Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

C-section not real birth

453 replies

Washingforweeks · 12/04/2023 19:27

I was just scrollling through Facebook and saw a post about women getting shamed for c-sections. I’ve had 3 vaginal births never a c section so I have never personally experienced this kind of…. Well wtf is it…. Ridiculousness. Is this genuinely a real thing?? Are there women out there being shamed for having c-sections? If so Jesus Christ. Seriously?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WotsitsMadeIn1927 · 15/04/2023 01:09

I have two children. One natural and one was emergency c section.

I’ve had to deal with some idiots saying c sections aren’t real births.
what are they then? The mother is opened up and has her organs taken out to birth a baby. And it takes MONTHS not weeks for her body to return to ‘normal’.

I’ve also found myself defending natural births as apparently c sections were easier and the person ‘arguing’ had a whole list of crude defences. It was ridiculous.

Unfortunately, you cant argue with stupid OP

Hardbackwriter · 14/04/2023 08:31

AngryBirdsNoMore · 13/04/2023 23:30

That’s so wonderful to hear.

I wish I could see natural birth that way. With tokophobia, I am absolutely terrified of the idea for myself - it makes me feel deeply panicky and anxious and nauseous. So c sections for me - and I loved my first c section.

I am really happy for you, that you and some other women do have positive and empowering natural birth experiences too.

Thank you - and I'm really pleased to hear that you were able to choose a birth that was best for you, and that that was an excellent experience. I would want every woman to have that option. I didn't get have all the options I wanted available to me due to circumstances - I would have chosen a homebirth for my second if it weren't for COVID - but I think the way some women are forced to fight for their own choices, particularly for an elective caesarean, is disgraceful and unjustifiable.

Just to note that I'd always refer to my births as vaginal not natural - both because of the potentially offensive implications of 'natural' and also because it's just untrue! I had gas and air both times and used a birthing pool for the second (which was a much better experience overall for no physiological reason but purely because my care was better, which is pretty sad and also doesn't support maternal choice). I know there's a big idea that birthing pools are 'peak natural' but it's basically a jacuzzi!

red78hot · 14/04/2023 08:18

AngryBirdsNoMore · 13/04/2023 23:24

Poor maternal effort?

I think that’s honestly worth a complaint. How galling.

Apparently it's a generic term for the woman being exhausted.
Health visitor was supposed to put me through for a "talk through" with someone of how the birth went. There's a term for it but I forget what it is.
This was in August, I'm still waiting, I shan't bother, I know how things went and that's all that matters.
I'm guessing "poor maternal effort" is a term invented by a bloke!

Opine · 13/04/2023 23:54

@Ithurtsthebackofmyeyes it doesn’t matter how many times I read your reply I still can’t make sense of it. How does anything you say relate to what I wrote?
I haven’t made any reference to women choosing sections. I chose one myself so how would I be ‘piqued’ about it??

Bbdm1984 · 13/04/2023 23:42

I have experience of both, my first two children were VB 18 and 15 years ago and had a C-section (breech) 4weeks ago.

I can easily say the C-section was the worst experience of my life. As a was being closed up I suffered a cardiac arrest due to amniotic fluid embolism, I also had pleural effusions and blood clots on my lungs, possibly had a stroke and was in a coma for 4 days. It took two weeks longer to get out of hospital after stays on ICU and HDU.

AngryBirdsNoMore · 13/04/2023 23:32

Ithurtsthebackofmyeyes · 13/04/2023 11:07

I don’t think that’s true. You’ve made a sweeping generalisation based on women on a thread about them being criticised for choosing a section by women who had vaginal births. You obviously feel piqued by that for some reason.

Of course I’m sure some women out there will deride a woman for choosing a vaginal birth, same as anything, but it’s very much the norm to have a vaginal birth and is what is pushed as the ultimate goal and the ‘ideal’, from everyone from medical staff, to Instagram mummy bloggers. Women are sold an ideal birth scenario and buy into it. I didn’t.

I don’t know anyone who sees vaginal birthing as the ‘easy option’. It’s seen as the noble and correct one.

I have been castigated for choosing a section, because I didn’t want labour. The pain and unpredictability of it was very much not for me. I didn’t choose a section because I saw vaginal birthing as ‘too easy’. 🤔

Agree with every word.

AngryBirdsNoMore · 13/04/2023 23:30

Hardbackwriter · 13/04/2023 18:26

Clearly you won't believe me, but that wasn't my experience of birth. I was clearly very lucky and unusual, but I'm not delusional, whether or not you 'buy it'!

I am genuinely mildly sad that I will never give birth again.

That’s so wonderful to hear.

I wish I could see natural birth that way. With tokophobia, I am absolutely terrified of the idea for myself - it makes me feel deeply panicky and anxious and nauseous. So c sections for me - and I loved my first c section.

I am really happy for you, that you and some other women do have positive and empowering natural birth experiences too.

AngryBirdsNoMore · 13/04/2023 23:24

red78hot · 13/04/2023 14:08

Christ, I'd be proper "shamed" then, I had failed epidural, a 2nd epidural, gas and air, diamorphine, fentanyl, forceps, spinal block ? ( maybe) and then c section.
After the 2nd epidural ( I think, I was pretty wasted by this point 😅) he used forceps and said "push like your having the biggest poo ever"
I couldn't feel anything from my boobs down, I literally couldn't feel my own arsehole to push anything!
My notes say reason for c section "poor maternal effort" !
Is been on call for induction for 6 days, literally no sleep due to the stress of being asked to ring hospital every day, told no room, then 8.45pm 6 days later called to come in, awake all through the night til birth at 6pm next day, only allowed water as soon as drip hooked up at 10pm, although I was too wiped out from drugs to ask for water, or explain how bad the pain was at the right side of my back.
Pushing a melon sized object of your vagina is not a fun prospect and neither is being sliced open.
No one should be shamed about either.

Poor maternal effort?

I think that’s honestly worth a complaint. How galling.

LoveBluey · 13/04/2023 23:20

Yup with my first when I went to the hairdresser for the first time my stylist said to me oh you had a C-section, that's good you got the easy option then.
It was more laughable than anything as she was clearly clueless.

Meandfour · 13/04/2023 18:28

Hardbackwriter · 13/04/2023 18:26

Clearly you won't believe me, but that wasn't my experience of birth. I was clearly very lucky and unusual, but I'm not delusional, whether or not you 'buy it'!

I am genuinely mildly sad that I will never give birth again.

I’m with you. I’ve recently had my 4th child and I’m really sad I will never get to experience it again. I don’t think it’s an “unavoidably awful experience” at all.

Hardbackwriter · 13/04/2023 18:26

Thepeopleversuswork · 13/04/2023 10:18

@Twizbe

There is so much negative portrayal of birth. I was watching a drama where several women give birth (historical characters so we know each survived and the long term outcomes for their children) every birth was some mega dramatic scream fest. If that's all you've seen of birth that's what you might expect for all births.

Your clarification makes sense and I see what you're getting at, but I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on this.

I'm afraid fundamentally I think birth is an unavoidably awful experience however you look at it. The only positive thing that emerges from it is the baby. Which is a big positive and ultimately why we put ourselves through it. But I honestly think people who convince themselves a vaginal delivery is a spiritual experience are deluding themselves. It's almost a kind of religious denial of reality like people flagellating themselves in the name of the Catholic Church. I just don't buy it.

Yes it helps to be informed, to plan and to argue your case. But pretending this will help manage pain is just dishonest. Far healthier for people to face up to the fact that it's a really difficult, painful and traumatic process but that modern medicine will make it survivable and have faith that it will be worth it in the end.

Clearly you won't believe me, but that wasn't my experience of birth. I was clearly very lucky and unusual, but I'm not delusional, whether or not you 'buy it'!

I am genuinely mildly sad that I will never give birth again.

MotherofBingo · 13/04/2023 18:05

StevieNic · 13/04/2023 13:26

Allot of women on this thread are OTT triggered and offended, there are plenty of commenters agreeing that their c secs weren’t ‘birth’ or ‘labour’.They’re entitled to their opinion and you are unreasonable for being so easily offended. I’ve had friends say to me they didn’t give birth but the baby was surgically delivered. They’re not upset about any suggestion it isn’t ‘birth’.

Also the women saying at least they don’t have floppy fannies or whatever are vile and shouldn’t be parents. Not even factual I don’t know anybody who had a noticing your wider vagina after giving birth.

There are clear definitions of what birth and labour are - regardless of uneducated and ignorant opinions, those definitions don't change. C-sections are births as defined in the English language, we are talking about babies not teeth. Many women do go through labour before having a c-section, again the stages of labour are clearly defined and are not dependant on the delivery that comes after. Shaming shouldn't happen either way round but denying a medical fact (c-sections are births) isn't going to help matters.

Thepeopleversuswork · 13/04/2023 17:56

Babooshka1992 · 13/04/2023 13:13

@Saschka there’s loads out there about natural births being healthier for baby first that comes up is this article https://www.thetot.com/pregnancy-and-fertility/9-benefits-of-a-vaginal-birth/

This is highly unscientific and all the assumptions in this article are based on best-case scenarios with no risk factors whatsoever.

GoneTillNovember · 13/04/2023 17:42

Maybe even every stage of womanhood, mother or not!

GoneTillNovember · 13/04/2023 17:42

@CountingMareep ok, no worries at all. It is a sad state of affairs that women are made to feel inadequate about their birth experiences, no matter what form that takes. I find it hard to comprehend that women could tear each other down like that. Unfortunately it seems to be something that is replicated at every stage of motherhood! 😩

CountingMareep · 13/04/2023 17:13

I am not sure if you were trying to be snarky towards me..? I was saying that I couldn't understand the appeal of vaginal birth until I witnessed my sister's 2 births, which were straightforward.

I was absolutely not trying to be snarky towards you @GoneTillNovember . In fact, I’m rather envious of people like your sister. I used to read stuff by Sheila Kitzinger (she was something of a feminist as well as a natural birth pioneer) when I was an impressionable teenager finding out about the ‘facts’ of life, and scenes like that often featured in my fantasy far-off future.

The snark comes from my own anger at how ‘normal’ births are perceived to be more normal (and more controllable) than they really are, IYSWIM. While I was a bit more clued up at 33 than I was at 16 (not mad enough to ask for a home birth for my first, for example), I did feel to some extent that I had been misled for many years about the true likelihood of achieving that happy scenario.

ny20005 · 13/04/2023 17:08

I had this from my mother in law - asked me if I felt cheated from having a normal birth. No, funnily enough, I'm pleased that my baby survived without life changing injuries Hmm

thatsn0tmyname · 13/04/2023 17:07

Competitive birthing can fuck off.
I had an emergency caesarian and a vaginal birth. Both experiences left me with stitches, pain, soreness, tiredness, constipation but ultimately a healthy baby.
I see no difference.

Fandabedodgy · 13/04/2023 17:03

StevieNic · 13/04/2023 13:26

Allot of women on this thread are OTT triggered and offended, there are plenty of commenters agreeing that their c secs weren’t ‘birth’ or ‘labour’.They’re entitled to their opinion and you are unreasonable for being so easily offended. I’ve had friends say to me they didn’t give birth but the baby was surgically delivered. They’re not upset about any suggestion it isn’t ‘birth’.

Also the women saying at least they don’t have floppy fannies or whatever are vile and shouldn’t be parents. Not even factual I don’t know anybody who had a noticing your wider vagina after giving birth.

Hypocrisy Klaxon

Fandabedodgy · 13/04/2023 17:00

Why do we accept this shit?

EliosBackPack · 13/04/2023 15:19

I can’t imagine the utter, crass stupidity of anyone thinking or saying this to a new mother who has had a C-section.
It’s vicious and stupid, if I heard anything like this I’d take their face off.
PS: I am a mother and grandmother and never had a C-section.

bossonext · 13/04/2023 14:51

StevieNic · 13/04/2023 13:26

Allot of women on this thread are OTT triggered and offended, there are plenty of commenters agreeing that their c secs weren’t ‘birth’ or ‘labour’.They’re entitled to their opinion and you are unreasonable for being so easily offended. I’ve had friends say to me they didn’t give birth but the baby was surgically delivered. They’re not upset about any suggestion it isn’t ‘birth’.

Also the women saying at least they don’t have floppy fannies or whatever are vile and shouldn’t be parents. Not even factual I don’t know anybody who had a noticing your wider vagina after giving birth.

People who don't like things you agree with = OTT and unreasonable to be offended.

People who say things you disagree with = vile and shouldn't be parents.

Ithurtsthebackofmyeyes · 13/04/2023 14:48

YirumaFan1 · 13/04/2023 14:27

I don’t not agree with you but find it pretty hilarious you’re giving out about women on this thread being OTT triggered and offended by posters saying ‘it wasn’t a birth it was an extraction’ and ‘too posh to push’ amongst other nasty comments while simultaneously being OTT triggered and offended yourself by comments made about the aftermath of vaginal birth to the extent you’re saying those posters shouldn’t be parents @StevieNic

It’s an irony that will be lost on posters that basic.

YirumaFan1 · 13/04/2023 14:27

StevieNic · 13/04/2023 13:26

Allot of women on this thread are OTT triggered and offended, there are plenty of commenters agreeing that their c secs weren’t ‘birth’ or ‘labour’.They’re entitled to their opinion and you are unreasonable for being so easily offended. I’ve had friends say to me they didn’t give birth but the baby was surgically delivered. They’re not upset about any suggestion it isn’t ‘birth’.

Also the women saying at least they don’t have floppy fannies or whatever are vile and shouldn’t be parents. Not even factual I don’t know anybody who had a noticing your wider vagina after giving birth.

I don’t not agree with you but find it pretty hilarious you’re giving out about women on this thread being OTT triggered and offended by posters saying ‘it wasn’t a birth it was an extraction’ and ‘too posh to push’ amongst other nasty comments while simultaneously being OTT triggered and offended yourself by comments made about the aftermath of vaginal birth to the extent you’re saying those posters shouldn’t be parents @StevieNic

GoneTillNovember · 13/04/2023 14:15

*Oh, I wanted one like that. Childbirth how nature should have organised it if ‘Mother’ Nature really knew best. Sadly when I went to the Birth Choice Shop a couple of decades ago they were all out of straightforward home births in my size. I think there’s always been supply issues with those.

More seriously, there’s often a really unpleasant undercurrent of eugenics/nature fascism in a lot of the natural childbirth movement’s ideas. I sometimes encounter the idea that somehow women who have had sections have passed on their defective birthing equipment to the next generation and are bringing down the human race. Which, as well as being staggeringly offensive and misogynistic, is really inaccurate scientifically*

I am not sure if you were trying to be snarky towards me..? I was saying that I couldn't understand the appeal of vaginal birth until I witnessed my sister's 2 births, which were straightforward.

I've had 3 c sections (1 emergency, 2 elective). I also have IVF so they didn't go in or come out 'naturally' so how's that for deficient genetics...