Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I feel so guilty about this money? AIBU and a CF?

41 replies

Wasthismystupidfault · 12/04/2023 22:44

I grew up in kinship care with grandparents. From sometime in my teens, my beloved grandmother, who was essentially my Mum, was able to get a fostering allowance for me. We had a brilliant time from when she got this, she loved her independence and paid for me to do lots of hobbies and school trips etc.

I developed a serious illness in my teens as well and then anxiety and depression. I really fucked up my uni course and ended up dropping out and then because I was out of full time education, the money stopped.

Grandma was really angry about the money because she then had no money of her own, she was from a generation that had to stop working outside the home when women got married. But she forgave me pretty fast. I was earning a very small amount part time but she was still paying for lots of things for me and letting me live there.

I feel awful about this as an adult. She's dead now many years and I am only fully realising how guilty and ashamed I am?

She had a very old fashioned financial arrangement with my grandfather, he bought their house outright and had a good pension and just gave her housekeeping.

In hindsight, it was mean at best and by today's standards probably a financially abusive set up.

I was just so selfish back then and couldn't cope, and now can never make it up to her Sad

I am so ashamed really and don't know what to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Howmuchfurther · 09/08/2023 22:42

Wasthismystupidfault · 12/04/2023 22:56

I'm sure she knew I loved her, but I didn't look after her properly? I just couldn't.

She didn’t want you to look after her. She wanted you to appreciate her looking after you. You have always appreciated and loved her. She knew that. That was giving her everything she needed. You have nothing to be sorry about.

billy1966 · 13/04/2023 22:41

Wasthismystupidfault · 13/04/2023 20:35

Thank you all, truly. I'm just having a very difficult time at the moment and it's like all past mistakes are hitting me hard.

She definitely knew how much I loved her, and I know she loved me, so that is the main thing I need to focus on.

Absolutely what you should be reminding yourself of.

You both clearly cherished each other.
She only ever wanted the best for you, and to do her best by you.

You were much loved.

I hope things get a bit easier soon.

We are here if you need us.

Wasthismystupidfault · 13/04/2023 20:35

Thank you all, truly. I'm just having a very difficult time at the moment and it's like all past mistakes are hitting me hard.

She definitely knew how much I loved her, and I know she loved me, so that is the main thing I need to focus on.

OP posts:
blobby10 · 13/04/2023 10:31

@Wasthismystupidfault I'm in my early 50s and during a recent conversation with my parents, I apologised for being the self entitled and sometimes downright cruel little madam I was in my teens and 20s. You know what? They didn't remember any of the things that I remembered! I have been holding on to all this guilt about the cutting things I said and thoughtless things I did which just weren't perceived as such by them!!!.

Your grandmother sounds like she truly loved you and I'm sure would not have held anything that happened against you. She's probably sitting on a cloud right now looking down on you and willing you to forgive yourself!!!! Flowers

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 13/04/2023 10:20

Most people have regrets. One of my adult kids was truly dreadful as a teen. She is now a lovely adult with a child of her own. I have a better understanding now of why she acted like she did and have come to terms with it.
I, on the other hand have no such regrets cos I was manipulated into being a people pleaser through and through. I regret not kicking off more!

billy1966 · 13/04/2023 10:06

You poor pet.

Of course you have absolutely nothing to feel guilty or ashamed about.

You well ill.

It happens.

Your grandfather was mean and that is on him.

Your grandmother loved you dearly and will have known you loved her back.

Please try and be kinder to yourself.

You have been through a lot.

I sincerely hope you get counselling soon to help you realise, you have NOTHING to be ashamed of.

Luredbyapomegranate · 13/04/2023 09:56

In the kindest way your gran had no business being angry with you. You were unwell, plus the fact you were a teen and you hadn’t had the easiest start.

It sounds like she was great and did a great job bringing you up, but in that she was wrong - there was nothing to forgive you for. It was not your job to provide an income for her, that isn’t any child’s job. As you note, she had her own issues with your grandad’s financial control, but that is no reason to blame you.

So please let any guilt go, it’s entirely unnecessary. Also don’t fall into the trap of thinking of your behaviour in your teens and early 20s as that of an adult. You were an adolescent.

Remember you did the best you could.

The thing to focus on now is moving forward and building your life, which is what she would have wanted.

As a PP says when you have spare time, energy or money, then pass it on.

NuNameNuMe · 13/04/2023 09:37

Forgive yourself. You've done nothing wrong and everything normal for the age and stage you were at. Teenagers can be thick as mince with their choices at the best of times, and you had anxiety on top of that. Having parented teens I think your beloved gran was expressing her own fear and frustration, and it appeared as anger. She wanted the best for you and could have felt scared she had done a good enough job herself to put you on the "right path". You sound thoughtful and self aware, and likely you've turned out just fine. Please show your younger self some compassion. Living well is the best tribute you can give her now.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 13/04/2023 08:22

You did what felt right at the time. Also you're not in charge of the rules of either her money from the state or from her husband - you were just a kid.

Thehonestbadger · 13/04/2023 05:51

I wonder how old you are now OP and whether you’ve had your own children/taken responsibility for a child.

You reach a stage as a younger adult where you become aware of how atrociously you acted as a teen. For me this happened in my mid 20’s.
You then reach another stage (for me this happened now at 30 with two small children in tow) where you realise that kids are just difficult and hard and generally behave in ways that test you to all of your limits but it’s the circle of life and you adore them regardless. As a parent you know that children and teens lack the emotional maturity to understand their actions and consequences but that this develops as they grow, you don’t resent them for it even if it’s hard at the time.

Tezza1 · 13/04/2023 05:41

I am probably a fair bit older than you, but this still applies, I think.

My mum told me that her mother said to her that when she, my grandmother eventually died, mum would probably feel guilt but mum was never to reproach herself for anything mum felt should have, or had not, done. In was just one of the things that happens in the circle of life: many children will inevitably will feel guilty after a parent's death even when there is no need.

Mum went on to assure me that yes, when she died I would probably feel guilty about thing(s) but she didn't want me to ever feel that. I had not done anything to reproach myself with. And of course, I did feel guilt, but her words consoled me a great deal. I'm sure your grandmother would have said the same, particularly if she knew the effect it was going to have on you. It sounds like you had a lovely bond that brought you both so much joy. Don't let it be spoilt.

Blueblell · 13/04/2023 05:15

you shouldn’t worry about this. She would have perhaps had this extra money for 3 years maximum during your course. You had to drop out as many people do for various reasons. The three years was cut short but she wouldn’t have received that money forever and as you say you have great memories of the years when she was able to spend money on you and outings together.

it sounds like those years were happy for both of you so just try to focus on those good times. The old fashioned financial set up with her husband was not your fault.

FictionalCharacter · 13/04/2023 05:06

IronicElf · 12/04/2023 22:56

None of that was your fault. You were never responsible for her financial status. You were not selfish - you got ill.

I can understand how your grandmother might have missed the financial side of things and built up resentment, but that wasn't on you. Forgave you? She had no right to make you feel that you did anything wrong, by simply making choices for yourself in the moment.

You do need to make peace with this, but only from the point of view that you need to let this guilt go. The first question is - if someone else told you this story would you blame them? There's nothing in your post that I can see that makes me think you did anything wrong.

Do you have a local wellbeing service you could refer yourself to? There might be a therapy that will help support you.

I completely agree. @Wasthismystupidfault you did nothing wrong. It’s not like you took money from her or withheld money from her. You got ill and it must have been a horrible experience for you. I hope you manage to get rid of this misplaced guilt.

Murdoch1949 · 13/04/2023 04:47

Surely the fostering allowance ended when you went to university anyway?

mamabear715 · 13/04/2023 00:13

I think, @Wasthismystupidfault anyone who doesn't look back with horror at some teen / early adult behaviour is a liar.. do you have children of your own? If so you'll know that whatever they do, we still love them..

AllOfThemWitches · 13/04/2023 00:10

Look she was probably more stressed than angry with you. It wasn't your fault and she obviously knew that.

JustTurned90 · 13/04/2023 00:04

It sounds like you had an absolutely amazing grandma who treated you well and truly like her own daughter. That relationship is so precious and I doubt very much that she ever begrudged giving you everything that she did, as she loved you and was so fond of you.

I think that it is a natural part of life and growing up to look back on our teens and early 20s in horror at some of the things we put our parents and care givers through! In conversations that I’ve had with my own mum, I would say it’s a rite of passage into adulthood, and something that your grandma will have done when she was younger (although maybe not as explicitly as we do today!)

Don’t spend too much time on the feelings of regret, because we can’t change the past and regrets just steal our focus. Try instead to think about how thankful you are to her.

Mariposista · 12/04/2023 23:38

Hi OP. My beloved grandmother died two weeks ago, and I go over and over so many things and pray that she was and is proud of me. I promise your gran does not bear grudges to you now she has died. Life was different back then, as you say she had no career (would be pretty unacceptable for a modern woman now but normal then), and you were a child, and it was not your job to provide for her. Be kind to yourself and do your gran proud by living a good, honest life, working hard and doing your best in everything you do. All the best.

literalviolence · 12/04/2023 23:29

YABU to give yourself a hard time. You did nothing wrong.

flipflop00 · 12/04/2023 23:27

The money would have been due to stop once you turned 19 so in the long run it really wouldn't have made much difference!
I was so selfish in my teens. I thought I knew everything, I was rude and obnoxious. I feel so embarrassed to think of how I used to be! But that's not me anymore, and I think it's hard to find a teen who hasn't gone through that spell. You did what you needed to do while going through a lot at such a young age, your gran most likely understood your reasons 🧡 it's a bit 'out there' but since I lost a close family member and struggled with guilt about things I could have done different, I spent a lot of time reading stories about people who had been brought back to life and their experience of 'dying' and every single one said that they experienced total love and joy and every ounce of anger or hurt or upset just vanished. That really was a comfort to me to think my loved ones hold no bad feelings about things I could have done better 🧡

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 12/04/2023 23:26

I don’t think you’ve anything to feel guilty about. It’s not your fault your parents were unable to care for you. It’s not your fault you were ill. It’s not your fault your grandmother had no income and was perhaps in a financially abusive relationship. It wasn’t your responsibility to look after her. Looking after you was a responsibility she accepted.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 12/04/2023 23:26

Wasthismystupidfault · 12/04/2023 22:46

Was anyone else very naturally selfish as a teen and young adult, and then matured later into a reasonable human? How do you make peace with the stuff you did from your selfish immature period?

Honestly I think you've just described 99% of teenagers! I was certainly like that, I was absolutely horrible to my mum in particular.

I agree with @HappinessDragon:

You did look after her properly because you did what you could with what you had.
You were a teenager and she loved you.
You were ill and she loved you.
You were probably a massive pain in the arse sometimes (teenager!) and she loved you.

Just imagine saying “Nan, years after you’ve gone, I am going to feel ashamed and guilty and upset about you not having that money” and then imagine what she would say to you.

Give yourself some kindness OP.

QueenSmartypants · 12/04/2023 23:26

It wasn't your responsibility to look after her, it was hers to look after you. Being unwell isn't anything that warrants forgiveness. But you do need to forgive yourself or this will eat you up completely unnecessarily.

They had a traditional marriage, again you have no responsibility for that.

Your only responsibility is to yourself - to live a good life, which I'm sure is all that your grandmother wanted for you.

Bunnyhair · 12/04/2023 23:21

HappinessDragon · 12/04/2023 23:01

You did look after her properly because you did what you could with what you had.
You were a teenager and she loved you.
You were ill and she loved you.
You were probably a massive pain in the arse sometimes (teenager!) and she loved you.

Just imagine saying “Nan, years after you’ve gone, I am going to feel ashamed and guilty and upset about you not having that money” and then imagine what she would say to you.

Give yourself some kindness OP.

This.

(But also, OP, if your gran wouldn’t have had anything comforting or kind to say about that, then give yourself EXTRA kindness.)

You had a very hard time of things. I don’t see anything in your OP that suggests you were selfish.

Ilovetea42 · 12/04/2023 23:19

You were a child who I'm presuming came through trauma to end up living in kinship care with a formal allowance. Your grandmother didn't just take you on for the money by the sounds of things, she loved you, she was invested in you as a person with all your talents and flaws and you are her family. I don't think any adult is so naieve that they enter into a kinship or fostering arrangement without expecting that the young person is going to have some tough patches, make mistakes and maybe take a little longer to figure things out for themselves than a young person who hasn't had family instability (no matter the cause). It sounds like you got there eventually and I'm sure she'd be really proud of you for that. She cared for you freely, not just because she thought you'd look after her and bring in an extra income so it sounds to me like you've repaid her in the best way, by growing into an adult who is kind and considerate and loved her enough to even think of these things. It sounds like you feel very grateful to her for all the love she gave you, but I would suggest that people who grow up with their biological parents are grateful for the love their parents gave them but they recognise that this is just what parents do, I love my son because he is my son, I'd take my neice or nephew in in a heartbeat because they're my neice and nephew- not because I expect a single thing in return. I think your sense of guilt is a little misplaced. She loved you the way she did because that was what you deserved no matter who you turned out to be or what you got wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread