Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a serious error and the resolution doesn’t really cut it

438 replies

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 08:01

Visited a well known chain restaurant, early in the week so it wasn’t busy, only about six tables tables taken. I was with my daughter, asked if I could have a table instead of a booth, as I have an assistance dog. My dog is a small/medium size, and was wearing his harness. I got asked if he was a guide dog, I said no an assistance dog. He then asked what that meant. I explained that the dog helps me with tasks that help me live my daily life. He then asked what exactly that meant. So I explained I have neurological damage after breaking my neck, and I can’t feel my fingers so drop things and the dog retrieves them. I also explained I have balance issues, so bending down without falling over is a problem. I then got asked if it was a guide dog again. I said no. He then said you can’t come in because it’s not a guide dog and you’re not blind!! I am not a confrontational person so I just said ok, we’ll just go the restaurant next door, (which is owned by the same group) as they always welcome me. The next day I rang head office and they admitted that what he did is unlawful, and they would do some staff training. Turning away a disabled person because of their equipment is a serious issue. Dogs are classed as auxiliary aids same as wheelchairs. I have been offered £20, I think they’ve got off lightly. What do mumsnetters think?

YABU-restaurants can choose who dines
YANBU-it’s discrimination

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
DotAndCarryOne2 · 14/04/2023 17:31

Thelnebriati · 14/04/2023 14:03

Genuine assistance dogs are highly trained and won't cause an issue, and thats the answer.
If the dog causes and issue the business owner can ask the dog owner to leave.

The dog wasn’t causing a problem and the OP was still asked to leave. Where’s the answer to that ?

Thelnebriati · 14/04/2023 14:03

Genuine assistance dogs are highly trained and won't cause an issue, and thats the answer.
If the dog causes and issue the business owner can ask the dog owner to leave.

Redlocks30 · 14/04/2023 13:46

Interestingly, that pamphlet doesn’t actually answer a lot of the questions put to it. All of the ‘what do I do of the dog does x/y/z?’ questions are basically answered with ‘Well, they won’t, as they are highly trained by their owners’. If there is no standardised system is in place, it’s open to individual interpretation.

Thelnebriati · 14/04/2023 13:13

@Redlocks30 I posted a link upthread by the EHRC that answers this question.

Assistance dogs can be owner trained and there is no requirement for them to be registered or carry ID.
https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/sites/default/files/assistance-dogs-a-guide-for-all-businesses.pdf

https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/sites/default/files/assistance-dogs-a-guide-for-all-businesses.pdf

Zumzum · 14/04/2023 09:54

i think this thread is concrete proof of why a specific ,certified, country wide recognisable scheme is needed. Theres a good reason why the blue badge scheme is set up as it is, it's highly open to abuse and people are regularly fined for abusing their relatives/friends blue badges by using them for their own needs. Somebody taking advantage of a blue badge directly impacts on those needing to use their passes for essential use and its exactly the same for assistance dogs. The US in particular shows how quickly this can escalate, i think someone linked to the article about support pigs, peacocks and horses! It is easy to claim a dog is an assistance dog but this impacts on those likewise needing their dogs for essential purposes, and an ill-trained dog that is supposedly an official assistance dog will only make people less understanding & tolerant of those that do need their dogs for specific roles.

OhwhyOY · 14/04/2023 09:46

@Myinterestingnewpath I'm so sorry you feel like you shouldn't post on mumsnet any more and that you've had some horrendous responses from some people. I hope at least some people on here have been educated about different forms of disability and the impact discrimination has. My mum has a hidden disability that sometimes leaves her unable to walk, talk, or even think properly. She often has people question her bus pass, blue badge etc despite the fact that she can only walk a few steps and often needs a wheelchair. I don't know why people can't just mind their own business rather than always assuming the worst.

SophieJo · 14/04/2023 09:45

ZeroWorshipHere · 13/04/2023 08:11

Was your dog wearing an assistance dog jacket?

Have you answered this question?

Redlocks30 · 14/04/2023 09:40

HecticHedgehog · 13/04/2023 23:23

Funnily enough I had to do some research on this a year or so ago. only dogs for the blind or deaf are legally classed as assistance dogs. For anything else it's a bit of a grey area. Would be interesting to see how a court would interpret it.

That’s interesting. Could someone with eg anxiety say their dog is an assistance dog and take it into a normally dog-free pub/restaurant on those grounds?

Is there specific training or licensing/certification needed to show this? Perhaps there should be.

Yawningalldaylong · 14/04/2023 09:35

HecticHedgehog · 13/04/2023 23:23

Funnily enough I had to do some research on this a year or so ago. only dogs for the blind or deaf are legally classed as assistance dogs. For anything else it's a bit of a grey area. Would be interesting to see how a court would interpret it.

I find this really interesting. I'd really like to see the source of this, articles and definitions often don't differentiate between the type of assistance dog. Where in law does it define which assistance dogs the law covers?

Government papers describe assistance dogs as those 'trained in order to provide assistance to disabled people or those with certain medical conditions such as epilepsy' but I've not seen it state only a certain disability.

HecticHedgehog · 13/04/2023 23:23

Funnily enough I had to do some research on this a year or so ago. only dogs for the blind or deaf are legally classed as assistance dogs. For anything else it's a bit of a grey area. Would be interesting to see how a court would interpret it.

ZombieKettle · 13/04/2023 21:55

Looneytune253 · 13/04/2023 20:51

@DotAndCarryOne2 but surely that means that anyone can take their dog as an 'assistance dog' without being properly trained. My child has autism and they love the dog. Does that mean we can call him an assistance dog and take home everywhere with us?

If your dog helps prevent meltdowns and helps to regulate their emotions and keep them safe then you could argue it's an assistance dog. (I'm a mum to a disabled child). There's a charity that provides training to disabled people to train their pet dogs into assistance dogs.

breakingintopieces · 13/04/2023 21:45

I don't think the OP should need to disclose what disability they have. But I do think a working dog should be able to prove its status as a trained working dog, ideally at a glance by wearing an official harness that can't be bought from the likes of Amazon. It's always obvious that a guide dog is a working dog as they all tend to be the same breed, and they all have a special harness - plus, of course, it's obvious from their behaviour.

It sounds like other types of working dogs can't be readily identified, and that's a problem, both for the owner and for businesses such as restaurants. I think this is the serious problem that needs to be addressed, not how this one waiter behaved.

Maybe there's a gap for a charity to come forward and take ownership of this issue.

Mangolist · 13/04/2023 21:11

I'm so sorry about the horrendous and rude responses on here OP. I have a hidden disability too and luckily can manage with very small almost imperceptible adjustments, but you clearly need your dog. I hope your life continues to move forward well

Dobby123456 · 13/04/2023 21:10

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 15:37

The opinions on here are very interesting. The overriding opinion seems to be that if you are disabled it should be blatantly obvious. It’s been questioned how I pick poo up, I gave an answer to that and then was told they feel sorry for my dog, because I ask it to go toilet before going out. It is this very training that stops a trained assistance dog from fouling in an establishment. It’s been questioned how I even can have a puppy and train it, I have three adult children who consecutively booked time off work, to help with the very early stages. They have seen how I have worked hard to learn to walk again and make it look normal. The neurological symptoms I experience are still there. I have just kept trying to improve and now at least people don’t think I’m drunk, when I walk. My dog picks things up a lot for me because I drop things a lot, on account of having incorrect feeling in my fingers. I probably drop more things in the six hours I can be on my feet, that most people drop in a month. The feeling in my fingers cause nausea and sometimes triggers dizziness. The opinion seems if you’re disabled you shouldn’t do anything that appears normal or your disability isn’t real. I’ve been accused of lying on here, my dog is registered and has passed exams and is owner trained with the guidance of an assistance dog charity. My dog helps me do the everyday things that most people take for granted, that I also took for granted. My life changed from an accident in my home, there’s been a lot of loss, most of all my three horses, as I couldn’t care for them. My dog gives me purpose to keep trying and helps with the difficult bits. I think society as a whole needs more empathy.

It's really impressive how you're getting on with your life OP. I think I would have given up on going to restaurants myself in your position. Being honest, I've never heard of an assistance dog before. I'd probably have been as confused as the waiter why you needed the dog. I don't think a disability needs to be visible, but some kind of special collar or tag for the dog would help. Not quite sure why people are so against this idea.

Looneytune253 · 13/04/2023 20:51

@DotAndCarryOne2 but surely that means that anyone can take their dog as an 'assistance dog' without being properly trained. My child has autism and they love the dog. Does that mean we can call him an assistance dog and take home everywhere with us?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 20:39

Looneytune253 · 13/04/2023 20:35

Is this an officially trained assistance dog or not. I think that makes a difference to the opinions to be fair.

It’s already been established that it doesn’t need to be - there’s a link upthread somewhere.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 20:36

KittyAlfred · 13/04/2023 19:20

I’m not disabled in any way, but I like to park near the entrance at places. Would you be happy for me to take the last remaining disabled space in a car park, if I didn’t have a blue badge? I could just say I had a hidden disability, and you were being rude to ask what it was. And no, I wouldn’t have a badge, my word should be enough. You’d just have to accept seeing me take the space, and you would either have to manage a longer walk, or go home and come back later. Would you be happy with that?
Blue badges were designed to reduce the risk of this happening, and that’s why people are saying that “self declaration” shouldn’t be enough.

That’s not how it works, and it’s not what blue badges were designed to do. They were designed so that genuinely disabled people would know they have conveniently placed designated parking close to amenities. To park in a disabled space, you need a blue badge. That’s how people know you’re disabled, and it doesn’t need explanation. You can’t just park in one because you feel like it. I’m a disabled driver and I acknowledge the fact that if I forget to take my badge out when I leave the house, I won’t be able to park in a disabled space - my disability is not the get out of jail card you seem to think it is.

Looneytune253 · 13/04/2023 20:35

Is this an officially trained assistance dog or not. I think that makes a difference to the opinions to be fair.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 20:29

KittyAlfred · 13/04/2023 19:11

But what’s to stop me using a disabled toilet, parking in a disabled space, jumping a queue, bringing an animal to an inappropriate place - just for the hell of it? If no one is ever asked to demonstrate their need, then we can all claim a need. Then the people who are genuine lose out.

The Equality Act 2010 exists so that disabled people don’t have to answer those questions ad nauseam. If you attempted to park in a disabled space without a badge you would be fined, if you used a disabled toilet and there was no obvious disability you would probably be challenged and all you’d need to say was that you have a disability that’s not obvious - no one would question you as to what that disability was. Guide and assistance dogs are allowed in places that don’t normally allow dogs, and the reasons for them are, in the main, obvious. And I don’t know any disabled people who routinely jump queues just because they’re disabled. Can you imagine how hard life would get for people whose lives are already difficult, if the law allowed them to be grilled about their disability before being allowed to participate in normal life ? I would spend my life explaining myself.

KittyAlfred · 13/04/2023 19:22

GoodChat · 13/04/2023 19:13

@KittyAlfred OP demonstrated her need and was still turned away

Did she have paperwork? I missed that. Sorry.

KittyAlfred · 13/04/2023 19:20

SchoolTripDrama · 13/04/2023 13:21

@Bamboux Blatant ableism. Totally disregarding hidden disabilities. I have MS but I suppose people like you will just assume I'm 'helping myself' to disabled facilities! So to you, disabled toilets are only for "severely disabled" is that right? What about working, functioning adults who need space to empty their colostomy bags? Ffs

I also have fibromyalgia and I can tell you it's NOT self diagnosed AT ALL! I was diagnosed by Rheumatology and separate to my MS, I am in a LOT of pain daily. I certainly DO need disabled toilets.
Oh and I was awarded full PIP, a Motability car and a Blue Badge on the basis of fibromyalgia- I was diagnosed with MS after these were all awarded.

God your ableism is vile

I’m not disabled in any way, but I like to park near the entrance at places. Would you be happy for me to take the last remaining disabled space in a car park, if I didn’t have a blue badge? I could just say I had a hidden disability, and you were being rude to ask what it was. And no, I wouldn’t have a badge, my word should be enough. You’d just have to accept seeing me take the space, and you would either have to manage a longer walk, or go home and come back later. Would you be happy with that?
Blue badges were designed to reduce the risk of this happening, and that’s why people are saying that “self declaration” shouldn’t be enough.

aibuaibuaibu · 13/04/2023 19:17

@DotAndCarryOne2 go back and tell the company what you want.

Say I'm not after financial gain, I want you to acknowledge you acted illegally and perhaps this was due to poor training. I don't even know if non office jobs have training on diversity etc.

Say you want to speak to someone senior?

GoodChat · 13/04/2023 19:13

@KittyAlfred OP demonstrated her need and was still turned away

KittyAlfred · 13/04/2023 19:11

Jonei · 13/04/2023 12:42

The op has already told you the reason for the dog.

However, she doesn't have to tell you. And you (general you) have no right to demand this information from a disabled person. Because that is discrimination. And businesses need to understand their legal obligations around this. They wouldn't generally use Mumsnet as a basis for staff training. The equality act would be their place to start.

Of course, if there was something I really wanted to know, then there is always Google to discover what tasks assistance dogs might carry out. But no restaurant / business has the right to demand this information from individuals. Just like they don't have the right to ask why someone is in a wheelchair. They just are. That's all they need to know.

But what’s to stop me using a disabled toilet, parking in a disabled space, jumping a queue, bringing an animal to an inappropriate place - just for the hell of it? If no one is ever asked to demonstrate their need, then we can all claim a need. Then the people who are genuine lose out.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 13/04/2023 19:10

aibuaibuaibu · 13/04/2023 18:50

Go back and tell them what you want,,..

Having re-read the OP’s first post, I think a lot of people have misunderstood the question. I don’t think she’s after material compensation, it’s more that she feels the whole incident wasn’t given the weight it deserved, given that it was a form of discrimination. Granted, they have said that the employee will be trained, but I think it’s a measure of the lack of awareness of and adherence to the Equality Act that the employer clearly didn’t ensure that he had received the appropriate training before customer facing. Disability discrimination of this type is common and it is minimised, and the OP was right to stand up for her rights.