Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you or would you not ban someone who swore once and then immediately apologised?

137 replies

Changingggggggggggg · 12/04/2023 13:01

Just that really ...

Strange situation - in a hotel - one price had been agreed, they wanted to charge a higher price, they wouldn't speak quietly and calmly about it, but shouted at the guest and said there was no point in listening to what she said.

After 15 or so minutes of this, the guest, in enormous frustration did say "For F... Sake, please lets..." and then realising what they'd said, immediately apologised. The guest was rather shocked by what they'd said, having not done this before. She did then pay the higher price.

When they tried to book the hotel again a couple of months later, they discovered they had been banned - was told they had been told this by multiple people, despite there having been no communication.

Is this a banning situation - or do you give someone the benefit of the doubt, given their immediate apologies and contriteness?

OP posts:
pinkySilver · 12/04/2023 16:17

I also think that the price that was quoted was probably just that - a quote - subject to change - and not a booking, (or it would have been secured with a payment).
It was done over the phone and the hotel had no guarantee the OP would turn up (unless payment was taken). When she did confirm the current price was charged,

Mariposista · 12/04/2023 16:16

I wouldn’t want to subject my staff to anyone using foul language, no. Plenty of other ways to express displeasure.

WheelsUp · 12/04/2023 16:14

You have to remember that the person that you're talking to is not the one who profits from the higher price nor do they write the policies or determine price. They can't argue back if customers are out of order and usually on not much more than minimum wage.

WheelsUp · 12/04/2023 16:09

In this day and age where staff are hard to retain, I can see why they banned you for arguing. I think it's the arguing and not the swearing. While it sounds unfair that some were allowed the quoted price, legally they can ban you for whatever reason.

pinkySilver · 12/04/2023 16:08

I work in a customer facing role. People are understandably upset or frustrated by the time they get to me. Most manage to behave reasonably. There are however still a lot who don't.

I am at work. I don't see why I should be shouted at, sworn at, argued with, ranted at, subjected to snide comments or accusations and in some cases worse.
It doesn't matter if it's just once. I am at work and usually what's being challenged is outside my control anyway.

So yes - I think a ban is fair and I only wish more organisations would support their staff.

(And how would you feel if it was you or your lovely teenage DD who was regularly sworn at? It's not on is it?)

RiktheButler · 12/04/2023 15:55

ClaudiaWankleman · 12/04/2023 15:24

they wouldn't speak quietly and calmly about it, but shouted at the guest and said there was no point in listening to what she said.

Yes, very respectful. Try reading the first fucking paragraph.

There - I’ve done it.

Just so I'm clear - an op who cheerfully admits to arguing for 15 minutes and swearing and has steadfastly chosen to drip feed information while ignoring direct questions is definitely not giving a one sided version of events?

For absolute clarity, I don't believe the OP's version and from what they have admitted I would have removed them from the premises on the spot.

TheFireflies · 12/04/2023 15:50

Greensleevevssnotnose · 12/04/2023 14:12

Unless the room was paid in advance no contract exists. I used to a front desk manager. We might quote 125 a night but if the booking isn't confirmed in writing and paid upfront the charge could change on the day. It's called fluid pricing very common in hotels, airlines etc.

Not entirely true. Once a booking has been made and price agreed, the contract exists even if no payment is yet taken.

It sounds like OP booked over the phone though, so very hard to prove in that case.

Turfwars · 12/04/2023 15:48

There's a difference in swearing at a situation and swearing at staff. Service staff know when you are being a dick about the situation or being a dick towards them. And funnily enough, plenty of us totally get why a customer would be pissed off at something happening and often are secretly agreeing with you. But you'd be surprised at how insulting people can get towards customer services people and they don't even realise they are doing it.

My guess is that somewhere in the 15 mins of "arguing" involved either personal comments to the manager or to the staff before it got escalated, or it involved shouting and the swearing was the nail in your coffin.

Maverickess · 12/04/2023 15:42

Changingggggggggggg · 12/04/2023 15:08

The booking was made by phone - as it had been on previous occasions. This was how they operated. It was then confirmed by phone two weeks later, when I learnt that some people were being asked to pay more than agreed.

It is a small place and as students we were all meant to pay the same price - which is what happens now.

I didn't imagine that having agreed and confirmed a price on the phone, ie two occasions, that they wouldn't honour it - as they did for other students (but not all, one left as I said).

The booking was made by phone, with no following confirmation? It's a bit risky just from the regards of actually knowing you have the booking, on the right date, for the right amount of people/right room with no written confirmation, never mind pricing. They could have quoted you anything over the phone, you could have misheard the amount they said. I've never worked or booked anywhere that doesn't do that tbh.

If what you're describing is accurate then either they are deliberately trying to fleece students on this course, though they're pretty silly to think they'd get away with it because you know, people talk to each other, or they're very lacking in communication between themselves.

Doesn't mean you can swear at people though, and yes I do consider saying "FFS" in the way you describe swearing at someone.

That said though, I have had people at my desk who have booked themselves in online, not bothered to check their confirmation, turned up on the wrong day, with more people than they've booked for and then kick off at me because somehow that's all my/ the hotels fault they're getting what they booked instead of what they imagined 🤷🏼‍♀️.

But, as it's a business and not a public service, unless you are being discriminated against for a protected characteristic then they can refuse your business if they want to, for any reason, and they don't have to tell you why. You don't have the God given or even legal right to demand service from a business that doesn't want to give it to you, even though most people seem to think you do.

ReadersD1gest · 12/04/2023 15:39

2bazookas · 12/04/2023 15:35

And do you suggest OP use a fake credit card to make the fake ID booking with?

There's a reason hotels ask someone booking a room for their name, land address, contact phone number, credit card details.

Wear a wig 🤣🤣🤣🤣. Jesus Christ...

Agapornis · 12/04/2023 15:39

2bazookas · 12/04/2023 15:35

And do you suggest OP use a fake credit card to make the fake ID booking with?

There's a reason hotels ask someone booking a room for their name, land address, contact phone number, credit card details.

I quite clearly did not suggest that - the mention of a wig may have indicated it was not too be taken entirely seriously.

OP please wear a wig Grin

KnittingNeedles · 12/04/2023 15:37

Hotel can decide who they want to trade with based on any reason they choose, discrimination excepted.

slashlover · 12/04/2023 15:37

The booking was made by phone - as it had been on previous occasions. This was how they operated. It was then confirmed by phone two weeks later, when I learnt that some people were being asked to pay more than agreed.

If you phoned and booked then when did you need to phone up two weeks later to confirm? You had already booked at a specific price.

2bazookas · 12/04/2023 15:35

Agapornis · 12/04/2023 15:02

Contact the course leader - I can't imagine they're happy about their students constantly having the hassle of this hotel.

Alternatively: fake name, fake ID (if they ask), wear a wig.

And do you suggest OP use a fake credit card to make the fake ID booking with?

There's a reason hotels ask someone booking a room for their name, land address, contact phone number, credit card details.

LBFseBrom · 12/04/2023 15:35

I don't think it matters. The person who had a fifteen minute argument with a member of hotel staff, swore, apologised and left, is unlikely to do it again but there are presumably other hotels.

JackHackettsMac · 12/04/2023 15:33

Sounds like the hotel is in breach of contract if you’d made a booking with them based on their original offer and the fact you confirmed it by phone later. I’d write to them and threaten to sue them in the County Court and see what they say.

Alwayswonderedwhy · 12/04/2023 15:31

Impossible to tell without hearing the 15min discussion but if you really need to say there just book using a different email address.

ClaudiaWankleman · 12/04/2023 15:24

RiktheButler · 12/04/2023 15:00

The op argued for 15 minutes and then swore. We know this. We don't know what the issue with the price actually was because op hasn't told us and we don't know that the staff showed any disrespect at all. Please never enter any of my settings if you think swearing at staff is acceptable

they wouldn't speak quietly and calmly about it, but shouted at the guest and said there was no point in listening to what she said.

Yes, very respectful. Try reading the first fucking paragraph.

There - I’ve done it.

Namechangingagain111 · 12/04/2023 15:17

In terms of them increasing the price, that's pretty poor so would merit a poor review on Tripadvisor etc.
Honestly, I would have lost my temper with them - if there's not much choice of hotels nearby they're clearly trying it on....

BelindaMelinda · 12/04/2023 15:11

After 15 or so minutes of this, the guest...

😂

15 minutes? It's not the swearing that did it, it was this.

You made a right royal pain in the arse of yourself, wouldn't accept their response for 15 minutes of arguing at the desk and they no longer want your custom as a result. I don't blame them.

Changingggggggggggg · 12/04/2023 15:08

The booking was made by phone - as it had been on previous occasions. This was how they operated. It was then confirmed by phone two weeks later, when I learnt that some people were being asked to pay more than agreed.

It is a small place and as students we were all meant to pay the same price - which is what happens now.

I didn't imagine that having agreed and confirmed a price on the phone, ie two occasions, that they wouldn't honour it - as they did for other students (but not all, one left as I said).

OP posts:
Bluekerfuffle · 12/04/2023 15:08

If I were the guest I wouldn’t have gone back there anyway after they wouldn’t discuss something in a civil manner and went back on their word.

Kennykenkencat · 12/04/2023 15:08

ReadersD1gest · 12/04/2023 14:25

What do you mean by "systems are up the creek"? If you hadn't booked in advance you take the going rate on the day. That's how it works.

You not understanding how it works can't be blamed on their "systems".
And you're banned so it doesn't matter 🤷🏻‍♀️

I think the point is that everyone had booked in advance and confirmed price etc but when some of the guests arrived the hotel were altering the confirmed price for some and not others. One of those people was the OP.

I must admit that I too would have sworn.

Can you take them to the small claims court for the higher price you were charged as you have it confirmed by the hotel it should have been a much lower price.
You have nothing to lose as you don’t be returning to this place again.

I would be wary about booking a place that does this and it doesn’t look like it is an isolated incident given the reviews

Given it is so isolated I would imagine owner and management think that once they have guests make the journey to them that they can rip up the confirmation price and charge what they want and for everyone that walks away there will be one like op who pays.

KaihahUmoniiv · 12/04/2023 15:05

OK I missed the clarification that was posted later.

The "mix up" was that the "if you book now" price quoted by phone at some unspecified previous time was different from the "turn up on the day and ask for a room" price? And no booking was made at the time when the original cheaper price was quoted?

That's absurd. No hotels have a totally fixed price like that. The prices fluctuate according to supply and demand.

Agapornis · 12/04/2023 15:02

Contact the course leader - I can't imagine they're happy about their students constantly having the hassle of this hotel.

Alternatively: fake name, fake ID (if they ask), wear a wig.