Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

… to say I don’t think I need life insurance?

84 replies

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 13:48

I am 42, no children (or other financial dependents) and am not married. My job is 100% WFH, desk based. I have a boyfriend and we have been together six years. Our finances are totally separate. We split our time between a city, where he has a property, and the country, where I have a property. Both properties have mortgages right now. Mine will be paid off by the time I am 58, if not before (at the moment I choose not to overpay the mortgage a lot but invest more into pensions etc, but this approach does fluctuate). We have good Bupa healthcare plans.

If you have no financial dependents, what is the benefit to having life insurance? If I die, the house will be sold to repay the bank. I know there is critical illness cover but if that is the only benefit, compared to the additional benefits to someone who has financial dependents, the loss- benefit analysis just doesn’t seem worth it to me.

I accept basic life insurance is not a huge monthly outgoing, but those basic policies seem even less worthwhile in my situation. Adding it up over the years it is massive and I’d much rather invest it in a private pension that will grow and can be accessed ten years before pensionable age.

Thoughts? Am I missing something obvious?!

OP posts:
SmallAngryPenguinWoman · 12/04/2023 17:55

Genuine question please from a non-UK person; do you not need to take out life assurance cover for death when you take out a mortgage?
From my experience here, banks won't lend you money for a mortgage unless you have a policy to cover loan in the event of your death. Of course you can add critical illness but death is a minimum requirement.
I was read threads/news articles of UK experience in bewilderment when there's a story that says something like ...... I lost my home when DH died because I couldn't keep up mortgage payments...
If my DH died the mortgage protection cover would kick in and pay off the balance.

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:51

@Blondeshavemorefun Unless you are in negative equity for some reason, like the housing market takes a massive crash, or you didn’t keep up with your payments, there will always be money back to you (or in this case your estate) after the sale of a house, even if you sold it soon after buying it, because banks ask you to put down a mortgage deposit.

Example:
House bought in 2013: £200k
Deposit £20k
Mortgage/ amount owed to bank: £180k
Same house sold in 2023: £250k example
Mortgage/ amount owed to bank: £130k example
Cash back to you: £120k

OP posts:
PixiKitKat · 12/04/2023 17:43

We don't have children but do have a mortgage. We have life insurance and critical illness cover, never thought we claim on it but my husband has been diagnosed with an illness which is life long. So we're claiming the critical illness element and if successful, we will have no mortgage.

Marmight · 12/04/2023 17:42

Your pension would probably pay out a lump sum on your death (the fund value) and do you not have life assurance from work?
I know I do and it will pay out 4 x my annual salary.

Whisper23 · 12/04/2023 17:42

£25-£35 a month would allow you to include critical illness of something like ~£40k payout, or £2k a month for two years. Rough figures from a few of the big providers. It’s not like they pay you forever until you’re better. I’ve got that sort of cash in savings.

This is incorrect. Proper Income Protection would pay out for as long as you're unable to work, or the end of the policy (which is usually chosen to match your retirement age). There are budget versions which will only pay out for two years but the better policies aren't like that.

If I was in your position I'd seriously consider Income Protection.

Hankunamatata · 12/04/2023 17:40

Get enough to cover the mortgage or perhaps look a combined plan which includes illness cover incase you can't work. I think some policies payout on cancer diagnosis etc which would be handy if worst happened to you and needed to stop working and pay for care

Blondeshavemorefun · 12/04/2023 17:38

Guess depends how much mortgage is left op

But you seemed to have made up your mind

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:32

@mast0650 thanks for your thoughts! Yes I think this is still my opinion but from what others have said I think I might also look at a shorter policy to take me through to private pensionable age, maybe less coverage too.

It’s not like I’m saying £40 a month would break the bank, it’s that I think it might be far better spent elsewhere.

I suppose it all comes down to how risk averse we are though and the answer will be different for all of us.

OP posts:
PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:29

@Zumzum My BF has always taken it out for this reason! He just believed the mortgage brokers over the years. I think they have to be a bit more transparent these days.

58 is what my plans are based around but I think this will likely be extended for the reasons you state. Your point about taking it out for a shorter term is well taken 🙏

OP posts:
mast0650 · 12/04/2023 17:27

It sounds as if you have thought about it carefully and looked at the costs and benefits of critical illness cover. I agree that if you have a pretty good savings cushion anyway, no dependents, and good sick pay etc from your employer, then it may not make financial sense. It's not free money - the insurance companies expect to make a profit on it! From what I understand, these policies are often quite restricted in what they pay out and in what circumstances. They are certainly not some cheap, magic solution to loss of earnings in the future.

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:26

@Saracen Haha! Aww he sounds lovely 🤗

OP posts:
Zumzum · 12/04/2023 17:25

OP@PARunnerGirl the really good thing is that you are sitting down and thinking about it and discussing with a financial planner,it sounds like you are in a far better position than many if you could afford to keep yourself afloat via savings for a couple of years. You could of course choose to buy a policy and pay into it only up to the point where you could technically access your private pension. The caveat is of course what governments do to change rules….for eg. they are putting back the minimum age at you which can access a private pension from 55 to 57 from 2028 and no doubt they will be keen to push this back further. It is all about contingency planning for your particular circumstances, having worked in healthcare I am risk averse as you do see the “worst case “ scenario happen ,cancer treatment in particular can leave you in a dire financial situation and sadly I have seen people lose their homes because of it. I’ve been surprised to learn this year (via mumsnet!) that people don’t have to take out insurance products linked to their mortgage,I always presumed this was compulsory!!

Saracen · 12/04/2023 17:24

My dad did a brief stint as a life insurance salesman. He wasn't very good at that job, because he told people like you the truth: they didn't need it! He couldn't bear to see people waste money.

Aandornot · 12/04/2023 17:21

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:16

@Aandornot There is no rage here. Apologies if something in my reply read like that.

“Everyone that can have it should have it in my opinion.” - this read very black and white to me.

🤷 thats my opinion generally, of course there are exceptions. I've never met anyone who regrets taking it, particularly if they take it when young and I then requote them later in life and its ridiculously expensive or things are then excluded due to medical history. But you do what's right for you, I wouldn't throw similar looking rage at your IFA though- they're trying to help and probably have similar experience to me if they've been in the game a long time. They've seen clients get ill, struggle, die etc or get ill- get a payout- enjoy life til they then die or they live a long fruitful stress free life. It's a gamble either way I guess. Now I really will take my leave, au revoir.

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:16

@Aandornot There is no rage here. Apologies if something in my reply read like that.

“Everyone that can have it should have it in my opinion.” - this read very black and white to me.

OP posts:
Aandornot · 12/04/2023 17:12

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:09

@Aandornot It’s absolutely mental to think everyone’s situation is the same and this is a black and white matter! Unless perhaps your job is so commission driven that you have been brainwashed not to even listen to and consider completely reasonable arguments.

I didnt say its black and white. In your situation I think you'd be silly not to take it. From the limited information you've given and your high risk age. What's the point of making a thread about it when you've already made your mind up and now you're just getting the rage for no reason? Can't handle a difference of opinion. Also I don't get commission 👍 I'll leave you with it, take care and good luck.

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:12

@Blondeshavemorefun Of a 180k mortgage.

OP posts:
PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:11

@Blondeshavemorefun They don’t take what you’ve paid! What do you think happens when a house is sold? Let’s say you’ve paid off £179,000 of a house that is then sold for £180,000? You think the bank keeps the full £180k?!

OP posts:
PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:09

@Aandornot It’s absolutely mental to think everyone’s situation is the same and this is a black and white matter! Unless perhaps your job is so commission driven that you have been brainwashed not to even listen to and consider completely reasonable arguments.

OP posts:
Blondeshavemorefun · 12/04/2023 17:08

@PARunnerGirl tho seems pointless to pay towards a mortgage and if something happened to you before paid off that the bank will reclaim it

Life insurance isn't expensive and sounds like you. Qb afford it if have investments etx

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:06

@Blondeshavemorefun I have a will and my brother will get my estate. But I absolutely know he would not expect me to insure that I can pay off a mortgaged house posthumously so he can own it in full!

Funeral costs would be covered by my savings, investments etc.

I just realised I covered your £10 a month comment in my reply to @RosemaryAndTime - sorry both! I got your posts mixed up.

OP posts:
Aandornot · 12/04/2023 17:04

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:00

@RosemaryAndTime This is exactly the dilemma because it depends when something like that would happen.

£10 a month wouldn’t get you decent critical illness or income protection. It would get you an ok life insurance policy, which might pay out if you were diagnosed with a terminal illness.

£25-£35 a month would allow you to include critical illness of something like ~£40k payout, or £2k a month for two years. Rough figures from a few of the big providers. It’s not like they pay you forever until you’re better. I’ve got that sort of cash in savings.

I’ll access a good private pension at 58 (although realistically probably 60 or more by the time it comes). And of course I have a partner with a good salary who would hopefully not see me destitute! But I try to be completely independent of him when making financial decisions.

So if it happened tomorrow, and I went from FT work to absolutely nothing overnight, then I might struggle after a couple of years. But if it happened in my mid 50s or I could work through some of my illness, I’d likely be OK.

£35 a month into my pensions or investments for the next two decades is worth a lot!

You've already made up your mind, it's a shame. Is that really all you've been quoted? £40 a month? Probably half most people's sky bill. I'd just have it, check the limitations and compare policies maybe. I hope no one reads this and thinks actually yeah I don't need that and then does...

PARunnerGirl · 12/04/2023 17:00

@RosemaryAndTime This is exactly the dilemma because it depends when something like that would happen.

£10 a month wouldn’t get you decent critical illness or income protection. It would get you an ok life insurance policy, which might pay out if you were diagnosed with a terminal illness.

£25-£35 a month would allow you to include critical illness of something like ~£40k payout, or £2k a month for two years. Rough figures from a few of the big providers. It’s not like they pay you forever until you’re better. I’ve got that sort of cash in savings.

I’ll access a good private pension at 58 (although realistically probably 60 or more by the time it comes). And of course I have a partner with a good salary who would hopefully not see me destitute! But I try to be completely independent of him when making financial decisions.

So if it happened tomorrow, and I went from FT work to absolutely nothing overnight, then I might struggle after a couple of years. But if it happened in my mid 50s or I could work through some of my illness, I’d likely be OK.

£35 a month into my pensions or investments for the next two decades is worth a lot!

OP posts:
RosemaryAndTime · 12/04/2023 16:10

I would agree that you don't need life insurance to pay out if you die but how would you cope if you were unable to work due to illness?
You really should consider buying an income protection policy.

Blondeshavemorefun · 12/04/2023 16:10

You may not have dependants but isn't there someone in your life who would Benefit(if that's the right word) from your death

Rather then sell and pay back the mortgage :bank

What will happen to the access money

Do you have a will ? Would partner not get your home if no family /friends uou went it ti go to

My friend is single and childless but her house will go to her nephews in event of her death

For maybe £10/20 a month I think it's vital to have life insurance to pay off any debts /funereal costs