Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

… to say I don’t think I need life insurance?

84 replies

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 13:48

I am 42, no children (or other financial dependents) and am not married. My job is 100% WFH, desk based. I have a boyfriend and we have been together six years. Our finances are totally separate. We split our time between a city, where he has a property, and the country, where I have a property. Both properties have mortgages right now. Mine will be paid off by the time I am 58, if not before (at the moment I choose not to overpay the mortgage a lot but invest more into pensions etc, but this approach does fluctuate). We have good Bupa healthcare plans.

If you have no financial dependents, what is the benefit to having life insurance? If I die, the house will be sold to repay the bank. I know there is critical illness cover but if that is the only benefit, compared to the additional benefits to someone who has financial dependents, the loss- benefit analysis just doesn’t seem worth it to me.

I accept basic life insurance is not a huge monthly outgoing, but those basic policies seem even less worthwhile in my situation. Adding it up over the years it is massive and I’d much rather invest it in a private pension that will grow and can be accessed ten years before pensionable age.

Thoughts? Am I missing something obvious?!

OP posts:
2bazookas · 12/04/2023 15:58

We've had no life insurance since the mortgage ended along with its compulsory policy. We've got none now; when one of us dies the survivor will have no financial worries.

acuppatea · 12/04/2023 15:56

I know someone who had critical illness cover and was diagnosed with cancer in their early 30s. The critical illness cover paid out enough to pay off their substantial outstanding mortgage, and they went on to completely recover from the cancer and are now able to live mortgage free and maintain a good income through work. So a pretty good outcome (obviously bearing in mind a cancer diagnosis!)

KickHimInTheCrotch · 12/04/2023 15:47

I don't have life or critical illness insurance. I'm 45 and a single parent to 2 young children. In the event of my death my children would go to live with their dad (they have bedrooms there and could stay in the same schols) and the equity on my mortgage (about 300k currently) would pay for funeral costs and help fund my children's future.

However if I got diagnosed with something awful but survivable and was unable to work I would be in the shit because I have no savings to speak of and I'm more than a decade away from being able to claim my (fairly decent) workplace pension . But I can't really bring myself to pay another fairly sizable bill every month "just in case".

Lovelyring · 12/04/2023 15:46

I didn't get critical illness. I got the impression that the list of illnesses they'll pay out for is very specific and not worth it compared to the cost. My job had good sickness pay and the life insurance would pay out if I were diagnosed with a terminal illness.

Lovelyring · 12/04/2023 15:42

I took it out when I was 25 because it was super cheap when I was that young. I figured one day I might have dependents, and if not I'd leave it to my favourite charity or other family and friends.

In your situation not sure I'd bother though. I had some life insurance through work which was enough for me.

Aandornot · 12/04/2023 15:31

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 15:20

@Aandornot Even someone who has good health, no mortgage, has accessed their private pension of, say, £1M at age 60 with a smaller workplace pension still to come ten years later? Surely that would just be throwing money away for no reason!

So my point is that it’s not black and white, more that there is a sliding scale of needing life/ critical/ income insurance and many factors that help you decide whether or not you need it and how much you might need. This is the part I am struggling with.

But you're not 60? There's no point considering your future financial affairs if you wake up tomorrow with cancer etc and can't work/don't want to work for an extended period. For context I'm a mortgage broker I hear a lot of reasons for not taking cover all the time, never had one that doesn't have a counter argument. Had a few come back and wished they'd taken it as they're now ill, had a few reluctantly take cover then claim on it and never have to work again. No one can make the decision for you though.

3dogsandarabbit · 12/04/2023 15:29

OP - If you are quite happy to use your savings to pay your mortgage/bills if you were ever in that position, then I think if I was you I wouldn't bother with mortgage or critical illness protection and just put some money away each month to add to your savings.

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 15:20

@Aandornot Even someone who has good health, no mortgage, has accessed their private pension of, say, £1M at age 60 with a smaller workplace pension still to come ten years later? Surely that would just be throwing money away for no reason!

So my point is that it’s not black and white, more that there is a sliding scale of needing life/ critical/ income insurance and many factors that help you decide whether or not you need it and how much you might need. This is the part I am struggling with.

OP posts:
teenagetantrums · 12/04/2023 15:16

I don't have life insurance. I did when my kids were little they adults now. My pension will pay out for them if l die before l claim it. I have enough money in savings for cremation and no debts l don't see the point now.

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 15:13

@3dogsandarabbit I understand your point. I have savings that would last me about a year if I really couldn’t work at my desk job and had to leave my job. Critical illness/ income protection for my mortgage/ income would be a significant monthly bill and I often struggle to see the benefit given my circumstances. It’s more than very likely it’ll just be lost money. But I guess this is what insurance is at it’s very core. You are paying for peace of mind.

The savings I mention would cover a funeral.

OP posts:
Aandornot · 12/04/2023 15:12

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 14:53

@Aandornot It was actually my financial advisor that got me thinking about this a bit more. His advice isn’t to take it out, but to weigh up the factors I have explained in other posts above and make a decision (see reply to @Heroicallyfound). It’s not so easy though!

Many would say: just pay it, it’s not a big monthly cost. But critical illness cover is much more expensive than life insurance alone and when you add it up over the years and consider the cash lost from not investing, it’s huge.

It’s quite difficult to purchase critical illness alone, although not impossible from my research and discussions with brokers. Life insurance can and often is purchased alone and is inexpensive. Life insurance is usually included when you request critical illness because it’s such a small cost compared to that associated with a life insurance policy.

So your query is about whether to take out critical illness cover or not rather than life insurance?

Yes
Absolutely. Everyone that can have it should have it in my opinion.

3dogsandarabbit · 12/04/2023 15:04

I think you need mortgage protection insurance so that if you were ill or had an accident and couldn't work your mortgage would still be paid every month for a certain amount of time.

Also I think that all adults should make sure they have the funds to pay for their funeral. It is selfish to expect other family members to pay for it.

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 15:04

@Can2022getanyworse Thank you for your thoughts! 😊 🙏

OP posts:
PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 14:57

@Zumzum A friend of mine in her late 40s had to stop work due to a serious cancer diagnosis last year and I have been living with her a few days a week to help her out. This has got me thinking about exactly this!

Of course I understand this could happen to me too. So that’s why I am considering all the factors and whether or not i should take out insurance. When I add critical illness, it’s a sizeable monthly bill and I can’t help but think it’s better invested elsewhere given my savings are good, the sort of job I have etc.

OP posts:
Can2022getanyworse · 12/04/2023 14:56

OP you have no need for life insurance, but I would recommend some critical illness cover. These policies pay out if you are diagnosed with something REALLY SERIOUS and take away the worry whilst you are going through treatment.

You could always consider income protection in the event of being unable to work through medium-term illness/accident/unemployment - again would pay the bills without eating through your savings.

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 14:53

@Aandornot It was actually my financial advisor that got me thinking about this a bit more. His advice isn’t to take it out, but to weigh up the factors I have explained in other posts above and make a decision (see reply to @Heroicallyfound). It’s not so easy though!

Many would say: just pay it, it’s not a big monthly cost. But critical illness cover is much more expensive than life insurance alone and when you add it up over the years and consider the cash lost from not investing, it’s huge.

It’s quite difficult to purchase critical illness alone, although not impossible from my research and discussions with brokers. Life insurance can and often is purchased alone and is inexpensive. Life insurance is usually included when you request critical illness because it’s such a small cost compared to that associated with a life insurance policy.

OP posts:
CleaningOutMyCloset · 12/04/2023 14:51

When I was single, or had boyfriends that I didn't live with and no kids I didn't bother with life insurance. Why would I? I had no dependants, my house went to my parents, or what little equity there was would go to them anyway. All that was needed was my funeral coats which could be taken from the equity

Aandornot · 12/04/2023 14:43

You need critical illness cover and/or income protection. Life insurance doesn't 'include' critical illness cover although you can buy them as one policy - you can also but them as separate independent policies. See a good broker/IFA for further advice.

Zumzum · 12/04/2023 14:40

I would consider consider illness/income protection yes…..if you were diagnosed with eg. A survivable cancer, who would pay your mortgage/living expenses? Savings?are you assets easily accessible?would your boyfriend choose to help you out?You are only 42 and the whole point is you don’t know what will happen between now and retirement age so if you were unable to work for 6 mths/12mths/never again how would you finance this, that’s the question to ask. I’m very aware being in my 50s of a number of both friends and acquaintances who have died from cancer or had to have treatment for cancer in their30s/ 40s/50s .I have not been able to work since my early 40s due to illness and am unlikely to work ever again but luckily I have a spouse to support me (needless to say he has insurance!)

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 14:37

@jennytheonionslayer Thank you- it’s a good way to think about it. The other point I suppose is the amount that you choose to cover doesn’t necessarily need to be your full outstanding mortgage but perhaps a portion that you think covers the worst case scenario, taking any savings and time to retirement into consideration.

OP posts:
PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 14:34

@Heroicallyfound I definitely understand your point. But it’s not the same for everyone is it? It’s risk based. It makes most sense for someone with no/ limited savings to see them through a period of illness, a manual or non-WFH job, or only a workplace pension that can’t be accessed until state pension age (thereby increasing the time there is to get sick and not have money to live).

None of these things apply to me. My cash savings aren’t endless but I’d need to be so sick I couldn’t do a desk job and on zero income for probably a year before they’d run out.

My thinking has always been that the money is better saved or invested and that in turn reduces the risk even more of needing the insurance.

OP posts:
jennytheonionslayer · 12/04/2023 14:28

Ask yourself is there an insurable interest anywhere?

Will anyone suffer financially in the event of your death?

If not, you don't need life assurance.

I would also apply the same questions to yourself in respect of income protection and critical illness.

Heroicallyfound · 12/04/2023 14:19

You need to think of them as separate things.

It doesn’t sound like it’s worth getting life insurance in your position.

Critical illness cover makes sense for anyone. Think about what money you would need if you got cancer or lost a limb etc before retirement. How would you pay your mortgage and what would you live on?

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 14:15

When I referred to life insurance I was actually thinking about both life and critical illness, which are often sold together. I should have said that- sorry! Critical illness makes up the majority of the cost of policies like that.

This is the risk/ benefit part I think about. There is a risk I could get sick before the age of 58 (or whatever the age is then for accessing a private pension), but is it really worth it with the kind of job I have (family-owned, flexible, WFH), my current health/ family history, the private pension I can access in 15-20 years etc. Of course anyone can get ill at any time. But weighing all that up, it just seems such a waste. Even a £10pcm policy, paid from the age of 30 to 70, would likely be worth £10k in a mediocre performing pension over that time!

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 12/04/2023 14:08

I agree that you don't need life insurance. My children want me to have a funeral, so I've got insurance to cover that. I'm mortgage free etc. The insurance is easy to access, I've made one DD my executor, but I can see there being arguments. So insurance was the best course of action for my funeral costs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread