Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a serious error and the resolution doesn’t really cut it

438 replies

Myinterestingnewpath · 13/04/2023 08:01

Visited a well known chain restaurant, early in the week so it wasn’t busy, only about six tables tables taken. I was with my daughter, asked if I could have a table instead of a booth, as I have an assistance dog. My dog is a small/medium size, and was wearing his harness. I got asked if he was a guide dog, I said no an assistance dog. He then asked what that meant. I explained that the dog helps me with tasks that help me live my daily life. He then asked what exactly that meant. So I explained I have neurological damage after breaking my neck, and I can’t feel my fingers so drop things and the dog retrieves them. I also explained I have balance issues, so bending down without falling over is a problem. I then got asked if it was a guide dog again. I said no. He then said you can’t come in because it’s not a guide dog and you’re not blind!! I am not a confrontational person so I just said ok, we’ll just go the restaurant next door, (which is owned by the same group) as they always welcome me. The next day I rang head office and they admitted that what he did is unlawful, and they would do some staff training. Turning away a disabled person because of their equipment is a serious issue. Dogs are classed as auxiliary aids same as wheelchairs. I have been offered £20, I think they’ve got off lightly. What do mumsnetters think?

YABU-restaurants can choose who dines
YANBU-it’s discrimination

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
theemmadilemma · 13/04/2023 11:20

I think £50-100 would have been much more appropriate.

But it does sound like staff training is needed and some idiot couldn't figure shit out for himself.

Woodandsky · 13/04/2023 11:19

I have a friend with a medical assistance dog (properly trained and certified before anyone else jumps in). He is legally entitled to take him anywhere that he needs to go, just like a guide dog.

I've been with him when he's had issues and luckily he's very good at fighting his corner, carries copies of the legislation with him and if that doesn't work he calls the police, that tends to do it. It's not nice to have to assert yourself just to be able to lead something resembling a normal life but sometimes that's what you have to do, hopefully then it makes things a bit easier for the next person.

Oh and he regularly asks if anyone has allergies or a problem with dogs and usually no-one has but would of course sit away from them if they did.

Theluggage15 · 13/04/2023 11:17

I know someone who thought it was hilarious that to get out of their dog having to stay in the car on a ferry they said it was an assistance. I’m sure the staff thought it was hilarious when this dog shat all over the floor and they had to clear it up.

Why are you talking about training your dog OP? Guide dogs are trained by experts. Your dog sounds no different to any other dog.

ForeverGenX · 13/04/2023 11:13

’It’s not about money’ but actually the amount they offered is insulting. THEY made it about the money by offering a derisory amount. Yes it is about staff training but that does not help assuage the OP’s experience. Funny how other posters are so cavalier and dismissive about disability as a protected. The only way corporations respond is by hitting them where it hurts. Bad publicly or financial penalty. If they’re listed, they will hate the publicity as will their shareholders… They think you are a pushover who will be grateful for their £20 voucher. Probably because you are a middle aged woman with a disability so they think you’re not worth much. Had it been a glamorous celeb or a white entitled businessman, you can bet they would have offered an apology running into the hundreds. I don’t think they’ve learned their lesson and this offers no incentive to training staff beyond ‘let in people with assistance dogs’. Have you expressed dissatisfaction at the amount? Go to the local press. It will do them some good. They will keep your name out of it if you ask/insist (though may want a pic of your dog!).

Tessisme · 13/04/2023 11:13

It was rude and insensitive of this person to press for so many personal, medical details. Then after being a nosey, officious jobsworth, he maintained his original (erroneous) stance. I think the apology from the restaurant and assurance of appropriate staff training is reasonable enough though. It all sounds like a very unpleasant experience.

Ofcourseshecan · 13/04/2023 11:05

useitorlose · 13/04/2023 08:09

Discrimination and against the law. Go to the press if you don't mind the publicity. They'll give you a lot more than £20 then, and I know it's not about the money.

I agree. Staff who don’t know the law should ask their manager before turning away someone with a disability. The dog’s harness was evidence. Saying sorry later isn’t good enough.

Redpriestandmozart · 13/04/2023 11:02

My dog is a registered therapy dog, we visit nursing homes, hospitals, schools etc. You'd be surprised at how many people have said to me 'Oh so you can take her into restaurants as she's a therapy dog' NO the answer is NO she is not an assistance dog. It does highlight that most of the general public either don't know the difference or are chancers and don't care.

PuttingOnTheKitsch · 13/04/2023 10:56

Rosula · 13/04/2023 10:28

You've missed the point, Starting on a path of refusing to recognise disability unless someone has a badge or a piece of paper is the start of a slippery slope that leads to that sort of conduct. Society expects a reasonable amount of sensitivity to disability, not demands for proof before making standard accommodations. Obviously there is no issue that OP is disabled, witness the fact that the next door restaurant within the same group has no problems with accommodating the dog and head office offered compensation.

Traffic Wardens "refuse to recognise disability" unless someone displays their relevant paperwork and everyone accepts that, because they know if that requirement didn't exist, cheeky people would use disabled parking facilities and which means that actually disabled people couldn't use them.

The same applies to assistance dogs. There should be a registration system, otherwise, people sticking a coat labelled "assistance dog" on their pet will cause problems for those who genuinely need them.

Arapawa · 13/04/2023 10:56

They've apologised. I don't imagine it will happen again. You should have asked to speak to a manager when you were in the situation.

Leave it. Their training will improve.

ShowUs · 13/04/2023 10:54

Rosula · 13/04/2023 10:19

When it comes to demanding people produce proof of their disability, it's the start of a very slippery slope. Can you imagine? "Sorry, sir, for all I know you're in that wheelchair because you're lazy, unless you show me a badge I can't help you go up in the lift". "Sorry, madam, I know you claim to be pregnant, but unless you show me a badge I'm going to assume you're just lazy and I won't offer you a seat." "Unless you show me a badge, I'm going to assume that you're breathing badly for fun and I'm not going to help you find your inhaler".

If you want to use a disabled parking space then you need to show your blue badge.

I think showing proof is much better than standing there and having to explain yourself, especially as so many disabilities are not obvious.

There are many times when you have to show proof eg I.D to buy alcohol.

I don’t think showing proof is offensive.

GoodChat · 13/04/2023 10:54

@LittleBlueBrioTrain at 08:44 she said he's registered. At 09:12 she says he's qualified.

LittleBlueBrioTrain · 13/04/2023 10:53

GoodChat · 13/04/2023 10:50

He's passed qualifications to be an assistance dog. He's not just well trained.

OP has gone into great detail about her dogs toileting habits but hasnt once confirmed that her dog has been assessed by a legitimate organisation to be given official assistance dog status.

She has said he is registered but that could be with anyone (not necessarily legit)

ReplGirl · 13/04/2023 10:52

niugboo · 13/04/2023 10:41

They’re asking you if he’s a registered assistance dog and the answer is clearly no. Which means he was right to refuse. You buying a dog and teaching him to fetch makes him a dog that can fetch.

OP has stated he's registered. She just didn't show the paperwork (although in this case not sure if the waiter would even know what that is anyway)

GoodChat · 13/04/2023 10:50

niugboo · 13/04/2023 10:41

They’re asking you if he’s a registered assistance dog and the answer is clearly no. Which means he was right to refuse. You buying a dog and teaching him to fetch makes him a dog that can fetch.

He's passed qualifications to be an assistance dog. He's not just well trained.

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 13/04/2023 10:48

I suspect the reason the waiter was spectacularly wrong in how this is handled is because of the rise of entitled dog owners who think their creatures should be allowed everywhere. He's been told to shut down requests with a blanket no for anything other than guide dogs, not having the sense or confidence to allow assistance dogs into this bracket where they belong.

I think the company are handling it correctly to be honest. I bet behind closed doors the waiter is having more than just extra training for getting it wrong.

ReplGirl · 13/04/2023 10:48

YABU OP.
The 'terminology' means nothing here. Only the legally issued paperwork. While it's not a legal requirement, and you shouldn't have to, the number of people carrying around untrained animals calling them all manner of things (assistance dogs, service dogs, blah2) is becoming a problem.
In a non-dog friendly environment these untrained animals can be dangerous. I've seen them cause waitstaff to trip up, jump on other people's tables to steal food. And worse, disturbing ACTUAL registered service dogs!

Honestly because the law is a gray area there's probably a case for discrimination, yes but logically allowing in everyone who claims to have an assistance dogs is going to make things worse for people like yourself. They definitely need more training. Not sure how to solve this

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 10:41

Rosula · 13/04/2023 10:34

How much of a problem is this in reality? There is a real danger that, in demanding certification, we are putting in place a cumbersome, expensive scheme that potentially disadvantages disabled people quite badly to remedy a minuscule problem. Plus if someone is that determined to pass their untrained dog off as an assistance dog, it's hardly going to be difficult to forge a certificate.

I'm sorry you aren't aware of this problem and therefore dismiss it as 'miniscule'.

Here is just one example article from the Guardian about the huge explosion in fake 'emotional support animals' and the very serious problems they are causing, including biting, violence, and defecation.

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/aug/12/fake-emotional-support-animals-service-dogs

This article focuses on the USA but it is also a significant issue here in the UK. Here is one incident that happened here. In this case the genuine assistance dog was attacked by a fake 'support' dog. So in fact insisting on the paperwork would have protected the genuinely disabled person

www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/womans-shock-after-fake-service-26685451

The number of fake emotional support dogs is exploding – why?

It’s easy to get your pet designated an emotional support animal. But abuse of the system takes a toll on those with genuine needs

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/aug/12/fake-emotional-support-animals-service-dogs

niugboo · 13/04/2023 10:41

They’re asking you if he’s a registered assistance dog and the answer is clearly no. Which means he was right to refuse. You buying a dog and teaching him to fetch makes him a dog that can fetch.

IfYouLikePinaCoIadas · 13/04/2023 10:40

I was in a chain restaurant recently and there was a clearly untrained dog wearing a service dog vest, eating off the table. Absolutely gross. The staff vivisibly felt unable to do anything.
This is a problematic area. Most of us don't want dogs where we are eating, certainly not sat on the chair, eating off the table. Yet anyone can now claim their dog is a service animal, and now dogs are everywhere.

LookItsMeAgain · 13/04/2023 10:37

The fact that when you went to the restaurant head office they thanked you for not going to the press and/or taking legal action makes you realise that there were MASSIVE red flags over what their employee said and did and you would be well within your rights to challenge the £20 token amount.

They were so wrong to block your entry.

I'm also surprised that more people haven't heard of assistance dogs as opposed to guide dogs. I've heard of many many conditions that require assistance dogs, watching television can be educational on this. There was a lady who has an assistance dog and she was featured on The One Show because her dog basically can sense when she is about to have an episode that could be life threatening to her and her dog helps alleviate that.

I'm so sorry that there are ignorant people in the service industry that prevent so many people with assistance dogs from leading a normal life.

Education is key and yes, @Myinterestingnewpath , I would be challenging them on their measly offer of £20. They got off extremely lightly.

Bamboux · 13/04/2023 10:36

Rosula · 13/04/2023 10:28

You've missed the point, Starting on a path of refusing to recognise disability unless someone has a badge or a piece of paper is the start of a slippery slope that leads to that sort of conduct. Society expects a reasonable amount of sensitivity to disability, not demands for proof before making standard accommodations. Obviously there is no issue that OP is disabled, witness the fact that the next door restaurant within the same group has no problems with accommodating the dog and head office offered compensation.

No. I haven't 'missed the point'. How patronising.

We are asked for ID for lots of things, some of them sensitive (age, pregnancy - that's why you get a maternity exemption card, entitlement to benefits, etc.)

If you are asking for something that would not generally be allowed (discounted ticket, free prescription or dental care, free entry to council facilities, etc.) then it's completely reasonable to expect to demonstrate that you are in fact entitled to that exemption or benefit.

Otherwise, very obviously, many people would take advantage of it.

To suggest it's analogous to watching someone struggle to breathe and refusing help is... extremely silly.

Rosula · 13/04/2023 10:34

CalloohCallayFrabjousDay · 13/04/2023 10:30

I think this should be done. There's nothing to stop people from saying that their pet is an "assistance animal" when it's just a family pet.

How much of a problem is this in reality? There is a real danger that, in demanding certification, we are putting in place a cumbersome, expensive scheme that potentially disadvantages disabled people quite badly to remedy a minuscule problem. Plus if someone is that determined to pass their untrained dog off as an assistance dog, it's hardly going to be difficult to forge a certificate.

breakingintopieces · 13/04/2023 10:34

I've seen plenty of guide dogs in my time, but I've never seen an assistance dog, so it's perfectly plausible that this member of staff had never encountered a customer like you and was not equipped to deal with the situation. The resolution of staff training seems like a good one.

If you're inclined to answer - how are people supposed to identify an assistance dog over any other dog?

I'm very allergic to dogs, and allergies do actually come under the Equality Act as they are a long-term condition that impacts your life negatively. If you genuinely had an assistance dog, I would try to seat you in a different section, get another waiter to serve you and hope I could get through my shift without being ill. But how would I know you had an assistance dog?

Guide dogs tend to be chosen not just for their temperament but because they don't really trigger as many allergic reactions as some other breeds.

Jonei · 13/04/2023 10:32

Well hopefully they will learn something from this op. It is frustrating though that so many of these businesses do not understand their legal obligations.

WalnutWhippy · 13/04/2023 10:30

I don't think it's unreasonable to offer an assistance dog's ID if asking for them to be admitted to a restaurant. I have a child with additional needs and if I am asking for accomodations such as moving to the front of a queue with them, I will show their ID listing their condition. I wouldn't put someone in the awkward position of having to accept my word for something or not.