Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making a "healthy" meal plan is futile

217 replies

MooseBreath · 12/04/2023 13:08

I'm trying to lose weight. Over my 20s and after having 2 kids, I am no longer a good weight and I am trying to fix that. It is entirely because my portion control is crap and I love crisps.

I'm trying to eat healthier with weight loss in mind, without letting my children see their mother struggling with food. I also want them to know that moderation is key. We walk the dog every day for 45 minutes and have frequent dance parties and play active games throughout the day.

I thought my plan was healthy, but when I add up calories, it just works out that I won't be losing any weight at all (1722cal). No crisps, no sweets, no baked goods. But I don't know what to cut out without losing the energy to care for my boys and dog!
Breakfast: Raisin granola in a cup of milk
Lunch: Scrambled eggs, baked beans, and avocado with a slice of toast
Snack: Carrots, cucumber, and celery with hummus
Dinner: Baked gnocchi casserole with bacon

I don't see how I can make this better without starving myself. AIBU that demonstrating moderation will never work while I'm trying to lose weight?

OP posts:
IDontWantToBeAPie · 12/04/2023 22:38

ladyofshertonabbas · 12/04/2023 22:30

Bacon isn’t a diet food!

It can be. You can lose weight on any food so long as its in a calorie deficit.

2 slices of bacon is 90 calories. It's fine to eat.

ladyofshertonabbas · 12/04/2023 22:30

Bacon isn’t a diet food!

IDontWantToBeAPie · 12/04/2023 22:28

I've always struggled to lose weight. I managed it once - two stone. The only way (for me personally) Gym most days (Mon-Thurs) and eating three meals with lots of volume from vegetables.

The key struggle of my diet was that I was often ravenous. Usually after the gym or late at night I was hungry! But I'm pretty sure that's the point - you're in a calorie deficit so you're meant to be hungry.

labamba007 · 12/04/2023 21:09

This is the problem with diet advice on MN. No one knows op's weight and height, current diet, exercise levels etc. It may be that 1700 calories a day will provide a healthy 1-2lb loss every week. I had 1670 calories a day and lost 6-8 pounds a month myself.

And cutting carbs, fine. But in honesty,
Some people have diets of a packet of crisps and a chocolate bar for breakfast so going from that to granola in the first instance isn't so bad! Baby steps op, that's how you stick to it.

I also got rid of scales, haven't weighed myself in 6 months. Best decision ever!

KirstenBlest · 12/04/2023 19:43

I wouldn't eat the sauce on its own, I'd bung in a pile of veg.
Pasta and rice doesn't have a lot of flavour however you cook it.
Potatoes can have a lot of flavour, although mash is pretty bland if you use all rounder potatoes and don't add anything to them.

NotTerfNorCis · 12/04/2023 19:37

I'm trying to diet at the moment. Ideally sticking to one meal a day, lunch, a big salad. Tuna for protein. Tomatoes are good because they fill you up but are low calorie. Avoid cheese. Take vitamins.

I'm losing about 2lb a week.

Emigratingimmigrant · 12/04/2023 19:36

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 12/04/2023 19:35

Carbs have lots of flavour if they're cooked properly.

To turn it around, why would you just want to eat plain sauce without any extras?

Carbonara without oasta would be plain weird

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 12/04/2023 19:35

KirstenBlest · 12/04/2023 19:32

@coffeecupsandwaxmelts , it has some flavour but it's not very exciting, and I don't see the point of them. Why not just eat the sauce, or something that has flavour.

Carbs have lots of flavour if they're cooked properly.

To turn it around, why would you just want to eat plain sauce without any extras?

KirstenBlest · 12/04/2023 19:32

@coffeecupsandwaxmelts , it has some flavour but it's not very exciting, and I don't see the point of them. Why not just eat the sauce, or something that has flavour.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 12/04/2023 19:30

I don't understand why people want to eat empty carbs like gnocchi, rice and pasta. It has no flavour.

You don't just eat them dry - you add sauce, spice, herbs, protein and flavour!

If food has no flavour, you're not cooking it properly.

Emigratingimmigrant · 12/04/2023 19:27

If you like crisps, just take off elsewhere. I still have crips with my drinks at weekend and had throughout my weightloss. I just accounted for it throughout the week. That's the beauty of calorie counting. You can have occasional foods alongside daily foods, just account for it overall. What's a life without pizza 😁

Emigratingimmigrant · 12/04/2023 19:25

I don't understand why people want to eat empty carbs like gnocchi, rice and pasta. It has no flavour,

You are supposed to put something on them. Foods work together. Secondly, they have flavour if they are cooked right.
Few billion people manage

Unfriendly · 12/04/2023 19:24

If you’re a crisp fan why not make your own veggie crisps.. kale crisps with a little salt are absolutely gorgeous!

KirstenBlest · 12/04/2023 19:17

It really makes me wonder how people can eat snack foods (actual tasty ones, not just fruit and plain popcorn) without sacrificing a filling meal.
I don't understand why people eat snacks.
I don't understand why people want to eat empty carbs like gnocchi, rice and pasta. It has no flavour, and means I feel hungry after a few hours.
Fruit is tasty.

I make my own hummus. It's easy and doesn't need oil - I just add some of the aquafaba if it's too dry.

bellac11 · 12/04/2023 19:17

MooseBreath · 12/04/2023 18:43

I am learning a lot from this thread. I honestly thought granola, gnocchi, hummus, and avocado were genuinely healthy foods. They are advertised as such, and all of my health-conscious friends eat them regularly. This is why I didn't understand why my calories were adding up so quickly.

You need to understand the difference between healthy generally and what is useful for weight loss

Of course humous and avocado is 'healthy' meaning (in my eyes) that it is nutrient dense, lots of vitamins and minerals in those two things.

But watch the portion sizes when you want to lose weight only because they are also calorie dense (although not as much as a pizza or burger or cake for example)

So I had humous for lunch today. I had 197 cals worth, which is a lot. But I had it with one ryvita so my whole lunch was a reasonable amount of cals, high in protein, high in good fats, high in fibre and tasty.

Nothing wrong with either of those two foods, even if you're losing weight, just watch the amounts or dont have both on the same day, or same plate. Also make your own humous and then you have control over the oil in it.

LemonSwan · 12/04/2023 18:59

MooseBreath · 12/04/2023 18:43

I am learning a lot from this thread. I honestly thought granola, gnocchi, hummus, and avocado were genuinely healthy foods. They are advertised as such, and all of my health-conscious friends eat them regularly. This is why I didn't understand why my calories were adding up so quickly.

I think you should just listen to your body. It has a funny way of telling you what you need! But we lose touch with it.

Considering you say you always want crisps. Strikes me your body is telling you it needs carbs, oil and salt to survive. I have that body also!

So find something you can eat which fulfills this craving. When I want salt and oil I usually go for tomatoes doused in olive oil, salt and pepper. Can have with white pitta, on bread as bruschetta, as a side to a sandwich etc.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 12/04/2023 18:58

MooseBreath · 12/04/2023 18:43

I am learning a lot from this thread. I honestly thought granola, gnocchi, hummus, and avocado were genuinely healthy foods. They are advertised as such, and all of my health-conscious friends eat them regularly. This is why I didn't understand why my calories were adding up so quickly.

They aren't unhealthy, you just need to need to factor in the calories when eating them.

LSSG · 12/04/2023 18:51

Teachingteacher · 12/04/2023 13:33

OP, look up healthy volume eating. Like PPs have said, your choices are far too calorie dense. Egg whites, cottage cheese, turkey, 0% yoghurt (not flavoured) tonnes of veg, clear broths etc. Watch the sugar - granola is a killer as others have said. Watch your oils - hummus is full of oil (unless you make it yourself) which doesn’t give you much bang for your buck calorie wise. I’m at about 1500-1600 cals a day and I feel like I eat loads. If I’m starving at the end of the day, right before bed, then I’ll have 1/2 cup oats cooked in water with 1 scoop protein powder which is 275 cals.

Will Tenneyson on YouTube has some great diet hacks for volume eating. His mum, who is 60 and looks insanely good, also has a YouTube channel called ‘mama tenny’ which I’ve found really helpful.

This is just such terrible advice. If you eat things like egg white only you will be under nourished and over eat. Can't believe people want you to limit avocado too. These are the healthy foods/fats that fill you up without causing sugar crashes and over eating.

Forget calories. Go low carb and sugar - others are right though - ditch the toast and granola if possible. I would definitely eat (the whole) egg(s) for breakfast.

Remove all seed oils from your diet as far as possible (in nearly all crisps and fries and many processed foods) or only as an occasional treat. Replace with olive or coconut oil or grass fed butter. Don't be frightened of good fats, our bodies need them, they keep you full and help prevent blood sugar crashing.

RaininSummer · 12/04/2023 18:50

I think they are healthy but as they are high in calories not much good on a calorie counting diet.

MooseBreath · 12/04/2023 18:43

I am learning a lot from this thread. I honestly thought granola, gnocchi, hummus, and avocado were genuinely healthy foods. They are advertised as such, and all of my health-conscious friends eat them regularly. This is why I didn't understand why my calories were adding up so quickly.

OP posts:
LemonSwan · 12/04/2023 18:43

mumlikeaboss · 12/04/2023 18:27

Really?? What is that reason?

The outer parts of wheats/ rice (natural or what we call brown) are abrasive. The sharp husk parts pierce tiny holes in the gut and cause all manner of issues - both long and short term. This inflames your lining and can stop nutrient absorption. Bits of poop start flying about your body on a micro level. In the short term bloating, indigestion, discomfort etc.

People say white is a western thing but it’s not. Every culture came to the same conclusion of 100s if not 1000s of years that refined carbs are better. In China they eat white rice. In Mexico they eat refined corn products. In Italy white pasta, in U.K. white bread. Considering its a lot more effort to refine than not I don’t think it’s a coincidence.

bellac11 · 12/04/2023 18:39

Bobshhh · 12/04/2023 13:41

This 100%

I’m quite shocked by the responses here, this sounds like a sensible food diary to me.

Can you up your cardio exercise and add in some strength training?

It is a sensible food diary for someone just maintaining their weight, it is also one days food so doesnt say anything about the whole diet overall

But OP specifically asked about losing weight, so her diet will be very different to someone who is not wanting to lose weight. Portion sizes need to be smaller and the type of food might need to be different (its very individual)

Ultimately losing weight relies on a deficit and there are lots of different ways to achieve that deficit such as fasting, types of food intake, low fat, low carb etc, but ultimately it will reduce intake in some form or another.

For a lot of people things like sugary granola or high carb gnocci wouldnt be of a lot of use becuase they might cause more hunger but also they are fairly calorie dense, leaving not a lot of room or space for lower calorie and more nutrient dense foods. Hence why people are pointing that out. There are very nutrient dense foods that are also high calorie such as humous or avocado etc which one has to be careful about portion sizes or eking them out more

Thats what the other posts are about, not saying the diet is unhealthy overall

mumlikeaboss · 12/04/2023 18:37

MooseBreath · 12/04/2023 14:59

I am ok when it comes to exercise. I am a dance teacher (on maternity leave), so being active is very much a part of my life.

I don't drink much alcohol, maybe 2 glasses of wine per month. And 2 or 3 cups of tea/coffee per day, but I have swapped to sweetener instead of sugar. Otherwise I only drink water.

Cutting carbs further is just not realistic for me. I know myself and if I try to cut it completely, I will binge. I also want my kids to see me eating a balanced diet, and they have the same food I do.

I may try the intermittent fasting. Breakfast isn't key to me and I was doing it to kick-start my metabolism.

Should have read through properly before commenting before - here's your answer: breakfast isn't key to me

Eating breakfast to 'kick-start metabolism' is a load of bollocks, can't quote a reference but I've read somewhere that the slight increase in metabolism from eating earlier does NOT have a positive benefit when you add in the extra calories that you end up eating.

So if you could fairly easily skip it, then absolutely do. Have water and black tea or coffee until lunch, enjoy a filling and balanced meal at lunch and dinner, and stop eating after dinner (ie don't graze / snack late at night).

All the best ❤️

mackthepony · 12/04/2023 18:34

Sounds like you're doing great op.

It is tough but will be worth it and does get easier

mumlikeaboss · 12/04/2023 18:27

LemonSwan · 12/04/2023 17:25

Don’t cut back on carbs without finding out your amylase levels. You can do a cracker test to work that out. Also switching to brown is not good for gut health regardless of what everyone goes on about. There’s a reason all cultures ended up eating white as standard.

Really?? What is that reason?