Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to speak to friend about her child’s weight?

239 replies

wingingit1987 · 12/04/2023 21:55

For a bit of background- there is a group of 4 of us who have known each other since primary school. We all have young kids and see each other often. I’m closer to one of the girls and consider her my best friend.

She has a son who just turned 5. He is very overweight for his age. I would go as far as to say obese. He wears age 10-11 clothes and recently outgrew a lot of them and passed them on to one of the other girls sons(he is 10). This is what sparked this conversation as we are due to meet up for one of the kids birthday parties this week, and the other two have been texting me privately to say they think we should speak to her about her sons weight.

I see my friend at least once or twice a week and I realise he is big. It is down to diet- my friend is also obese. By her own admission he overeats- she said he eats 6 packs of crisps a day, adult portions of food etc. she always dismisses his weight being an issue and says he wears bigger clothes because he is tall, that it’s puppy fat etc.

I agree with my other friends 110% that he is unhealthy and overweight but my issue is that health professionals already know this and I don’t see what difference it would make for us to have some sort of intervention. She has several professionals involved in his care as he has additional support needs. They have addressed this with my friend already.

My friends think we are being neglectful not to say anything but I just don’t see how it would help as she absolutely does not feel it’s an issue.

OP posts:
retrosteamband · 13/04/2023 11:02

He’s 5. I know you stated he has “complex needs” but over eating here is learnt behaviour. She’s exposed him to adult portions of food and 6 bags of crisps a day - he didn’t magically have a reasonable diet and then decide to eat to excess himself. He’s only 5. I have concerns about safeguarding if she doesn’t know that it’s not acceptable to feed her child like this. What else is she being complacent on?

BonnieLisbon · 13/04/2023 11:02

RubbishHusband · 13/04/2023 10:52

As with my previous post the professionals may have advised not losing weight. We haven't weighed this child so we have no idea what's actually going on with his weight, and it's not a friends place to comment on what is actually a very complex medical issue. We have no idea what medical professionals have advised with regards to his weight, amd they are best placed to make the decision as to what to do and safely.Managing intake in SN children is complex. He maybe Sensory seeking hence the crisps, having meltdowns or getting extremely distressed. He may not be able to identify feelings of hunger/thirst. There maybe underlying medical conditions e.g prader willi syndrome that are yet to be diagnosedYes weight management in a SN child is a medical issue. And whilst yes obesity has health risks this needs to be balanced against managing his other needs. Which a fucking dietician and paediatrician, who is under the care of, will be best placed to determine. Not some random Internet person who has never met the child.If the child was anorexic with SN and being cared for by medical professionals would you think it appropriate to have a concerned conversation with the parents? And tbh if he has complex needs awaiting diagnosis that is a bigger issue in terms of his emotional wellbeing right now than his weight

An intelligent post.

User5464245 · 13/04/2023 10:58

The elephant in the room is that the mum is also overweight. How is a son with complex SEN needs supposed to lose and maintain a healthy weight with an obese mother who does the food shopping and cooking? There can be all the professional support and nutritional guidance in the world but it would be very optimistic to expect drastic changes. She would effectively have to be shopping and cooking for two separate people. He gets the fruits, veg, low carb, portion controlled mealplan (if that's even remotely feasible in light of his other support-requiring needs) and she continues with her diet of high carbs, fat, sugar and salt which he can't partake in. That's completely unrelated to whether the food budget even allows that.

As a friend, just bringing up the issue may be with the best of intentions but she will have no help with the logistical or financial side of things.

Sceptre86 · 13/04/2023 10:56

Nope. I'd keep shtum. It sounds like you have a lovely friendship and I wouldn't risk it. Also like another poster said his sen could play into his eating habits re textures and not having a varied diet. In stead I would choose to have playdates at the park, in your garden of you have one at softplay, basically anywhere he can run around. It must be incredibly isolating for her with a child who is non verbal and those feelings will likely increase as he goes through school and all your kids are achieving in a way he isn't. I'd be a supportive friend, if she asks for advice then by all means give it.

I'd tell your other friends they can do as they wish but to leave you put of it.

Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:56

@RubbishHusband - still swearing I see.

The question here is should the person speak to her friend about the weight. YES
Let's not assume it's some complex issue but use the information at hand- which is that the parent is obese and over feeding her child.

If there are complex issues and advice against weight loss- ok doke. I doubt the doctors are recommended adult portions and 6 packs of crisps a day though..

So thoughtful friends might say ''how can we support his care..''

wingingit1987 · 13/04/2023 10:54

AmaryIlis · 13/04/2023 08:46

I would suggest you refer your friend to SOS SEN or to specialist education lawyers (e.g. Irwin Mitchell, Simpson Millar). If the council acknowledges this child needs a special school place but is not planning to give him one, they are acting unlawfully and it may well be that your friend can challenge this, funded by legal aid in her child's name.

Thank you- I’ll tell her about this.

OP posts:
Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:53

@Brewskipa - I don't think it was a sweeping assumption. Sounds like your son is the exception. But for most (especially children who are massively over fed) the sizing indicates a serious health issue.

RubbishHusband · 13/04/2023 10:52

Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:45

Adult portions and many packs of crisps a day is not a medical issue....

As with my previous post the professionals may have advised not losing weight. We haven't weighed this child so we have no idea what's actually going on with his weight, and it's not a friends place to comment on what is actually a very complex medical issue. We have no idea what medical professionals have advised with regards to his weight, amd they are best placed to make the decision as to what to do and safely.Managing intake in SN children is complex. He maybe Sensory seeking hence the crisps, having meltdowns or getting extremely distressed. He may not be able to identify feelings of hunger/thirst. There maybe underlying medical conditions e.g prader willi syndrome that are yet to be diagnosedYes weight management in a SN child is a medical issue. And whilst yes obesity has health risks this needs to be balanced against managing his other needs. Which a fucking dietician and paediatrician, who is under the care of, will be best placed to determine. Not some random Internet person who has never met the child.If the child was anorexic with SN and being cared for by medical professionals would you think it appropriate to have a concerned conversation with the parents? And tbh if he has complex needs awaiting diagnosis that is a bigger issue in terms of his emotional wellbeing right now than his weight

Brewskipa · 13/04/2023 10:51

Jojobees · 12/04/2023 22:18

At 5 needing clothes for a child double his age is scarily overweight, damaging to health and potentially life limiting.
You need to have some difficult conversations with her.

@Jojobees this was my 5yo in 9-10 clothes at 142cms - he’s heavy and solid and tall, but by no means “scarily overweight”. Don’t make sweeping assumptions.

To not want to speak to friend about her child’s weight?
Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:45

Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:45

@RubbishHusband - no need for swearing.

Being obese at 5years old is a serious h physical and emotional issue. Perhaps her friends can say ''how can we help here..we're worried about yours and child's health'

It's very clear the parent is over feeding the child - perhaps as a way to parent high needs- understandable BUT not acceptable and it's dangerous for the child. She's making her own life easier temporarily at the serious detriment to her child.
Just because she cares about her child it doesn't mean her care is good enough.

Adult portions and many packs of crisps a day is not a medical issue....

Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:45

@RubbishHusband - no need for swearing.

Being obese at 5years old is a serious h physical and emotional issue. Perhaps her friends can say ''how can we help here..we're worried about yours and child's health'

It's very clear the parent is over feeding the child - perhaps as a way to parent high needs- understandable BUT not acceptable and it's dangerous for the child. She's making her own life easier temporarily at the serious detriment to her child.
Just because she cares about her child it doesn't mean her care is good enough.

RubbishHusband · 13/04/2023 10:41

Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:37

@Rosula - because we're human and sometimes we need to hear hard truths from people who love us.
The friend might need some moral support to face up to her own health issues / poor parenting and she can't get that from professionals.
Also- morally- I couldn't stand to watch a child be harmed so seriously and say nothing.

She is a single mum caring for a non verbal, high needs child. Fuck off with your home truths and poor parenting. We have no idea as to the significance of this child's needs

Its not just about losing weight, losing weight at 5yo isn't ideal. A dietician will most likely advise weight maintenance rather than loss and growing into his weight. Weight management is complex and is really not as simple as poor parenting, it's a medical issue and should be handled by medical professionals

EnaSharplesStout · 13/04/2023 10:41

Babsexxx · 13/04/2023 09:31

My child’s non verbal autistic and he is not over weight so there’s that….

@Babsexxx my autistic kid doesn’t know the difference between thirsty and hungry, or tired and hungry, or bored and hungry. He interrupts every uncomfortable physical sensation as hungry. Add that to the fact he is obsessed with oral sensory sensations and it can be a nightmare. This boy may be the same.

Mine isn’t overweight (he has medical problems which means he is regularly weighed and measured and the doctor/nurse/consultant would definitely tell me, you can see his ribs etc) but it feels a lot like luck- he is obsessed with the crunchy sensation of cucumber sticks so he gets his sensory satisfaction from that- if he was obsessed with crisps our house would be a constant battleground.

Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:39

@RubbishHusband - child protection is EVERYONES job. The input from professionals clearly isn't working and perhaps she needs a friend honest support.
The mother is admitting to large portions and many packets of crisps. She is buying and preparing the food - she is to blame.

Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:37

@Rosula - because we're human and sometimes we need to hear hard truths from people who love us.
The friend might need some moral support to face up to her own health issues / poor parenting and she can't get that from professionals.
Also- morally- I couldn't stand to watch a child be harmed so seriously and say nothing.

RubbishHusband · 13/04/2023 10:37

Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:17

I'm really surprised people are saying stay out. This a child's serious health issue - of course we should speak up!! Perhaps the woman needs to hear it from her best friend?
If it was any other kind of abuse would you not speak up?! Obesity causes serious physical health issues, can cause a child major emotional issues from low self esteem and bullying. And you want to say nothing for fear of a friends reaction?? That's shameful.

But she has already seen the health professionals who will know the risks to his health balanced against managing his complex needs.

For example some children can Sensory seek by eating certain foods, or not be able to tell they are full, he maybe having serious meltdowns etc.

Managing weight in a non verbal, high needs 5 Yr old is very different to managing weight in mildly overweight adult and is best done by a peadiatrician and a peadiatric dietician, who he has already seen. Her mates coming along with some carrot sticks as a healthy snack is not going to cut it. He has professional involvement, it is none of her friends business.

wingingit1987 · 13/04/2023 10:27

monkeysmum21 · 13/04/2023 08:25

This is another type of abuse and you should (if you can) help in this situation. I am not sure how your other friends conversation is going to help.
Is that meeting a supporting one: “we are here for you, shall we all bring healthy snacks for play dates, do you need help with planning meals, etc” or it is going to go down the patronising route? Big difference!

They other girls have said she needs “tough love” but I feel like the GP, HV, dietician etc would have already been very frank with her.

OP posts:
TrueScrumptious · 13/04/2023 10:27

Rosula · 13/04/2023 10:21

Why would hearing it from friends help when the advice of experts hasn't resolved the problem?

Because lots of people don’t believe or trust “experts”. There’s a backlash against them.

zingally · 13/04/2023 10:25

Yeah, don't go anywhere near this OP.

Despite all her "he's just tall" statements, she'll know in her heart that he's massively overweight. She will need friends, not more judgement. Especially as a parent with an additional needs child.

Rosula · 13/04/2023 10:21

Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:17

I'm really surprised people are saying stay out. This a child's serious health issue - of course we should speak up!! Perhaps the woman needs to hear it from her best friend?
If it was any other kind of abuse would you not speak up?! Obesity causes serious physical health issues, can cause a child major emotional issues from low self esteem and bullying. And you want to say nothing for fear of a friends reaction?? That's shameful.

Why would hearing it from friends help when the advice of experts hasn't resolved the problem?

Jellyx · 13/04/2023 10:17

I'm really surprised people are saying stay out. This a child's serious health issue - of course we should speak up!! Perhaps the woman needs to hear it from her best friend?
If it was any other kind of abuse would you not speak up?! Obesity causes serious physical health issues, can cause a child major emotional issues from low self esteem and bullying. And you want to say nothing for fear of a friends reaction?? That's shameful.

RubbishHusband · 13/04/2023 10:12

lljkk · 13/04/2023 09:55

I do wonder if parents do "know". The amount of excuses I've heard. "His dad is big too" (er no, I've seen dad, he's not big at all), or "We are super relieved she's not big like her mother" (er, yes, she is, she's already rather big), or "I guess it could be all the milkshakes") (do you think?), or "We used to walk but now we have the car we want to get a lot of use out of it so we always drive to school" (coz that will help your daughter's fitness, sure it will). No I didn't ask, these comments just came out in casual chat. Those were all "NT" kids, though. Maybe parents of kids with SEN are never blind to their child's body size.

There's a lad down road now in yr6 & about 5'6", towers over the other boys, still merely plump having been very overweight age 2-8. I wonder what if anything his family tried.

He has seen his Hv and dietician who have come up with a meal plan. What the fuck do you think they said in those sessions?

I think she knows, and if she doesn't I think the professionals are best at handling it given his complex needs. He is already under the care of people who manage this

RubbishHusband · 13/04/2023 10:10

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/04/2023 09:48

SqB · Yesterday 22:19
My daughter is very overweight. It is a very sensitive issue. I’ve done my best in terms of healthy eating and exercise but she has now been diagnosed with a thyroid problem so fingers crossed things will improve now we have answers. My friends have been supportive but not interfering. They don’t abhor me!”

Why would they, your daughter has a medical condition and you are doing everything you can.
OP’s friend is in a very different situation. Allowing a five year old child 6 packets of crisps in a day is pretty awful.

Did you miss the bit where he has complex needs, is non verbal and has multiple professionals involved in his care, including a dietician and Hv who have come up with a meal plan?

We have no idea as to this child's needs, but they quite likely explain why he has 6 pockets of crisps. She is a single mum managing in a very difficult situation.

Morningcoffeeview · 13/04/2023 10:08

She already knows. If they want to say something and upset the apple cart they can. What do they want you to say that they think she doesn’t know already?

Babsexxx · 13/04/2023 10:05

I do have empathy but also on the original op it states the child’s mum is also overweight? My child only eats certain things and no they are not healthy but do I let him help himself/et overweight no I don’t he already has health problems and there is no way I would add to that if it meant healthy eating for the entire family then it’s tough that’s what we would all have to do.

Now if her child had genetics that are a diagnosed contributor to weight gain insatiable hunger for example completley different ball game.