Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a serious error and the resolution doesn’t really cut it

438 replies

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 08:01

Visited a well known chain restaurant, early in the week so it wasn’t busy, only about six tables tables taken. I was with my daughter, asked if I could have a table instead of a booth, as I have an assistance dog. My dog is a small/medium size, and was wearing his harness. I got asked if he was a guide dog, I said no an assistance dog. He then asked what that meant. I explained that the dog helps me with tasks that help me live my daily life. He then asked what exactly that meant. So I explained I have neurological damage after breaking my neck, and I can’t feel my fingers so drop things and the dog retrieves them. I also explained I have balance issues, so bending down without falling over is a problem. I then got asked if it was a guide dog again. I said no. He then said you can’t come in because it’s not a guide dog and you’re not blind!! I am not a confrontational person so I just said ok, we’ll just go the restaurant next door, (which is owned by the same group) as they always welcome me. The next day I rang head office and they admitted that what he did is unlawful, and they would do some staff training. Turning away a disabled person because of their equipment is a serious issue. Dogs are classed as auxiliary aids same as wheelchairs. I have been offered £20, I think they’ve got off lightly. What do mumsnetters think?

YABU-restaurants can choose who dines
YANBU-it’s discrimination

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
LittleBlueBrioTrain · 13/04/2023 10:30

Theluggage15 · 13/04/2023 10:15

Anyone can call their dog an assistance dog. Only guide dogs are properly trained.

There are far more tha just guide dogs. There are officially recognised hearing dogs, disability assistance dogs, medical detection dogs

CalloohCallayFrabjousDay · 13/04/2023 10:30

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/04/2023 08:23

I actually think this is not a straightforward issue. I worked in an eye hospital where certified guide dogs were obviously welcome. Other patients would then try to bring "assistance dogs" to clinics, and their behaviour caused problems (growling, snarling, peeing), so we began to ask for evidence of training and certification.

Most of those dogs had no certification. They had not been received any training or testing, let alone the very extensive training and selection guide dogs receive before being certified. Their owners found their presence helpful and the dogs may fetch things for their owners, so the owners out an "assistance dog" coat on them and tried to bring them into spaces where dogs are not permitted. Unfortunately I think this is why businesses are not welcoming all "assistance dogs", and why it is important to bring proof of certification.

I think this should be done. There's nothing to stop people from saying that their pet is an "assistance animal" when it's just a family pet.

PoBaFla · 13/04/2023 10:29

I agree that anyone can buy a harness or tag and try to claim their pet is a service dog and legislation does need to be clarified, but that’s not on the OP.

I agree the legislation does need tightened to endure all assistance dogs are trained, certified and then welcomed everywhere.
I know a woman with MS who has trained her own assistance dog (with help from a trainer) to fetch, carry and pick up things for her at home.
But the dog has not been trained to behave in restaurants the way eg. a Guide dog would be as he simply hasn't had that level of exposure on work outside the house.

Rosula · 13/04/2023 10:28

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 10:24

Someone who would watch a person struggling to breathe and not help because they had no paperwork would be a sociopath, so it's a good thing you just invented that.

That's not really comparable to suggest that you carry round the paperwork that proves your dog is legally allowed to be in a place that other dogs aren't. It would have stopped this whole scenario from happening.

You've missed the point, Starting on a path of refusing to recognise disability unless someone has a badge or a piece of paper is the start of a slippery slope that leads to that sort of conduct. Society expects a reasonable amount of sensitivity to disability, not demands for proof before making standard accommodations. Obviously there is no issue that OP is disabled, witness the fact that the next door restaurant within the same group has no problems with accommodating the dog and head office offered compensation.

Thelnebriati · 13/04/2023 10:27

Who supports paying more tax to fund this new dog training and registration scheme?

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 10:24

Zumzum · 13/04/2023 09:46

i am likewise confused about the growth of "assistance dogs" when the role of the dog is to pick something off the floor in a restaurant??as someone else said if you are taking the dog out on your own how do you pick up your dogs poo??? if you are walking and mobile how does this dog help with your balance...your problems suggest you wouldn't be able to go out without assistance? if you are with someone else can't they pick stuff off the floor when you go out?? is your dog a registered assistance dog?

In answer to your question how do I pick up poo. First of all I can bend down, but to do so repeatedly in the course of a normal day, has a cumulative effect on the pressure in my neck. When the pressure builds I am more likely to fall. Secondly the dog is trained to toilet, on command, it’s something I’ve always trained in my dogs. Thirdly I have a raised patio and my dog is trained to toilet on that, so I can pick up from waist height. He usually goes on the patio before a walk. Walks are for his enrichment and my mental health. He very rarely poos on a walk, but I do manage to clean up on the rare occasion this happens. If I’m in danger of falling I would ask a fellow dog walker to oblige and offer to buy them a coffee.

OP posts:
KittyAlfred · 13/04/2023 10:24

I think YABU.

If you have an assistance dog that you want to take everywhere, you should keep the paperwork with you. Otherwise how can people know if you’re telling the truth? We could all pretend our dogs are assistance dogs.

Also, can’t your daughter pick things up for you?

AutumnColour89 · 13/04/2023 10:24

RoxTen · 13/04/2023 08:39

This is definitely an area where the law could do with tidied up. As others have said many problems have been caused by people just saying their dog (or other assorted animal) is an assistance dog. The animal has no training and causes problems. Airlines have I know tightened up on this.

Yes, I know people who are claiming their dog as an assistance dog but it's only assistance is being present iyswim. It's had no training, and in fact is less trained and would cause more of a nuisance in a restaurant than my pet dog.

I'm not clued up on the law, but lots of places locally seem to state guide or hearing dogs only.

This.

I worked in a Jobcentre around 5 years ago, and one of the customers used to bring in her dog in, dressed in a home-made "assistance" jacket. And it caused so many problems;

One of our colleagues was blind and had a registered guide dog, and the customer's dog kept barking at him while he was working. Whenever that customber visited, we also had to manage comments and complaints (not just from customers but also security contactors) that the customer's dog smelt so badly they couldn't be in the vicinity. When a manager spoke to the customer about her dog, she then filed a complaint against the staff member on the basis of discrimination.

Not that I'm suggesting your dog is badly behaved (or pungent) OP, I'm just trying to highlight the problems that venues face currently, and how a certification process (and legislation tightening) is much-needed.

I'm sure a lot of assistance dogs are perfectly well behaved, but without full training and certification etc, venues cant be sure that it won't cause problems. Or that it's not just a chancer taking advantage of a loophole to bring in a family pet. Because sadly the way it is at the moment, it's completely open to abuse.

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 10:24

Rosula · 13/04/2023 10:19

When it comes to demanding people produce proof of their disability, it's the start of a very slippery slope. Can you imagine? "Sorry, sir, for all I know you're in that wheelchair because you're lazy, unless you show me a badge I can't help you go up in the lift". "Sorry, madam, I know you claim to be pregnant, but unless you show me a badge I'm going to assume you're just lazy and I won't offer you a seat." "Unless you show me a badge, I'm going to assume that you're breathing badly for fun and I'm not going to help you find your inhaler".

Someone who would watch a person struggling to breathe and not help because they had no paperwork would be a sociopath, so it's a good thing you just invented that.

That's not really comparable to suggest that you carry round the paperwork that proves your dog is legally allowed to be in a place that other dogs aren't. It would have stopped this whole scenario from happening.

Mummyoflittledragon · 13/04/2023 10:21

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 09:32

@Chessetchelsea

So, official assistance dog, blatant discrimination, derisory £20 voucher offered as compensation. Can you imagine if the restaurant had turned away someone because of the colour of their skin? Or visibly of a certain religion? Everyone would be up in arms and heads would be rolling at head office. The attitude here seems to be there, there, dear. Nothing to worry about. Pipe down and be grateful for the voucher!

Op has said she'd be satisfied with a voucher , she just wants a more expensive one.

I'm not white. If I were refused service on the basis of my race, it wouldn't be the case that £80 rather than £20 would make it ok, and I wouldn't ever set foot in the place again.

The fact that op is just dissatisfied with the amount of the voucher is one indication that it's not a comparable situation.

The man was uninformed, not racist. And racism shouldn't be minimised like this

Both types of discrimination are the same under the 2010 Equality Act. I do understand that society sees racism as far more disturbing than disabelism, ableism or sex discrimination for example. This difference can be a big issue for a lot of disabled people and the disablism op experienced should not be minimised either.

As a disabled woman myself, casual ableism as well as casual disablism is very disturbing, frightening and can lead to me being physically injured. I can walk but do not use walking aids as they would be a hindrance. My disability rather like op’s is invisible.

I have a blue badge. Whenever I am out in public, I am constantly aware of just how vulnerable I am and how easily I could be knocked to the ground, which would be pretty catastrophic for me. I have chronic pain, fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue.

I was once discriminated against in an M&S changing room by a member of staff, who treated me like a child when I went to the disabled cubicle and humiliated me when I tried to explain I’m disabled. I was struggling to get a word in edge ways as she tried to usher me to a normal cubicle and berated me when I forcefully spoke over the top of her saying I am disabled.

I was with dd and she was about 7 at the time and we were both in tears. I haven’t been back to that shop since and she’s 14 now. It was an incredibly humiliating experience.

This isn’t my only experience. Eg I asked a young woman to keep their dog away from me as it was running around like a loon (big greyhound) and she screamed at me that I’m not as disabled as her mother (who owns the dog). Luckily I was next to a bush and could lean my whole body against it for support. Another time when I asked a man to help get someone’s dog away from me (the owner was over 100m away), he told me I should expect dogs to bounce around me and shouldn’t be walking where I was walking. I could go on…

Mariposista · 13/04/2023 10:20

This is awful. He was asking intrusive questions about your condition and what your dog's role in that is. He was on his harness, and I guess you had the correct proof that he was an assistance dog with you. That should be enough for anyone. He was hardly a bouncy puppy leaping all over the tables and seeing everywhere!

Rosula · 13/04/2023 10:19

When it comes to demanding people produce proof of their disability, it's the start of a very slippery slope. Can you imagine? "Sorry, sir, for all I know you're in that wheelchair because you're lazy, unless you show me a badge I can't help you go up in the lift". "Sorry, madam, I know you claim to be pregnant, but unless you show me a badge I'm going to assume you're just lazy and I won't offer you a seat." "Unless you show me a badge, I'm going to assume that you're breathing badly for fun and I'm not going to help you find your inhaler".

Thelnebriati · 13/04/2023 10:18

To raise awareness, since so many people are ignorant of the law?

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 13/04/2023 10:17

The next day I rang head office and they admitted that what he did is unlawful, and they would do some staff training.

They have admitted fault and said they will take action.

Why are you posting?

Theluggage15 · 13/04/2023 10:15

Anyone can call their dog an assistance dog. Only guide dogs are properly trained.

alloalloallo · 13/04/2023 10:14

LittleBlueBrioTrain · 13/04/2023 09:52

It's not a legal requirement to carry it. Its not a legal requirement in the UK to carry your driving license at all times when driving like it is in some countries.

But as in your screen shot, all registered assistance dogs are issued with official documentation. In all the years I've worked with people who have assistance dogs, I've never known them not carry something official in case challenged if entering somewhere a dog would otherwise not be allowed entry.

Anyone can buy a generic assistance dog harness/jacket very cheaply though and claim their dog is an assistance dog, with no training or assessments

It’s not required by law so OP not having her ID with her or not showing the ID for whatever reason is no excuse for the restaurant to refuse access. There is no difference between the 2 scenarios in the original post I quoted, as service dog users are not required by law, as the law currently stands, to carry their ID

I agree that anyone can buy a harness or tag and try to claim their pet is a service dog and legislation does need to be clarified, but that’s not on the OP.

Dobby123456 · 13/04/2023 10:13

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 08:10

He did go check with a mature woman who was at the bar. No the £20 doesn’t cover the meal.

Does your dog have some kind of tag or label to say that he/she's a support dog? From their point of view, anybody with no visible disability could come in and say 'This is my support dog' - and how are they to know?

I agree with you, treating you to a nice meal would have ben a better way to make up for it, once they realised their mistake.

ShowUs · 13/04/2023 10:12

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 09:58

He’s trained to only lay eggs at home on his special egg shelf.

Sometimes when you have to go, you have to go.
Dogs are no different.

You can get claw (designed for people with mobility issues) thing that picks it up in a bag without needing to bend down.
It may be worth getting one of these just in case.

Do you have any proof that he’s your assistance dog?
Like people need to show their blue badge to park in a disabled spot.

Lots of people claim to have assistance dogs but they’re not. Whereas if you had s badge or something it would be way better than having to explain your condition which would make me feel
a bit embarrassed having to explain myself in front of everyone.

WalnutWhippy · 13/04/2023 10:12

It sounds like the OP caused the situation by refusing to show assistance ID for the dog or being unable to do so. Surely there's some sort of ID that can clip on to the harness to avoid this type of scenario. Asking people to just accept the word of an owner that a dog really is an assistance dog seems awkward.

DannyZukosSmile · 13/04/2023 10:11

@Myinterestingnewpath

It's definitely discrimination and it's definitely wrong. And it definitely needs reporting. Write to head office (or email) so that this doesn't happen to anybody else.

I know several people with Guide Dogs who have limited vision. I also know a few people have Guide Dogs who have limited hearing, and also a few who have one to help with neurological conditions like yours. This guy was ignorant at best. Bigoted, and discriminatory, at worst.

Definitely write to the head office about this. This should not be happening. I'm really sorry this happened to you. Flowers

Maverickess · 13/04/2023 10:10

Keha · 13/04/2023 09:26

I think £20 is low. I have a friend with a (trained and registered) assistance dog. If I'd been out with her and this had happened, I think I'd have felt very judged, and quite embarrassed. Especially being asked about why and medical needs etc. I think £20 is low to recompense you for putting you out, discrimination etc. A full meal for two would be more reasonable.

But the OP wasn't asked about her medical needs, she was asked if the dog was a guide dog, to which she replied he was an assistance dog, she was asked what that means and went on to explain what the dog does for her and her disability.
A simpler and clearer way to respond, and without needing to explain any disabilities or the dogs actual tasks, would have been to say that a registered assistance dog is the same as a registered guide dog - because he asked what assistance dog meant, not why she had one or what the dog does for her on a daily basis - no need to explain anything other than an assistance dog is the same as a guide dog and therefore allowed into restaurants etc under the same rules.

Yes he should have been aware of that in the first place, but the company has admitted that flaw, are seeking to resolve it and offered compensation - if OP doesn't feel the compensation is enough she can ask for more, even possibly ask for the steps they've taken training wise to improve the knowledge of their staff and prevent further discrimination where assistance dogs are concerned

Viviennemary · 13/04/2023 10:07

The restaurant apologised and said they would do staff training. Maybe enough to cover a meal for two would habe been better since that was what you didn't get at that restaurant.

Notreadyfortrip · 13/04/2023 10:03

Rosula · 13/04/2023 09:56

But it's not a guide dog, and saying that it was could cause all sorts of problems when it became obvious that OP didn't have a visual impairment.

OP would at least be seated by then and could ask for the manager if there was a further issue. Surely not all staff members were as uninformed? I'm assuming it was one particularly silly or new/inexperienced member of staff and unfortunately you'll get those everwhere.

Obki · 13/04/2023 10:01

Moonmelodies · 13/04/2023 09:32

Given you can't bend down and pick things up, what happens when the dog lays an egg?

The rest of the dog owning community should step in and pick up the poo in the unlikely event her dog does one.

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 09:58

Moonmelodies · 13/04/2023 09:32

Given you can't bend down and pick things up, what happens when the dog lays an egg?

He’s trained to only lay eggs at home on his special egg shelf.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread