their criteria. She shouldn’t have to explain herself to self appointed busy bodies - and she generally doesn’t, but you know, people are arseholes and won’t give it a rest.

Oh invalidation of non visible disabilities definitely common, but I was thinking more of spiteful comments like I feel sorry for your dog etc, and variations I've seen on MN - I feel sorry for your husband/mum/children - said with malice

CurlyhairedAssassin · 13/04/2023 17:40

MarkWithaC · 13/04/2023 17:14

I'm afraid I find your justification very disingenuous. You could easily have phrased your questions so that it was clear that you wondered how she did it, rather than sounding like you were sceptical that she did it.

And the closing 'Perhaps now as a result of this thread we all understand a bit more about how and why assistance dogs might be used' I also find disingenuous, and very cynical indeed.

Well I'm sad for you that you're such a cynical person. And also that you are quick to make assumptions about people and jump on someone if you've misunderstood the intent of a question rather than asking them to clarify what they mean first. Like I said, MN used to be the place I came to for open, honest and patient discussion. It used to be a place where if someone came to a thread displaying an opinion that suggested a lack of knowledge of something, an interchange would take place, and that person would often have their opinion changed, for the better. It was so refreshing and a true place of education and influence.

Lately it has just turned into people jumping to dramatic conclusions prematurely and rather than trying to influence someone's opinion with a view to changing it they just start throwing accusations wrong. It's a shame because it's a lost opportunity.

There have been a few posts that have been really helpful. Whoever posted this link - thankyou. https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/sites/default/files/assistance-dogs-a-guide-for-all-businesses.pdf

It was really informative and I learned things I didn't know, and followed to the link to the website Sherlock Hounds which explained exactly how the dogs are trained for anyone, like me, who is interested.

Thankyou to the OP for giving more details about exactly how she managed to go from needing an assistance dog to having a fully trained one, and what it means to her have one. I'm sorry about the loss of the life you had before, including your horses, and salute you for finding solutions to help you adjust to your new life.

https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/sites/default/files/assistance-dogs-a-guide-for-all-businesses.pdf

CurlyhairedAssassin · 13/04/2023 17:19

DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 16:02

I’ve had this with my blue badge. When these arseholes say ‘you don’t look disabled’ ask them what they think a disabled person should look like. Alternatively tell them your condition is between you and your doctor, and if the relevant authorities have seen fit to issue a bus pass, what business is it of theirs. I find that shuts most people up.

There is a lot of misunderstanding about blue badges. So many people don't know that the driver themself doesn't have to be disabled, for example. They could easily be dropping a disabled passenger off. They are also only for use for on-street parking. Supermarket and hospital parking will have their own rules (disabled spaces etc).

If the council has issued a blue badge then they have assessed the need for one and approved its use. Why anyone would think they know better than the council I have no idea.

sandgrown · 13/04/2023 17:14

In my shop we have a young couple who insist their chihuahua is an assistance dog . The dog does not have an official jacket. The owner has seizures and apparently the dog can tell when one is going to happen. Not sure how this works when he is being walked by the partner !

MarkWithaC · 13/04/2023 17:14

CurlyhairedAssassin · 13/04/2023 17:04

I think you've totally misread some people's intentions. I personally was wondering HOW ("how" meaning "method", not "how on earth" in a disbelieving sense) someone who needs an assistance dog to help them trains a puppy themselves from scratch in the first place, as puppies are very demanding and it doesn't seem to fit the lifestyle of someone with needs. That's a valid point as I only know about guide dogs and the way they are trained. I had no idea about OP's injuries, her recovery or what help she had prior to the point of the dog being fully trained, hence my interest. The fact that I asked does not mean that I disbelieved that it was possible.

I do get fed up of people thinking the worst of others on here these days when they're often simply trying to understand someone else's position. It never used to be like this here. You used to be able to ask people about the reality of living a different life to your own, particularly with regards to disability and LEARN something from them relayng their experiences without getting accused of accusing THEM of lying, or spreading bile. Without posters being professionally offended on the OP's behalf and apologising to them for the "appalling" act of having to disclose personal information. We will never learn from each other if disabilities, especially hidden ones, and the things that help people to manage life with them, are not talked about openly, on a DISCUSSION forum.

The OP has kindly explained now how she came to need the dog, how it became trained, how it helps her. Perhaps now as a result of this thread we all understand a bit more about how and why assistance dogs might be used. There are a few posters that had not even heard of them, and I bet most of us had had no idea before that people can train them themselves.

I'm afraid I find your justification very disingenuous. You could easily have phrased your questions so that it was clear that you wondered how she did it, rather than sounding like you were sceptical that she did it.

And the closing 'Perhaps now as a result of this thread we all understand a bit more about how and why assistance dogs might be used' I also find disingenuous, and very cynical indeed.

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 13/04/2023 17:09

Tealsofa · 13/04/2023 16:21

This is where I was (clumsilly) going (and today I cannot spell either)

As there are avenues where people can take advantage by pretending something they are not, sadly official passes are needed.

I cannot buy a blue badge, and therefore cannot park in a blue badge bay
I can buy a harness, or make my own and pretend I am disabled to gain advantage.

So surely having a pass to say "yes this is an official assistance animal" could be a good thing?

I agree with this. It shouldn't be necessary, but because some people are horrible, selfish idiots (see the Guardian piece linked earlier) they make it difficult for people with genuinely needed assistance dogs to be taken seriously.

We have to navigate the world as it is, not the world as it should be.

DonnaBanana · 13/04/2023 17:08

They should just call them all one term to prevent confusion. They’re all ultimately guide dogs or assistance dogs or working dogs or whatever.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 13/04/2023 17:07

Domino20 · 13/04/2023 15:54

Jesus this thread is an eye opener! Clearly the OP should just always stay at home, how dare the injured and disabled try to find enjoyment and meaning in life.

I'm sorry, who has said that? You're being ridiculous and stirring things up for the sake of it.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 13/04/2023 17:05

That was to @MarkWithaC

CurlyhairedAssassin · 13/04/2023 17:04

MarkWithaC · 13/04/2023 15:46

I think it's appalling, OP, that you've had to disclose so much personal detail on here in the face of so much ill-informed opinion and straight-up spite.
Let's just hope none of those having a pop at you or your dog ever find themselves on the other side of things and having to negotiate through a disability on top of the associated bureaucracy and the (manifestly still rife) ignorance and bile that is displayed by so many on here.

I think you've totally misread some people's intentions. I personally was wondering HOW ("how" meaning "method", not "how on earth" in a disbelieving sense) someone who needs an assistance dog to help them trains a puppy themselves from scratch in the first place, as puppies are very demanding and it doesn't seem to fit the lifestyle of someone with needs. That's a valid point as I only know about guide dogs and the way they are trained. I had no idea about OP's injuries, her recovery or what help she had prior to the point of the dog being fully trained, hence my interest. The fact that I asked does not mean that I disbelieved that it was possible.

I do get fed up of people thinking the worst of others on here these days when they're often simply trying to understand someone else's position. It never used to be like this here. You used to be able to ask people about the reality of living a different life to your own, particularly with regards to disability and LEARN something from them relayng their experiences without getting accused of accusing THEM of lying, or spreading bile. Without posters being professionally offended on the OP's behalf and apologising to them for the "appalling" act of having to disclose personal information. We will never learn from each other if disabilities, especially hidden ones, and the things that help people to manage life with them, are not talked about openly, on a DISCUSSION forum.

The OP has kindly explained now how she came to need the dog, how it became trained, how it helps her. Perhaps now as a result of this thread we all understand a bit more about how and why assistance dogs might be used. There are a few posters that had not even heard of them, and I bet most of us had had no idea before that people can train them themselves.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 13/04/2023 16:56

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 16:21

No, I'm fucking not.

I've not said one single fucking word about what the experience of being disabled is.

That is the entire fucking point I am making

Unlike the many, many white posters on this thread who feel confident in saying things like:"Discrimination such as this is actually a human rights issue and I can't help but feel that there would be far more outrage if the discrimination was aimed at other groups im society."

I don't go around claiming to know what other people's lived experience is, but many posters on this thread are so fucking confident that they know what it's like to experience racism. (Or not experience it, because as far as they're concerned, it never happens and if it did there would be outrage.)

You absolutely have claimed to know about what it is like to experience being disabled. In fact, you went further than that, you dismissed it. See here from your post of 16.12:

“always feel so confident in declaring things like:

it’s the one that seems to carry the least in the way of penalties.

Disabled people are attacked, abused and ridiculed and the police are reluctant to prosecute as hate crimes.

it's the only acceptable form of prejudice”

Do you not see that what you’ve done here is dismiss the poster’s assertion that hate crimes against disabled people are often not prosecuted? Do you recall reading or hearing much about prosecutions taken against discrimination against the disabled? Because I can assure you, they’re not abundant.

Many disabled people have experience of people happily overlooking them and discriminating against them and the prevailing attitude to be indifference towards that, rather than outrage. But you wouldn’t know about that because you don’t live it, and it’s not a big issue for anyone else, it seems.

Disabled people want it to be taken seriously when they’re discriminated against. It’s not that they’re saying racism is tackled perfectly. It’s that they’re saying it is their perception that discrimination against the disabled is taken even less seriously than some other forms of discrimination. There’s a difference.

You can swear at me all you like, if you think that’s acceptable. It’s clearly struck a nerve. All the more baffling why you don’t understand that disabled people don’t enjoy being discriminated against either.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 16:41

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 16:12

It's isn't 'less valid' It's you, and multiple other posters on this thread (and I've seen the same thing, often, on other threads) who ALWAYS have to start comparing disability discrimination with racial discrimination and always feel so confident in declaring things like:

it’s the one that seems to carry the least in the way of penalties.

Disabled people are attacked, abused and ridiculed and the police are reluctant to prosecute as hate crimes.

it's the only acceptable form of prejudice

they would come down like a ton of bricks if it was racial discrimination

All of which is absolute bullshit. I don't tell you what your life is like as a disabled person, but you and multiple other posters on this thread have repeatedly (and it is repeatedly, it's in at least 15 to 20 different posts on this thread if not more) stated that disabled people 'have it worst', 'are treated worse', 'there would be an outcry if it was racial discrimination'.

Fucking bullshit.

So you think that disabled people being attacked, abused and ridiculed, and the police doing nothing about it is fucking bullshit do you ? You have that lived experience do you ? Because I do. I am judged every single day, not by who I am, or what my capabilities are, but by my disability. I have had to fight to be included in education and employment on equal terms with non disabled people, despite being equally or better qualified. I have been discriminated against in healthcare and denied entry to various establishments as a ‘fire hazard, among other lazy excuses for people who can’t be bothered to respect my legal right to inclusion.

People see the disability first and foremost. Everything else that I am comes second until I prove myself. I could go on. Is any of this familiar to you ? Do you not see any similarity ? I can’t possibly know the full impact of discrimination simply because of the colour of my skin, just as you can never know the same because of a disability. But there is common ground. And at no point did I ever state that disabled people ‘have it worst’. What I said was that there seems to be the least amount of recourse for this type of discrimination, because despite there supposedly being laws in place to deal with it, it’s routinely disregarded and when disabled people complain, they’re treated as a nuisance. Why do you insist that in asserting my rights as a disabled person, I’m denying you yours as a person of colour ?

niugboo · 13/04/2023 16:41

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 15:37

The opinions on here are very interesting. The overriding opinion seems to be that if you are disabled it should be blatantly obvious. It’s been questioned how I pick poo up, I gave an answer to that and then was told they feel sorry for my dog, because I ask it to go toilet before going out. It is this very training that stops a trained assistance dog from fouling in an establishment. It’s been questioned how I even can have a puppy and train it, I have three adult children who consecutively booked time off work, to help with the very early stages. They have seen how I have worked hard to learn to walk again and make it look normal. The neurological symptoms I experience are still there. I have just kept trying to improve and now at least people don’t think I’m drunk, when I walk. My dog picks things up a lot for me because I drop things a lot, on account of having incorrect feeling in my fingers. I probably drop more things in the six hours I can be on my feet, that most people drop in a month. The feeling in my fingers cause nausea and sometimes triggers dizziness. The opinion seems if you’re disabled you shouldn’t do anything that appears normal or your disability isn’t real. I’ve been accused of lying on here, my dog is registered and has passed exams and is owner trained with the guidance of an assistance dog charity. My dog helps me do the everyday things that most people take for granted, that I also took for granted. My life changed from an accident in my home, there’s been a lot of loss, most of all my three horses, as I couldn’t care for them. My dog gives me purpose to keep trying and helps with the difficult bits. I think society as a whole needs more empathy.

Want to share who you registered it with?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 16:22

FinallyFoundIt · 13/04/2023 12:58

I've never heard of assistance dogs. Why didn't you just say it was a guide dog? It falls in to the same category, and would have meant you had no hassle - why the need to be so specific?

Because she’s clearly not blind, so rather than there being no hassle, it would create more hassle as to why a guide dog was necessary for a seeing person.

Tealsofa · 13/04/2023 16:21

Theluggage15 · 13/04/2023 15:50

I can buy a harness on Amazon for a tenner, can’t buy a blue badge there. That’s the whole point, anyone can pretend their dog is an assistance dog and they do.

This is where I was (clumsilly) going (and today I cannot spell either)

As there are avenues where people can take advantage by pretending something they are not, sadly official passes are needed.

I cannot buy a blue badge, and therefore cannot park in a blue badge bay
I can buy a harness, or make my own and pretend I am disabled to gain advantage.

So surely having a pass to say "yes this is an official assistance animal" could be a good thing?

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 16:21

ATerrorofLeftovers · 13/04/2023 16:18

Are you disabled? Are you speaking from lived experience? Because if you’re not, then telling disabled people what their experience is, and where you think it ranks, is as offensive and unacceptable as it would be for a white person to tell you how you experience racism.

No, I'm fucking not.

I've not said one single fucking word about what the experience of being disabled is.

That is the entire fucking point I am making

Unlike the many, many white posters on this thread who feel confident in saying things like:"Discrimination such as this is actually a human rights issue and I can't help but feel that there would be far more outrage if the discrimination was aimed at other groups im society."

I don't go around claiming to know what other people's lived experience is, but many posters on this thread are so fucking confident that they know what it's like to experience racism. (Or not experience it, because as far as they're concerned, it never happens and if it did there would be outrage.)

ATerrorofLeftovers · 13/04/2023 16:18

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 16:12

It's isn't 'less valid' It's you, and multiple other posters on this thread (and I've seen the same thing, often, on other threads) who ALWAYS have to start comparing disability discrimination with racial discrimination and always feel so confident in declaring things like:

it’s the one that seems to carry the least in the way of penalties.

Disabled people are attacked, abused and ridiculed and the police are reluctant to prosecute as hate crimes.

it's the only acceptable form of prejudice

they would come down like a ton of bricks if it was racial discrimination

All of which is absolute bullshit. I don't tell you what your life is like as a disabled person, but you and multiple other posters on this thread have repeatedly (and it is repeatedly, it's in at least 15 to 20 different posts on this thread if not more) stated that disabled people 'have it worst', 'are treated worse', 'there would be an outcry if it was racial discrimination'.

Fucking bullshit.

Are you disabled? Are you speaking from lived experience? Because if you’re not, then telling disabled people what their experience is, and where you think it ranks, is as offensive and unacceptable as it would be for a white person to tell you how you experience racism.

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 16:17

Can you imagine if the restaurant had turned away someone because of the colour of their skin? Or visibly of a certain religion? Everyone would be up in arms and heads would be rolling at head office.

from page 3 of this thread. Absolute fucking minimising bullshit. Yeah right. Because no one of a visibly different race or religion is ever refused service, and if it ever were to happen, 'heads would roll'. I mean, if you are unable to see how massively stupid, ignorant and offensive this is, I don't know where else to start.

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 16:14

@DotAndCarryOne2 The shorter version of that is that there is no fucking need for posters to constantly try to 'compare and contrast' forms of discrimination and, in doing so, implicitly devalue and deny the actual experiences of racism which non-white people live through every day. It's a thread about assistance dogs and disability discrimination. There is no need for a load of white people to start mouthing off about how much better they would be treated if they were at risk of racial discrimination, rather than for being disabled. Leave racism out of it. It is completely inappropriate and insulting to use this false comparison to try to make a point about being 'the most oppressed'

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 16:12

DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 16:06

Don’t twist my words, that’s not what I’m saying. Why is my experience as a disabled person any less valid than yours as a non white person ? I’ve been verbally attacked and threatened because of my disability and the police weren’t interested in classifying it as discrimination or a hate crime. We should be united in our experience shouldn’t we ?

It's isn't 'less valid' It's you, and multiple other posters on this thread (and I've seen the same thing, often, on other threads) who ALWAYS have to start comparing disability discrimination with racial discrimination and always feel so confident in declaring things like:

it’s the one that seems to carry the least in the way of penalties.

Disabled people are attacked, abused and ridiculed and the police are reluctant to prosecute as hate crimes.

it's the only acceptable form of prejudice

they would come down like a ton of bricks if it was racial discrimination

All of which is absolute bullshit. I don't tell you what your life is like as a disabled person, but you and multiple other posters on this thread have repeatedly (and it is repeatedly, it's in at least 15 to 20 different posts on this thread if not more) stated that disabled people 'have it worst', 'are treated worse', 'there would be an outcry if it was racial discrimination'.

Fucking bullshit.

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 16:10

l was told by my neurologist that with my injury I shouldn’t be here, let alone walking and talking. I feel that I have been given a second chance and I am not going to waste it by naming and shaming or persuing court action, that is negative and potentially a load of hassle, that I don’t need. I am very lucky to be alive, and that’s why I try not to engage with negative people. My lesson has been learnt, in that respect, I will not post on MN again. Thank you to every one who showed understanding and to those struggling with disability, stay strong, you’re not alone. I will walk myinterestingnewpath with my head held high (as I can) and with dignity.

OP posts:
DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 16:09

Theluggage15 · 13/04/2023 15:50

I can buy a harness on Amazon for a tenner, can’t buy a blue badge there. That’s the whole point, anyone can pretend their dog is an assistance dog and they do.

So that excuses the OP’s experience does it ?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 16:06

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 16:02

Yeah, you're right. Non-white people get a really easy ride and police are always extremely keen to prosecute all of those who racially discriminate against and abuse us.

Don’t twist my words, that’s not what I’m saying. Why is my experience as a disabled person any less valid than yours as a non white person ? I’ve been verbally attacked and threatened because of my disability and the police weren’t interested in classifying it as discrimination or a hate crime. We should be united in our experience shouldn’t we ?