Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making a "healthy" meal plan is futile

217 replies

MooseBreath · 12/04/2023 13:08

I'm trying to lose weight. Over my 20s and after having 2 kids, I am no longer a good weight and I am trying to fix that. It is entirely because my portion control is crap and I love crisps.

I'm trying to eat healthier with weight loss in mind, without letting my children see their mother struggling with food. I also want them to know that moderation is key. We walk the dog every day for 45 minutes and have frequent dance parties and play active games throughout the day.

I thought my plan was healthy, but when I add up calories, it just works out that I won't be losing any weight at all (1722cal). No crisps, no sweets, no baked goods. But I don't know what to cut out without losing the energy to care for my boys and dog!
Breakfast: Raisin granola in a cup of milk
Lunch: Scrambled eggs, baked beans, and avocado with a slice of toast
Snack: Carrots, cucumber, and celery with hummus
Dinner: Baked gnocchi casserole with bacon

I don't see how I can make this better without starving myself. AIBU that demonstrating moderation will never work while I'm trying to lose weight?

OP posts:
midgemadgemodge · 13/04/2023 09:03

It's hard to say if she is under or over

If she is a dance teacher she may well have good muscle development and if she is very active she could be under at 1700

ImSweetEnoughDarlin · 13/04/2023 08:58

midgemadgemodge · 13/04/2023 08:29

Being 100 calories a day under your tdee will take you a month to lose a pound on average

( and playing with a toddler all day isn't as calories consuming as you might like)

Shes not eating under her TDEE, she's aiming to eat over it 🤔

Emigratingimmigrant · 13/04/2023 08:34

Minfilia · 13/04/2023 08:20

You can buy low sugar beans.

Technically fruit is also full of sugar, but that isn’t demonised 🤷‍♀️

Because it's not sugar as sugar and people need to get that into their heads. It's not that hard.
Re demonising fruit. Come on, it's on here all the time. And peas

midgemadgemodge · 13/04/2023 08:29

Being 100 calories a day under your tdee will take you a month to lose a pound on average

( and playing with a toddler all day isn't as calories consuming as you might like)

JaneFondue · 13/04/2023 08:22

Minfilia · 13/04/2023 08:20

You can buy low sugar beans.

Technically fruit is also full of sugar, but that isn’t demonised 🤷‍♀️

Sure. But we don't know if OP is eating low sugar beans. I am just saying there are easy swaps to be made here and a lot of hidden sugars in the original diet posted.

MaryBeardsShoes · 13/04/2023 08:22

OP first thing to do is not to take any of the advice from Mumsnet. Y

MooseBreath · 13/04/2023 08:21

ImSweetEnoughDarlin · 13/04/2023 08:18

So continue to eat 2000 and gain weight then 🤷‍♀️

I'm not bloody eating 2000 though -+which has no reason to make me gain weight as it's still a reduction of what I was having-- ! I explicitly stated that yesterday was 1722.

OP posts:
Minfilia · 13/04/2023 08:20

JaneFondue · 13/04/2023 08:04

Baked beans are full of sugar, are they not? I eat tons of beans, but not baked beans. I find them way too sweet for me.

You can buy low sugar beans.

Technically fruit is also full of sugar, but that isn’t demonised 🤷‍♀️

ImSweetEnoughDarlin · 13/04/2023 08:18

MooseBreath · 13/04/2023 08:16

Except I have stated that I am active and have a physical job when not on maternity leave, and I currently spend all day running and dancing with my preschooler. And even if the number to maintain my weight is 1800, which is not backed by PHE, I am under that.

So continue to eat 2000 and gain weight then 🤷‍♀️

MooseBreath · 13/04/2023 08:16

midgemadgemodge · 13/04/2023 08:11

Used to be right

Women used to be a lot more active

And the average woman was a bit taller than you ( possibly 5 4 I can't recall)

There is also a lot of stuff saying that 2000 figure isn't helping and for the uk population 1800 is better estimate

Except I have stated that I am active and have a physical job when not on maternity leave, and I currently spend all day running and dancing with my preschooler. And even if the number to maintain my weight is 1800, which is not backed by PHE, I am under that.

OP posts:
midgemadgemodge · 13/04/2023 08:11

Used to be right

Women used to be a lot more active

And the average woman was a bit taller than you ( possibly 5 4 I can't recall)

There is also a lot of stuff saying that 2000 figure isn't helping and for the uk population 1800 is better estimate

MooseBreath · 13/04/2023 08:07

https://www.womenshealthmag.com/uk/food/weight-loss/a28241466/2000-calories-a-day/

A quick Google led me to Public Health England saying that 2000 calories is used to maintain weight for the average women based on studies.

Is Eating 2,000 Calories the Key to Maintaining a Healthy Weight

No more Googling

https://www.womenshealthmag.com/uk/food/weight-loss/a28241466/2000-calories-a-day

OP posts:
MaireadMcSweeney · 13/04/2023 08:05

If people's TDEEs are really that low then you need to get more active. I'm 5'4 and weigh 13.5 stone and mine is 2300 a day. Work out twice a week and walk minimum 10k a day, so nothing out of the ordinary.
I appreciate if you're very short or a much lower weight it will be lower but increasing your TDEE through activity is really easy.

JaneFondue · 13/04/2023 08:04

Minfilia · 13/04/2023 07:57

I absolutely agree.

Imagine demonising baked beans (full of fibre and protein) or avocado (full of healthy fats and fibre).

And carbs are FINE TO EAT on a diet (so OP I am absolutely with you - don’t cut them out. I’m similar and I need them too). Shocking, I know. Fasting? Totally unnecessary and makes no difference whatsoever if you aren’t in a calorie deficit.

“Eat half a sandwich” that’s disordered eating. Have a healthy sandwich on a protein bagel with a fuckton of salad instead.

The only sensible advice on this thread is to work out your TDEE which you’ve already done (as you need a deficit to lose weight) and to up the veggie intake (as it ups your fibre, which aids weight loss, and keeps you fuller).

Weight loss threads on MN do tend to bring out the clinically insane, though.

Baked beans are full of sugar, are they not? I eat tons of beans, but not baked beans. I find them way too sweet for me.

ImSweetEnoughDarlin · 13/04/2023 07:57

Hmm, so according to Google, the 2000 cals per day came about from being based on the average American diet at that time.

There you go then.

Minfilia · 13/04/2023 07:57

oldtree54 · 12/04/2023 17:45

Some of the comments on this thread are unhinged...

Your meal plan is fine, just pay attention portion sizes and log the calories. 1700 per day is low enough for weight loss.

I absolutely agree.

Imagine demonising baked beans (full of fibre and protein) or avocado (full of healthy fats and fibre).

And carbs are FINE TO EAT on a diet (so OP I am absolutely with you - don’t cut them out. I’m similar and I need them too). Shocking, I know. Fasting? Totally unnecessary and makes no difference whatsoever if you aren’t in a calorie deficit.

“Eat half a sandwich” that’s disordered eating. Have a healthy sandwich on a protein bagel with a fuckton of salad instead.

The only sensible advice on this thread is to work out your TDEE which you’ve already done (as you need a deficit to lose weight) and to up the veggie intake (as it ups your fibre, which aids weight loss, and keeps you fuller).

Weight loss threads on MN do tend to bring out the clinically insane, though.

Anyotherdude · 13/04/2023 07:56

The only time I’ve successfully lost weight, I did it using the Fast 800 diet and fasting 16 hours a day. It seemed to be the fasting, more than the 800 calories allowed, as I definitely went over some days… I lost 20lb in just over a month

Wallywobbles · 13/04/2023 07:56

A tip that might work for you is to start meals with crudités or a side salad. Coleslaws etc are good starter salads and you can make a few days worth.

Or a veg soup.

That way you're upping your veg and filling up a bit before you eat the main part of the meal.

Calories in carbs are a lot for little nutrition.

ImSweetEnoughDarlin · 13/04/2023 07:49

MooseBreath · 13/04/2023 06:54

I'm 5'2, but I haven't posted my weight because I genuinely don't own a scale (and when pregnant, closed my eyes when the midwife checked). I go by whether or not my clothes fit, and at the moment, they're very snug and I'd like to move down a couple sizes. I think if I knew a number, I would become obsessive.

I'm 5'1 and yesterday I was 198.2lbs.

My tdee for maintenance is about 1400 so I think you will definitely struggle to lose on 2000 (might even gain, I do) and even 1700 a day.

I don't know where that 2000 figure came from, it's not correct for a lot of women. Probably from a food industry study to push us to buy more. Or maybe it was from when we did a lot more physically? Doing all the housework manually, the way they did back in the day would require more calories than we need in our lifestyles today. Or maybe it was after rationing? When they needed to feed people up?

MooseBreath · 13/04/2023 07:47

My friend is very into her health and is a scientist, so has a good understanding. I trust her. I am not being irresponsible. I do not want to crash diet. I want something sustainable to continue whilst raising my children.

OP posts:
midgemadgemodge · 13/04/2023 07:44

At 5 ft 2 unless you have a very active life 1600 could be your maintenance calories ( which would also expalim your weight if you routinely overestimate what you need)

( typical woman 1800 plus 200 if you are quite active less 200 as you are short )

Loads of veg help

And yes it's hard
And yes you are likely to feel hungry

MaireadMcSweeney · 13/04/2023 07:36

MooseBreath · 13/04/2023 07:28

A friend calculated it for me at her house. I stood on her scale with my eyes closed and she worked it out.

You need to take a bit more responsibility here. What calculation did she use? I'm really sceptical of that figure (unless you're about 9 stone already and walk less than 2000 steps a day??)
You need to calculate TDEE not BMR.

MooseBreath · 13/04/2023 07:28

MaireadMcSweeney · 13/04/2023 07:18

If you don't know your weight, how did you come to the 1600 calories a day figure?

A friend calculated it for me at her house. I stood on her scale with my eyes closed and she worked it out.

OP posts:
comfyoldjeans · 13/04/2023 07:26

It all depends on your build but if you drop to 1500 cals, in theory you'll start to lose. If it were me, I'd drop the granola for breakfast and switch it for porridge or eggs. Dinner, instead of gnocchi casserole have something like chicken breast with veg and potatoes. I'm currently trying to lose weight and I love doing potato wedges in the air fryer and have them with baked chicken breast (bit of light cream cheese/garlic etc on top) and serve with veg. All the extra protein will keep you filled up.

If you plan well, you can definitely eat 1500 cals a day and not feel hungry. I'm currently on 1200 but I bulk out with protein, veg, zero fat cottage cheese, yoghurts etc and it's very rare that I'm hungry. Good luck OP! It's not easy but it IS possible.

MaireadMcSweeney · 13/04/2023 07:18

MooseBreath · 13/04/2023 06:54

I'm 5'2, but I haven't posted my weight because I genuinely don't own a scale (and when pregnant, closed my eyes when the midwife checked). I go by whether or not my clothes fit, and at the moment, they're very snug and I'd like to move down a couple sizes. I think if I knew a number, I would become obsessive.

If you don't know your weight, how did you come to the 1600 calories a day figure?