Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

C-section not real birth

453 replies

Washingforweeks · 12/04/2023 19:27

I was just scrollling through Facebook and saw a post about women getting shamed for c-sections. I’ve had 3 vaginal births never a c section so I have never personally experienced this kind of…. Well wtf is it…. Ridiculousness. Is this genuinely a real thing?? Are there women out there being shamed for having c-sections? If so Jesus Christ. Seriously?!

OP posts:
UneFoisAuChalet · 12/04/2023 20:23

Beamur · 12/04/2023 19:33

Well, I'd rather have a C-section than die and also kill my baby. Which is probably what would have happened to me. Shame away, I really couldn't give a stuff.
There seems to be a vein of competitive parenting that sets arbitrary rules around how to achieve birth/feeding/parenting. Very tiresome.

Yes, precisely that. I won’t even go into the details of my birth stories because they were so traumatic and the push - no pun intended - for me to give birth vaginally could have ended very differently.

I had one woman make a disparaging remark about my sections and telling her ‘every cloud eh? At least my vagina is intact. Nearly as tight as a virgin’s 😉shut her up.

Most women do not choose sections. Maybe in some netherworld celebrities do, but I certainly didn’t. And I find it offensive that I’m judged for a life or death situation.

PoptyPinnnngggg · 12/04/2023 20:22

RamsayEaster · 12/04/2023 20:00

If a c section is the only safe way to deliver a baby and keep mum safe of course it’s a real birth

However if your too posh to push and have a c section then that’s another story 😂

I was too posh to push then!! My preferred birth choice was C-section and that's what I got.

Tell me more about this other story... 😜. Should I be shamed for my poshness or my dislike of pushing 😂😂😂

MotherofBingo · 12/04/2023 20:20

Midwinter89 · 12/04/2023 20:08

@goodenoughmum88 I thought the medical definition of ‘birthing’ was a vaginal birth, whereas a c section is an operation to deliver a baby without labour?

Birth: the process of bringing forth a child from the uterus or womb (Britannica encyclopedia) or the time when a baby or young animal comes out of its mother's body (Cambridge dictionary).

Also many women do labour before their c-sections.

Pseudonamed · 12/04/2023 20:19

Oh I remember after a particularly hard labour with forceps and ventouse lasting almost 48 hours before I had to have an emergency section being told afterwards when I mentioned the section that 'well we always knew you were too posh to push'. There are people out there that judge. Sadly all ignorant of the fact that a section is a fairly major operation and takes around 6 weeks to recover from physically.

Flittingaboutagain · 12/04/2023 20:19

I do think the people who opt for planned sections and never attempt a vaginal delivery don't give birth. They don't experience contractions, dilation etc and technically don't know what it is to give birth or labour. They have an extraction I suppose. Nothing wrong with it, not lesser or unworthy but obviously not the same.

Spottycarousel · 12/04/2023 20:19

I very nearly died from blood loss as a result of a pph following a vaginally delivery. I wish I'd had- and should have had, on hindsight- a c section.

What is wrong with people? Medical interventions are a gift.

Twizbe · 12/04/2023 20:15

KalimbaMoon · 12/04/2023 20:12

Misogyny, pure and simple, to judge how a woman brings a baby into this world. For me, the most important thing is the health and well-being of mother and child. I had a planned C-sec, so yes I was spared the pain of a long, drawn-out labour, but the aftermath of having your innards carved open is not for the faint of heart. There’s a long recovery period because it’s major surgery.

There is no easy way to give birth. If anybody dared tell me I hadn’t properly given birth, I dread to think how I’d react!

Women who have a VB should NEVER feel ashamed to need pain relief, epidurals etc. Why suffer more than you have to?

By the same token, if you have a straight forward vaginal birth with limited pain relief and it was a positive experience for you, you're told to not talk about it as 'it's bragging' etc.

Picassa · 12/04/2023 20:15

My two dc were born via c section. The first an emergency and second time round I elected. Absolutely NO shame about that. They’re both here- healthy, happy and thriving. In my eyes the one and only aim of birth is to get the baby and mum through it safely!

PoptyPinnnngggg · 12/04/2023 20:14

Very proud of my C-section and have never been shamed for it. I didn't even have any medical need...I asked for a C-section from the outset because that's what I wanted. None of the health professionals tried to put me off or dissuade me (it happened in 2020 during COVID times so the only discussions I had was to make me aware of the risks of being in hospital when COVID was rife and checking that I still wanted to plan it).

Many people who know I opted through personal choice didn't even know you could. If more people were aware of this as a positive birth option perhaps that would help with the apparent negativity that other people have faced??

BecauseTheOnlyWayIsUp · 12/04/2023 20:14

Yeah this happens to me. I had three sections. First was an emergency after three days of labour. I was fully dilated by the end, pushing, failed forceps. I lost 1.5l of blood and we both got septicemia. I've been told repeatedly by my sister that she faired much worse with her vaginal birth, and when she had a planned section for her second due to breech baby she told me she couldn't understand how I bonded with mine as the c section was not natural and she felt sad I had never done it properly. Really saddens me as I spent about a year feeling like a complete and utter failure of a mum and blamed myself for my son being so poorly. It really bothers me to this day.

KristalBall90 · 12/04/2023 20:13

I laboured for two days and got to 10cm before my daughter was born via emergency c section. I absolutely birthed her.

KalimbaMoon · 12/04/2023 20:12

Misogyny, pure and simple, to judge how a woman brings a baby into this world. For me, the most important thing is the health and well-being of mother and child. I had a planned C-sec, so yes I was spared the pain of a long, drawn-out labour, but the aftermath of having your innards carved open is not for the faint of heart. There’s a long recovery period because it’s major surgery.

There is no easy way to give birth. If anybody dared tell me I hadn’t properly given birth, I dread to think how I’d react!

Women who have a VB should NEVER feel ashamed to need pain relief, epidurals etc. Why suffer more than you have to?

Magpiecomplex · 12/04/2023 20:12

Two sections here, and no one has said it to my face, but both times some idiots suggested to my husband that I was too posh to push. He calmly explained that it was that or mother and child probably wouldn't survive, and the twits wound their necks in.

Kittypack · 12/04/2023 20:12

@Midwinter89 why do you think a c- section is pain free? It's major abdominal surgery and the recovery is pretty painful even if the procedure isn't. And as you can see, most of us here with c- section babies did go through long painful labours too.

Meandfour · 12/04/2023 20:12

Kittypack · 12/04/2023 20:08

Oh also the nhs ante natal class leader: "we are not going to talk about c section birth and recovery here, we're going to focus on natural birth only as that's the goal"

dont they realise it’s actually not the goal for everyone? You only have to look on MN to see how many women are requesting ELCS.

princesssugarless · 12/04/2023 20:11

VisitationRights · 12/04/2023 19:38

My sister, who has no children, balked at my saying something about my son’s birth. She said, “But you didn’t really give birth!” Meaning having a c-section wasn’t considered giving birth. I am not sure how she expected me to talk about her nephew coming into the world 🤷‍♀️

Wonder if I know your sister... or if there are more out there

suzyscat · 12/04/2023 20:09

Plannersareus · 12/04/2023 19:33

My sister had 3 vaginal births with no pain relief, she wears them like a badge of honour. I had 1 c-section due to placenta previa and nearly died due to blood loss and she says I had a 'sun roof' birth...

Ah my friend who always banged on about how easy is had it with my section ended up having one. She certainly changed her tune after that.

Kittypack · 12/04/2023 20:08

Oh also the nhs ante natal class leader: "we are not going to talk about c section birth and recovery here, we're going to focus on natural birth only as that's the goal"

princesssugarless · 12/04/2023 20:08

Yep, my first baby I laboured for 2 days, back to back and big baby(10lbs). He got stuck and his heart rate dropped so I was rushed down for a crash section, general anaesthetic. I got told I'd had the easy route by other mums, sun roof delivery, "aren't you glad you didn't have to go through 'real' birth" I stopped going to mother and baby groups. Someone even asked me it I had 'given birth' as it was a c section. No you twat - it's just magicked out of me.

Midwinter89 · 12/04/2023 20:08

@goodenoughmum88 I thought the medical definition of ‘birthing’ was a vaginal birth, whereas a c section is an operation to deliver a baby without labour?

Kittypack · 12/04/2023 20:06

The old fashioned comment a few posts up of "too posh to push" - there you go, there's your c- section shamer.

I requested an elective section when they started talking about inducing me. I knew induction carried a 50% risk of c section anyhow and preferred the peace and safety of a planned section. I was declined, coerced into a sweep and induction I didn't want, which ended in a crash section under general anaesthetic and me missing the birth of my baby. Two lines stuck with me;

"You're not Victoria Beckham you know, you won't have help and support after a c section like she did" - midwife

"You should at least try and have a normal birth and see how it ends up, so you can an last say you tried" - consultant obstetrician

Starburst8 · 12/04/2023 20:06

The whole C-section Vs Vaginal births have been a thing for a long time. Even on Google it's C-section Vs Natural births.
It irritates me that this still continues, I still had to go through the 9 months of growing the child, my waters broke just like everyone else's and I still went through the pain of contractions.
C-sections in my opinion are just as much as a birth and women need to stop tearing others down for it. Most of the time C-sections are due to medical needs.

itsgettingweird · 12/04/2023 20:06

I had ds by emergency c section.

I've never personally experienced such comments but I have heard others say they have.

Vinniepolis · 12/04/2023 20:06

I knew someone who had three C-sections and beat herself up about it and considered herself a failure somehow (she was quite into ‘alternative lifestyles’ / veganism etc.) I think she only fell pg the 3rd time so she could try again at a natural birth, despite her relationship with her husband being a bit wobbly - they split soon after.

Skinnydecafflatte · 12/04/2023 20:05

I had a c-section for an undiagnosed breech baby for no:1 and then had a vaginal delivery with no: 2.
didn’t get a medal for either…