Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to speak to friend about her child’s weight?

239 replies

wingingit1987 · 12/04/2023 21:55

For a bit of background- there is a group of 4 of us who have known each other since primary school. We all have young kids and see each other often. I’m closer to one of the girls and consider her my best friend.

She has a son who just turned 5. He is very overweight for his age. I would go as far as to say obese. He wears age 10-11 clothes and recently outgrew a lot of them and passed them on to one of the other girls sons(he is 10). This is what sparked this conversation as we are due to meet up for one of the kids birthday parties this week, and the other two have been texting me privately to say they think we should speak to her about her sons weight.

I see my friend at least once or twice a week and I realise he is big. It is down to diet- my friend is also obese. By her own admission he overeats- she said he eats 6 packs of crisps a day, adult portions of food etc. she always dismisses his weight being an issue and says he wears bigger clothes because he is tall, that it’s puppy fat etc.

I agree with my other friends 110% that he is unhealthy and overweight but my issue is that health professionals already know this and I don’t see what difference it would make for us to have some sort of intervention. She has several professionals involved in his care as he has additional support needs. They have addressed this with my friend already.

My friends think we are being neglectful not to say anything but I just don’t see how it would help as she absolutely does not feel it’s an issue.

OP posts:
Nowtbettertodo · 13/04/2023 07:46

RunningFromInsanity · 12/04/2023 23:21

Yes abhor.
Starving a child is abuse. So is over feeding. Neglect at best, child abuse in reality.

Strong word for a mother of a non verbal child with additional needs who is being seen by professionals.

WishIwasElsa · 13/04/2023 07:43

@RunningFromInsanity

That is one of the most awful things I have read. Way to go for making decisions based on how someone looks. Most parents are doing their best. Great way for those kids to grow up ostracised and remain overweight and live an unfufilled life. All because you and yours are busy distancing yourselves 😡

Babsexxx · 13/04/2023 06:45

As much as I’m with the nothing needs mentioning brigade I’m also wondering if your friends are concerned because she’s not taking anything on board? Is she actively trying to help him lose weight op?

He’s only 5 she is complete control of his feeding if she’s not it’s neglect I’m afraid.

Murdoch1949 · 13/04/2023 05:03

Realistically the only thing you can do is what you are already doing, being supportive to your friend when you can. She's getting professional advice & help, so that's obviously not your role, even though she may not be utilising the advice appropriately. She knows she can turn to you for help when she is struggling, which will mean a lot to her. It's a very sad situation for her & her son, but you've recognised that it's not for you to offer dietary advice.

ehb102 · 13/04/2023 05:00

Good to know that it's not my imagination how needlessly snotty some people have been over the years. These nasty judgements have been felt by those of us with fat disorders and connectivity disorders who look "fat" . Christ, it's like the people who despise those who have children out of wedlock.

OP, you're right. This is fat hatred pure and simple. The poor woman is trying to keep body and would together in a high pressure situation and your friends want to shame her? Taking away packets of crisps won't make a child magically thin even if it will appease some judge supposed friends, and it sounds like it is one of the few coping tactics your friend has. It's not going to help telling her that she should be doing something different, and I appreciate your humanity in understanding this. Your friends however sound as lovely as some of the people on this thread.

OldFan · 13/04/2023 02:35

Ffs, it’s hard enough to get some NT kids to eat healthily, let alone kids on the spectrum who tend to eat virtually only “white” food because they suffer from ARFID, total food refusal

Sounds like a degree of food refusal (from the mum) would be helpful TBH. Even if someone only eats white food, they can still have it in sensible amounts. If a small child will only eat bread, doesn't mean they should be given the whole loaf a day or more.

OldFan · 13/04/2023 02:28

I agree with you @wingingit1987 and I'm very anti obesity.

If professionals are involved then you don't have to say anything; doctors will be mentioning it to her regularly.

One thing one of you could say to her maybe is she's making a rod for her own back. It happened with a friend of mine's son as well as with Katie Price's Harvey. You say he has aggressive episodes and these will be harder for her to manage as he gets older the bigger he is. If he does ever have to go into a residential unit or something then that could be the most likely reason.

Fraaahnces · 13/04/2023 02:01

I agree with you entirely that the other “friends” approach would be destructive and divisive and not at all helpful. Poor woman is isolated enough. Of course she knows! Ffs, it’s hard enough to get some NT kids to eat healthily, let alone kids on the spectrum who tend to eat virtually only “white” food because they suffer from ARFID, total food refusal, the extreme behavioural responses some mothers have to deal with from growing and grown kids about this are frightening too! Not to mention the fact that she is a single mum. Thank goodness she has you! It would be better if you and the friends went into bat for her at school and told them that she is drowning.

cornfleurs · 13/04/2023 01:49

I agree with @Winter2020

Winter2020 · 13/04/2023 01:46

Your last post is what your friend needs (emotional and practical support) - not that you are necessarily in a position to offer practical support with your own family needs but being there for her emotionally without judging or having the answers is everything.

Perhaps you can remind your other friends that what your friend needs from them is their emotional support (and time if they have any available). She doesn't need their advice as she has professionals for that or their judgement - she will get plenty of that elsewhere too.

MavisMcMinty · 13/04/2023 01:39

I read once that parents often have no idea their child is obese/overweight, and my overweight friend was exactly the same with her son. It was only when she got a photo back from the developers (remember that?) after a holiday, showing her son in trunks by the swimming pool, that she finally realised how huge he was. (Interestingly, she has completely revised history now he’s normal weight and in his 30s, telling people - and she seems to genuinely believe it herself - that her son had a very healthy varied diet as a child, when he actually ate nothing but chicken nuggets and lots and lots of puddings in pots from the fridge.)

I see the same thing with dog-owners, who think their dogs are normal when they’re horribly, unhealthily fat.

But if your friend already has professionals trying to address her son’s weight, probably safe to assume she is aware, although doesn't seem to much care, if she’s still feeding him 6 packets of crisps every day.

wingingit1987 · 13/04/2023 01:34

Winter2020 · 13/04/2023 01:24

If I have seemed defensive OP I don't have an overweight child - I have a young non verbal autistic child at special school and if people who have little involvement with my son (i.e. don't care for him themselves and have so specialist knowledge of him) wanted to tell me how I should be parenting him they can fuck right off.

I genuinely have no interest in telling my friend how to parent. I was just made to feel like I was being ridiculous by my other two friends.
I don’t offer to babysit because I know I simply couldn’t manage- I have 5 kids and wouldn’t be able to give my friends son the attention he needs. He has one to one support in nursery, for example. I do try to be there as much as I can though. She had an incident recently where she simply was so overwhelmed with it all. He had been very aggressive and had a huge meltdown. She send me a text saying she has got to the point she was at the end of her tether and needed help. I had to ask my sister to watch the older kids and take the newborn with me to walk to hers and help out a bit. That evening was hard enough and I only had my youngest with me then. I don’t know how she copes day to day on her own. I’ve told her to be a bit more frank with her health visitor about how much pressure she is under but she worries that she will end up losing him (even though I’ve tried to reassure her otherwise). I get it though- I work in mental health nursing and patients often panic at the thought of services knowing the true extent of how much they are struggling and they think their children will end up in care.

OP posts:
Winter2020 · 13/04/2023 01:24

If I have seemed defensive OP I don't have an overweight child - I have a young non verbal autistic child at special school and if people who have little involvement with my son (i.e. don't care for him themselves and have so specialist knowledge of him) wanted to tell me how I should be parenting him they can fuck right off.

Winter2020 · 13/04/2023 01:17

OK- so I have interpreted your dilemma as "I don't know whether to speak to my friend about her son's weight" (wrongly) but understandably considering all the discussion of his weight/eating and size.

If what you are saying is "I refuse to speak to my friend about her son's weight AIBU" No you are not being unreasonable. Tell your nosy friends you are not in a professional capacity in your friendship group, that the chikd has professionsl involvement and they should (unless asked for their opinion) mind their own business.

wingingit1987 · 13/04/2023 01:14

Sorry I haven’t managed to reply to everyone individually. There has been lots of helpful pointers and advice from you all and I appreciate it.

OP posts:
LuvSmallDogs · 13/04/2023 00:55

Well if the lad hates soft play/park, she needs to stop taking him there, yes even for bday parties - it sounds like she's taking him there when invited, because that's where most of her friends are happy to meet her and she wants to see her friends.

Only they're not real friends, because her child isn't good enough to visit their homes, and they've set up a group chat to "tee hee, no YOU say something" over her parenting.

The advice you should give her, is to look for groups for parents of children with SN. That way, she can hopefully meet people who wouldn't balk at letting her 5 year old in their homes while they have a cuppa and then she can get shot of the bitch pack!

You want to think hard on what "failings" you have, and what little slip it would take for you to end up with a group chat about "helping" you via public humiliation!

wingingit1987 · 13/04/2023 00:52

Winter2020 · 13/04/2023 00:31

Quote "I don’t feel like I need to tell her how to look after her son at all."

What do you feel you need to tell her?
"Your son is fat - don't give him crisps"?

I don’t feel the need to tell her anything. That’s been the whole point of my post.

OP posts:
Ktime · 13/04/2023 00:52

Winter2020 · 13/04/2023 00:31

Quote "I don’t feel like I need to tell her how to look after her son at all."

What do you feel you need to tell her?
"Your son is fat - don't give him crisps"?

What are you on about? OP has consistently said she doesn’t want to say anything.

From the first post:

I just don’t see how it would help as she absolutely does not feel it’s an issue.

NortieTortie · 13/04/2023 00:41

She will already have professionals involved due to his SN, surely they would have taken it up with her? It's a shame for the little boy absolutely but even if it were appropriate for you to comment I doubt you could say anything that hasn't already gone through her mind. Sounds like she's sticking her head in the sand.

StaunchMomma · 13/04/2023 00:41

It says a lot about them that they see a friend trying to get help for a child with complex needs and think the only thing they 'need' to help with is stopping the child being fat!!

It's very common for a child with special needs to find comfort/soothing in food. How exactly do THEY think they have the knowledge to advise her on how to deal with that incredibly complex issue?!

They sounds utterly vile, honestly. If they really wanted to actually help they would support, not criticise.

WilsonMilson · 13/04/2023 00:40

This is a no win situation for you.

I would personally say nothing unless she brings it up. Sounds like there are complex issues at play.

Coffeeandcake15 · 13/04/2023 00:33

It is selfish and neglectful, I don’t think you saying anything will change that, I’m sure she knows already the risks of being obese.

Phoebo · 13/04/2023 00:32

No need to say anything, she will know. I'd probably struggle to be friends with someone like this, as from your OP it sounds like it's negligence and not a medical issue that is causing this, so she's basically abusing her child

HamBone · 13/04/2023 00:32

I agree that you need to stay out of this, medical professionals are involved and they’ll give her the correct guidance.

Unlike other posters, however, I can also understand the feeling that a close friend “ought” to say something-even though we really shouldn’t!

I have an old friend whose children are overweight and I’ve felt the urge to talk to her to about it, because I genuinely care. But I know I can’t. Medical professionals are also involved with one child and I just hope she’s following their advice. Unless my friend or your friend asks for advice, OP, we have to keep our mouths shut.

Winter2020 · 13/04/2023 00:31

Quote "I don’t feel like I need to tell her how to look after her son at all."

What do you feel you need to tell her?
"Your son is fat - don't give him crisps"?